Cutting Costs 70% Using Milestone With HD Analog

By: Brian Karas, Published on Feb 23, 2017

HD analog and enterprise VMSes are often thought of as being on opposite sides of the spectrum, with HD analog best for small jobs due to its low cost while enterprise VMSes only justifiable in large ones due to its high cost.

However, we have been seeing a trend where users combine the two.

HD Analog is less expensive than IP, but generally seen as a low-end offering, particularly when it comes to recorder options and interfaces, outlined in our HD Analog vs IP report.

However, Intertrade Security Distributors out of South Africa have found a way to combine the strengths of Milestone and HD analog into a cost effective offering, in this report we share their approach and analyze its competitiveness.

Universal ****** *** ** ********

*********'* ********* ****** ****** *** * *****-**** analog ****** ** ******* just * *******. ** combining *** ********* ****** and * ** ******* analog ** ***, ** analog ** ******* *** be ********* ** ********* with * ****** *******, which ******* *** ********* cost ** **** **** 90%.

Cost ******* ********

********* ******** *** ********* example *** * ** channel ****** ***** ** cameras *** ********** ******** (top) *** ** ****** components *** ********* ****** licenses (******):

********* ****** **** *** ** channel ****** *** *****, ******* ***** ** analog **** **** *** ability ** ****** * full ********** ** ****** for **** ** ****** camera ***** ****. *** *** ** ****** **** **** Exacq, ********* *** ******* VMSes ******

******* ** ** ***, and ********** **** * local ****** ***** *** for *** *** ****** options, ***** *** ****** HD ****** ** ****** 70% *******. **** ***** a ** ******* *********/****** HD ****** **** **** $80/channel, ******* ********* ** server/storage ********.

Vote / ****

Benefits ** ***** ****** ** *******

** ****** ******* *** significantly ******* **** ********** IP *******, **** **** you *** ** *** cost ** *** *** that **** ** ** encoder ** ******* *** IP ********* ** *********. Resolutions *** ********* ** to *** (**** ** ** **), *** ***** ******* from ******* ********** ** ****** cameras ** ********* ** par **** ** ******* in ****** ******.

Drawbacks ** ** ******

* ***** ******** ** HD ****** ** *** reliance ** **** *****. For ******** ** ******** systems, *** ******* ** reuse ******** **** *** be * **** *** cost *****, *** *** new *************, ******* **** will ******* ***** ****** options *** *** ****** system. *********** **** **** commented ********** **** ******* a ****+***** *****, **** terminating ****, *** ** more **** ********* **** pulling/terminating * ****** *******-**** cable *** ** ** camera.

** ****** **** *** fewer ****** ******* *******, particularly *** ********* ************ (multi-imagers, ******* ***-*****, *******, super ****-***, ***.), ******* customers ******* *** * low-budget ****** *** *** need ***** ************, *** if ***** * *** like ********* ** ** camera **** ***** ***** requirements *** ** **** for ***** ******** ********.

Setup ****

********* ** **** *** ****** [link ** ****** *********] at ***, *** ********** highlighted **** ********, ***** primarily ******** ******** *** correct ********** *** ** the ********* ****** *** each ******* ** *** DVR. *** ****** ** shown ** *** ********** below ***** ** ********:

Challenges *** ****, ******* *************

******* ************* **** **** ignoring ** ******, ************ Axis *** **** ** ****** **** *** out, *** ** **** cases ***** ******** *** been ********* ** ** analog ******** **** ******** low-end ************, ***** *** much **** ********* *** organizations **** * ***** sales ***** ** ** profitable **. *******, **** Milestone-based ******** ****** *********** to ***** * ****** that ******** ************* **** larger *********, ***** ******* manufacturers **** **** ******** compete, ** * ***** point **** ****** ******** Western ************* **** *************. Even *** ***-**** ******* from******************** ******* **** $**/*******.

*********** ********

*******, ** **** **** is ** *********** ******** *** integrators ********* ** *****-********* jobs. ***** ********* ** the ***/**** *********, ******* of * ****** ***/***, opens ** **** ************* for ******** *************** ** well ** ****** ****** upgrades ***** ******* *** initial ****** **** **** competitive.

Comments (29)

Scott Sheldrake

02/23/17 03:34pm

Under the "drawbacks of HD analog" section : it is not true that you need to run coax. We run cat5 and use video baluns for all "HD analog" installs which gives the customer options to upgrade to IP later without increasing the cost of Labour or wiring. Baluns are cheap. $9 a pair etc 

Avatar

Brian Karas

IPVM | In reply to Scott Sheldrake | 02/23/17 03:41pm

Scott -

Thanks for the feedback. Do the baluns you use supply power over the Cat5 as well, or are you still pulling a separate power cable?

Avatar

Raymond Shadman

IPVMU Certified | In reply to Brian Karas | 06/16/17 09:15pm

You can use video-only baluns, which usually require a single twisted pair cable, or power/video baluns, which require the entire Cat5/Cat6 cable.

Scott Sheldrake

02/23/17 04:06pm

Depends on the cable length / camera location, but for short runs, we supply power over the unused pairs of the cat5.

Shay Fogel

02/23/17 05:43pm

From our experiencne, powering HD analog cameras through unused twisted pairs cause interference to the video signal.

Do you use UTP Cat.5e?

Central power supply?

 

xiong zhang

In reply to Shay Fogel | 02/24/17 01:24am

Hi Shay,there was one balun which can support HD signal and power together for HD camera,if balun quality is good,there is no interference problem.You should use UTP cable

Shay Fogel

In reply to xiong zhang | 02/25/17 06:17pm

Thanks. Anything specific?

Undisclosed Manufacturer #5

In reply to Shay Fogel | 03/11/17 03:52am

do you have details contact information,I send email to you

Avatar

Raymond Shadman

IPVMU Certified | In reply to Shay Fogel | 06/16/17 09:17pm

We use these baluns for everything except HD-SDI and EX-SDI: http://edigitaldeals.net/surge-protected-pair-hd-cvi-tvi-passive-balun-video-power-coax-to-rj45.html. They have been tested up to 5MP HD-TVI.

Undisclosed Integrator #1

02/24/17 04:24am

Even cheaper with Milestone Essentials. The 16 channel universal driver only takes up one license. 

With your free 8 licenses you can add up to 128 hd analog cameras.

Avatar

Scot MacTaggart

In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #1 | 02/24/17 12:41pm

As I understand it, the universal driver doesn't work with Essential.

Avatar

Brian Karas

IPVM | In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #1 | 02/24/17 12:58pm

According to Milestone's Universal Driver Page:

XProtect Professional 6.5b, XProtect Enterprise 6.5f, XProtect Corporate 2.0d or newer versions are required to use the universal driver.

So, will not work with Essential. 

Undisclosed Integrator #1

In reply to Brian Karas | 02/24/17 02:30pm

 Maybe it is not supported/recommended but I have it working in essentials with a Chinese 4ch TVR. Here is a screenshot: 

Undisclosed Integrator #3

In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #1 | 02/24/17 11:52pm

Well now that its posted probably not for much longer. Wait for that next update!

Avatar

Mark Jones

02/24/17 01:18pm

For the past 10 years we have run Coax and CAT5 for our customers.  We have used the coax traditionally, and the CAT5 for power.  When the customer was ready to switch over the infrastructure was in place.  Using multiple pairs of CAT5 meets the circular mils required by the NEC to carry the power per code for the current carrying conductors.  We now have the CAT5 and Coax necessary to use IP and AHD on one installation, license free for the analog side.  Not every camera needs to be IP to meet the customer's expectations, and to the consternation of some, AHD is not going anywhere.  As the resolution increases, so will its popularity.  It is a matter of value.  

Undisclosed Manufacturer #2

02/24/17 08:30pm

what do the file sizes look like for HD analog in comparison to IP?

I'd have to think there is a substantial difference

Avatar

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #2 | 02/27/17 04:01pm

I would say in general, IP cameras will be lower bitrate than HD analog DVRs on average, due to the increase in smart codec usage, which are now common in cameras, but only recently introduced in DVRs (such as Dahua's 4MP models). Once smart codecs are more universally implemented in DVRs, it's likely to even out.

Historically, in our tests (with standard H.264 encoding), HD analog has been lower at times, such as our original Hikvision TVI test, but higher in others. I don't think it's possible to say one or the other will always be lower as a rule, at least not without more standardized testing. 

Avatar

Mark Jones

02/24/17 08:33pm

I have not done the math, but what makes you think they would be different?  1.3MP is 1.3MP no??

Undisclosed Manufacturer #2

In reply to Mark Jones | 02/24/17 08:38pm

I have not done the math, but what makes you think they would be different? 1.3MP is 1.3MP no??

 

There is (was) a significant noise factor with analog using encoders, when I started in IP 10 years ago. At that time file sizes were much larger for the encoder streams than from the IP cameras on hybrid installs.

I'm just wondering if anything has changed

Avatar

Mark Jones

In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #2 | 02/24/17 08:55pm

I had not actually considered encoders.  My remarks were geared more towards a hybrid machine.  You could have an excellent point.

Undisclosed #4

In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #2 | 02/25/17 07:29am

At that time file sizes were much larger for the encoder streams than from the IP cameras on hybrid installs.

IP cameras use analog encoders as well, they're just single-channel and built-in to the camera.

guy fauquembergue

02/25/17 05:50pm

Hi everybody, each time we are talking of connecting to HD DVR we forget remote playback. RTSP is fine but what about remote playback?

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to guy fauquembergue | 02/25/17 05:56pm

each time we are talking of connecting to HD DVR we forget remote playback. RTSP is fine but what about remote playback?

Guy, they are actually using the DVR as an encoder only typically. So the DVR, even though it could record, does not record, it simply encodes and RTSP outs to the VMS that handles the recording.

The main reason this is done is that there are many HD analog DVRs out there that support RTSP out but much fewer and often more expensive HD analog encoders.

Avatar

Alex Knapik

Milestone Systems | 01/08/18 02:54pm

On this topic - noted without comment: 

Hanwha Techwin DVR/NVR Driver Information

Nicer to have a dedicated driver than relying on the universal driver for this kind of approach...

Undisclosed #6

In reply to Alex Knapik | 01/08/18 04:59pm

This will save some money over encoders and single channel licenses. Can you record on the Milestone server or just the Hanwha DVR? Can your review and pull recordings from the Hanwha DVR?

Avatar

Alex Knapik

Milestone Systems | 01/10/18 05:37pm

Hi UD6,

Think of the Hanwha unit as essentially an encoder "passing through" the HD analog streams to Milestone. So yes to the "record on Milestone" (and do anything else you'd want to do) and "no" on pulling and reviewing on the Hanwha unit. 

Undisclosed Integrator #7

02/10/19 12:54pm

What happens if you add video analytics to the cost saving measures converting analogue to ip with Milestone.

does every dvr/camera on the system benefit ? 

Avatar

Sean Patton

IPVM | In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #7 | 07/29/19 03:11pm

Sorry I missed this question originally, what video analytics are you refering to?

If it is a third-party system typically those are licensed per video channel/camera processed, not per-Milestone-license. Milestone's native analytics (e.g. IPVM Test - Milestone LPR) are typically also offered per-channel. 

Undisclosed Integrator #7

07/29/19 01:31pm

What is or was the answer to the above question?

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 6,533 reports, 880 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now

Related Reports

Uniview H1 2020 Financials Examined on Sep 08, 2020
While Dahua and Hikvision, helped by fever camera sales, are recovering from...
AHJ / Authority Having Jurisdiction Tutorial on Aug 06, 2020
One of the most powerful yet often underappreciated characters in all...
Injes Tiny Temperature Terminal Tested on Jul 17, 2020
While temperature terminals have trended bigger, the Injes DFace801 is...
Infinova, March Networks and Swann H1 2020 Financials Examined on Sep 02, 2020
While Dahua and Hikvision, helped by fever camera sales, are recovering from...
HID Presents Signo on Apr 23, 2020
HID Global presented their new Signo readers they claim read farther and...
Hikvision Fever Screening Thermal Solutions Examined on Apr 13, 2020
Hikvision is marketing "safer, faster, smarter" with their Fever Screening...
Hikvision MinMoe Temperature Screening Terminal Tested on Jun 23, 2020
Hikvision has expanded its temperature screening options. We tested...
Opgal ThermApp MD Thermal Screening System on Apr 21, 2020
Israeli thermal provider Opgal claims they were first on the market detecting...
Hikvision and Uniview Entry Level Thermal Handheld Cameras Tested on Jun 05, 2020
While most screening systems cost $10,000 or more, manufacturers such as...
Dahua Profits Surge Due To Fever Camera Sales on Aug 25, 2020
While Dahua's overall revenue is down, driven by challenges within China, the...
Costar Technologies / Arecont H1 2020 Financials Examined on Sep 16, 2020
Costar's financial results have been hit by the coronavirus with the company...
Door Fundamentals For Access Control Guide on Aug 24, 2020
Doors vary greatly in how difficult and costly it is to add electronic access...
Dedicated Vs Converged IP Video Networks Statistics 2020 on Sep 10, 2020
Running one's video system on a converged network with other devices can save...
Mobotix Thermal Detection Camera Tested on Jun 09, 2020
For years Mobotix has struggled but now sales are surging driven by Mobotix's...
Sunell "Panda Cam" Thermal Body Temperature System Examined on Apr 09, 2020
Sunell's Panda Cam is the most visually recognizable coronavirus camera, sold...

Recent Reports

Hikvision Sues Over Brazilian Airport Loss on Sep 24, 2020
Hikvision was excluded from a Brazilian airport project because it is owned...
China General Chamber of Commerce Calls Out US Politics on Sep 24, 2020
While US-China relations at an all-time low, optimism about relations...
Verkada Disruptive Embedded Live Help on Sep 24, 2020
Call up your integrator? Have someone come by the next day? Verkada is...
IP Networking Course Fall 2020 - Last Chance - Register Now on Sep 23, 2020
Today is the last chance to register for the only IP networking course...
Drain Wire For Access Control Reader Tutorial on Sep 23, 2020
An easy-to-miss cabling specification plays a key role in access control, yet...
IPVM Camera Calculator User Manual / Guide on Sep 23, 2020
Learn how to use the IPVM Camera Calculator (updated for Version 3.1). The...
Installation Course Fall 2020 - Save $50 - Last Chance on Sep 22, 2020
Today is your last chance to save $50 on registration for the Fall 2020 Video...
SimpliSafe Business Security Launched Examined on Sep 22, 2020
SimpliSafe has launched "SimpliSafe Business Security" that the company...
FLIR CEO: Many New Fever Entrants "Making Claims That The Science Just Won't Support" on Sep 22, 2020
FLIR's CEO joins a growing number calling out risks with fever / screening...
China Bems Temperature Measurement Terminal Tested on Sep 22, 2020
Guangzhou Bems (brand Benshi) is the manufacturer behind temperature...
Axis Exports To China Police Criticized By Amnesty International on Sep 21, 2020
Axis Communications and other EU surveillance providers are under fire from...
Milestone XProtect on AWS Tested on Sep 21, 2020
Milestone finally launched multiple cloud solutions in 2020, taking a...
Mobile Access Control Usage Statistics 2020 on Sep 21, 2020
Most smartphones can be used as access control credentials, but how...
Axis Compares Fever Camera Sellers to 9/11 on Sep 18, 2020
Axis Communications, the West's largest surveillance camera manufacturer, has...