Cutting Costs 70% Using Milestone With HD Analog

By: Brian Karas, Published on Feb 23, 2017

HD analog and enterprise VMSes are often thought of as being on opposite sides of the spectrum, with HD analog best for small jobs due to its low cost while enterprise VMSes only justifiable in large ones due to its high cost.

However, we have been seeing a trend where users combine the two.

HD Analog is less expensive than IP, but generally seen as a low-end offering, particularly when it comes to recorder options and interfaces, outlined in our HD Analog vs IP report.

However, Intertrade Security Distributors out of South Africa have found a way to combine the strengths of Milestone and HD analog into a cost effective offering, in this report we share their approach and analyze its competitiveness.

** ****** *** ********** VMSes *** ***** ******* of ** ***** ** opposite ***** ** *** spectrum, **** ** ****** best for ***** **** *** to *** *** **** while ********** ***** **** justifiable ** ***** **** due ** *** **** cost.

*******, ** **** **** seeing * ***** ***** users ******* *** ***.

** ****** ** **** expensive **** **, *** generally **** ** * low-end ********, ************ **** it ***** ** ******** options *** **********, ******** in *** ** ****** ** ** ******.

*******,********** ******** ************ *** ** ***** ****** **** ***** * *** to ******* *** ********* of ********* *** ** analog **** * **** effective ********, ** **** report ** ***** ***** approach *** ******* *** competitiveness.

[***************]

Universal ****** *** ** ********

*********'* ********* ****** ****** *** * *****-**** analog ****** ** ******* just * *******. ** combining *** ********* ****** and * ** ******* analog ** ***, ** analog ** ******* *** be ********* ** ********* with * ****** *******, which ******* *** ********* cost ** **** **** 90%.

Cost ******* ********

********* ******** *** ********* example *** * ** channel ****** ***** ** cameras *** ********** ******** (top) *** ** ****** components *** ********* ****** licenses (******):

********* ****** **** *** ** channel ****** *** *****, ******* ***** ** analog **** **** *** ability ** ****** * full ********** ** ****** for **** ** ****** camera ***** ****. *** *** ** ****** **** **** Exacq, ********* *** ******* VMSes ******

******* ** ** ***, and ********** **** * local ****** ***** *** for *** *** ****** options, ***** *** ****** HD ****** ** ****** 70% *******. **** ***** a ** ******* *********/****** HD ****** **** **** $80/channel, ******* ********* ** server/storage ********.

Vote / ****

Benefits ** ***** ****** ** *******

** ****** ******* *** significantly ******* **** ********** IP *******, **** **** you *** ** *** cost ** *** *** that **** ** ** encoder ** ******* *** IP ********* ** *********. Resolutions *** ********* ** to *** (**** ** ** **), *** ***** ******* from ******* ********** ** ****** cameras ** ********* ** par **** ** ******* in ****** ******.

Drawbacks ** ** ******

* ***** ******** ** HD ****** ** *** reliance ** **** *****. For ******** ** ******** systems, *** ******* ** reuse ******** **** *** be * **** *** cost *****, *** *** new *************, ******* **** will ******* ***** ****** options *** *** ****** system. *********** **** **** commented ********** **** ******* a ****+***** *****, **** terminating ****, *** ** more **** ********* **** pulling/terminating * ****** *******-**** cable *** ** ** camera.

** ****** **** *** fewer ****** ******* *******, particularly *** ********* ************ (multi-imagers, ******* ***-*****, *******, super ****-***, ***.), ******* customers ******* *** * low-budget ****** *** *** need ***** ************, *** if ***** * *** like ********* ** ** camera **** ***** ***** requirements *** ** **** for ***** ******** ********.

Setup ****

********* ** **** *** ******** ***, *** ********** highlighted **** ********, ***** primarily ******** ******** *** correct ********** *** ** the ********* ****** *** each ******* ** *** DVR. *** ****** ** shown ** *** ********** below ***** ** ********:

Challenges *** ****, ******* *************

******* ************* **** **** ignoring ** ******, ************ Axis *** **** ** ****** **** *** out, *** ** **** cases ***** ******** *** been ********* ** ** analog ******** **** ******** low-end ************, ***** *** much **** ********* *** organizations **** * ***** sales ***** ** ** profitable **. *******, **** Milestone-based ******** ****** *********** to ***** * ****** that ******** ************* **** larger *********, ***** ******* manufacturers **** **** ******** compete, ** * ***** point **** ****** ******** Western ************* **** *************. Even *** ***-**** ******* from******************** ******* **** $**/*******.

*********** ********

*******, ** **** **** is ** *********** ******** *** integrators ********* ** *****-********* jobs. ***** ********* ** the ***/**** *********, ******* of * ****** ***/***, opens ** **** ************* for ******** *************** ** well ** ****** ****** upgrades ***** ******* *** initial ****** **** **** competitive.

Comments (29)

Under the "drawbacks of HD analog" section : it is not true that you need to run coax. We run cat5 and use video baluns for all "HD analog" installs which gives the customer options to upgrade to IP later without increasing the cost of Labour or wiring. Baluns are cheap. $9 a pair etc 

Scott -

Thanks for the feedback. Do the baluns you use supply power over the Cat5 as well, or are you still pulling a separate power cable?

You can use video-only baluns, which usually require a single twisted pair cable, or power/video baluns, which require the entire Cat5/Cat6 cable.

Depends on the cable length / camera location, but for short runs, we supply power over the unused pairs of the cat5.

From our experiencne, powering HD analog cameras through unused twisted pairs cause interference to the video signal.

Do you use UTP Cat.5e?

Central power supply?

 

Hi Shay,there was one balun which can support HD signal and power together for HD camera,if balun quality is good,there is no interference problem.You should use UTP cable

Thanks. Anything specific?

do you have details contact information,I send email to you

We use these baluns for everything except HD-SDI and EX-SDI: http://edigitaldeals.net/surge-protected-pair-hd-cvi-tvi-passive-balun-video-power-coax-to-rj45.html. They have been tested up to 5MP HD-TVI.

Even cheaper with Milestone Essentials. The 16 channel universal driver only takes up one license. 

With your free 8 licenses you can add up to 128 hd analog cameras.

As I understand it, the universal driver doesn't work with Essential.

According to Milestone's Universal Driver Page:

XProtect Professional 6.5b, XProtect Enterprise 6.5f, XProtect Corporate 2.0d or newer versions are required to use the universal driver.

So, will not work with Essential. 

 Maybe it is not supported/recommended but I have it working in essentials with a Chinese 4ch TVR. Here is a screenshot: 

Well now that its posted probably not for much longer. Wait for that next update!

For the past 10 years we have run Coax and CAT5 for our customers.  We have used the coax traditionally, and the CAT5 for power.  When the customer was ready to switch over the infrastructure was in place.  Using multiple pairs of CAT5 meets the circular mils required by the NEC to carry the power per code for the current carrying conductors.  We now have the CAT5 and Coax necessary to use IP and AHD on one installation, license free for the analog side.  Not every camera needs to be IP to meet the customer's expectations, and to the consternation of some, AHD is not going anywhere.  As the resolution increases, so will its popularity.  It is a matter of value.  

what do the file sizes look like for HD analog in comparison to IP?

I'd have to think there is a substantial difference

I would say in general, IP cameras will be lower bitrate than HD analog DVRs on average, due to the increase in smart codec usage, which are now common in cameras, but only recently introduced in DVRs (such as Dahua's 4MP models). Once smart codecs are more universally implemented in DVRs, it's likely to even out.

Historically, in our tests (with standard H.264 encoding), HD analog has been lower at times, such as our original Hikvision TVI test, but higher in others. I don't think it's possible to say one or the other will always be lower as a rule, at least not without more standardized testing. 

I have not done the math, but what makes you think they would be different?  1.3MP is 1.3MP no??

I have not done the math, but what makes you think they would be different? 1.3MP is 1.3MP no??

 

There is (was) a significant noise factor with analog using encoders, when I started in IP 10 years ago. At that time file sizes were much larger for the encoder streams than from the IP cameras on hybrid installs.

I'm just wondering if anything has changed

I had not actually considered encoders.  My remarks were geared more towards a hybrid machine.  You could have an excellent point.

At that time file sizes were much larger for the encoder streams than from the IP cameras on hybrid installs.

IP cameras use analog encoders as well, they're just single-channel and built-in to the camera.

Hi everybody, each time we are talking of connecting to HD DVR we forget remote playback. RTSP is fine but what about remote playback?

each time we are talking of connecting to HD DVR we forget remote playback. RTSP is fine but what about remote playback?

Guy, they are actually using the DVR as an encoder only typically. So the DVR, even though it could record, does not record, it simply encodes and RTSP outs to the VMS that handles the recording.

The main reason this is done is that there are many HD analog DVRs out there that support RTSP out but much fewer and often more expensive HD analog encoders.

On this topic - noted without comment: 

Hanwha Techwin DVR/NVR Driver Information

Nicer to have a dedicated driver than relying on the universal driver for this kind of approach...

This will save some money over encoders and single channel licenses. Can you record on the Milestone server or just the Hanwha DVR? Can your review and pull recordings from the Hanwha DVR?

Hi UD6,

Think of the Hanwha unit as essentially an encoder "passing through" the HD analog streams to Milestone. So yes to the "record on Milestone" (and do anything else you'd want to do) and "no" on pulling and reviewing on the Hanwha unit. 

What happens if you add video analytics to the cost saving measures converting analogue to ip with Milestone.

does every dvr/camera on the system benefit ? 

Sorry I missed this question originally, what video analytics are you refering to?

If it is a third-party system typically those are licensed per video channel/camera processed, not per-Milestone-license. Milestone's native analytics (e.g. IPVM Test - Milestone LPR) are typically also offered per-channel. 

What is or was the answer to the above question?

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Axis Perimeter Defender Improves, Yet Worse Than Dahua and Wyze on Sep 19, 2019
While Axis Perimeter Defender analytics improved from our 2018 testing, the market has improved much faster, with much less expensive offerings...
Directory of 68 Video Surveillance Startups on Sep 18, 2019
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known. 2019...
Vivotek "Neural Network-Powered Detection Engine" Analytics Tested on Sep 17, 2019
Vivotek has released "a neural network-powered detection engine", named Smart Motion Detection, claiming that "swaying vegetation, vehicles passing...
Panasonic 4K Camera Tested (WV-S2570L) on Sep 13, 2019
Panasonic has released their latest generation 4K dome, the WV-S2570L, claiming "Extreme image quality allows evidence to be captured even under...
Genetec Stratocast VSaaS Tested on Sep 05, 2019
The VSaaS market is rapidly expanding in 2019, with Verkada, Meraki, Eagle Eye, Avigilon and numerous startups growing their market share. When we...
Top Ways Security Integrators Improve Their Careers on Sep 03, 2019
With DIY products expanding and the future of integration debated, how do integrators stay sharp so they are not left behind? 180+ integrators...
Scylla AI Video Analytics Company Profile on Aug 29, 2019
Scylla, an AI analytics startup, says they are targeting 1 Billion dollar valuation in 5 years and it "is not rocket science" to detect weapons and...
Uniview Pro 4K Camera Tested (IPC3238ER3-DVZ) on Aug 29, 2019
In our 8MP / 4K Fixed Lens Camera Shootout, Uniview's low end 8MP was firmly in the middle of the pack. Does their higher end Pro Series 4K camera...
Warning: Windows 7 Update Crashing NVRs on Aug 26, 2019
Windows 7 updates are causing VMS servers to fail to boot. After running the update, impacted systems do not boot as normal, instead display this...
Security Integrators Outlook On Remaining Integrators In 2025 on Aug 22, 2019
The industry has changed substantially in the last decade, with the rise of IP cameras and the race to the bottom. Indeed, more changes may be...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Open Access Controller Guide (Axis, HID, Isonas, Mercury) on Sep 19, 2019
In the access control market, there are many software platforms, but only a few companies that make non-proprietary door controllers. Recently,...
Axis Perimeter Defender Improves, Yet Worse Than Dahua and Wyze on Sep 19, 2019
While Axis Perimeter Defender analytics improved from our 2018 testing, the market has improved much faster, with much less expensive offerings...
Directory of 68 Video Surveillance Startups on Sep 18, 2019
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known. 2019...
Uniview Prime Series 4K Camera Tested on Sep 18, 2019
Is the new Uniview 'Prime' better than the more expensive existing Uniview 'Pro'? In August, IPVM tested Uniview 4K 'Pro' but members advocated...
US Army Base To Buy Banned Honeywell Surveillance on Sep 17, 2019
The U.S. Army's Fort Gordon, home to their Cyber Center of Excellence, has issued a solicitation to purchase Honeywell products that are US...
Vivotek "Neural Network-Powered Detection Engine" Analytics Tested on Sep 17, 2019
Vivotek has released "a neural network-powered detection engine", named Smart Motion Detection, claiming that "swaying vegetation, vehicles passing...
Schmode is Back, Aims To Turn Boulder AI Into Giant on Sep 16, 2019
One of the most influential and controversial executives in the past decade is back. Bryan Schmode ascended and drove the hypergrowth of Avigilon...
Manufacturers Unhappy With Weak ASIS GSX 2019 And 2020 Shift on Sep 16, 2019
Manufacturers were generally unhappy with ASIS GSX, both for weak 2019 booth traffic and a scheduling shift for the 2020 show, according to a new...
How Cobalt Robotics May Disrupt Security on Sep 13, 2019
While security robots have largely become a joke over the last few years, one organization, Cobalt Robotics, has raised $50+ million from top US...
Panasonic 4K Camera Tested (WV-S2570L) on Sep 13, 2019
Panasonic has released their latest generation 4K dome, the WV-S2570L, claiming "Extreme image quality allows evidence to be captured even under...