Bandwidth vs Low Light Shootout - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Geovision, Hanwha, Hikvision, Uniview, Vivotek

By IPVM Team, Published on Feb 08, 2019

Nighttime bandwidth spikes are a major concern in video surveillance, but do all manufacturers' cameras perform the same? Are some more consistent from day to night than others? And do manufacturer models all similar?

To find out we shot out and compiled results from over 50 cameras from 9 manufacturers - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Geovision, Hanwha, Hikvision, Uniview, Vivotek - to see how each did, what was average, and who was worst and best and how much performance has improved in the past several years.

Manufacturer ***********

**** ** ************ *********** compared ** *** *****:

**** *** ***** ****** spikes/most **********:**** *** ***** ********** IR ****** **** ************ produced *** ******** ******* spikes, **** **** ********* close ** **%, ***** 1/3 ** *** ******* average. **** *** *** true ** ***** ***-** models, ***** ****** *********** like ***** ****** (*** below).
******/***** **********, *** ******:******'* ****** ******** ***** 125% ********, ***** **** average *** ****** **** Axis/Bosch. ****** ****** **** generally *** ***** ** average, **** *** ***-***** an *******, ********** **** ~52%. ***** ****** ******** only **** ******** ***** the ****** ******** (***% vs. ***%), **** **** one ***** ******* **** 200%.
********* **** ***********:***** *********'* ******** ** average **** ***** ***%, their ****** ******** *** two ******* ****** ** IR ******* **** ** our *****, **** ***%. There *** ** ***** trend ** *** ********* models *********, **** **** newer ******* ******* ****** than *****, *** **** versa. ***%
******** ****** **** *******:******** ******* ****** **** over *** ******* *******, ~225%, **** *** ***** increasing ***% ** *****.

General ********

** ******** ** *** manufacturer ******** *********** *****, there *** ******* ******* takeaways:

~***% ******* ******** ** Integrated ** *******:****** **+ ******* ******* from ***** ** **, bit **** ********* ** average ** ~***% **** day ** *****. ********* varied **** * *** of ~**% ** **** 400%.
***-** ******* **** ******:***-** ******* ****** ********* in *** ***** **** day ** *****, **** a *** ** ~***% to * **** ** over *,***% (*** *********). However, ***** ****** *** far **** ****** ** surveillance ** ****, **** the **** ******** ** models ********* ********** **, while **** *** *** in *** ******** **** test.
******* ******* ****** ***** past *****:*** ***% ******* **** in **** **** ** roughly **% ***** **** the ***% ******* ** our **** ***** *** to *** ********** ***** of ********** ** ** 2019.
*** (*** **** * cap) ***********:** ****** ********* ******, we ********* ***** ******* bit **** ****, ** this ****** *** ***** to **** ** *** as ******** ****** **** complex *****, *** **** bandwidth ** * ********* limit ** ***** ****** network ******* *** *******, with ******* ****** ** video *******.

**** **** ***** **** no ********** ****** ** how ****** ****** ***** on **********, **** **** models ********* *** ********* and ****** ******* ** each ********** ******.

Results ********: ***% ******** *******

**** *** *** ******* sorted ** ************. ****** 30+ ******* ******, *** average (****) ********* ******** from *** ** ***** was ~***%. *** ****** was ***%, ****** ****** increases ****** ***********, **** outliers ** *** ** 17% *** **** **** 400%.

2019 Nighttime Bandwidth Spikes By Manufacturer

Most ********** *************: **** *** *****

** *** * ************* tested, **** *** ***** integrated ** ****** **** consistently ******* ******* ******, with **** ********* ***** to **%, ***** */* of *** ******* *******. Note **** ***** ****** fewer ** ****** **** Axis, **** **** ** their **** *** ****** lacking *** ******* (*.*. the********* **** *********), ***** **** ****** integrated ** ** *, P, *** * ****** domes *** *******.

Others **** ******

***** ************* ****** **** more ******. *** *******, some *** ********* ****** increased ** ***** ***** to **** *** *****, below ***%, ***** ****** produced *** ******* ****** of ** ******* ******. Additionally, ******* ******* ******** the **** ****** ********** increase (**%) ** ***** 4MP *****, *** *** of *** ******* ** the ** ******.

Much ******* ****** **** **** *****

** ******** ** *** 145% ******** **** ** current *****, ******* ** our **** **** ******** 498% ****** ********* ** night, **** *** ****** spiking ****** *,***% ******.

2014 Nighttime Bandwidth Spikes By Resolution

Integrated ** ******* ****** / ***-** ******* ***** *********

*** **** ********* ****** in ****** ********* ****** is ******* *** ****** includes ********** ** ** not. *** **** ********* single ****** ** ****** performance ******* *** ******** test ** **** *** models ****** ** **** is *** ********* ** integrated ** ** ****** every ****** ******. ** 2019, **** ************* ******* integrated ** ** **** models, **** **** *** cameras *** * ******** of **** ******* ******* it. *******, ***** *** some, **** ** *****, whose ******* ********** ****** (such ** ************ **** ***** *****) ** *** ******* IR, ****** ***** *** the ********.

***** ***-** ****** ***** much **** ************* **** non-IR ******, **** **, 10x, ***, ** ****** increases ********.

2019 Non-IR Cameras Spike Drastically

***** ****** *********** *** improved, **** **** ********* encoders, ****** *** **** sensitive *******, *** ****** processing, *** ******** ** infrared ***** ** ********* surveillance ******* *** *** biggest ******** ****** ** bitrate.

Fisheye *********** ****** ***********

*** ******** ** ***** the ******** ***** ***** down ** ******* *******. In *** *****, ******* models ****** **** *********** than ******, **** **** the ******* ****** ******************** *****. **** ** generally *** ** **** low ***** ***********, **** night **** ****** **** darker, *** **** **** detailed **** *******, *** this ** *** *********** true, ** *** **** M3058-PLVE *** *** ** the **** *** ***** performers ** ************ ******* ****** ********.

2019 Fisheye Cameras Vary Drastically

Root ***** ** ********* ******: ******** *****

*** ****** ** ***** spikes ** *** ******* moving *****, *** ****, static, *******, ** **** that ** ********* *********** **** *******.

****** *** *** ***** to **** * ***** or ***** **** ***** was *** ****** ****** is ******** **** **** noise, ***** ***** **** this:

** ** *******, **** noise, **** *** **** contrast (***** *** ***** near **** *****) *** rapid ********* (******* ******), make ** ****** ** encode. ******,********* ******* *** ****** / ***** **** *** similar *** **********. ***** undermines **** ** *****.

Recommendation: *** *** **** * ***

*** *** ** ***** massive ********* ****** *** be ******* ** ******* *** **** * cap, **** ***** ** MBR(******* *** ****). **** method ****** ******** ** fluctuate ** ********* ** fit *** *****, *** only ** ** * specified *****, ** ***** point *** ****** ********* compression ** ****** ** drop ****** ** **** within *** *** (********* the ****** ** *********).

** *** *****, **** when **** ******************** ********* **** ** average ** ~** ** 35, ***** ******* *********** were *******, **** ****** bandwidth ***** ** **** 80%

bandwidth cap minimal impact on details

Constant *** **** *** ***********

******** *** **** *** also ** **** ** prevent ******, ***** ** locks *** ***** ** one ********* ***** ********** of ******** ** *** scene. *******, ****** *** day, **** ****** *** less *******, *** *** waste *********/******* ** *** camera ***** **** *********** encode *** ***** **** set ** ***. ******* of ****, *** ** not *********** ****** ** the **** ****** ***** does *** ******* ***.

Digital ***** ********* ******

******* ****** ********* ***** is **** ** ****** spikes *** ** ********* noise ** ******* ***** reduction (***), ***** ******** to ******* ***** ****** by ********* ** ****. There *** *** *** methods, ******* (***** ********** in * ****** *****) and ******** (***** ********* by *********** ******** ******), which *** ********* ******** in ******. ***** ***, spikes *** ** *********** cut, **** **-**% ********** in *** **** ******** *** *****.

*******, *** *** **** introduce ******** *******, ** well, **** **** ****** of ******** ***** ********* causing **** ** ***** (shown *****), ********* ******* to *** ******* ** slow *******. ******* ** this, ***** ****** ** careful ** *** ******** DNR ** ******* ******.

*** **** ******* *** testing, *** ********* *** (******* ***** Reduction) ******** ****.

Test *******

** ****** **** ** cameras **** **** ************* day (~*** ***) *** night (~*.* ***) ******** motion ****** ** ** FPS.

*** ******* *********** ****** were************ ***-** ****** ******* smart ****** **. ***** codecs **** ******* ** their ********* ****** ***** on *** *****. ***** codec ******** ****:

****:****************, ****, ******* *** 300, ******* *** ***
*****:***** *.***+ **
******:***************, ******* *** ***, Dynamic *** ***
*********:*.***+ **
*******:*-**** **, *****
*******:*********** **/***, ******* *****-***** period *******

*.*** *** **** *** consistency, ** **** ******* did *** ******* *.*** streaming.

Comments (24)

Undisclosed Manufacturer #1

02/09/19 04:18pm

* ***** **** ****** this, *** **** *********** did *** **** **** on, *.*** ** *.***? I'd ** ********** ** know ** *.*** ** the **** ****** ***** lower *** ********** ********. The ******* ******* ***** most ****** ** *****. What ***** *********** ****** do, *********, **********, *.***+, etc.

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #1 | 02/11/19 02:26am

*** ****'* **** **, I ****** ** *** it **! ***** ************ are *** *.***, **** smart ****** **. *'** double ***** **** ****** in ***** ** *** detail ** *** ****** on ***** ******** *** post **** ********.

Guilherme Barandas

In reply to Ethan Ace | 02/14/19 11:16am

*****, ** *** *** the ***** ** ****, could *** **** **.

Ariel Levy

In reply to Undisclosed Manufacturer #1 | 02/12/19 02:38pm

*.*** ** ****.

Undisclosed #2

IPVMU Certified | In reply to Ariel Levy | 02/12/19 03:25pm

**** **** *.***+!

Jörg Steuerwald

02/11/19 01:00pm

*** *** ******** **** the ******** ** *** cameras , **** *****-****, and ***** ******* ********. In **** ***** *** 4MP ******* **** ********* as * **** ********** from *** **** ******.

Jason Crist

02/11/19 01:05pm

**** *********** **** **** wasn't ******, *** ***** and ***** *** *** light ******* *** *** hottest ***** ** *** industry.

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to Jason Crist | 02/11/19 01:13pm

**, **** *** *** the ******* ***** ** the ********. ******, ***** ************ ****** ** Sony **** ************ * *** ** 200+ *********** **** ********* Sony's *** ***** *********.

**** ****, ** ********** *** ***** ****.

Jason Crist

In reply to John Honovich | 02/11/19 03:09pm

*'* *** **** ** I'm ******** *** *****. The ******* ** *********** clearly *** *** ***** useful ** *** ** the ********* ****, *** gets *** **** **** and *** **** *** (paraphrasing *** **'* * clear *********). * ******** a ******** ******* ***** engineering ***** ****** ******, which ********* **** ******** on **** *** *** the ******* *** ******* not. *** * ****'* bring ** **, *** referenced ** ** **** context.

**** ****'* **** * great *** ** ******* their ******** ** ***** through ********* ********, **** aren't ***** ** *** any ********** ********, *** the ***** *** ******** some ********* ** **'* short **** ** *** market. *** *** ***** has **** *** ****** of **** **** **** focused ** ** *** past ****** ** ***** and **'* ************* *** to *** **** ********. Not **** ***** ****'** been ***** *** * while, *** *** ******** performance ** ***** ******** from ***** ******* *** reliability *** ****** **** factually *********.

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to Jason Crist | 02/11/19 03:26pm

* ******** * ******** reports ***** *********** ***** review ******

***** ** ** - **** **** ***** *** Light ****** ****** *** ** **** *** **** ** **** ***** Size ******** (***** ** SNC-VB770)

*** ******* ********** *** engineering / ********** ***** to **** **** * wide ******* ** *********** are *****.

****'* *** ***** *********** is **** **** - but **'* **** *********. It's **** ** **** many $*,*** ******* **** pretty **** *** ***** cameras *** ****** ********* under $*,***. ***** *** applications ***** *** *****'* price ******* ** ********* but, ******* ** *** significant ***** *****, **'* a *****.

Undisclosed #2

IPVMU Certified | In reply to Jason Crist | 02/11/19 05:01pm

...*** ***** *** ***** gen *** ***** ******* are *** ******* ***** in *** ********.
**** ****'* **** * great *** ** ******* their ******** ** ***** through ********* ********, **** aren't ***** ** *** any ********** ********...
...*** *** ******** *********** of ***** ******** **** video ******* *** *********** has ****** **** ********* contended.

”****’** ********** **** *** cakes!”

Jason Crist

02/11/19 05:12pm

*****, ****'* ***** *** not ******* **** *** there *** *** ****** releases ******* **** ******** low ***** ************ **** the ****** **** *** a ******** ** *** cost ** *** *****.

Undisclosed #2

IPVMU Certified | In reply to Jason Crist | 02/11/19 05:35pm

...**** *** ****** **** are * ******** ** the **** ** *** VB770.

* ***** **** **’* a **** ***** ********, since **’* */**** ** low-light ********* ** *** VB700.

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to Jason Crist | 02/11/19 06:13pm

** ** *****, *** VM772R ** ****** *** a ** ********** ** camera.** ****** **. *** ** **** a **** ******* ****** than *** ***** *** its *********** ** ******* near **** ******. **** our *****:

****, **** * ******* that *** * $*,***+ camera (****** *****), ***** makes ** * ***** outlier **** **** ******* are ***** $*,***, ********* far ***** $*,***. ** even ** **'* * fraction ** *** **** of *** *****, ** is ***** ****** **** above ******* *** ** IP ****** ** ****.

************, ** ** *** a **** ********** ** include ****** *** ****** or ***** ** **** test, ** **** ** not ******* * **** VBR ************** (**** ** not *** *********** *** vary ******* ** ** typical). **'** ********* ** in *** ***** ** those ******** *******, ** well ****** ******. ** ******* **** against **** *** ******* which **** ******* **** widely (**** ****** *** lower) ***** ** **********. If ****'** ***** **** in ********, **'* ** interested ** **** * look, *** **** ** checked, ** *** ***** true.

Jason Crist

02/11/19 05:54pm

*****'** **** **** ** have ****** ** ******* the ****** ;)

Undisclosed #3

02/12/19 04:54am

**** **** ** ***** meter ** *** ***? Can *** *** * column ** **** ******* to **** * ** 2 ********* *** ****** used ** *** ****** tests? * ***** **** you *** *** ** would ** **** ** see *** ******* **** a *** *********** ******* for * ********. ****** in *******.

Edouard Sonnenschein

In reply to Undisclosed #3 | 03/13/19 02:14pm

* ***** **** ** interested ** *** ***** meter *** *** *****.

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to Edouard Sonnenschein | 03/13/19 03:08pm

** *** ******** *****. **'* *** ** the *** **'** ***** that ******** **** ** 0.01 ***. **** ****** are *** **** *** low ***** ************. **** people *** ******** *** by **** *.* ********, but *** *** ******* we *** ********* ***** that *****.

Edouard Sonnenschein

In reply to Ethan Ace | 03/13/19 07:47pm

* *** *** ****** HD400. **** ** *.****/*.****. *** Extech ***** ***** **** *.****/***. So * *** *** sure ** ** ******** went **** ** .** lux.

***** *** *** *** information.

Alfredo Santiago

ALFREDO'S TELEPHONE SERVICE
02/19/19 08:46am

**** **** *** ** that *** ***** ******* if *** **** ** see *** ** ****. You **** *****.

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to Alfredo Santiago | 02/19/19 12:38pm

* ***** ***** **** your ********* ** *******, just **** ** ******* that ***** *****'* **** to **** ******* *****. Most ** *** ******* in **** **** **** integrated **, ** ***** was ***-******* ***** ** the *****.

Juan Banda

IPVMU Certified | In reply to Ethan Ace | 08/01/19 03:54am

***** *** *** ********* the ***** *********** ******-**.#*******

daniel tobias

09/05/19 09:47pm

*******,

***** *** *** **** informative *******.

*** *** ****** ******* the **** ** *********** for *** *** *** night ********* ******?

*** ***** ****, **/*, or ** ********* *****?

***** ***.

Ethan Ace

IPVM | In reply to daniel tobias | 09/06/19 04:15am

******* ** *** ****** are ** ******** *** second (**/*, ****, ******* you ****** ** ****** it). *'* ***** ** send ***** ****** ** our ******* ******** ** add **** ******** *** will ****** **** **** it's ****.

** *** **** *** other *********, *** ** know!

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 6,596 reports, 889 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.