UK Camera Commissioner Calls for Regulating Facial Recognition

By Charles Rollet, Published Apr 15, 2019, 07:41am EDT

IPVM interviewed Tony Porter, the UK’s surveillance camera commissioner after he recently called for regulations on facial recognition in the UK.

tony porter facial recognition

There is currently no clear legal framework for the technology despite the passage of the GDPR last year, and important questions remain, such as:

  • What would future regulations on facial recognition actually look like?
  • Is a retail store using facial recognition to catch shoplifters legal under the GDPR?
  • Should private facial recognition use be banned outright, as Belgium has done?

In this note, we ask Porter the above questions, explain the current state of facial recognition law in the UK, and where it’s headed.

Who ** *** ************ ****** ************?

*** ******** *** ******* in **** ** ******** security ****** *** ** the ** *** ** technically * **** ** the**** ******– *** ******** *** enforcement ********.

** ****** ** **********, *** ************ ****** Commissioner *** ** ****** enforcement ** ********** ******. Its ***** ******* ** upholding**** ** *********** ***** ************ *** by ***** *********** (*** not ******* ************* ** households.)

Tony ******: ******* ***** “******* *** ********”

** ***** ************* ** ***** **, Porter ****** *** “* robust ********** ** *********** regime ******* ******” ****** recognition. ****** *** **** because, ** ** **** IPVM,

*** ********** ** ****** into *** ********** - it’s **** ** ********** and **** ** * reality. [***] *** *********** or ********** ********* **** oversees ** ** ******* and ******** *** * don’t ***** **** **’* helpful

****** **** **** **** several *************, **** ** himself, ***** **** ******, ************* ************, *** ********* ********* ***************** ******** ****** *********** use. ** ****, ***** agencies **** ** * patchwork ** *********** ***** makes ** ****** ******* of ****** ***********, ******* the********** ** ******** *** of ****, ******* **** ********** ***, *** *******.

What ****** ** **** *******

****** **** **** ** supports *** ******** ******** to ***** ** *** legal **** ****:

  1. ******** *************** ****** **** ** Practice- **** ** ******* *** should ** ******** **** the **** ** ******. But ****** ** ******* for *** ******* ***** ****-******* ************ *** ***** ****** organization************** ****** ** ***** for ***** ****** *********** on ******. *** **** has ** ***** ** punishments *** ******** **; however, *** **** ** admissible ** ***** *********** (See ******* *.**). ***** the **** **** ******* to ********** ******, ******* sector ******** *** ** added ** *** ***** (Section *.*), ** ******** it ***** **** **** an ****** ** ******* sector ********* ** ****.
  2. ******* ******** *********** ****** by ********** ***** *** practice, *** ******** ******** “a ****** ****” **** oversees ****** ***********. *******, this ***** ** ***** away, ************ ** *** UK ** ******** ** Brexit ************.

Core ******: **** ***** *********** ******, ******* *** ******* ***********

*******’* ******* ******* **** ********** ********** is ****** ****** *** two ***** ******** ** video ************: ***** *** informed *******, ***** ******* would *** ** *** case *** **** ****** recognition ************ ******* ** access *******, ** “*********** public ********.”

*******, *** **** **** not ******* **** “*********** public ********” ******** *****. Porter **** *** **** is “************ *****” **** it *** ** *********** in **** ****, *********** creating * ***** **** area:

* ***** ** **** stage, '*** ****'* ***** out' ** * **** kind **************

** *** ******* ******, Porter **** **** ****** recognition *** ** ******* unregulated:

********** *** ****** *** extremely **** ** *** UK *** **** ****** very ******* **** ******* [on ****** ***********]…*** ********, it’s *** ********** ****** which ** ***** *** technology, ***** ** **** more **** [******] ***, and ****’* * *** less *********.

Minimum ************ *** ****** ***********

** **** ********* ***************** ** ** **********, Porter ****** **** *** AFR ***, ** * minimum, ******:

  • ********* ******* **’* ********* on ****** ******** *******;
  • ********* ******* *** ***** is ************;
  • ******* ** ********** ********* intrusion *****.

Facial *********** ** ***** *********** 

***** **** ******** ** not ********** ******* ** the **, ***** ***** so **** ******* ** the ***** **** **** operations **** *** ****'* "substantial ****** ********" ********* - **** ****** ***** are ** *********** ********** what **** ********* ******** is.

(*** *******, ** **************** ******** ****** *** ******* ******** its ***-********** ****** *********** solution ***** *** "*********** Public ********" **** *** is ********* ****-*********.)

****** ********* **** **** shops *** ****** ***** facial *********** *** **** purpose ** *** **, but **** ** *** "many ********".  ****** **** IPVM ** ********* *********** making ** ***** **** covert ****** *********** *** by ***** **** ** catch *********** ** ****** not *******:

***** ****** ** * very ****** ********* **** that’s *** **********. 

** ** ** ***** to ** ****, *** public ***** ** ** informed ************* **** **'* being ****, *** **** need *** *********** ** reject.  [**** *** ** somewhere ****] *** **'* not ***** ** **** a ******* **** ****** their ********* *********** ********.

For **** ******* ********* - '***************' ** ***

**** **** ** ***** to * **** ***** facial *********** ** *********** with ****** ** ***** higher-level ********* ** **** missing ******, ****** *** substantial ************. ** **** IPVM "********** ********* ** proportionality" *** *** ** this ********.

**************** **** **** **** * shopping **** ** ********** secretly **** ****** *********** to ******* ******** ** shoppers ******* *** ******* for *** ******; *** goal *** ** **** matches ** * ****** watchlist ** ** ******** and ******* ******. ****** found *** ********** ** be **************** ***** ** his ************** ** "******* of ****** ***".

*** ****** **************** ** *** ********, Porter ****:

** *** * *********** impact *** ****** *** cessation ** *** *******.

Should ******* ****** *********** ** ****** **** ** *******?

** ******* ** ****, ******* **** **** outright ****** *** *** of ****** *********** ** security ******* *** ******* use, ******** ** ******** legal *** *** ***********.

****** **** ** ****’* support ** ******* * proposal, ****** *** ******** opportunities ******* ** ********** facial *********** (**** **********):

*** ***** **** ***** a ******* *** *** opportunities *** **** **** of **********. * ***** we ****** ******* **** with ********. **** *****’* mean ** ****** ********** carte *******, *** **** it **** ** ***, like *******, ** **** it *** **********

**********

******’* ***** *** ********** make ***** ***** *** rise ** ****** *********** use. ****’** * **** reminder **** *** **********'* status ******* ***** ** legal * **** **** in **** ** ******, as **** ******* ***** to **** **** "*********** public ********" ***** *** their *** *******.

***** **** *** **** the ********** ******* ******* all ********** **** ***** the ********** ** ****** them *** ***** ** do **, ******** ******** should *** ***** *********.

Vote / ****

Comments (10)

****** *********** **** **** appropriately *** ***** ********** to **** ****** *** law *********** *******. ** technology ** **** **** improves, **** ** ****** we ***** ** **** point ******** ****** * white **** *** **** potentially * ***** **** system ** *** ***** alarm ********, ***, ** reduce ***** ****** *** bane ** **** ******* stations  *** ***, ** potentially ******** *  **** intruder.  ** ****** **** would ** ********** *** the ********** ****** ******** the ******** *** *** for *** **** ********. In **** ********* *** latter  ***** ********** **** to ** ********* *** could ** ********* ******, time ****** *** ********* particularly *** *** ***********. 

** ****** **** ***** be ********** *** *** legitimate ****** ******** *** location *** *** *** the **** ********.

*****, *** **** *** make ** '********** *** the ********** ******' '*** not *** *** **** intruder'? * ** ********** to ********** ** ** general. *** *******, ** I ** ** * store *** ** * 'opt ***' ** *** system? * *** **** them ***'* *** ** on * ********* *** I ***** ***** ** mistakenly ******* ** ******* on * *********, **?

*** **********, **’* ***** to ** ********* ** regulate ** ************ ********** open ** *** ****** but *** ** ** controlled ************ **** ** a ****, ****** ** yard ******* ** *******. Technology ** **** **** things **** ******** *** example ***** *** *** a ***** **** *** name ** *** ****** in *** ***** **** any ***** ***** ***** with *** **** ****** in **,  *** ******** works ** ***. *** we *** *** ** the **** ***** **** alarm ******* ***** ******* to  * ***,  *** alarm ******** **** ****’* of ****** * ***, he **** * *****, but ***’* **** *** difference ******* **** ***** or ********, *** ******** could. * ***** **** would ** **** **** stop *** ***** ******** calling *** ****** ******* it ***** ** *** guy ** * **** guy. *** *** ***** however **** ********** *** more *********** *** ******* consideration ***** ** ****** on *** ** ***** them, **** *** ***** circumstance ***** **** ** be ********, **** ***** into ************* ***, **** would **** ** *********** to ******** *** ******** not **********. 

**** *********** ******** ***** pictures ******* ***** ** a ***** *******, ******** the ***** *** ** it ******* ***** ***** it **** ******* ** to * ********. ** the **** ** *** person ********* ** *** image ** *** ***** in *** ******** **** no ****** ** ***** and **** ** ****** is ****** ** *** person *** *** ********* at * **** ** a ****** **** *** this **** ** ********. In *** ******* ******, I ***** *** **** important ***** ** ** regulate *** *** **** what ******* * ****** can ***** *** ********. Any ***** ***** *** already ******** ** *** video ******* ** *** system.

** *** **** ** the ****** ********* ** the ***** ** *** found ** *** ******** then ** ****** ** taken *** **** ** damage ** ****** ** the ****** *** *** surprised ** * **** by * ****** **** has **** **** ** analysis.

****, *** ******* ** when *** ****** ***** a *******. ***'* *** you *** * **** into * ***** *** the ****** *********** ******* us ** ******* *** picture / ******** ** a ***** ******** *** then ** *** ******** / ********, ***.

***** ******* **** **** mistakes, **** *** '****' of ****. *** ******* becomes *** ** *** handle ***** ******** ******* damaging *** ***** ** innocent ******. **** ** you ***** ***** ****?

**, **** **** ***** !

*****, * ***** **** is **** ***** ********** and ******* ******* ** police ** ******/******* ******** when ** ************** ******.

* *****, **** ** talk ***** **** ******* or ***** ********, ** should *** *** **** technology *** ***** **. Even ** ** **** to ***** *, * or * ******* ** your ** ** **** to **** **** ** authority. ** ******, *** actions ****** ** ******* and *** ** ******* our ***** **** **** necessary. 

** *** ****** ** detained ** ******** ******* of **** ** ****** !!! ** ****** ******* more ******** ************* ** authorities. ** ****** *** system **** ** ***** help *** **** ** investigation *******! 

*** *** * *** it, *****'* * ********** between ******** ****-**** ************** and *******. ***********, *****'* an ***** ** ******** large ************ ** **** based ** **** - still - ********** ****.

* ***'* **** ***** recorded **** * **** - ****** ** - but * ***'*. ** there's ** ********, *** involving **, *** *** staff **** ** ** the *******. ** ******* with **** ******.

** *** ****** ** looking *** * *********, and **** **** * couple ** ********, *** run ** ********* ****** which ********* ****** ***********, I ***** ****** **** there ***** ** * number ** ***** *********. Those ***** (*********) ** quicklydismissed ** *** ********.********* ********* *** **** to *** ****** ******* up, *** * ******'* have * ******* **** that ******. **** ** no ********* **** * person ****** ** *** on *** **** *** calling *** **** ****** that * **** **** the ******** **** **** saw. *** * ***'* want *** ***** ** cache *** ****** *******, or **** **** **** of ******** ***** ******* about ** *** ****** ("Male, ** ***** ***, Excited, ** ***")

** * ****** **** the ********, * ***** even ****** ** **** popping ** ** * screen ***** ** ******** real-time **********. ** *** data ** *********** *********, and *** ****** *** ages ** **** ******, unsecured *** ******.

*** ******* **** ******************** **** ** **** some ****** ***** ** abuse **. **** ***** stalking **-***********, ***********, *** celebrities, **** *** * hot ***** *** ***, and **** ***** ********* through *** ******** ** see ** *** *** a *********, **** ******* and ** **.

*** ***** ******* ** that *** *** **** some ******* *****, *** like **** ****** ***, the ****** *********** ****** erroneously ****** ** ***. If **** "***" ** published ** ****** *****, the ************ ***** ** dramatic. **** ** ***'** totally *******, *****'* ***** to ** ****** *** will ***** **** *** probably ************.*************, *** *********** ** innocence ** *** ********* the ******* ********** ********** to - *** ****** certainly *** ** *** crime ******** ********. ** your ****** ** ** jeopardy *** (*********, * human ******* **** ****** the **** ********, *** that *****'* ******* ********** the ********** ** ** happening *** **).

** **** ****, * am *** *** **********, but * **** ****** faith ** ****** *** meaningful ********** ***** ****.

** ***** **** ***  

***** ******** **** *********** camera ** ******** ** an *** *** **** concerns *** ****. *** using ******* *** **** good ***** ****** ***** and **** ****** ***** export ********** *** ******* operators *** *** ******* the ******** *****. *** can ***** ***** ** faces ******** **** ** admin. **** *** **** can *** **** ******* to *** **** *** boss ** ****** ** office ** ***** ******** interest. 

****, * ***** **** restricting ****** ** ******* but ** ***** **** the ******** - **** if ***** ****** *********** users ** ***? ** you ******** **? ** you ******* ** ** law?

*** **** *** **** the ******** ** **** if *** **** ***** to ******* ********* ** customers */** ***** **********?

** ** *****, **** can ** **** **** conventional ***** ************ ******* ************ ********* **** ****** ***********, you *** ********** *** process.

*** **** **** ****** / *** ************** *****, e.g.,**** **** ********* ********* video:

****'* *** **** ** misusing **** **** ** technology?

**** ******** ******** *********. In ***** ** ********* and ******* ******** ***** you **** ******* *****. Using ***/***** *** *** ot ******* ***** ***** anything *** ******. 

***, *** ***** ** analytics *** *** ******** share ***** ****** **** you ** *******/******** **** is *** **********? ****** we *** *** ************ systems? **, **** ******** are *** ********* ** FR *** ********* ** surveillance *******. 

 

********* ***/******, ** **** are **** *** ********** not *** ****** ** persons **** ******/**-***** *** only *** ********** ******* like ****** ******* * think *** ** *** mind. 

* ****** ***/*****/*** *** not ********* **** **** of ********** !! *** because ***** ******** ****** it *****’* **** **** we **** ** *** all ***** **** *** give *** **** **********  

 

* ****** *** *** we ***** ***** **** LPR ** ***** ** open *** ******* *** not ** ********* ***** personal ****? **** ******* it ** **** *******?

 

 

 

 

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 6,810 reports, 914 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports