Ranking Video Analytic Architectures

Author: IPVM Team, Published on May 13, 2016

Video analytics may be implemented in a number of fundamentally different ways. Many ask: Which one is best? Each has important tradeoffs. Moreover, in our experience, some are far more likely to be accurate as well as simpler to deploy.

Below, we rank and analyze five fundamental approaches (alphabetically):

  • Add-On camera analytics
  • Analytics appliance / encoder
  • Cloud analytics
  • Embedded camera analytics
  • Embedded DVR / NVR / VMS analytics
  • Server based analytics

We also look at recent advancements in video analytics and what may be available in the future.

Let's start with a review of each approach:

***** ********* *** ** *********** ** * ****** ** ************* different ****. **** ***: ***** *** ** ****? **** *** important *********. ********, ** *** **********, **** *** *** **** likely ** ** ******** ** **** ** ******* ** ******.

*****, ** **** *** ******* **** *********** ********** (**************):

  • ***-** ****** *********
  • ********* ********* / *******
  • ***** *********
  • ******** ****** *********
  • ******** *** / *** / *** *********
  • ****** ***** *********

** **** **** ** ****** ************ ** ***** ********* *** what *** ** ********* ** *** ******.

***'* ***** **** * ****** ** **** ********:

[***************]

Add-On ****** *********

**** ** **?********* ******** ** ****** **** ** ** ******. ***** ** analyzed ****** *** ****** *** ******/****** *** **** ** *** systems *** ******* / **********.

**********

  • *********** ** **** *** ****** ***** ******* *** ***** ** run ********* **.
  • ******* ** ****** ********* ****** ************ ****** **** ***** ****** into * ******** ****** ******.
  • **-****** ********** ******* ****** ******** ************

*************

  • **** * ******* ** ************* ********* ******* ****, **** ******* Axis. *****, *** ********* ****** * ******* *** **** ********* by **** *******.
  • ********* *** ********* *** ********* *** *** ******** ****** *****.
  • **** ****** **** *** ******** ****** *** ** ********** **** one's ***

****: ****** ***** **** ***** ********* ******* ***** * *******. We ********. ***** ** *** **** *********, **** ** ********* not * *** *******. *** ******* ** ****** *** ***** stream *** ** ***** ******* ****** ** ********* *** ******* using ***** ********* **** *** **** * *** **********.

**** ********* *** ******** ** ****?***** **, ***** **********.

Analytics *********/*******

**** ** **?******** ******** ** ****** ***** ********* *** ******** ****** *********. A ********* ******** ****** ******* ******** ******** ******** ** ***** stream **** * ******.

**********

  • ********* ******* ******** ********* *** ***** ***** **** ******-***** *********.
  • ****** *****/*********** *** ** ******** ******.
  • *** *** ********-***** ********* ** ******* **** ** *** **** the *********/******* ** *** **-***** *********.

*************

  • ****** **** ******** ** ***-** ** ******** *********, *** ** being ********* ********.
  • ***** **** ******* *** ************.
  • *** ** **** ********* ** ************ *** ** *** ** camera ****** *** ********* ******.

**** ********* *** ******** ** ****?******** (******),*** (******).

Cloud *********

**** ** **?***** ** **** ** * ***** ******* ******** *** ********.

**********

  • ****** *** ** ********** ****, **** ******* * '*******' ***** stream ***.
  • ***** ******** ***** *********** ** ******* ***** ******* ****** ** add ************ ** ******** **-****.
  • ***** ********* *** ***** **** **** ** ***** **** ** them ** ******* ***** ********* ***********.

*************

  • ******** ********* ** **** ***** ******** ** *** *****, ***** is ***** ******* / *********, ********** ** **** ******* **** a **** *** ***** ****
  • *** ** *********, ********* ******* ******* ****
  • ******* ****** ** ********* *** ******** ****

** *** ****** (******* ****** ****), **** ** ****** ** become * **** ****** ******, **** **** *********.

**** ********* *** ******** ** ****?******* ***** ***,*****,**** ***

Embedded ****** *********

**** ** **?*** ************ ******** *** ************* * ****** **** ***** *** embedded ***** *********.

**********

  • ***********: ************ *** ******** *********** ** ******** ****** ********, ******** and ******.
  • ********** ** *****: ** **** ** ******* ******** ******** ** new ********.
  • ********** ** ************/*******: ***** * ****** ****** ** ****** ****, easier ** *** ***** ******* ***** **** ** *****.
  • ******** ** *** ******* ** ******** *** *******.
  • **-****** ********** ******* ****** ******** ************

*************

  • ******* ** * ******* ** ********* **** ***** ****.
  • ****** **-*** ******** '*******' *******.
  • * *** ***** ************* **** ***** ******** ****** ********* "*********" which ** ********** *** ****** ** *******.

*** ** **** ****** ********* **** *********?

****** *********-**** ******* **** **** **** *** ********** *** *****, generally * ******/**** *** * *********** *********. **** ******** ****** detection ******* *** ** ** *** ** ************ * ****** tripline-style *****.

**** ********* **** **** ********-***** *****, **** ** *********, ********* of ******, ** ****** ******* ****** ******. **** ********* **** also ****** *** *********** ****** **** ****** ** **** ** the *****, ************* **** * ******* **** ****** **** ** smaller **** * ****** ***, *** ****** *********** ***********. **** true ********* ******* **** **** ****** *******, ******* **** ***** can ** ******* **** ** ******, ** **** ** ********.

**** ********* *** ******** ** ****?*** **** ***** ********* ******** ** ******* - ********, ****, Bosch, ****/*******/*****, **********.

*** ****** ********* ******** ** ***** ********* - **** *** Samsung ***** ******.

Embedded ***/*** *********

**** ** **?********* ******** ** ***-****** ** * ***/*** ********* ** ****** VMS ********. ************** ****** ******* ***/** **** ** ********* *** their ******* *******.

**********

  • ****** *****: ** ******* ** *****, ** ********** ******** ** install *** ** **** ** ********* **** ******** ********
  • ********** *******: ******* *** ********* *** **** ** *** ******** solution, ********* *** ********'* ****** ******** ****** ********** ******, ****** and/or ********* ******.

*************

  • ******** ******: ******* *** ******** ******** **** *** **** *** quality ** *************** ** *** ******* *********, ** ****** ******** its *********** *** ****** ******** ******.
  • ***** **** ** *******: ***** ********** ******** ** **** **** H.264 ******* ***** ************* ******* ****** ** ***** ******* ****.
  • *********** ***********: ********** ** *** ** ***/*** **********, *** ********* may **** *********** ************ ** ***** *********** ** ******* *********.
  • ********* *** ******: *********, ***** **** ***** ** ********* *** numerous ******* *** ******* **** * ******** ** *****. ********* to ****** **** ** *** *********.

**** ********* *** ******** ** ****?*******, ***.

Server ***** *********

**** ** **?********* ******** ** ****** ** * **/****** **** ** ******** from *** ********/*** ***** ****. ***** ** ******** ** ** the ****** *** ******/****** *** ********* ** *** ********'* ****** or **** **** ** * *** ** **** ******.

**********

  • ****** **** ********* ** *** ****** ** *** ********* ********* inside ******* *** ********* (***** ** ***** *******).
  • ********** *** ****** *** **** ** ** ******** ****** ********** of *** ******* ** ********* ******* ** *********.

*************

  • ******** ****** ******* ***** ** ********, ********* ******** ******* ** many ******* **** *** *********
  • ********* ******* ********* - *** ****** ***** ** ********** ****** from *** ******
  • ******: ******* **** ******** * *** ****** *** *** ******** is *****, **** ***** ** ** *** **** ****** ********.
  • ******** ******: ******* *** ******** ******** **** *** **** *** quality ** *************** ** *** ******* *********, ** ****** ******** performance *** ****** ******** ******.
  • **********: ******* * *** ****** ***** ** ** *** *** integration **** * *** ** **** ***** ** ** *****, this *** ** ***** **** ********* ** *** **.
  • *********** ******* *******: ********** ******/*********** *** ****-**** ****** ***** *** not ** ********* *** *** *** *********

**** ********* *** ******** ** ****?***** ****, ***********, ***, ********

Rating ***** ******** *************

*** ***** **** ***** ******** ****** ********* ** ***** *** most ******** ******* ***********, **** ********* ********** ******** ******* *********** when **** **** ******* *******.

** **** ***** ********* ************* ** *** ********* *****, ******* in **** **** ** * **** ** ***** *** *** absolute:

  1. ******** ********* - ******* *****, ***** ****, ********* ****** *********** but ****** ****** *** ********** ** ** *********.
  2. ********* ********** - **** *********** ** *******, *** ****** *****.
  3. ***-** ********* - ********* ****** ***********, *** ******* ******* *******.
  4. ***/*** ********* - ****** *****, ******** ********** **** ***. ***** lower ***********.
  5. ******-***** ********* - ******** ****** ***********. ****** ** ** ******* cost, ******* ***** *** *** ******* *********** ***** **** ***.

****: ***** *** ******* **** **** *******, ** ** ** too ***** *** ******* ** ********* *** *** **** ** bad ** **.

***** **** ******* ***** ******* ******, ***** *** ***** ** video ********* *****, *** *** ******** *** **** ************ ** reliable ***********. *** ****** **** *** ******* **** ***** ********* works. * ******* **** ***** ** ****** *** ******** **** most ** *** **** **** ****** *** ********** ***.

**** ********** *******, ***** (** *************) **** ***** ***** ********* on ******* *****. ***** ***** ** *********, ***** ******** **** should **** ** ********* (**: ** ******** ****** **** ******** 500' *****, *** **** **** ** **' **** ********** ***** of **** *** ** **** ****** **** ** ******** ****** with * ***' *****, *** * ***' **** ***** ** view). ***** ****** **** ******** ******* ********* ********** ***** ** their ***********, ** **** ***** ** ** ********* ** ******* >500' ***** ************ ** *** **** ** ***** ** ****, snow, ***, **** ******, ** ***** *******.

************, ***** ***** ********* ****** ** **********. ** ********* * 500' ********* ***** ***** ** *** **** ** * **** number ** ***** ******, *** ****** *** *** ** ** unreliable *******.

Recent ******* *** ************

***** ********* *** ******** ************ **** **** ********** ****** *********** over *** **** ******* *****.

**** ******* ***** ******* ***** ** ****-****-********* **********, *** *** few ******* **** ****** ****** ********** ****** *** *** ****** 2MP (****: ***** **** ********* ******* *** ******** **** ** 4K ** ****** ***********, **** ****** **** ****** *** *****, this ** ******** ** *** **** **** ****** ******** **** does *** ******** ***** * ***** **********).

****** ********* ******* ****** ********** *******, ******* ***** ******** *** humans ** "******" *** **** ********** ******* ******* ******* ("***/***** vehicle", "*****/***** *******"). ***** ***** ** ****** *******, **** ** "boat", "*******", "********", "******", "********", "***", ***. *** ****.

************ **** ********* **** ** *** **** ** **** ** deployment *** *************, **** ********* **** ******* *** *****/*** ********* auto-calibration ** ****** ***** **********.

****** ******** *** ********, **** ******* ****** ****-**** ******* ********** power **** ******, ***** **** **** ******** ** ***-** ********* even **** *********.

**** *** **** * *****, ** ****************** *** *********** ** ***** ********* *** ******** ************ ** improve *************. *** *******, ******** ********** ******** ***** ********* ********* ***** ********** *** ******-******* **********. ****-******* ******* ************ are **** ********* ******* ******** ** ****-**** ***** ********** *** object **************. ***, **** *** *** *****, ***** **** ******* with **** **-***** ********** ***** **** **** ***** ********* **** viable.

[****: **** **** *** ********** ******* ** **** *** ************* re-written ** **** ** ******* ******** ************ ********** ** ****** side ********* *** ***** *********.]

Comments (16)

Great breakdown of a high overview look at the state of today's analytics. Wish I knew more of what I know today just 4 years ago.

I would be very interested to see the changes on the report 2011- current. The development since 2011 has not been nearly as advanced as a lot of us thought it would be by now. I can only assume it is due to the big players in the industry not putting more money in the R&D sector, and at the same time litigating patents. Or it could just be a lot harder than it looks!

Jeremy,

The main change, in terms of new analytic areas, was for cloud analytics. We changed a lot to make the report clearer and more detailed but the fundamental analytic options and features have not changed much otherwise.

I agree with you that it has been a combination of factors that have held the analytics market back. Things seem to be on the upswing now though starting from a very depressed base.

Cloud analytics have an additional dimension. Credible reports suggest that at least federal investigations are able to access cloud resources and data without any notification to the user/customer. Retaining data locally has the advantage that (non-hacking) access requires serving a warrant to the holding organization. Such early awareness may be important to addressing critical issues within an organization. Whether or not this should be a meaningful consideration for most businesses, must be determined by the companies themselves.

So you think analytic advances will not "hockey stick" up, due to big brother being tapped into the cloud? So if they do figure out how to do it better, cheaper, and extremely accurate in the cloud...you will not participate due to "federal investigations"? That's rich.

Avigilon claims it has "Self-Learning Video Analytics" attempts to use the self-learning (30 true, 30 false) has not produced any demonstrative better results to eliminate false positives. For example false positives from "ballons on car dealerships". If it did work - no path to copy it from one camera/ appliance to extend the effort invested. Technical support doesn't seem to know how to use it. No documentation/ case study available. Is this just marketing hype?

Some clarification on how Avigilon's analytics learn/work.

In normal mode, the self-learning is automatic and continuous. It only learns based on observing human activity. Vehicle activity doesn't do anything to assist with learning, and if the scene is mostly idle the learning process will take longer than a busy scene.

The teach-by-example process of marking True and False is optional and mostly intended for challenging or odd situations. In a "good" environment you shouldn't have to do any teach-by-example marking of events.

The reason you can't copy analytics learning/data from one device to another is because every scene is different. For just about any object-classification analytics device, the system is attempting to establish an understanding of ground area, where the horizon is, mounting height/angle, and lens AoV. This is so that it can develop a set of expectations about how/where objects should appear in the field of view, and roughly how large/small objects should be in different areas.

If you copied calibration data from one camera to the next the odds are very high that you'd make things worse because the geometry of the scene would be quite different.

An exception to the above rule would be thermal cameras mounted around the perimeter of a site at equal distances. If the thermal cameras are all the same model, they'll have the same fixed lenses, and if the mounting height and tilt angles are pretty close you could potentially get by with copying calibration data from one unit to the next.

For Avigilon analytics specifically, if you have scenes where you are getting a lot of false alarms the problem is often traced back to a lack of good observable human activity in the scene. If you're using a Rialto (IP or Analog), the problem can also be lack of good input video, meaning that there may be noise or other problems in the video stream (poor contrast, low framerate) that impair the analytics from "seeing" what is really there.

Thanks,

However, my issue is false positives on balloons, streamers and banners - with 50,000 objects in the database, what is the problem with Avigilon adding few more? (Didn't I see a marketing piece that it was 250K now?). This has been an issue on every car dealership with every camera, encoder made by Videoiq/ Avigilon in the last 4 years. The triggers are in broad daylight in HD. It is the single biggest source (1000s per week)of false positives at our monitoring station.

I am a little skeptical that the Avigilon lab is real world enough to take analytics to the next level. Can you elaborate the process of how Avigilon goes about improving its analytics?

2, that's a good question. I've forwarded it to Avigilon for comment. Can I share your contact info with them as they may want to speak offline?

Brian certainly knows many things about the VideoIQ / Avigilon analytics but, for current product performance details (like handling balloons, etc.), it would be more appropriate and accurate for Avigilon to comment directly.

Sure,

I also extend an invitation for their analytics engineering group to visit during a shift at our monitoring station when the sites are armed. We are just a 20 minute drive from their factory in Richmond, B.C.

Wouldn't an additional advantage of add-on camera analytics be that you are spreading the processing workload across multiple devices? In my experience you can save significantly on your server needs.

Yes, that is a good point, I'll update the report to make that clear.

Thanks very much for considering my suggestion on updating this article. As I look on the research side, there is no clear methodology that may significantly improve VA without incurring into a large computational cost.

I am waiting to see what is presented at the http://avss2016.org/ conference. I hope we start seeing some paper on deep learning methods.

It is/will be enough to have Tegra K1/X1 or Snapdragon 820 on board of let's say a camera to add solution based on the artificial neural network. In case of server side solutions it is also possible to either use something like Tesla for multi-channel processing or use multiple custom GPU boards (that can also be based on Tegra K1 or even consumer boards). Thus for sure it will add to hardware cost but if Qualcomm will be serious with their Zeroth project then we will get access to the reasonably priced SoCs.

Other than AVSS I can recommend to check http://www.gputechconf.com/

In your assessment of analytics architectures, it seem you have omitted the option of selecting a VMS that has integrated analytics. In your suggestions of what server based analytics is, I assume you are including a VMS and then integrating a 3rd party analytics solution to go with it. I agree that this would require said 3rd party to have its own HW and SW which would add to the cost, but with a VMS that has its own analytics, you would reduce that cost substantially. I may have missed something, but that's what I get from your article....

  1. Embedded Analytics - Simpler setup, lower cost, generally strong performance but beware camera VMD pretending to be analytics.
  2. Analytics Appliances - More flexibility of cameras, but higher costs.
  3. Add-On Analytics - Generally strong performance, but overall limited choices.
  4. DVR/VMS Analytics - Simple setup, directly integrated with VMS. Often lower performance.
  5. Server-Based Analytics - Greatest design flexibility. Likely to be highest cost, complex setup and can present integration risks with VMS.
Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

The IP Camera Lock-In Trend: Meraki and Verkada on Jan 18, 2019
Open systems and interoperability have not only been big buzzwords over the past decade, but they have also become core features of video...
Mobile Surveillance Trailers Guide on Jan 17, 2019
Putting cameras in a place for temporary surveillance where power and communications are not readily available can be complicated and expensive....
Testing Bandwidth Vs. Low Light on Jan 16, 2019
Nighttime bandwidth spikes are a major concern in video surveillance. Many calculate bandwidth as a single 24/7 number, but bit rates vary...
Access Control Cabling Tutorial on Jan 15, 2019
Access Control is only as reliable as its cables. While this aspect lacks the sexiness of other components, it remains a vital part of every...
Avigilon Favorability Results 2019 on Jan 15, 2019
Since IPVM's 2017 Avigilon favorability results, the company was acquired by Motorola and has shifted from being an aggressive startup to a more...
Gorilla Technology AI Provider, Raises $15 Million, Profiled on Jan 15, 2019
Gorilla Technology is a Taiwanese video analytics manufacturer that recently announced a $15 million investment from SBI Group, saying this...
Pelco Favorability Results 2019 on Jan 11, 2019
Pelco had a significant favorability problem amongst integrators in our previous study (see 2016 Pelco results). Now, in the first edition of our...
Bad: Dahua Villa Video Doorbell Tested on Jan 11, 2019
Doorbells are one of the hottest segments in the residential market but Dahua's Villa Video Doorbell is the worst we have tested.   We bought and...
Winter 2019 IP Networking Course on Jan 10, 2019
Today is the last day to register for the Winter 2019 IP Networking course. This is the only networking course designed specifically for video...
NTP / Network Time Guide For Video Surveillance on Jan 10, 2019
Inaccurate time can lead to missing or inadmissible video, yet this topic is often overlooked, with cameras and servers left defaulted,...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Cable Trenching for Surveillance on Jan 21, 2019
Trenching cable for surveillance is surprisingly complex. While using shovels, picks, and hoes is not advanced technology, the proper planning,...
Milestone Favorability Results 2019 on Jan 21, 2019
Milestone's favorability moderately strengthed, in new IPVM integrator statistics over their results from 2016. While the industry has been...
Intersec 2019 Live Day 1 - Massive China Presence on Jan 21, 2019
There’s a massive presence from Chinese or China-focused video surveillance firms, chiefly Hikvision, Dahua, Huawei, and Infinova, at...
The IP Camera Lock-In Trend: Meraki and Verkada on Jan 18, 2019
Open systems and interoperability have not only been big buzzwords over the past decade, but they have also become core features of video...
NYPD Refutes False SCMP Hikvision Story on Jan 18, 2019
The NYPD has refuted the SCMP Hikvision story, the Voice of America has reported. On January 11, 2018, the SCMP alleged that the NYPD was using...
Mobile Surveillance Trailers Guide on Jan 17, 2019
Putting cameras in a place for temporary surveillance where power and communications are not readily available can be complicated and expensive....
Exacq Favorability Results 2019 on Jan 17, 2019
Exacq favorability amongst integrators has declined sharply, in new IPVM statistics, compared to 2017 IPVM statistics for Exacq. Now, over 5 since...
Testing Bandwidth Vs. Low Light on Jan 16, 2019
Nighttime bandwidth spikes are a major concern in video surveillance. Many calculate bandwidth as a single 24/7 number, but bit rates vary...
Access Control Records Maintenance Guide on Jan 16, 2019
Weeding out old entries, turning off unused credentials, and updating who carries which credentials is as important as to maintaining security as...
UK Fines Security Firms For Illegal Direct Marketing on Jan 16, 2019
Two UK security firms have paid over $200,000 in fines for illegally making hundreds of thousands of calls to people registered on a government...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact