Hytera Alleged Did Not Need Stolen Motorola IP

By Isabella Cheng, Published Jun 15, 2021, 09:52am EDT

Hytera alleged it did not need stolen Motorola IP to launch its first DMR radio. Instead, the company maintains it had done "all the hard work" before the "villains" arrived, and the product launch was actually delayed due to the "villains" attempts to "cut a corner".

IPVM Image

In this report, IPVM examines Hytera's argument as well as testimony from a Hytera expert witness.

This is the second post in a series of reports explaining the Motorola Solutions v. Hytera US court case. For background on Hytera and the lawsuit, see Hytera Company Profile and Hytera Blames "Villains" for Stealing Motorola IP.

****** *** "**% ** the *** *****"

****** *******, ***** ******* *********, **** *** ******* had * *** ******* that *** "**% ** the *** *****" ****** G.S. *** ******* **** Motorola:

***'* ** ** *** September **** ** ****** 2008 *********, ***** ****** the **** ****** *** right ****** *** **** that ***** ***** **** Motorola **** ****. **** continue, ****** ********* ** work ** *** ***********. They ******** ** ******** the *******. *** **** get ** *****75 ******* ** *** *** there when G.S. is hired. [emphasis added]

*******, ****** ********* "**** convinced" **** ***** **** "gotten *** *** *** there" ******* *** **** from ********:

*** **** *** * prototype *******, *** **** were ** ******* ** the *** *****, *** they **** *********, ****'** come *** **** *** they ***** **** ****** all *** *** *****. They ****'* **** *** help **** ********.

*******, *** * "********" stole ******** *********** *** unnecessarily ******** ******'* *** product ******* **** **** not ******** **** *** existing *******:

***** ***** **** ********'* bad ******, **** **** in. **** *** ***** information **** ****, *** they *** * ****** here *** ***** *** they *** ***** ****** at ******. ** *** at ****** *** *** wiser.

Hytera "********" ************* ******* **** ****** ** ***

******** ****** ******* *** a ********* "**%" ** the *** ***** ****** the "********" *******, ****** claims *** "********" ************* removed *** **** **** and *********** ********. *** changes **** ****** **** expected, ***** ** *** the "********" **** **** Motorola **** ** "*** corners," ********* ********'* ******* *********:

*******, ***, *.*., *.*., they **** **** *******. They ***, ** **** to **** *** ******* cost * ****** **** so ** *** **** some **** *****. ** want ** *** ** a ****** **** ******** architecture, *****. **** ****** the ****** * ****.

** ******* ** ******: You **** ****, *** bad. ** ****'* ***** it *** ***** ** take **** ****. ***** it ****'* **** * good ****. ******* ** saying **** *** ****** up ** **, **** this ** ***** ** take * *** **** months **** ********, **** pull **** **** *** of ***** ********* ** whatever **** ******* ** in *** *** ** for ***** *********, *** carrier ******, *** *******, things **** **** **** in ****** * **** time, ****** **** *** in ***** ****** ****** that *** ****** ****** have ***** ******, *****.It *** ******* *******, *** **** *** ** *** ***** *******, *** *** *******'*. [emphasis added]

******'* ****** *********** ********, ****** *** ********, ******* ***-*** ***** company *** ****** ***** of *** ********* ******* group ** ****** ***********,************* ~*% ** ******'* source **** *** ****** from ******** ****** **** files. ******, *** ******** to ****** *** **** and ** ********** *** software ******** ** *** copying:

[******'* ********] *. ** where *** ****, *** 4 -- *** ******* 4 ******* ** ******'* source **** **** *** copied **** ******** ****** code *****, ***** *** that **** ****? **** there **** ****** **** took ***** **** *** Chia *** *.*. *** showed ** **** ******** in **** * *******?

*. ***. ** **** my ****** ** **** happened ******* *** ************* I've ****, ***** ****two *********** ****** **** ******** ** **** ***. The first was the decision ** ****** *** **** and move that into the DSP. That resulted in some use of code that was packaged into the library files that we've heard about. The second reason was a ******** ** **-********* *** ********, so to reorganize some of it. And that resulted in some additional source code files being used as well. [emphasis added]

Motorola **** ***** ****** "** **** **** * ******" ** ****

***** ****** *** *** FPGA *** ************ ********, Motorola **** **** ***** Hytera "** **** **** 6 ****** ** ****," Hytera's ****** ******* ****, assuming ** ********* **** working ** *** *******. He ******** **** "* portion" ** *** "***** bit" "**** ******** ***********." However, ** **** **** Motorola *********** ***** ****** not **** **** *** months ** ******:

*. *** **** *** piece ***** ****, * portion ** **** ***** bit, **** ******* ** thata ******* ** **** **** ******** ***********?

*.Yeah, * **** ***** ******. [emphasis added]

*. *** **** ***** result -- ****** ***** the ******** ***********, ** would **** ***** ******, in **** *******, ***** six **** ****** ** development ****?

*. ****, *'** **** no **** **** *** months ******* * ***** this ** ***** -- I've **** ***** ******** in ****** ****.

****** ***** **** ************** its *** ****-***** *** in ****** ****, ** the ******, ******'* ****** witness ******. *******, ****** ultimately ******** *** ***-**** DMR ********, **** ******** code, ** ***** ****. According ** *** ****** witness, **** ** ****** had ***** *** *** FPGA *** *********** *** software, ******* ******** ****'* help, * ************ ********* product ***** **** **** launched ** ******/********* ****:

*. ** ** ***** to ********** *** **** product **** *** ********, but ******* ***** ******** information, *** ***** **** would **** ** ********** 6 ******?

*. ***, * ****** elapsed.

*. ** *** ** all ***** **** ******** through ***** ******** ***********, through *** ******* ** G.S. ***, *** ****, Y.T. ***, ***** *****, that ******** ** *********** a * ***** **** start?

*. ****, ** **** 6 ******, ****.

Hytera *** "*** *** **** ****"

****** ****** **** *** company *** "*** *** hard ****" ****** *** G.S. *** *** *** others ******* ** ******, and *** ******* **** G.S. *** **** **** had ******* ******** *** R&D *****. ******'* ****** witness ********* "*** *** hard ****" *** **** completed ** ****** ****** the "********" ****** **:

*. *** *****. ** you've ********* **** *** looked ** **** ** where ****** *** ** before *** -- *.*. Kok, *** ****, *.*., Peiyi ****** **.

*. ***.

*. ** *** **** -- ***** *** **** get **?

*. ** *** ***** I've **** ** -- the **** ***** ** that **** ****** ** against **** **** *****. So **** ******** **** hardware *** ******** **** worked **** * ******** radio. *** **** -- you ****, **** ** knowledge ** ***, **** shows **** ***** *** foundation ** * *****. And *** *** **** was ***** ** ** was ****** **********.They [******] **** ***** *** *** **** ****. [emphasis added]

******* ****** *******, ********* Sun *******, *** *** the ****** *** *&* team ******** ** **** until ** ****** ** over ** *.*. *** in *** ***************** ** ******* ****, before *** ** *** "villains" *** ****** ******, the ******* *** ******** the "**** **** ******** of ***," ********* * prototype:

* **** ** **** [a ****** ** *** Chen ** ******* ****] talking *****?

* ** **** **** the **** **** ******** of *** **** ** have ** *** *** standard *** **** ******** and ** ************ ********** with ********.

* *** ** **** that **** **** **** interoperability ***** **** **** were **********?

* ***. **** ********* can ******* *********** **** each *****.

* *** **** **** to ******* ***** *****, at ***** ***** *****, data ******* ********, ************** in ******** *****? * Yes. *******, ***** **** certain *************** **** ***** cannot *********** **** **** each *****. *** *** majority ** *** *************** could ************ *******.

** ******* ******* **** October ****, ********* *** had ******* **** "*** company's *** *******'* ********** pre-research *** *********** ** nearing **********":

** *** ** *** important ******** ** *** company's ****** ********, *** DMR *******'* ********** ***-******** and *********** ** ******* completion. *** ************ ** many *** ************, *** interoperability **** ******** ********* and *** ******* ********** of ************* ******* ** such **** ******* ** to *** *** **** of ***'* ******** *********** research *** *********** ** TDMA *** ********.

********* *** **** ****** that ** *** **** he *** "****** **** the ************ ********* ** G.S. *** ** *** of ****," *&* *** already **** *********:

* ** ** *** time *** ****** **** the ************ *********, *** handheld *********** ** *.*. Kok ** *** ** 2008, ** *** ******* that *** *&* *** complete?

* ** *** ******* been *********. * **** concise ** ******* **** frame *** **** ** completed *** *&* **** at *** *** ** 2007.

** ********* *** *** continued ** **** ** conventional *** *********, ** says *** **** ***** have ******** * ******* by *** ***** ******* of ****, ******* "*** commercialization **** ** *** very *********":

* ***, ** *** hadn't ***** ** ** R&D *** **** * DMR, ***** *** *** your **** **** ********* the ***************** ******* ** your ******** ****** **** both ** **** *** OMAP ****?

* ** ****** ** could. *** *** ***************** work ** *** **** difficult, *** ****** *** many ***** ** ********** doing *****************.

* *** **** ******** launch **** ***** **** been ****?

* *** ***** ******* of ****.

********* **** "********" **** Hytera * "*******" ** Developing ***-*** ******

*** * "********" **** Hytera * "*******" ** the ***-*** ***** *********** process, ** ********* ** Hytera ******* **** ****** his*** **** **********. ** ****** ****** realized ****** *** ********* period *** *** ***** that ******'* *** ****** have **** **** ** be ******** ******* ******* the "********":

*: ** *** *** item **, ** ****:"******** claims **** ****** **** a '********' ** *** development ******* ** ********* Motorola ********* *********** ********** by ****** ****, *.*. Kok *** *.*. ***. Does ****** ******* ***** any ***** ** ****?"

*: * ***** **'* another *** ******. **'* the ********.I ***** **** **** ** * **** ***. I mean, until last year we realized actually we should be able to release DMR earlier. They were trying to solve the problem they created. And the releasing date of Hytera DMR was delayed, delayed, delayed. We should have been able to release in 2009 without this team. [emphasis added]

*******, *** ******* *** a ****** ** *** "Malaysian *****" *** ****** to "******* ***** *** security." ****** **** ****** had ******* *.*. *** was********* ****** ** ** his ***** ******:

***** **** **** ****** understands **** **** ********* group **** ***** *****. This ** * **** small ***** *** **** were ****** ** ******* their *** ********.

***** ****** **** *.*. Kok *** ***** ** complete * *** **** he ******'* **, ****** had ***** *** ** 2008 *** *** *** fire *** ***** ** years *****. *******, *** 3 ********* **** ********** fired "*** *** ***** cooperative" **** *******, ********* to ****-****** ******* *********, rather **** *** *'* wrong-doings ** *.*. ***'* alleged ********* ** ******** his *** ** ******* for ***** ************.

Next ** ****** -********'* ******** ******* ******

** *** **** *******, we **** ******* ********'* responses ** ******'* ****, as **** ** *** evidence ******* ******.

Comments (0)

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 7,270 reports and 968 tests and is only available to subscribers. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a subscriber? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports