French Police Criticize Hikvision Body Cameras

By Charles Rollet, Published Dec 29, 2020, 07:19am EST

French police are criticizing their Hikvision body cameras, with one police union official even calling them "junk" after the government purchased over 10,000 in 2018. In response, the government has issued an open tender for 30,000 new body cameras which ends next week.

IPVM Image

The Hikvision partner who sold the original cameras, Allwan Security, told IPVM he was participating in this new tender with an improved model, dismissing the complaints, which both he and Hikvision said were due to the cameras not being meant for extended usage during protests which hit France after the deal.

But French media are now raising scrutiny against Hikvision over its US human rights sanctions and NDAA ban, adding another obstacle for Hikvision. In this post, IPVM examines this issue in depth.

Original **** **********

****** ********, ** **** ****** national ****** *****************,************ **-**************** ****** *********** ***** $*.* ******* or $*** *** ******, which ** ***** *** "low ****".

IPVM Image

*********** ****** ******** ******** tender *** *** **** cameras, *******, **** *** mention ******* **** *** is *** ******** ***** use ****. ** *************** *** ********** **** 60% ****** ** ******* and **% ** *****:

IPVM Image

** ** ******** **** other ****** ******** ******** specification ************* ****** ***, if ** *** ****** them, ** **** ****** this ***********.

French ****** ********** ***** ***** ******* ****

****** ****** **** **** complaints ***** *** **** cameras, ******** ** ***** battery ****. ********* **** *********** **** *****, * regional ******** *** *** Alliance ****** ********* ***** (one ** ******'* *********** **,*** ********** ** ******'****,*********** ****** ********) ******* the **** "****":IPVM Image

** *** [******] ******** today ** **** **** cameras ***unfortunately ****work * ** * ***** then stop because we bought body camsthat **** **** [emphasis added]

************* **** ********** ****** ****** **** "relegated *** ******* ** storage *****" *** ** their *** ******* ****, with ** ******** *** another ****** *****,**** ******, *é*** ******, ******* the *******' *** **** for **** *****:IPVM Image

*******, *** **** ** functionality ***** **** *** fact **** [*** **********] wanted ** ***** **** personnel, ** * *** was ****** ***a *****-**** ******* [emphasis added]

******** **** * ***************** *** ********* *******, noting **** ****** ******* "uninterrupted ********* * ***** x *" *** "******* on *** *****: * hours":

IPVM Image

**** **** **** ** does *** ******** ******** how **** ******* ** has, *** **** ** was ******'* "*****-*******" ******** police *****.

Other **********

******* **** ** *** main *****, ******* ***** issues **** **** ******, for *******,**** ************** "*** ******* ******* is [***] *******" ***** with ************ "********** **** for ***** ***********".

Allwan ******** **** ******** ** *****

****** ** ***, *** ** ****** Security, **** **** **** identity ****** "**** **********" to ** *** **** use **** ******** ** said *** ******** ****** did *** ************ ******* ID ******, *******, ***** large-scale '****** *****' *********** ****** *** ****** began ***** *** **** cams *** ******** ******* of ****:

IPVM Image

**'* ******, *** ******* have ***** ***** ***** of ******* **** *** they **** ***** *** ID ******, *** *** missions [...] *** ****** were ***** **** *** maintaining ***** ******* *** Yellow ***** *** ****** protests **** *** ******* was *** ** ****** [...] *** [***** ****] is **** ********, **'* not ***** ** ** on *********** *** ***.

********** ******* ** * gas *** ********, ***** were ******'* **** ****** protests ** *****, '**********' ****** **** ********** blocking***** *** **** ******.

Allwan ******** ** **********

****** **** ********-****** "**"***** ******* ** *** government ***** **** * hours ** ******* **** but **** **** ***** 3 ***** **** *** features ****** ** **** as *** *** *****, Le *** ****. (*********'**** **** ******** *** ****** ** the **** ****** "* hours" ** ******* **** at *****.) ** *** said ****** ****** **** aware ** **** ********** prior ** ***** ********; IPVM ********* ******* **** the ******** ******** ** this, *** ** **** not ***** **** ***.

*************'*********** **** *** **** was *** ********* ** even ********** ** *******, Le *** ********* ***** as "*****" ****** **'* "never *********** **** ********" before. ** *** ********* being ********, ** *** said *** ****** *** not *** ********* **** Allwan.

New ****** *********, ****** *************

**** *********,**** ********"******** *** *********" **** cameras. ****** ******* ******** ****** **** ******* due ** ********* ******** orders ***** **** ******** about ****** ********* ***** Paris ***************** **** *** ***** ** *** not ******* * ****.

** ********, *** ********** has******* *** ****** *** 30,000 **** **** *** 15 ******* ***** (** million) ** $*** ****. Le *** **** **** that ****** *** ************* albeit **** ** "********" version,*** **-***** "**"***** ***** "** ** 12 ***** ** ********** recording":

IPVM Image

** *** **** **** the **** *** ** hours' ******* **** **** all ******** ****** **, except ******** ***** *** reduce ********* **** ** about * ****.********* ********* * ***** ** recording *** **** ****** but ** *** ******* the ** ***** *** based ** "******* ** did ***** *** *** over * *****".

Hikvision ********

** ******** ** ****, Hikvision ****** ** ***, stating *** ******** **** cams ****** ** **** were ***** *** "******** checks" *** ******** *******:

*** ******* **** *** tenders ** **** ******* on ********** ******* ** assist ********* ****** ******** checks, ***** *** ********* short ********. *** ********** of *** ******* *** the ********** ** *** specified ** *** **** for ******* **** ****, particularly ** ***** ** autonomy. *******, *** ******* have **** **** **** for *** *********** ********, which ******* * **** longer ********* ****.

********* ******* ** **** that ****** ****, "***** manufacturers' ******* *******" **** had "****** * *****" battery ****. *******,**** **** **** ****** study***** ******* ******** ******* from * ** **+ hours, **** **** ******* supporting * ** **** hours' *******:

IPVM Image

********* ******** ** ******* about **** ***** **** cameras ****** *+ ***** of ********* **** **** in ****, ** ******** to *** ****** ***** "other *************’ ******* ******* was ****** * ***** too ** **** ****."

Longer ******* ****** ** *** *******

********* ****** **** ***** last ****, "*** ******* are *** ********* *** both ***** ** ******** (identity ******* *** *** enforcement)", ****** ** * new *******:

****** ****, * ***-***** chipset *** *** *** available *** **** *******, and *** ******* ******** of ***** *************’ ******* devices *** ****** * hours *** ** **** time. ** ****, ** upgraded *** **** ****** version **** *** ***-***** chipset, *** ******** *** battery ********.

** ******** ********* **** Allwan ** ******* ** hours ***** ** ***** own *******, ****** *********'* lower *-**** *************. ** Hikvision ******** ** ****, we **** ******.

Renewed ********* ******** ** ******

***** *** **** ****** deal, ********* *** **** under **** ****** ***** scrutiny *** ** *** US **********'*** ***** ****** **************** ***, *** *******:

*******, *** ****** ********** has ** ************ ** Hikvision *** *** *** publicly ********* **** ********. Le *** ****** **** a "**** ***********":

**** ****** **** *** concern ******. ** ****** wanted ** *** *********, itIPVM Image*****'** **** ** **** ago. *** *** [********* cameras] ********** **** [...] The **** ********** ** done ******** ** ****** - *** ****** **** they ******** *** ****, [France] ** ********** *** data [...] *****'* ****** these ******** ***** ***** but **** ***** ** made ** *****, *****? People *********** ****** ***** claims *** [...] ***** quarters ** ********** ** made ** ***** *** [...] **'* * **** controversy

**** *** ********* *** French ******** ******** ***** its ****** ** ********* and ******* **** **** change; ** **** ****** if ** **** ** receive * ********.

Tender *********

*** ****** **********'* ***************** *, ****, *** will ** "*********" ** July *, ****,*********** ******** ******** ****** Collomb. **** **** ****** when *** ******* *** announced.

Comments (13)

****** ** ****** ***** the ************ ** ***** cameras, ** **** **** Hikvision? ** ** ****** opinion ** ***** ** more ********* ** *** why *** ****** ******** material ***** *** *** adapted ** ***** *****? A ****-*********** & *********** complete ******, ***** ** precise ********* *** ********** needs ***** ********* **** prevented ***** ******* **** ending ** ** * closet.

***** : * ***'* work *** ********* ** a ****** ************.

Agree: 7
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

#*, ****** *** **** first *******!

* ****-*********** & *********** complete ******, ***** ** precise ********* *** ********** needs

* ***** **** **** general *********. **** *** don't ** ****, *** risk ******* '****' ******* sellers **** *** "*** all **** **** ** a ******* *" *** sell **** **** ***********.

Agree: 7
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

******. **** ****** **** been **** ** ********* these ****** **** * one ** ***-*** ***** trial. **** ** *** tender *** ******* **** should **** ** ***** tried ******* ****** ****** spending *.* *******.

Agree: 5
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

****, **** *****, * wonder *** **** **** actually ***** ***** ******* before ******.

**** *********** *** ********** government ****** **** - on *** *** ****, it's **** ** **** open **** ** ********* more ********* *** *** risk ** ********* ********* that ** *** ****** and ************ ** '****'.

Agree: 4
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

****, ****'* ***** **'* important **** *** *** user **** **** *** purchasing **** ** ****** they ******** *** **** they ****. *** ** the *** ***** * was ** *** ******* side ** ** ***, we **** * **** stage *********. *** ***** part *** ** ********* evaluation/scoring ** *** *** product *** *** ********. The ******* ******* * then ******* **** ******* in *** ** *** a ****** ********** ** the ******** ** * real ***** *********** **** the ****** ****** **** that ***** ****.

* *** ****** ********* me *** **** *** users **** ***** ******** to *** ********** ***** and *** **** ********* how **** ***** ** with ***** ******* **** don't **** ***** *****.

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny

****** ** ****** ***** the ************ ** ***** cameras, ** **** **** Hikvision? ** ** ****** opinion ** ***** ** more ********* ** *** why *** ****** ******** material ***** *** *** adapted ** ***** *****? A ****-*********** & *********** complete ******, ***** ** precise ********* *** ********** needs ***** ********* **** prevented ***** ******* **** ending ** ** * closet.

"* ****-*********** & *********** complete ******, ***** ** precise ********* *** ********** needs ***** ********* **** prevented ***** ******* **** ending ** ** * closet."

********* *****

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

***** ******* ;)

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

* *** ******* **** cameras ****** * ****** ago *** *** *********** and **** **** *** units (*****) *** ****** performance *** ****** ******* life **** **** ** reporting. **** ***** ******** was ****** *** ********! Just **** ****** *** payer ***** ***** ** a ********** ** ******* bad ******.

Agree: 5
Disagree
Informative: 5
Unhelpful
Funny

***** ******, *******! ** will ** *********** ** see ** ******* ********* and ****** ********* **** any ****** ** *** Interior ******** *** ** Allwan ** **** ** win *** *** *****.

Agree: 1
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

******:********* ** ****** ***** publication ** ****** *, *** ****** ********** has "*** *****" **** from *** ****** *** the **,*** **** *******, meaning *** ***** *** only *** ***** *********** left: **** *** ******/*********. The ****** ****** - based ** ********* *******, to ** **** - claimed **** **** *** because ****** ****** **** dissatisfied **** ***** **** cameras' *** ******** **** following *******. **** *** reached *** ** **** to *** ** **** have * ******** ** this ******.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

******: **** ******** ** lost *** ****, *** did *** **** ******* official ******** ** *** the **** *** ****.

**** ***** **** "**** ******** ******** *** in ***-********. ********* *** will ****** *********** **** ** *** the ***** *** ***".

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

******* *** ***** *** only *** ***** *********** left: **** *** ******/*********.

*** **** ****!, **** muscled **?

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

******** *** ************* **** *** *** deal ** ******* *********.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny
Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 7,264 reports and 968 tests and is only available to subscribers. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a subscriber? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports