Debunking Arecont's PTZ Elimination Claim

By: John Honovich, Published on Jun 23, 2011

Arecont Vision, manufacturer of only megapixel cameras, is contending that megapixel cameras 'virtually eliminate the need for mechanical PTZ cameras.' In this note, we debunk this prepostoerous claim and explain why this is a dangerous approach to designing real world surveillance systems.

Here is the full Arecont Vision MP vs PTZ claim [link no longer available]:

"The superior resolution provided by megapixel cameras enables highly detailed and accurate digital PTZ (pan-tilt-zoom) of live and recorded images. As a result, megapixel cameras virtually eliminate the need for mechanical PTZ cameras, which are often costly and feature mechanical parts prone to failure."

In English, virtually is generally accepted to mean "for the most part; almost wholly; just about." By contrast, no more than a fraction of locations using PTZ cameras would benefit from switching to Megapixel cameras. Indeed, far more would be better off considering MP PTZ cameras that combine both of the technologies.

Image Quality Not Close

We've tested SD PTZ vs megapixel camera comparative performance. The range of an SD PTZ's optical zoom produces far more details at far greater range than anything a megapixel camera can deliver.

Here are two summary comparison shots from the report that shows the contrast. First, daytime performance:

Here's night time performance:

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Only in very narrow FoV ranges (~50 degrees, 50 feet wide FoV) can megapixel cameras even come close. Any further out or wider and megapixel cameras can simply not compete.

The problem here is that most PTZ users want the capability of seeing more than the limited coverage area a megapixel camera can deliver.

Here's the difference in potential coverage area between a 5MP camera and a PTZ from our tests. It is massive:

Other Challenges with Megapixel Cameras

Arecont Vision's cameras nicely demonstrate two other important problems with megapixel cameras:

  • Challenges in handling light variations: In test after test, Arecont Vision image quality suffers with bright lighting. Essentially, the WDR performance is weak. By contrast, when zooming in with a PTZ, lighting variation problems are minimized as the lighting levels in smaller areas tend to be more even.
  • Massive bandwidth spikes: In test after test, Arecont Vision's bandwidth consumption explodes whenever lighting decreases (a few Mb/s during the day, 10Mb/s+ at night). This can have a major negative impact of networks and storage consumption.

Finally, we find it ironic that Arecont Vision criticizes PTZ failure when they have the worst reputation in the industry for reliability.

Megapixel Replacement for PTZ

Megapixel does have advantages against PTZs: (1) per camera, cheaper by ~$1,000-$1,500, (2) covers the full area at all times, (3) lower MTBF (in general).

On the other hand, the huge negative remains: optical zoom and mechanical control delivers a massive increase in coverage relative to megapixel cameras. It's just not close.

In small, generally indoor areas, where PTZ have traditionally been overkill, replacing with megapixel cameras is worth considering. This, though, is just a small fraction of overall PTZ use.

We understand why a company that only sells fixed megapixel cameras would promote that category. However, the megapixel replaces PTZ sentiment does a disserve to 'virtually' all security managers.

2 reports cite this report:

Top 5 Disruptive Surveillance Companies 2012 on Dec 15, 2011
What companies are driving changes in the video surveillance industry? What companies are the toughest competitors? In this new report, we answer...
Arecont 20MP Camera Examined on Apr 05, 2011
Arecont Vision has announced a 20MP camera. This would be the highest resolution production surveillance camera in the world. While there are some...
Comments : Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

Camera Resolution Usage Statistics 2020 on Mar 12, 2020
The average resolution used, for new cameras, is now 4MP, according to new IPVM statistics, continuing the rise that we have mapped from 2014,...
Video Surveillance Cameras 101 on Feb 25, 2020
Cameras come in many shapes, sizes and specifications. This 101 examines the basics of cameras and features used in 2020. In this report, we...
Glossary / Acronyms for Video Surveillance on Feb 10, 2020
This directory provides definitions and explanations for over 70 common video surveillance industry terms, including links to related IPVM...
Last Chance - Camera Course Winter 2020 on Jan 30, 2020
This is the only independent surveillance camera course, based on in-depth product and technology testing. Lots of manufacturer training exists...
2020 Video Surveillance Cameras State Of The Market on Jan 03, 2020
Each year, IPVM explains the main advances and changes for video surveillance cameras, based on our industry-leading testing and reporting. This...
Camera Field of View (FoV) Guide on Nov 13, 2019
Field of View (FoV) and Angle of View (AoV), are deceptively complex. At their most basic, they simply describe what the camera can "see" and seem...
Camera Focusing Tutorial on Oct 14, 2019
Camera focus is fundamental to quality imaging. Mistakes can significantly reduce details, making cameras less effective. In this guide, we...
Lens Iris Tutorial on Aug 08, 2019
Cameras, like humans, have irises, controlling the light which hits the imager and impacting image details. However, cameras have multiple types of...
Lens Focal Length Tutorial on Jul 10, 2019
3mm, 6mm, 2.8 - 9mm, 5 - 50mm, etc. Camera specifications often list lens lengths but what do they mean? These metrics are important in...
Startup Spectral Edge RGB+IR Claims "Unique Low Light Performance Tech" on Apr 03, 2019
This UK startup, born out of university research, is boldly proclaiming that they deliver "Unique low light performance tech for video surveillance...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Athena CEO Criticizes 'Deplorable' 'Nitpicking', IPVM Refutes on Mar 27, 2020
Athena Security's CEO Lisa Falzone has strongly objected to IPVM's reporting on Athena, calling it 'deplorable' and repeatedly criticizing IPVM's...
Hikvision Admits Sanctions Harming Its Financial Performance on Mar 27, 2020
While Hikvision initially downplayed being sanctioned for human rights abuses, the company is now admitting a significant impact in a new PRC...
New Axis M30 Cameras Tested on Mar 26, 2020
Axis has released a new generation of, for them, relatively low cost M30 series cameras, claiming to deliver "sharp video quality even in poor...
Coronavirus Shuts Down ADT Door Knockers on Mar 26, 2020
Coronavirus has another victim - this time, alarm giant ADT has stopped all door to door sales. Door knockers are a critical but controversial...
Access Control Course Spring 2020 - Save $50 Last Day on Mar 26, 2020
Register Now - Spring 2020 Access Control Course. Today, March 26th is the last day to save $50. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access...
Convergint Coronavirus Cuts on Mar 25, 2020
One of the world's largest security integrators, Convergint, has made a major move to handle the impact of coronavirus, with cuts across the...
VSaaS 101 on Mar 25, 2020
Video Surveillance as a Service (VSaaS) is the common industry term for cloud video. But what does it mean? How does it all work? Inside this...
TVT / InVid Facial Recognition Tested on Mar 25, 2020
Facial recognition is frequently sold for thousands of dollars per channel but some China manufacturers are offering full facial recognition...
IPVM Launches On-Demand Courses on Mar 24, 2020
For nearly a decade, IPVM has been a leader in online live courses. Now, we have added on-demand versions for all courses. The same course...