Yi 2 Intelligent Camera Test

By John Scanlan, Published May 11, 2016, 11:08am EDT

Mega Chinese manufacturer Xiaomi's investment into the security space, Xiaoyi, first entered the market with a super low cost $50 IP camera (the Yi Home Camera which we tested).

Now, they are back with their second generation offering. In addition to higher resolution (1080p vs 720p), the camera focused on intelligent video / analytics, such as:

  • Human detection
  • Baby crying detection
  • People counting
  • Gesture control

And unlike, big name competitors, such as Google Nest Cam that cost $200, the Xi 2 camera is just ~$130.

We bought one and tested it against Google Nest Cam and Yi's first generation camera:

*******

*** ** **** * offered *********** ******* ** or ****** **** *** Nest *** *** ~$** less *** ** ********* charges. ** *** *****, it *********** ***** ***** activations **** *******, ******, cars, *** ***** *******, though ***** ****** ** careful ** ****** *********** to ***** ****** ********** in *** *****.

*** ** *'* ******* Detection ** * ***** feature ***** ** *** (if ***) ***** *******, and ************ ****** ******** during *******. ** **** 1-2 ********* (**** *** course ** * **** testing) *** ******* ********* inadvertently *********.

*******, **** **** ******** such ** "**** ****** Detection" *** ****** ********, while ******** ** ******'* marketing ********, *** *** yet ******** ** *** app.

Key ********

**** *** *** *** findings **** **** ****:

  • *** ** **** * with ***** ********* ******* provided ****** ***** ***** rejection **** *** **** Cam **** **** *****, rejecting ******* **** ** cars *** ****** ******* and ******* ****** ***** caused *********** ** ****.
  • *** ** **** * experienced **** ********** ***** activation, ********* * ***** where ***** *** ****, typically ** *** *****, with ** ***** *****, occurring ***** ***** ** three **** ** *****. The ****** *********** ********** a *** ** * human **** ** *** tests, *** ******* * smaller ***.
  • *** ** * ****** detections ** ****** ** low ***** **** ***** the ******* "******" ***********, which ******* *** **** Cam *** *** ***** generation ** ******. ******** to "****" *********** ****** eliminated ***** ****** *********** with ** ******** ** false ****** **** ***** Detection **.
  • *** ** **** *'* 940nm ** ** *********, with ** *** **** seen ** ******* ********** IR *******.
  • ******* ********* ** ***** and ****** ** ********* in *** ***** (***** hand, ***** ****, *** follow ***** *******). ******* Detection *** ************* ********* during * ************ **** in *** ***.
  • ** ****** **** ******* was *********, ***** ** a ****.

*******

*** ** **** * is *** ** *********** *** ~$*** ***, ***** $** **** than *** **** ***, which ***** ***~$*** ******. *** ***** ********** Yi **** ****** *** sells ***~$**.

Tech ******* *** *********

****** ** *** **** telephone ** **** **** support. *** **** ******* methods *** ****** ***** and * ******* **** on ***** *******. *** inquiries *** ***** *** form **** **********.

Physical ************

*** ****** ** ******* in **** *** ****** to *** **** *** and ***** **** **** ******. *** ****** ** the ** **** * has **** ******* **** the ***** **********, **** an ***-**-*** **** **** design ******* ** *** "puck" **** ****** ***** snaps **** *** ***** (seen ** *** ** Home *** **** ***/*******).

*** ***** ***** ******** a ******** ******** ** the ** **** * camera.

Video *******

*** ***** ***** ***** the ***** ** **** in *** ********** **** used ****** *******.

*** ** **** * outperformed *** **** ********* Nest *** ** **** light ******. *** ******* taken **** ** **** 2 ***** ***** ***** more ******* ** *** subjects **** ** **** as *** ****** *****.

***** ** ********* **** in **** ***** ******, the ******* ********* ** the ** **** * were ***** **** *** first ********** ** **** camera. *** **** *** was **** ***** **** the ** **** *, though ****, *** ********* any **** ****** *******.

Human ********* *********

*** ** * ******** human ********* *********, ******** to ******* **** **** a ***** ** ** the *****, ******** ***** motion. ** *** *****, these ********* ****** **** in **** ***** ******, with **** *** ********** of ***-***** ******* ******** as ***** (********* *****).

**** *** ****** ** three **** ** ******* the ****** ******* ******* for ***** ********* ** three ******** *********. *****, it ********** * **** dog ** *****, *** below:

****, ** *** *****, we *********** *** ***** detection ****** **** ******* in *** *****, **** light ***** *******, **** below:

Nuisance ***** *********

**** ***** ********* *******, the ** **** * rejected ******** ****** ***** triggered **** *** ***** generation ** ** **** as *** **** *** with **** ***** (***** includes ****'* ***** ****** algorithms). *** *******, ** the ***** ***** (* residential ******* **** * street ** *** **********), passing ******** ********* *** not ******* *** ** 2 **** ***** ********* enabled, *** ****** ****** in *** **** *** and ** *.

**** ***** ******* **** triggered ** ****** ******* in *** **** *******, while *** ** **** 2 *** ***:

940nm ********* **

*** ** **** * uses ***** **, ***** is ********* ** ******, unlike **** ********** ** cameras ***** *** ***** LEDs, ******** *** *** glow **** ********* **** IR. **** ****** ** to ** **** *********** in *** *****, ** intruders *** **** ********** spotting *** ******. ************, the ********* ** ***** it **** ******** *** use ** * **** monitor ******** ** *** red **** ** **** cameras.

**** ***** ***** *** LED ******, ***** ***** purplish ** *** ****** (which *** ** ** cut ****** ****** ***** lets **** *********** *******). Note **** *** ******** blue *** ** *** camera's ****** ***** (***** can ** ****** ***).

Gesture *********

**** ** ******** * gesture ******** **** ** initiate ***** *********, ***** sends * "******** ***** Message", ***** ** **** to ***** ***** ** the ******. ** ******** recording, *** **** ***** the ******, ****** ***** hand **** **** *******, then ****** ***** ****. We *********** **** ** the ***** *****:

******* ********* ****** ******** in *** *****, ********** properly **** ***** ********* these ********. *******, ** some **** *****, ** inadvertently ********* ********* **** conversing ** ***** ** the ******, ********** *** feature **** ******* **** motion, *** *** ******** gesture ********. **** *** be * ******* ** some ***** ** **********, depending ** ******** ******** and ******** ** *** camera's ***.

Comments (8)

Why baby crying detector is missing? I find it nice, as this looks like to be the most useful function of this camera.

Any info about it?

The feature is advertised, but not included (as is people counting). We emailed the manufacturer and have not heard back. I will be sure to update here if / when a response is received.

Surprisingly, literally a week after completing our test, Xiaomi released an update to the camera which supports baby crying detection. We haven't tested it but it is indeed now part of the app:

Surprisingly, literally a week after completing our test, Xiaomi released an update to the camera which supports baby crying detection.

Apparently, Xiaomi is another Chinese camera maker who "really listens" to their customers requests. Just face the mic.

I know it's a long shot, but is there any evidence that this camera actually supports a RTSP stream that could be captured by a VMS or other client?

No evidence I've seen. All ports closed, and we've wiresharked it and it sets up a TLS tunnel pretty much immediately. If there's a way to get RTSP out of it, I don't know what it is.

Yes, it does support RTSP, but you will need a cracked firmware. Check out this link http://robinhenniges.com/en/fix-xiaomi-xiaoyi-small-ant

I was able to use the firmware and get it up and running some time ago. Check the attached screen shot.

Yes, it does support RTSP, but you will need a cracked firmware.

Nice find, Gauthum.

Though a cracked firmware could support just about anything, e.g. ONVIF profile S on a Mobotix q24. :)

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 6,653 reports, 896 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports