VMD Camera Shootout

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Oct 28, 2013

Video motion detection's inaccuracy can have disastrous effects on your VMS system, with recordings due to positives easily consuming far more storage than estimated. On the other hand, optimizing VMD to reject these alarms can decrease detection rates, missing real events.

In order to test whose on-camera VMD performed best, we used cameras from Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, and Sony in multiple scenes, day and night, starting with a simple indoor conference room:

Moving on to a more complex open office area:

And finally, an outdoor area with moving vegetation and headlights on a nearby road:

Our tests looked to answer the following key questions:

  • What issues most commonly cause false positives?
  • Whose VMD was best at rejecting these events?
  • How did detection range vary from manufacturer to manufacturer?
  • Can settings be optimized for better detection without increasing false alerts and vice versa?

***** ****** *********'* ********** *** **** ********** ******* ** **** *** ******, with ********** *** ** ********* ****** ********* *** **** ******* than *********. ** *** ***** ****, ********** *** ** ****** these ****** *** ******** ********* *****, ******* **** ******.

** ***** ** **** ***** **-****** *** ********* ****, ** used ******* **** ********, ****, *****, *** **** ** ******** scenes, *** *** *****, ******** **** * ****** ****** ********** room:

****** ** ** * **** ******* **** ****** ****:

*** *******, ** ******* **** **** ****** ********** *** ********** on * ****** ****:

*** ***** ****** ** ****** *** ********* *** *********:

  • **** ****** **** ******** ***** ***** *********?
  • ***** *** *** **** ** ********* ***** ******?
  • *** *** ********* ***** **** **** ************ ** ************?
  • *** ******** ** ********* *** ****** ********* ******* ********** ***** alerts *** **** *****?

[***************]

Key ********

***** ********* **** ***** **** *** ******* ***** ** *** tests, **** *** ********* ******** ****** **********:

  • ** ****** ***** ***** ** ***** "****" ** ********* ***** positives, ***** *** ******** ******** *********** **** ********* **********, *** and *****, ** ***** *** **** *****. *** ******** ** 1MP ******** ****** *** ** ******* ** ***** ****** **** others. *** **** ***** *** ********* ** ********* ********** **** than ***** *******. ***** **** ***** *** ******, *********** *** about *****.
  • *** ******* ******** ******** ***** ********* *** ** *** ******** of ********** ** *** *****, *** ** *****, ******* **** continuous *********. ** *** *****, **** **** ***** ** ****** out ******* ********* ***********, ** ** ***** ******** *** ******** in **** ****.
  • *******, ******* ****** ** ****** ******** ****** **** ***** ********* which ***** *** ** ******** *** ****** *****, ***** **** fell ********** *** ****** ********* ****.
  • ** *****, *** ******* **** ********* ** *** ********** ** our *****. *** **** ***** *** ********* ** **** **** when *** **** *** ******** **** *** ****** ****.
  • *******, ***** ******* **** *** ******* ***** ** ***** ******. These **** *** ** ***** *******/******* **** * *** *******, subjects ****** **** *** ****, ** *********** ** ********** **********. The **** ***** ** **** ***** ** ***** ****** ** this *****, ******** ** ***** ***-****, **** *****, *** ******** *.*-**-**. 

*** ********* *** ******** ******* *********** ** ******* **** ****** using * ***** *******:

  • *** ******** *.*-**-** ********* **** ** ****** *** ******* ****** at *** ***** ******, ******* **** **** ***** ** **** (<1lux). *** ****** *** *** ******* ********* ***** ***** ****** cameras *** ** ******, ** ****, ****** ********* ** ****** and ******** ** *** **** **********.  
  • ** ******* ******* *** **** ***** ****** *****, **** *****, Bosch ***-**** *** **** ***-***** ******* ******* ****** ********* *********** in ***** ** ********* ****** *** ***** ***** *****. 
  • ** *** *****, *** *********** ** ***** ***-**** *** **** SNC-VB600 **** **** *******, **** ***** ******** **** ******** ****** detection ******  *** ******** ***** ***** ***** *****.
  • **** *****, ** *** ***** ****, ****** ************* ****** ***** cameras ** *** *****, **** **** ***** ********* ******.

Optimization ***************

***** ** *** *****, ** **** ** *********** ** **** practices **** **** ************, **** *** *** *************** ** *** each ****** *** ** ********* *** **** ***********:

  • *** *** ******** *.*-**-**, ******* ******** ******** ****** *********** ** *** ******, **** ** *********** *******.
  • **** ****' ***** ******** ***, *** ******* ****** **** ******* is *** ***** *** **** ******.  ** ***** ** *** ****** detection ******, *** ****** **** ******* ****** ** ** ******* carefully ** * ***** ******** ** *** *****, ********* * or *****.
  • *** *** ***** ***-****, **** *** *********** *** **** ******** by ***** *** ******* ******** ** *** ****** ** ******. Lowering *** ****** **** ******** ** ************* ****** ***** ****** due ** ******* *** ****. 
  • *** *** **** ***-*****, *** ****** **** ****** ** ******* to *** ******* ***** *** **** ***********. ** *** *******, *********** can **** ** ******** ********* **** *** ******* ******* ** *** a ****** ********* *****. *** ** ****** ***** ***** ***** ** *** *****, ******* *********** ** ***** ** ** **** *********** in ***** **********.

***************

*** ** *************** ***** ****** **** ****** ******, ********, *******, *** ***** variations, ***** ****** ********* ******** ****** ********* *** ******* ******* when ******** ** *** ***** ****** *********. ****** ******* **** from ********** *** ****** ******** **** ******** **** ******* ******* performance, **** ****** ***** ******* ******* ** ***** *****.

******* *** ******** ****** *** ** ******* ******* *** *** cameras ** *** ******. ** **** ***** ***** ******** **** result ** ******** ***** ********* ** ****** **********. ***** ****** plan ** ****** ***** ******** **** ******* *** ** *****, and ******** ****** ** ********* ************ ** ****** *********** ** still***********.

*** ***** ********* ******** ****** ********* ** ****** ****** (>***' during *** **** *** >**' *****-****), *** ******** *.*-**-** ****** out ** *** **** ****** ***** *** ****** *******. *******, since ** ********** **** ***** ******* *** *****, **** **** will *** ******* ****** ****** **** *** ******, ******** *** use ** ***-**-*** ******** *******.

Comparison ** *****-** *********

******** ** *** ******** ****** ****** ********* ****** ****, **** ***** ****** ********* *.* ********* ****** ** **** ******. ****** *********, ********* ** *******, and ***** **** *** ********, *** *** ***** *********** *** reduced ********. ** ********* ** ** **** **** **** ******* whenever ********, *** *** *********** ** ******* *** ** *********** with **** *** **** (**** *** ******* ****).

******** ** ***** *****-** ***, ****, *****, *** **** ****** ********* **** ** ***** **** ********* ******** **** **** ***** ***** ******** *****. **** ** *** to *** **** ****** ********* ***** *** ******** ***** ******** for **********. ***** *** **** ** ******** ***** ********* ******* of ******** *** ***** ********.

*************

*** ********* ****** ****** ************* ** **** ************'* ***.

******** **

**** *****

**** ********** ******************** ** ****' ***. **** **** **** ***** **** ******** configuration ** **** ***** ****** ********* *.*, ***** ** ********* over ******** *** ******** ********. *******, **** ****** ******* **** on *******' ******** ******** ***. 

***** ***-****

**** *** ***

Outdoor ******* 

********, ** ********, ****** **** ******** *** ****** ********* ********** nuisance ****** ** *** *******. ** ******* ***** ***** ***** ******* windows, ** ******* ** ****** ********* *** *** ******** *********.

**** ****** ** ******** *** ********** ** *** *****, *** cameras **** ***** ********* *** ** *** ******** ** ******* in *** *****. ***** ***** ***** *** ** ******** ** they **** ** *** ****** ** *** ****** ****.

*** ***** ***** ***** * ******* ** * ****** *** ** front ** *** ******. *** ******** ** **** *** **** the *** ******* *** ** ** ****** **** ********** ********* for *** *****.

********* *****

*** *** ********* ***** ****, ** **** * **** ***** about **' **** **** ******** ** *****, *** ***** ***' *** ****** ****. *** ******* ********* due ** ** ****** ******* ******* *** *******. *******, ******** 1.0-H3-B2 ****** ** *** ******* **  ~ ***-***' **** **** the ******, ***** **** *****, ***** ***-**** *** **** ***-***** triggered ** *** **-**' *****. **** ****, **** ***** ******** VMD's ****** **** ****** ** ****** **** ** (*******) ** 1 ** ***** ** ******** ********* ***** **** **' ** 45'. ****, *** **** ***-***** ***'* *********** ******* *** ********* to *** **** *** ******* ***, ***** ******** *** ********* range ** ****** **'. ******* ******** ** ****'* *********** ******** in ********** ****** ********* *** ** ***** *********.

******** *.*-**-** **** ******** ******** ********** ** *** ****** **** (~280') ****** *** ***. **** ***-*****, ***** ***-**** *** **** ***** detected **** ***** **%, **%, *** *% ** ********, ************.

******** *.*-**-** *** **** **** ** ****** ****** ** *** distant *******, **** ***' **** *** ******.

 

Outdoor *********

** *** ******* ********* *****, ***** **** *** *** ******** of ***** *********. ** ** *** *******, ******* **** ****** and ********** ********* ******:

****, ******** ** ****** *** *** **** ** ******* ***** factors ** *** **** **********, **** ***-***** **** ***** **** sensitive ** *** ********** *** ** **** ********** ************ **** *** **********.

********* *****

** *** *****, ******** *.*-**-**'* ***** ********* ***** ********* ** about **' *** ***** ******* *** ******* ***** (***** ** ~40', **** ** ~**', *** **** ** ~**'). **** **** we *** *** ******** *** *********** ******* ** **** ***-***** this ****, ***** ** *** **** ******** ** ******** ***** positives *** ** ******* ** *** *****.

**** *** ******* ****** ****** *** *** ** ~**', ******** 1.0-H3-B2 *** ***** ***-**** ******** *** **********. **** ***-***** ****** him ***** **** ** *** ****, ***** **** ***** *** not ******* ** ***.

** **', **** ** *** ******* *********, **** *** ******* simply *** ***** ** ********.

Indoor ********** ****

*** **** ***** *** *** * ***** ***** **** ** 10%-15% **** *** ****** ** *** **********, ***** ***** ********* about *% ** *** ****.

******* *** **** ******* *** ***** ** *** ***** *** ****** the ********* ***** ***** *****: **** **%, **** **%, ***** 20%. 

**** ****** * ********** ********** *** ****, 

** *** ********** **** ** **** *****, *** ****** **** able ** ******** ****** * ***** ******* **  *** ****** up ** **'. **** **** *** **** ***** ***** *** detect *** ******* ** ******* ******** ** ******* ****** **** (15), *** *** ** ** ******* ** * *** ******** detection.

** *** ***** (~***), *** **** ******** *** ****** ** 100% ******** ** ** **' ** * ******* ****** ** the **** ***** ****.

 

Open ******

****** *** ******* ** ** **** ****** *****, ***** **' long, **** ***** *********** ** *** ******* **** ********. **** again, *** **** *****'* **** ** ******* ** * ** improve ********* *****

** *** *****, *** **** ** *** ****** (~**') *** lightened ** * ***** ********** ******** *****. *** ** ****, all ******* ****** **** ***** ******** *** ****** ** **** as ** ******* *** **** **' ****.

*******, ** *** ****** ***** **** *** ***** ** *** darker ****, **** ***-***** *** ***** ***-**** **** ********* ** ****** **' and **-******** *** ****** ** ***** **'. 

*** **** *****, ** *** ***** ****, ***** **** ****** the ****** ** *' **** **** *** ******. 

Cameras/Firmware ****

*** ********* ******* *** ******** ******** **** **** ** *** test:

  • ******** *.*-**-**: *.*.**.*
  • **** *****: *.**.**
  • ***** ***-****: *.**
  • **** ***-*****: *.*.*

 

Comments (7)

**** ****** **** *** **** ** *** ******** *** ** the *** ** *** ******** ** *** *****. **** ** integrator ***** ** **** **** = ***** ** **** ******* the ******* *** ***** ***** *** *** ******** ****** ** that ** ***** ******* *** ***** **** **** * ****** asking *** *** ****** ** **** ***** * *** ** money ** ****** ** *****. * *** **** ********* ** see **** ** *** *** *** ** *** **** *** creating *** **** ***** ********* **** ******** *******.

**** ** *** **** *****!

**** ****** ** **** *** ********** ** ** *********** *** ********.... :)

**** ****, **** **** ******** **** **** ****** *** *********** still *** ******. *******, ***** ** **** *** *********** (****** manufacturers ******** ***++ ** **** ** *** ************* ****** ******* for****' ****.*).

*** *** *** ******** ******* ** ********* ********* ************* *** wide ***/** **** ******? ****'* *** ***** * ******** ***** the **** ******* *** *** ****** ******* *** *** ** the **** ***********.

*** *****, ** *** *** *** ** ***** ******** ******* in **** **** ******* ** ***** **** *********** *** **** modest ******* ** **** *****. * ******* **** **** ** this **** ***** ***** ** ** ****** *********** *** ********** windows, ***, ****** ** * **** *****, ******.

****** *** *** ************* :) * **** ** ***** ********** on **** ******* *** ** ****** ** **** ****.

*****:

****** *** *** ******. *** *** ******** **** ** ******** that **** ** ***** ******* ***** ****** ********* **** ******** outdoors, *******, ********* ** *** ****** ** ********* *** ******* the ***** ** ****** **** ***** **** *****.

*** *** **** **** **** *** *** **** ********** (****** out ****** ****** *** **** ** ******) *** ***** *** best ******** **** ***** **** ****** *********, **** *** *** false ***** **** ** ***** **** * ** **** ****** for **** ***** ** **** **** ****** *** ********?

* ******* ************* ** ****, "*** *** ******** **** ** indicate **** **** ** ***** ******* ***** ****** ********* **** suitable ********"

**** ** ***** **************** ******** *** ******* ******************* **** *** *** ******** ****** *** ** ***** ********** crazy. *******, *** ******* *********, * *** ****** ** ****** detection, ***** ** ***** ********, **** *** ** **** ** there ***** ** ** *** *** *** **** ********/******** (******* *.* *** ******* **** ******* *** **********).

** *** '***** ***** ****', ** *******, *** ********** ** not ** **** ******** ******* *********** - *.*., **** ****** has ** **.*% ***** **** ** ******** ** ********, ******* there *** ****** **** ******** ********* **** * ****** ****** would ** **********.

**** ****, *'** *** ***** ******* ** ****** / ******** of *********** *** **** ******** ** ****** *** ****** *** cars, ***.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports on Low Light

Arecont Vision MicroDome Duo Tested on Feb 14, 2017
Arecont Vision is back with another multi-head camera, this time thinking smaller with the MicroDome Duo, a two-imager model, with the tagline...
Hikvision PanoVu Multi Imager Tested on Feb 08, 2017
Hikvision has entered the multi-imager market with their 180° PanoVu DS-2CD6986F-H, an 8MP, 4-imager model equipped with ~1/1.8" imagers and...
Axis 15MP Multi-Imager Tested (Q3708-PVE) on Feb 07, 2017
Axis continues to expand in the multi imager market, adding to a segment started with the 33MP Q3709. We bought the Q3708-PVE and tested it...
Sony Favorability Results on Feb 06, 2017
Sony is one of the largest brands in the world and a long term provider of both video surveillance imagers and cameras. But, like all incumbents,...
LAST DAY - Camera Course Winter 2017 on Feb 02, 2017
[NOTE: Today, Thursday is the last day to register.] Learn video surveillance and get certified. IPVM provides live online classes, recorded...
Invisible IR Camera Tested (Vivotek) on Jan 30, 2017
Integrated IR is everywhere in surveillance, from high-end long range cameras to even the lowest cost models. But this IR usually comes with a...
Panasonic Extreme H.265 Cameras Tested on Jan 26, 2017
Panasonic has released their latest generation, the i-Pro Extreme series, with enhanced compression (smart H.265) enhanced WDR and secure...
Avigilon Pro 4K Camera Tested on Jan 03, 2017
Avigilon is best known for their large sensor, high megapixel cameras. But with new offerings from Sony and soon Axis, the questions is how well...
Surveillance Cameras 2017 Review on Jan 02, 2017
This report concisely explains the developments and most common options for surveillance cameras offered in 2017, including resolution, H.265, HD...
Calculating Video Surveillance Storage / Bandwidth on Dec 29, 2016
Calculating surveillance bandwidth is complex, and inexperienced users can easily underestimate bandwidth, leading to reduced storage durations...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Hikvision Leads Multi-Manufacturer Sales Promo on Feb 21, 2017
Earlier this month, Hikvision launched new 'super value' kits, with 40% discounts, and now Hikvision is offering another promo, but this time they...
Washington DC MPD's Surveillance Equipment on Feb 21, 2017
The Washington DC Metropolitan Police Department's surveillance system was hacked in January 2017. Two immediate questions were: Whose...
Hikvision Ezviz Mini 360 Plus - $80 Autotracking Camera Tested on Feb 21, 2017
Autotracking, integrated IR, local storage, full HD, cloud access: $80. That is the claim of Hikvision EZVIZ's new Mini 360 Plus. But for this...
Lenel Improving Customer Support on Feb 21, 2017
Lenel has faced significant criticism recently (see Lenel Partners Angry, Lenel Does Not Care, Worst Access Control 2016, Lenel Favorability...
'Dirty': Hikvision Attacks Genetec on Feb 20, 2017
Hikvision is angry at the growing public awareness that Hikvision is owned by the Chinese government. They took aim at Genetec,...
Directory of Alarm Company Brokers on Feb 20, 2017
Selling an RMR based business, such as alarm company, can be highly profitable, with acquisition prices of 36 to 48x RMR (equivalent to 3 to 4x...
Hikvision Hiring 50, Direct Out of College, Sales People on Feb 20, 2017
Hikvision is hiring 50, direct out of college, field sales people across the country. This is the next major expansion for the Chinese...
Simplisafe is 'Blowing The Doors Off' on Feb 17, 2017
The company alarm dealers love to hate, Simplisafe, is 'blowing the doors off' according to Michael Barnes, one of the top financial advisors in...
Hikvision OEM DDNS Devices To 'Lose Remote Access' on Feb 17, 2017
The fallout of Hikvision's DDNS discontinuation is expanding, this time hitting OEM partner Supercircuits, who reports that on June 30th: The...
Milestone: "Easy Money Days Are Over" on Feb 17, 2017
Contrary to IPVM's criticisms, Milestone has reaffirmed that glory days remain. But they admit that they 'easy money days are over': Are the...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact