UK Facial Recognition Essex Errors Report

By John Honovich, Published Jul 05, 2019, 09:23am EDT

Facial recognition trials in the UK have generated significant controversy and debate over the past few years. This week, it flared again when Sky News / Guardian trumpeted that 81% of 'suspects' flagged were false. However, their posts did not analyze the details nor share the original research report. IPVM has.

london MPS police face rec report

In this report, we share and examine the 128-page report including:

  • The new and enhanced methodology that Essex used to analyze these results from more recent facial recognition trials in 2018 and 2019.
  • Why police / human review of matches was so critical and so difficult
  • How the 'accuracy' statistics vary and what the tradeoffs in different approaches were
  • How logs recorded show logistical challenges
  • How UK / EU / GDPR rules for consent complicate the challenges involved
  • China / PRC facial recognition systems contrasted

Report ********

************* ** ***** ***** Rights ****** *** ******** a ***-**** ******:

Observing ******

*** **** ********* ********** of **** ***** *** here ** ** ********** observe *** ****** ****** recognition *********** ** **** they ***** *** **** happened **** *** ****** were ******* *** ****** recognition *** ********** *******. The ***** **** ***** report ***** *** * trials **** ********:

Problems ********* **** *********** *******

*** ******* ******* *** perhaps **** ********** ******* of *** ****** ** that ********* *** ***** difficulty ******** ********* *******, i.e., ** *** ****** on *** ****** *** same ****** ** *** person *** ****** *********** system **** ********?

** ***** **** *** 6 ******, *** ****** were *** **** ******* the ***** *** *** person ** *** ****** so **** ******* *** person, *** **** ** 8 ** ***** ** times *** *** ****** flagged ** *** ****** the ****** ****** ** the ******, ** *** chart ***** *****:

***** ********* **** *** unreliability ** ****** ********* the ****** ** * key *******:

Sky **** **% *********

*** **% ******** ** Sky **** ******** ** matches **** *** ****** were **** ** ******* dismiss ** ***** ***** matches (*.*., *** ****-**** surveillance ***** *** ******* much ********* **** *** watchlist *****):

***********, *** **% ** wrong ** ***** **** only ** ******* **** were **** ** ** verified *** ** *****, 30 **** ******** ** being *****, *** * rate ** **.*%. *** difference ** **** * matches **** ****** ** be ********. ****** ***, the **** ** '****'.

Debate **** **********

**** *********** * ****** on *** ** ******* the *********** ** ***** systems.

************* ****** ******** **** use *** ***** ******* of ***** ******* ****** them ********** ** **% or ******. *** ****** mentions **** ********:

** **** ****, *** system ****** ******* ********* of ***** ** ****** walking ** **** ***** 6 ****** ********* **** ****** ** be *****. ********** ** this *** (*** ** false / **,*** ***** scanned) ***** * ***** positive **** ** **** 0.3% ** ** '********' of **.*%).

***** ** *****? **** are, ** **** *****. The ******** ******* ***** is **** ********.

Hard ** Visually ******

*** ******* ** **** it ** **** ** visually ****** ******* * match ** ***** ** wrong. ****** **** *****. For *******, ** ********* *********** ****, **** had ** ******** '*************'******* *** ****** *** generating *** **** ******, e.g.:

*** **** *** ********* high ******* ***** ******, not ************ ***** ***** where ******, ********, ******** variances, ***. *** **** it **** **** ** know *** **** ** just ******* ** * screen.

*************, *** ***** *** not ******* *** ******** of *** ******* ** show *** **** ** was ** **** ******* the ********* ***** *** the ****-**** *****.

Logs **** **********

*** *********** ******** * detailed *** ** ************ for *** ** *** test ***********. ** ******** one ******* **** ** front ** * ******* being ********:

** **** ******** ******** mistakes. ******* *** **** interesting ** * ** them ********* **** * minutes. ** *** *****, the ********* ******** ***** whether * ***** ** accurate *** *** ****** one ***** ***** *** ready ** ****** ***** they **** *** ******** processing *** *****:

*** *********** ******* ** that **** ** ***** have ********** *** ********** scores (** *.** *** 0.60). *** ****** ***** that *** **** *********** vendor (***) *** * threshold ** *.**:

*** ******* ********** ***** can ** ********, *** higher ** **, *** more ****** *** ****** rejects ***** ******* *** misses **** ******* *** vice *****. ** **** not ****** ***'* ****** recognition ** ** ****** opine ** *********** ******** but ******* **** ***** would ********* ****** ***** matches *** *** ******* "81%" ***** ****.

Technology ************

*** ****** ***** **** the **** ************ *** the ******* **** ********:

** ******* **** ******** about **** ******* **** used.

Positioning *** *******

*** ******* **** ********* mounted ********, ** ****, as *** ***** ***** from *** ****** *****:

*** *********** ******** ******* is **** *** *** strove ** ******* ******* and ***** ********* **** facial *********** *** ***** performed, ** **** ******* notes:

** *** **** ****, some ****** **** ******** after ******** *** ****** recognition:

China / *** **********

*** ******'* ******** ** China (***) ****** ** such ****** ******* ** facial *********** *** **** it **** *** ******* of *********** ******** ** it ** ************* ********** to ******** *** *********** of ***** *******.

**** ** **** ************** is *** **** ***** PRC ****** *********** ******* work (****** ***** **** been ******* ********* ** the ********, *.*.************************* ***********).

*** ******* **** *** PRC ****** *********** ******* is **** **** **** more ***** ***** ***** on ****, **** ******** data, **** ********* ****** (i.e., ******** ******** **), and **** (** **) legal ************.

*** ******* **** ** that ****** **** *******, especially **** *** *** dealing **** ***** ********** (e.g., ****** **** *** a *** ******* ** a *** ********, ***** PRC ******* ****** ***** have ********). ** ** inevitable **** ***** *** going ** ** ******** mistakes **** **** **** humans ** ******** ****** if **** **** ***** accuracy ** ********.

**********, ***** **** **** and ******* *** ****** about ***** *** ******* performance, ** **** ** hard ** ****** **** how **** ** *****.

UK ****** *********** ******?

***** ******* **** ********** about *** ****** ** facial *********** ** *** UK. ***** *** **** to *** **** (*******, software, *********, ***.) *** the **** ** ******* informed *******, ** ** hard ** *** **** as ***** * '**********' or *********** *******. ***** are ****** *** *** people ***** ******** *** the **** *** ********** involved.

**** ********* *** ****** as *** ********** ******** but *** ********** ** visually ********* ****** *** likely ** ************* ****** given *** **** ****** look ***** ********** ***** the *********** ** ***** quality ** ********** *******, open ****** ***********.

Comments (3)

Slava H

07/05/19 11:24pm

*********** ******, ***** ***. It's ****** ** *** real **** ***** *******.

******** ******* ****** ***** NEC **** **** ********* by ********** ********** ** Justice *****://***.****.***/*****/*******/******/**********-*****-******-********-*******-**-*************-******-***********-********

** *** ***** **** NN ******* ** ****** face ******** (*****, *** and ****..) ******** ****** in **** **** ********, where ******* ***/*** ******* are **** *** **** position ** *** ** perfect ** ** ********.

** ********** *** "******" (we *** ** ****** to **** *********) ** has **** ******** **** recognition ********** *** ************ performed **** ** ******* NIST *****. 

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 3
Unhelpful
Funny

Undisclosed Integrator #1

07/08/19 12:31pm

************* ****** ******** **** use *** ***** ******* of ***** ******* ****** them ********** ** **% or ******....

** **** ****, *** system ****** ******* ********* of ***** ** ****** walking ** **** ***** 6 ****** *** **** 30 **** ****** ** be *****. ********** ** this *** (*** ** false / **,*** ***** scanned) ***** * ***** positive **** ** **** 0.3% ** ** '********' of **.*%).

** *** ************* ** any *** **** ***** negatives **** ******* ** their **********? *** *** this ** ********* **** sounds ****** *****.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

John Honovich

IPVM | In reply to Undisclosed Integrator #1 | 07/08/19 12:42pm

** *********, ************* ********* just **** *** ***** numbers, *.*.,**** ** * ********* explanation:

** '*** *** **%' is ****** *****. **** does ** *** **%? How **** ***** *** it **, ***.?

***** *** ********* **** to **** ***** ********* into *******, ** ***** is ** ******** ******** between ***** ********* *** false *********.

* ********** ********* *** ******** ***** to *********** ****, *.*.:

Image result for roc curve facial recognition

*******, ** ************ *********, they *** ******, ** ever *****.

 

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 2
Unhelpful
Funny
Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 7,008 reports, 931 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports