Thermal Resolution Shootout

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Dec 06, 2012

thermal testEven for thermal cameras, resolution is a critical differentiator. While no MP thermal network cameras exist, users must choose between the equivalent of CIF and 4CIF cameras or roughly double the resolution. Doing so is important because the cost increase between the two is massive, essentially doubling the price and adding thousands of dollars per camera. Is it worth it for the higher resolution, and if so, what situations?

The Test

To better understand the performance differences between these two resolution levels we tested the two options from three manufacturers - Axis, FLIR and Pelco - in very dark conditions as shown in the image above.

The test was done in a open field, at multiple distances: 300', 600', 1200', and 1800', as illustrated in this image:

Site Overview

The increase in resolution did not deliver material tangible benefits and, in some cases, the lower resolution version, delivered a higher contrast, easier to discern image than the higher resolution one. Given how much more expensive the 4CIF versions are, we recommend extreme caution on purchasing them unless you can validate material advantages in your environments.

One clear benefit is in close ranges, i.e., narrow Field of Views. For instance, of the comparisons, the one with the narrowest FoV (80 feet) showed the greatest increase of details for the 640 cameras. However, using thermal for such applications is fairly niche and irrelevant to the long range, perimeter, exterior focus common in surveillance applications.

One other potential benefit of 4CIF is distances beyond 2000 feet. While most 'CIF' thermal camera's specified range is ~2000 feet, 4CIF typically are rated for ~3500 feet. However, in our tests at nearly 2000 feet, both versions looked to be fairly close to the edge of usability. If you are monitoring farther than 2000 feet with a 500+ foot FoV, it is possible than 4CIF provides some benefits.

Image Analysis Screencast

This 2 minute video overviews the main imaging differences between CIF and 4CIF:

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Image Optimization

For this test, each manufacturer's cameras used similar exposure zones, gain, and contrast settings wherever possible, to provide as much standardization as possible. Axis and FLIR allowed for custom exposure settings, while Pelco's cameras do not, instead operating in fully automatic mode.

Field of View Differences

Despite using the same focal length lens, each manufacturer's 320x240 or 384x288 camera has a slightly different field of view than its 640x480 model, due to differences in sensor size. We have noted this in each manufacturer's section. Though the lower-resolution models have slightly narrower fields of view, 640x480 models provide nearly double the horizontal resolution across a slightly wider area.

Axis Q1921 vs. Q1922

We tested two Axis cameas, a 384x288 resolution Q1921-E (~$4,300 online) and a 640x480 Q1922-E (~$9,000 online). Both of these cameras use 35mm lenses, with 16 and 18-degree focal lengths respectively. Axis claims a maximum human detection range of 2,298' with the Q1921 and 3,444' with the Q1922, well beyond the ranges we tested.

Users may download a 30-second video clip from both of these cameras themselves.

At 300 feet:

Axis 300'

At 600 feet:

Axis 600'

At 1,200 feet:

Axis 1200'

At nearly 1,800 feet:

Axis 1800'

FLIR F-313 vs. F-618

From FLIR's F Series, we tested an F-313 (320x240 imager, $5,500 MSRP) and an F-618 (640x480, $14,560 MSRP), with 13 and 18-degree FOVs, respectively. FLIR claims detection at 2,559' with the F-313 and 3,740' using the F-618.

Users wishing to see video from these cameras themselves may download a 30-second clip.

At 300 feet:

FLIR 300'

At 600 feet:

FLIR 600'

At 1,200 feet:

FLIR 1200'

At nearly 1,800 feet:

FLIR 1800'

Pelco TI335 vs. TI635

Finally, we tested two Pelco Sarix TI [link no longer available] thermal cameras, both with 35mm lenses, the TI335 (384x288, ~$5,000 online) and the TI635 (640x480, ~$10,000 online). Like Axis, this results in 16 and 18-degree fields of view, respectively. A 30-second clip of both Pelco cameras is available for review. Detection range is specified at 2,493' using the TI335 and 3,709' using the TI635.

At 300' feet:

Pelco 300'

At 600 feet:

Pelco 600'

At 1,200 feet:

Pelco 1200'

At nearly 1,800 feet:

Pelco 1800'

Related Reports

Cheap Camera Problems at Night on Feb 19, 2020
Cheap cameras generally have problems at night, despite the common perception that integrated IR makes cameras mostly the same, according to new...
FLIR A Series Temperature Screening Cameras Tested on Jun 04, 2020
FLIR is one of the biggest names in thermal and one of the most conservative. While rivals have marketed fever detection, FLIR has stuck to EST...
Converged vs Dedicated Networks For Surveillance Tutorial on Feb 12, 2020
Use the existing network or deploy a new one? This is a critical choice in designing video surveillance systems. Though 'convergence' was a big...
Integrated IR Camera Shootout 2020 - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Panasonic, Uniview, Vivotek on Jan 30, 2020
The best and worst cameras tested in this IPVM shootout showed major differences in quality and performance. While many view IR as being a...
New Axis M30 Cameras Tested on Mar 26, 2020
Axis has released a new generation of, for them, relatively low cost M30 series cameras, claiming to deliver "sharp video quality even in poor...
TVT / InVid White Light Camera Tested Vs Hikvision ColorVu on Mar 18, 2020
With mega China manufacturers Dahua and Hikvision facing both bans and human rights abuse sanctions, many budget buyers are turning to smaller...
The Booming Multi-Billion Coronavirus Fever Camera Market on Apr 21, 2020
The market for elevated body temperature detection cameras, aka 'coronavirus cameras' aka 'fever detectors', may be worth billions of dollars this...
Bleenco "Under The Tongue" Temperature Detection Examined on Jun 05, 2020
"Say aah", says Bleenco, a PPE detection video analytics company, offering a different method for measuring body temperature with a thermal...
Directory of 162 "Fever" Camera Suppliers on Jul 09, 2020
This directory provides a list of "Fever" scanning thermal camera providers to help you see and research what options are available. There are...
Bandwidth Fundamentals For Video Surveillance on Jan 13, 2020
Bandwidth is the most fundamental element of computer networking for video surveillance systems. Because video surveillance can consume an immense...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Remove Dahua and Hikvision Equipment "Immediately" Or Else Banned From US Government Contracts on Jul 10, 2020
The US government has directed contractors to remove covered equipment, such as Dahua, Hikvision, and Huawei Hisilicon products, "immediately." If...
ZeroEyes Presents Firearm Detection Video Analytics on Jul 09, 2020
ZeroEyes presented its Firearm detection Video Analytics system at the May 2020 IPVM Startups show. A 30-minute video from ZeroEyes...
Directory of 162 "Fever" Camera Suppliers on Jul 09, 2020
This directory provides a list of "Fever" scanning thermal camera providers to help you see and research what options are available. There are...
Clinton Public View Monitor (PVM) Mask Detection Tested on Jul 09, 2020
Face mask detection, or more specifically not wearing one, is expanding amidst the pandemic. Clinton Electronics has added this capability to their...
These Florida Real Estate Agents Are Now Selling "SafeCheck USA" Temperature Detectors on Jul 09, 2020
The "Kakon Brothers", William and Nathan, are self-described "south Florida Power Agents specializing in Luxury Real Estate" who "have closed over...
Avigilon ACC Cloud Tested on Jul 08, 2020
Avigilon merged Blue and ACC, adding VSaaS features to its on-premise VMS, offering remote video and health monitoring that was previously limited...
Hikvision's India Dominance Faces Threat on Jul 08, 2020
While Hikvision has become a dominant video surveillance provider in India, recent tension between the governments of India and the PRC is...
The US Fight Over Facial Recognition Explained on Jul 08, 2020
The controversy around facial recognition has grown significantly in 2020, with Congress members and activists speaking out against it while video...
Sperry West / Alibaba Tablet Temperature Measurement Tested on Jul 07, 2020
In April, we ordered a ~$500 temperature tablet from Alibaba. We set it to the side while doing 18 other temperature screening tests but, after...
Facial Recognition: Weak Sales, Anti Regulation, No Favorite, Says Security Integrators on Jul 07, 2020
While facial recognition has gained greater prominence, a new IPVM study of security systems integrators shows weak sales, opposition to...