Testing Color Analytics Performance

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Dec 16, 2013

In an industry known for overhyping its own value, color analytics have been considered pure science fiction, with few, if any, stories from the field to back up manufacturer claims.

In this report, we test Bosch's IVA color analytics to see which practical applications they performed in, and where they failed.

First, in an interior conference room with a human subject:

And an outdoor parking lot/driveway with different colored vehicles:

We varied the precision of the analytics to understand how performance varied, from least to most sensitive using their built-in scale:

We then tested a variety of colors from red, green, blue, orange, neons, etc.

**** ************* *** ********** *** *** *****, ***** ********* **** **** considered **** ******* *******, **** ***, ** ***, ******* **** the ***** ** **** ** ************ ******.

** **** ******, ** *********'* *** ***** *********** *** ***** ********* ************ **** ********* **, *** ***** they ******.

*****, ** ** ******** ********** **** **** * ***** *******:

*** ** ******* ******* ***/******** **** ********* ******* ********:

** ****** *** ********* ** *** ********* ** ********** *** performance ******, **** ***** ** **** ********* ***** ***** *****-** scale:

** **** ****** * ******* ** ****** **** ***, *****, blue, ******, *****, ***.

[***************]

Key ********

  • ** ****** *** *****, ******* *** ****** ** ******* **** the ***** ***, ****** ******** ********* ** ****** *** **** difficult. **** *******, ******* *****, **** **** ** ****** ****.
  • ******* ********* *** *** ******* ** ****** ******** ** *** desired *** ** *** ***** ***** ********** ****** (*.*., ****** and **** ********** **** **** ** *******).
  • ******************* ** * (********), **** *** **** ***** *******, ******* the ******** ** ***** ******* **** ***** ******, *** **** increases ****** ** ****, ** ****** **** ** **** ******** in ***** ** *******.
  • ******************* ** * ** * (**** ** **** ****) ******** in ******* ******* ** ****** ******* (**% *** **) ** alerts *** ********* **** ** * ***** ***** ** ****.
  • ** *** *****, ********* **** ****** ******** ******* ** * nearly ***% ******* ** ******, ** *** ****** ****** ******* colors ********, ****** *** ***** *** ***.
  • ** * ****** ******* ******* *** *****, ******** **** ************ detected **** ***** ********* *. ** ********* * *** *****, rules ****** ** ******** ** ***. 

***************

***** *** ********* ******* ******* ******** *** ***** ******, ** do *** ********* ***** ********* ** **** ** ******** ************. Alerting ** **** ******** ****** **** ****** ** **** ****** matches *** ** ****** *********** ** *****, ***, ** ******** lighting *** *******. *******, ******** ********* ******* ** ******** ****** for ****** ***** **** **** *** ** ********. ******* ** this, ***** ********* ****** **** ** **** **** ******* ** reduce *** ****** ** ****** **** ** **** ******** ************.

It ***** ** *****

*** ***** ********* **** **** ***** ** ** * **** end ****** (*** ***** ***-****) **** *** ***** **** ** *** ***** ******** **** *** *** ****** *** ***** ***********. *********** ***** ****** ** **** ***** ** ***** ******* cameras *** **** **** ****** ***** ***** ********* **** **** to **** **** ******* ******* *** ****** ****** ***********.

Configuring ******

**** ********** ******* ************* ** ***** ********* ** **** ** some ****** ****** ** *** **** ***** ********:

Selecting ******

*** ******* ******** ** *********** *****'* ***** ********* ******** ** compensating *** *** ********** ******* **** *** ****** "****" *** the ***** ******** *** *** ***** *****. *** *******, ** this *****, *** ****** ******* *** ** *** **** *******, as **** ** *** ****** ********** ** *** ***** *****, and ******** *** ********* ****:

*******, ** ***** *****, *** ****** *** ** ***, ****** mostly **** *******, ******* ** ******:

** ***** *** ******* **** **** *** *****:

  • *** ****** ** ****** *** *******'* ***** ** *** ******** color, ***** ** ****** ******.
  • ** ***** *****, ********** *** ***** ***** *** ***** **** the ****** ********** ** ** ****** ****** *** **** ******.

*******, **** ******* *** ******, ******* ********** ** *** ***** of *** ********** ****, *** ****** ***** ******** **** ****** as ****** ****, ********** ** ****** ***. **** *** **** of *** **** ***, *** ****, *****, ******, ******, ***.

****** ******

** *** *****, ********* *** *** **** ********* **** **** colors **** ** *****, ****, *** *****. ****** **** *** simply ******* *** ****** ***** *** *** ***** ** *** same ******** **** ** *** ***** *****, ****** *** ** variances ** ********** **** ******, ***.

*** *** **** ****** *** ******** ** *** ***** ***** also *** **** ******** ** ******, ** **** *****. ****** the ******** ****** ***** ***** ********* ***** ** *** ****** of *** ***** ******* ** **** ** *****. *******, ** also *********** ******* *** ****** ******* ** **** ***** **** the ****** ** *** *****, ****** ********** ********** **** **** difficult.

Color ********* **********

*** ***** ********* ******* ****** ******** **** ** ** ******** down ** **** * *** ******, ******** ** ******** ********. This ******* ****** **** * (*** ***** *******) ** * (only *** ******** *** *******), ** **** *****:

** *** *****, ** ***** **** ********* ***** * ******* reduced ******** *****. *******, ** **** *****, ****** ***** **** the ******** *** *** ******* ******, ** ****** *** ****** may ******* **** *** ** ********, *** *******. ** ********* 2 *** *****, *******, ******** *** ************, **** ***** *** rates **** **** ********* *, ** *** **** ********* ** all, ** **** ** ******** *****.

Color ********

** ***** ** * **** *** ****, ***** *** ***. Our ******* ****** ****** *** **** *** *****, ********* ** the ********* *******. ***** ***** **** ************ ********** ********** ** color, ********** ** ********* *, ***** ********* ** ***% ** attempts.

*****, ***, *** **** *** *****************, **** ***% ******** ** ********* *, ******** ** **% at ********* *. ****** ****, ** ********** * *** *, exact ****** ****** *** ******** ** ******* *** ****:

****** **** ****** **** ** *** ****** *** ***** ******** below **** ********* ** ***% **** ********* *, *** *** not ******* ** *** ** ********* * ** *****. **** was ******* *** ****** ***** *** ***** ****** ** ****** grey ** *****, ***** *** ******** ** ****** ********* ******.

Low *****

******** ***** ** ***** * ***, ******** ** **** ********* 1 ***** ************* ** ****** *** *****. ** **** ***** level, ** **** ***** ********* *** ********** ****** ** ********** for ****** ********* **** ** *** *****, *** **** *** no ****** ** *********** **********.

*****, ***** ***** ** ***** **% ******** ** ********* *, and ** ********** ** * *** *****:

 

********* ** *** ******* ****, **** ***** ***** ** ********* 1 ******** ** **** **%, **** ** ******** ** * or *****:

**** ********* ****** **** ****** *** ** *****, *********** ***** 70% ********, ****** ***** ******* ** ***** ****** ********* *:

**** ***** ********* **** *** ** *** ****** ** *** light, *** ** *** ******* **********. ** ********* *, ** remained ***% ********. ********** ** ********* *, ** ********** * 30% ***** ****, ****** **** *** ***** ***** ******:

*******, ****** *** ** ******** **** ****** **% ** ********* 1 ** *** *****, *** *** *** ******** ** * or *****: 

Vehicle ********* *********** 

** ********* *, ******** **** ************ ******** *** ** ***** larger ****. *******, *** ** *** *******'* ********, *** ***** changes ** ********* ******* *** ********* *** ******* ****, ****** the **** ****** ***** ****** ** ********* * *** ***** fail ** *******. **** *** **** ***** ******** ****** ** vehicle, ********* ****:

*** ***:

Comments (19)

Can this form of analytics be more usefull with thermal units delivering a colorized output?

Hello Birger.

No, unless you use radiometric thermal cameras giving the absolute temperature. The "standard" thermal cameras for video surveillance are differential, not radiometric: this means that they percept and show bodies with different temperatures, but you don't know if that temperature is 37° or 15°.. You just know that it is different, and the false colors (never use them with analytics; always black/white mode) are definitely relative and built frame by frame by the camera normalizing the whole image according to the different temperatures of the different bodies present in the scene in that moment.

This means that those colors are even much less reliable to search and track than when you search a color in an optical camera.

Cheers,

Simone

(TechnoAware)

Thank you for a very informative answer Simone.

/Birger

Finally!

Thank you so much John for this great report!

I will forward it to all people against whom I "fight" daily trying to convince them how much it is difficult to consider "color" as a reliable feature for analytics! And to all the writers of tenders who believes always to unlikely commercial brochures (not only from Bosh of course!..) without simply reasoning on the practical phisical issues..

Have a great time,

Simone

(TechnoAware)

Thank You Ethan & John

Great Report , Goes beyond the traditional reviews of the color dynamics of past reviews .

Great Job

Curious how it would work in a "perfect" scenario?

ie: assembly line, parking lot entrance/exit, doorway, etc. Basically if you had a setting with perfect lighting and small FOV.

Chris, parking lot entrance/exit and doorways are going to be especially challenging as varying light levels and strong backlighting are going to change the color appearance of objects over time.

I was thinking of possible applications that were made "perfect" vs "real world" applications.

Where you could control lighting and the "scene" at all times, possibly even the colors (no variations).

Yes, so if you can control things 'perfectly' it should work well. For example (I am making this up but I suspect this would work well), you have a conveyor carrying fruit and you want to automatically detect and flag fruit with 'off' colors. In such a scenario, you could carefully set it up and optimize it to accurately identify those off color fruits.

Yes, that would be a fine example.

So in a "perfect" scenario it should have a high % of accuracy otherwise don't bother...

I would assume it would also be best to pilot test the application before selling it ;-)

Chris, actually the point it's exactely this one you wrote, about making tests before.. Actually it's the main problem of this analytics market.. The problem is when the "smart" commercial always makes tests or shows demos in perfect scenarioes, with perfect stable conditions, for few minutes.... But unfortunately maybe that is not the reality.. Maybe that's just a trick, because unfortunately in the real world then the conditions are slightly never that stable for long time..

But after buying, the Customers verify in real life that it's all fake, that instead nothing works, and then none wants to see analytics anymore....... Of course Customers watch CSI in the evening and they want miracles; so "smart" commercials of course feel in need to show miracles.. But maybe it's not that "smart" and healthy to go on that way..

There are for example still many many products working by fixed background reference.. And believe me, there is no better method at all if you have 5 minutes of indoor perfectly stable and controlled environment, no shadows, no reflections, perfect stable light.. Uh, you can count the hair of a person by that method!.... But for 5 minutes... ...maybe! Nice trick..

As I always say to our Partners who tell to me "oh but what you say, I saw it by my eyes!....": yes, me too yesterday evening I was in a show of a good magician and I saw by my eyes a woman divided in 2...... But that doesn't mean the woman was really divided in 2, right?....;)

Cheers,

Simone

You got it ;-)

Guess that's why we are all here (reading IPVM), we appreciate the work they area doing in clearing the smoke screens and verifying reality...

We are using the color filter mostly for searching in the recorded video. It can help a lot to retrieve a certain person.

Thank you Bosch employee for that vague undisclosed endorsement. Care to elaborate on what people, situations, accuracy, and time frames you are doing this in?

John, perhaps you should add the additional caveat of 'Identity will be known to site admins' right after the "Post Without Disclosing Your Name" checkbox.

Some people must think they are truly anonymous, how else can you explain their audacity?

How's that? Guess we have to buy Micro SD cards then and record on the camera then run the analytics after the fact?

How does that help with alerting of an issue while it's happening vs hrs/days/weeks/etc after when it's realized, if the video is still on the card?

I would seem to think that analytics would be most powerful being run pro-actively vs re-actively, no?

Good luck finding which box the off color fruit is in, after you finally get time to run the analytics against the recorded video...

Yes, for "forensic analysis"...... Of course, because the issues of color when they come from an off-line video instead of a live one magically are solved, right?.. Wow, magic hard disk!....

Or maybe he was meaning that they open the off-line video in a Video Editor, they go to paint with bright red color the dresses of the person they want to search, then they run the analytics searching for red color and say "Oh! That's it!!..."........;)

The typical rejoinder for search is that it does not need to be as accurate as alerts. For example, if I search for a red car and get 50 matches and only one is really red, I can quickly scan through the 50 thumbnails rather than scan the full video over hours. This of course is premised on the fact that the true red car is not missed entirely.

But that's exactely the point John. As you correctly showed, the main problem is to see the color and find it.. Even in indoor as you showed, and we see then outdoor what it happens: when there are shadows, camera over/under-exposures, same camera light compensations and automatic gains, reflections of sun or any light, with artificial lights, by night, ...

I absolutely don't say it's useless, not at all. There are many examples of valuable possible applications, given a priori timely simplifying assumptions in the environment or in the application itself.. Infact also us we have this color filtering function. Only, as usual in the market there's a lot of science fiction and this kind of reports help to heal this market from confusion and false expectations..

Thanks, cheers

Simone

(TechnoAware)

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Covert IP Camera Shootout - Axis, Dahua, Hikvision, March, Vivotek on Mar 20, 2019
Covert cameras were one of the last holdout areas for analog cameras. However, in the past few years, IP / HD covert cameras have become...
BCDVideo Expansion And Switch From HP To Dell Examined on Mar 11, 2019
BCDVideo says they have more than tripled revenue in the past 5 years and are continuing to grow, powered most recently by switching their lead...
Church Technology Director Security Interview on Mar 07, 2019
With 40+ years of experience in IT from a wide array of verticals, including US and foreign military, and large corporate and industrial settings,...
Police Department Surveillance Manager Interview on Feb 28, 2019
Former Memphis PD Surveillance Manager, Lt. Joseph Patty retired months ago, but kept busy during his decades on the force, working to build up...
BluB0x Company Profile on Feb 20, 2019
BluB0x has doubled in revenue every year since its founding in 2013, according to CEO Patrick Barry. We originally reported on them in 2015. At the...
Axis IR Multi Imager Camera Tested (P3717-PLE) on Feb 18, 2019
Axis has released their first IR multi imager, the P3717-PLE, a repositionable model listing 360° IR illumination and flexible positioning,...
Hanwha Smaller Multi Imager Tested (PNM-9000VQ) on Feb 14, 2019
Hanwha's first repositionable multi imager PNM-9081VQ tested well, but was huge, over 12" wide and weighing in at over 10 pounds. Now, they have...
Solink Raises $12 Million - Company Profile on Feb 12, 2019
Most industry professionals have never heard of Solink, a company whose tagline is: It's time to revolutionize the way business uses...
Bandwidth vs Low Light Shootout - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Geovision, Hanwha, Hikvision, Uniview, Vivotek on Feb 08, 2019
Nighttime bandwidth spikes are a major concern in video surveillance, but do all manufacturers' cameras perform the same? Are some more consistent...
Sony Favorability Results 2019 on Feb 06, 2019
Sony Favorability amongst integrators improved moderately compared to their 2017 favorability results, with a modest net positive...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Silicon Valley Cybersecurity Insurance Startup Coalition Profile on Mar 20, 2019
Many industry people believe cybersecurity insurance is not worth it, as the voting and debate in our Cybersecurity Insurance For Security...
Covert IP Camera Shootout - Axis, Hanwha, Hikvision, March, Vivotek on Mar 20, 2019
Covert cameras were one of the last holdout areas for analog cameras. However, in the past few years, IP / HD covert cameras have become...
Top Metrics For Ensuring Integrator Profitability - Statistics on Mar 20, 2019
How do integrators ensure the profitability of their projects? As part of our profitability study, 100+ integrators answered the following...
Avigilon Launches 'Renewed Products Program' on Mar 19, 2019
There are lots of 'pre-owned' cars but pre-owned IP cameras? While such programs are common in other industries, in video surveillance, they are...
Hanwha Tax Evasion Probe, Camera Division Implicated on Mar 19, 2019
A Hanwha group subsidiary was raided as part of a tax evasion probe. While a Korean news media report listed the raided entity as 'Hanwha...
Genetec Security Center 5.8 Tested on Mar 19, 2019
Genetec has released Version 5.8. This comes after a wait of more than a year that caused frustrations for many Genetec partners. Our previous...
Retired Mercury President Returns As Open Options President on Mar 18, 2019
Open Options experienced major changes in 2018, including being acquired by ACRE and losing its President and General Manager, John Berman who...
Large US University End-User Video Surveillance Interview on Mar 18, 2019
Schools have become targets in modern days of active shooters and terrorist fears. The need for video and access security is high. Universities...
Hikvision Favorability Results 2019 on Mar 18, 2019
Hikvision favorability results declined significantly in IPVM's 2019 study of 200+ integrators. While in 2017 Hikvision's favorability was...
ONVIF Favorability Results 2019 on Mar 15, 2019
In the past decade, ONVIF has grown from a reaction to the outside Cisco-lead PSIA challenge, to being the de facto video surveillance standard...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact