Testing Samsung WiseNet III Panoramic CameraBy: Ethan Ace, Published on Apr 25, 2014
Samsung's IP video expansion efforts continue with their recent panoramic offerings. Their SNF-7010 [link no longer available] series claims true WDR and uses their WiseNet III chip.
Here are our key findings from this test:
- Above average WDR performance, with objects outdoor clearly visible, but washed out in all other cameras tested.
- Average low light (~2 lux) performance with detection at up to 18', but no details.
- Dark (<1 lux) performance below average
- Average full light performance (~160 lux), on par with other cameras.
- Dewarping currently officially supported via Milestone SmartClient plugin. Samsung says integrations with OnSSI, Genetec, and Exacq are underway.
- Lower than average bandwidth consumption in all scenes.
The Samsung SNF-7010 sells for ~$360 USD online, making it one of the lowest priced panoramic cameras we have tested, and priced ~40% lower than other cameras in this test, which all retail for ~$600 online.
- Axis M3007-PV: ~$600 USD
- Brickcom MD-300Np-360P: ~$600
- Samsung SNF-7010: ~$360
- Vivotek FE8172V: ~$600
The SNF-7010 has the strongest WDR performance of any panoramic camera we have tested, making it the best choice for areas with varying lighting conditions, such as lobbies and loading docks, where panoramic cameras have historically performed poorly. However, if low light image quality is the main concern, users would likely be better served by other options, such as Brickcom and Axis.
Readers may also reference our test of the ACTi E96, another fisheye panoramic in the SNF-7010's price range (~$360 online). The ACTi E96's performance was below that of the Axis, Brickcom, and Vivotek cameras in this test in all light levels tested.
In this video, we review the physical construction of the SNF-7010:
The web interface of the SNF-7010 is nearly identical to other cameras in the WiseNet III series, with the exception of true day/night options, as this camera has no mechanical cut filter (software day/night only). No specific options are included affecting panoramic operation. We've included the screencast from our WiseNet III shootout here:
In this screencast we review use of the Samsung Fisheye Milestone plugin:
We shot the cameras in this test in a typical warehouse scene on a sunny day, seen in this image, to test WDR performance:
The SNF-7010 had the strongest WDR performance of any panoramic camera we have tested, with the ability to clearly see object outside, past the brightly lit overhead door in our warehouse scene. This comparison shows WDR on and off to give an idea of the full effect:
Compared to other cameras in this scene, the SNF-7010 displays far more detail beyond the door, with others simply washed out. However, details of our test chart are reduced, with the Axis M3007 and Brickcom MD-300Np able to read lines 4/5, while Samsung is difficult to discern past line 3.
In low light, about 2 lux, the SNF-7010's performance is close to other cameras in details of both subject and chart.
This is true at 12', as well.
At ~18', the SNF-7010 is able to more easily discern letters of the test chart than other cameras, though subject details are approximately the same.
Dark (< 1 lux)
Below 1 lux, at ~6', the SNF-7010 is unable to detect our subject at all, though the chart is still visible.
At ~12', the chart becomes undetectable, while the M3007 and MD-300Np are still able to make it out.
Full Light Comparison
Full light performance of the SNF-7010 is average compared to other cameras, with slight blur obscuring some details, even after refocusing the camera. At 6', performance is about equal to the MD-300Np and FE8172V, while the M3007 is clearly able to read more lines of our test chart, and shows better details of the subject's face.
At 12', the test chart is moderately less legible than in the Axis M3007. Details are about equal to Brickcom and Vivotek at this range.
Finally, at 18', performance lags behind Axis and Vivotek, but is about equal to Brickcom.
With all cameras set to 10 FPS using H.264, the Samsung SNF-7010 had some of the lowest bandwidth in our tests, lower than Brickcom, the other 3MP camera in this test, and far lower than the Axis M3007 in all scenes. However, the Vivotek FE8172V, a 5MP model, was lower than the SNF-7010 in all scenes.
The following camera firmware was used for this test:
- Axis M3007: 5.55.1
- Brickcom MD-300Np-360P: v220.127.116.11
- Samsung SNF-7010: 1.12_131218
- Vivotek FE8172V: FE8172-VVTK-0102b
The following VMS and client versions were used:
- Exacqvision: 18.104.22.168118
- Milestone XProtect SmartClient 2013 R2 (8.1b)
- Samsung Smart Viewer: v4.3.2_140226