Disaster At ISC West: Reed And SIA Burn ManufacturersBy John Honovich, Published on Mar 16, 2020
ISC West is a disaster but there's a winner for now. Reed and SIA have burned the manufacturers in spectacular fashion.
The coup de grâce was setting the new dates. ISC West will start Monday, July 20th.
This further enraged manufacturers, with immediate responses:
- "Seriously, just cancel it already. Reed has botched this so badly the show is going to be a disaster no matter what. Between the crappy dates and lingering Coronavirus impact, enthusiasm for this show is basically gone."
- "Awesome, I get to burn a weekend in July setting up for the show. I hope my company just postpones until 2021."
- "The July show is merely a mechanism to recoup revenue for Reed/SIA and will be the worst attended show, of this size, in history. We will not be exhibiting."
- "Why are they not doing the honourable, sensible and safe thing by simply cancelling, moving forward and preparing for 2021. Are they that gREEDy that they couldn’t bear refunding exhibitors."
- "I would rather die myself than attend this utter disgusting, disgraceful debacle that puts money over human life otherwise known as ISC West. And not just this year, but any year thereafter."
Reed / SIA Already Made Their Money
Flaming the manufacturer's anger is that Reed / SIA has essentially made all their money for the 2020 show from the manufacturers. Attendees pay ISC West virtually nothing while manufacturers exhibiting have to pay, in full, many months in advance. And Reed is refusing refunds.
However much of a disaster ISC West July 2020 is, it does not matter financially to Reed and SIA. They keep all the money. The loss goes all to the manufacturers.
Monday Start Problem
The July 2020 show is starting on a Monday, which is a big problem compared to ISC West's normal Wednesday start.
Exhibitors need to set up during the weekend, which means paying much higher union labor costs, forcing their employees to sacrifice a summer weekend and having to do setup without any air conditioning while daytime temperatures average 105°F.
Attendees either need to travel on a Sunday in the Summer or miss the first day to travel on a Monday. This invariably causes even further declines in Monday traffic.
Reed told us those dates were the only ones available. This is likely true, given the challenges of rescheduling such a large event, but the problems remain.
The Sands told us that the show can opt to pay to turn on the air conditioning during setup but Reed did not confirm whether they would, telling us generally:
Over the next month we will be working on many planning details to produce a high-quality event, and be providing lots of communications re operations, conference programming, and special events @ ISC West 2020.
July Vegas Problem
Monday makes it worse, but any business event in July and especially with 105°F temperatures is highly problematic as many noted:
- "Attendance down Temperature up"
- "Nobody will show up as manufacturers already have their schedules planned for the year."
- "Hot Time to be in Vegas. People already have holidays booked."
- "Vegas is hot in July, and also conflicts with vacations etc. I think it will have a much lower attendance."
- "They should just cancel the show at this point. July means vacations for most people. Possible the worst month to organize industry events."
- "It’s going to be in the middle of everybody’s vacation. Attendance will be poor."
- "Summer is a tough time for events, there will be many vacation conflicts for attendees and exhibitors. Also, July in Vegas isn't ideal."
- "It’s hot as hell in Vegas, many people take vacation in July so I’m concerned that attendance will be poor."
- "Vegas in the middle of July, and just about 60 days prior to GSX? Yikes. Will most likely be poorly attended."
- "July is a huge vacation month and the average temp in Vegas in July is over 100 degrees"
Even without coronavirus concerns, a rescheduled business trade show in July starting on a Monday will have massively declining attendance.
And even if you are the SIA director who dismissed coronavirus, the shutdowns spreading across the world are going to further reduce the number of people willing to fly out to a trade show, even if these shutdowns are lifted before July.
Four months ago, we wrote about The Cowardly, Greedy "Leaders" of Video Surveillance - SIA.
It is the same scenario playing again. SIA is so fixated on its short term money and so incapable of standing up for what is right, that this disaster unfolds in slow motion.
SIA did not reply to IPVM's requests for comment.
Reed And SIA Will Lose Too
But the irony is that Reed and SIA will lose from this as well. A month ago, ISC West was overwhelmingly viewed as the most effective American trade show for manufacturers (see, e.g., our 2019 statistics). Now, legions of manufacturers are irate at Reed and SIA for forcing them into this position.
The manufacturers stand to lose a lot in 2020 but Reed and SIA will get theirs too.
Incredibly, ISC West has raised exhibitor prices for 2021 and are sticking to it:
They are going to face a sharply rising number of exhibitors who balk at all of this - demanding discounts, downsizing their booths or quitting the show in 2021.
This could have been avoided by canceling the show this year, taking the loss now but keeping the goodwill they have with their manufacturer customers.
Cowardly More Than Greedy
That this will be a disaster is not hard to understand. It is no obscure technological topic. Reed and SIA obviously know the problems of rescheduling a show in July on a Monday in the midst of coronavirus. They just do not have the backbone to stand up and protect their own long-term interests.
SIA loves to talk about leadership and how they are leaders. But while they talk about leadership, the manufacturers get burned while SIA cowers in the corner.