Open vs End-to-End Solutions: Integrator Statistics 2016

By: IPVM Team, Published on May 12, 2016

This is the first and only statistics that show preference levels for open vs end-to-end solutions.

150+ integrators told IPVM what they preferred, answering:

"For video surveillance systems, do you prefer open architecture or end-to-end (i.e., cameras and recorders/VMS from different manufacturers or a single manufacturer for both)? Why? Who?"

This is a key question, as end-to-end solutions have become increasingly hot, with manufacturer consolidation being a sign that open systems are on the decline. On the other hand, for years, the benefits of open architecture has been touted.

But which side has more support across integrators? Is open 'dead' or is end-to-end overhyped?

Integrator results show a clear winner - by a 3:1 ratio.

**** ** *** ***** and **** ********** **** show ********** ****** *** **** vs ***-**-*** *********.

***+ *********** **** **** what **** *********, *********:

"*** ***** ************ *******, do *** ****** **** architecture ** ***-**-*** (*.*., cameras *** *********/*** **** different ************* ** * single ************ *** ****)? Why? ***?"

**** ** * *** question, ** ***-**-*** ********* have ****** ************ ***, with manufacturer ************* ***** * sign **** **** ******* are ** *** *******. On *** ***** ****, for *****, *** ******** of **** ************ *** been ******.

*** ***** **** *** more ******* ****** ***********? Is **** '****' ** is ***-**-*** *********?

********** ******* **** * clear ****** - ** a *:* *****.

[***************]

*******

*********** ****** ********* **** systems, ******** **** ** * 3:1 ***** **** ***-**-***.

*** *** ****** ***** were:

  • **** *** ********* ********* for ****** *** '**** possible ********', ******** ****-**, and ****** **** ** ****** vendor *** ** **** at *** *****.
  • ***-**-*** *** ****** ****** preferred *** **** ** support/install, *** ******** ********** or usability.
  • ******** *** *** ***** top ****** ** *** "***-**-***" category
  • ********* *** *** **** preferred **** ******, ******* and ***** *** **** showings, ** ***** *** had ******* ********
  • **** *** *** **** preferred ****** ***** *** open *******, **** ********* 2nd
  • **** *********** *** **** for *** **** ** customer, *** ***-**-*** *** another, ****** * ***** answer 

Best ******** ******** - ****

********** *** **** ********* often ******** ****** ******* to ***** ********* *** best ******** ********:

  • "****- *** ** ******* the ****** **** *** best ********* *** ***** requirements."
  • "** ****** ************ *** cover *** *** ********** you ********* ** *** field ** **'* ********* to ** **** ** combine ********* ************ ******** into *** ******** ****** that ********* *** ********* needs."
  • "* ****** ****. * find **** *** ************ never *** *** **** solution ** *** ********, particularly ** ******* ** cameras."
  • "**** ************. ** *** add * ****** **** to ** ******** *** I *** *** *** best ******* *** *** application. ** **** ******* that * ** *******/ servicing ** *** **** of ** *******."
  • "* ****** **** ************. Client ***** *** **** from **** ** ****."
  • "** **** ***********, ** use ********** **** ******* manufacturers ** ******* *** best ********** ********* ** fit *** ********* *****."
  • '**** ************ ***** * wider ******* ** ********* for *** ********'* ************."
  • "**** ************ - ** typically **** * ******* of ****** ***** **** we **** ** ******* a ******* *** ******* no *** ************ ***** all *** ******* ** need. ** ********, ** don't **** *** ********* (or *********) ** ** one *** ** *******."
  • "**** ******. **** ****** for *** ****** ** use *** "**** ** breed" ********** ** **** their *** **********; ******* that ********* ** **** savings, *** ** ******** technology, ** ** ****** align **** *********** ** infrastructure *** ************ *********** goals." 

Avoid ****-** - ****

******** ***** ****** ****-** and *********** **** **** common *** ***** **** preferred **** *******:

  • "****** ****. ** ** view **** ******* ***** a *** ****** ******* solution *** ***'* **** clients **** * ****** vendors ******."
  • "**** ******. ** ***** vendor **** **, **** en **** ****** ** components. ** ****** ******** best *** ******** *** every ********* ** * need ** ** **** to *** *** ***** products ******** ** *** an ******* ********"
  • "****. ********* ***'* **** being ****** ** ** a ******* **** *****'* progress **** ********** ** offer ***** *******."
  • "**** ************ - *** locked **** *** *********** pricing, ******* *** ** philosophy. "
  • ** ****** **** ************. We ***'* **** ****** having *** ******* ** "limit" ** ** *** way *** ***-**-*** **** shown ** ****** *** and *** ******* ******* in ******* **********."

Manufacturers ****** ** **** ** **** - ****

*********** **** **** **** manufacturers ****** ** **** at ******* *** *** simultaneously:

  • "****! **** *** ** go,no *** ************ **** it ****"
  • "** *** ** **** a ***-**-*** ******** *** are ******** *** * mediocre ****** ******* ****** does ********** *******."
  • "* ********** **** *** Genetec/Axis ****** ****** *************. It ** ********* ** be ****** ** *** things, ** **** *** have *** ********** ********* that **** *** ******** in ***** ***** **** together ** ***********, *** outcome ** **** ********** for *** ********* *** very ********* *** *** integrator."
  • "****** ************* ***'* ** a **** ** *** trades *** ***** ************* differentiate **** ***** ******** that *** *** **** to **** **. *.*. Arecont ****'* *** ******** to ********'* ** *** opinion *** *********'* ****** are *** ***** ** go **** ** * series ******** **** * far ****** ********** *** in *** **** ********** or ***** **** *** with ****** ******."
  • "**** ************. * ******* you ****** *** *** Software ******* **** ******** and *** ******** ******* make ********. ** * have ****** ****, *** should ** ** ****** in **** *** **, not * **** ** all ******."
  • "**** ************ ******* ********* vms ********* *** **** cameras, ********* ***** ******** or ***** ******* *** feature **** ** **********. its ****** *** ** the *****."
  • "**** ************. *** ** end ********* *** ****** best ** ***** ** all *****."

Guaranteed ** **** - ***-**-***

***-**-*** ******* **** **** commonly ******** *** "********** to ****" *******, **** some *********** **** ******* they ****** ***-**-*** **** for ***** *** ******* (ease ** *******, **** of *******) **** ****** customer ******* **** ******** or *********.

  • "***-**-*** **** *** **** manufacturer ******* **** **** work **** ******** *********.  In *** ********** ** open ** **** ***** are **** ******* ****** which **** **** ** resolve"
  • "** ****** *** ** End ** ***** ************* issues. ** ** ***** a *******."
  • "* ****** * ****** manufacturer ******* ** *********** issues."
  • "** ** ********** ***-**-*** is ****** ** *******, service,manage *** ***."
  • "*** ** *** ****** works ***** **** *** me ** ****** * blame **** ******* ************* and ******* *** ** demand ****** ******* * always *** ** *** Bosch ****** **********"
  • "***-**-*** ******** *********** ********. Less ************ ********* *** support ** * ****** number ** ****."
  • "***-**-***. *'** *** **** problems *** ** **** architecture ******* **** ******* manufacturers; *************** *** ******** upgrades *** *** ** be * ******."
  • "*** ** *** **** Avigilon. ***** ** * significant ******* ** ************ labor **** ** *** Avigilon. *** ******* *** easy ** *******, *** user ********* ** ****** to ********** *** **** tech *** **********, *** all *** ******* *** updated *************."
  • "** ****** ***-**-***, ** is ****** *** ************ since ***** ** **** one ** *****"
  • "****** ****** *** *** from ****** ************. ** have ***** *** ** it ** ****** *** technicians ** ***** *** potential ***** ****** **** there ** *** ***** of ******* *** *** problem."

More ******** ******** - ***-**-***

**** ********* **** ***** that ******-****** ********* **** to **** ****** ******* for ******** ******** ******** work ** ********:

  • "** ******* ** ****** an *** ** **** solution ***** ** ****** enables ** ********* *********** features ** *** ****** such ** ****** ** board ***** *********, ******* it ****** ******* ** keep ***** ***** *********** possible ******* **** ********* such *****."
  • "********* ** ****** ** use *** ************. ***** in **********. ** ****** us ** *** *** extra ******** ***** **** the ******."
  • "********* *** ***'* **** any ****** **** ****** source ************* *** **** cameras **** **** ***** full ******* ********* ** the ***."

Mixed ** "****" *******

******* *********** ******** **** they ****** ***** ******** to *** ***** ** the **** ** ********** of *** ******. ***-**-*** solutions **** ******** ***** as ***** ***** *** smaller ** **** ********* installations, ****** **** *********** felt *** ***** ********.

  • "*** ***** ******* (********* 16 **** ** ****), end-to-end ********* *** **. However, ******** ****** * 'simple' ******** ** *** an **** ***. *******, hospitals, *********."
  • "**** ************* ******* ****** Open ************ ** **** advantage ** *** **** new ************ *********** ***** introduced *** *** **** platforms. *** *********** ***** and ******** ** **********. The ***** **** ************* clients **** *** ** end ********* **********, ***** they *** *** ******* for ** ******* * variety ** *******."
  • "** *** **** ********* on *** *********: ***-**-*** with ********* ** ***** jobs (***** ** *******) because *** ******* *** readily *********, **'* **** to ***-** *** *** clients ** *** **** to ** ******** ***** than ****** *** *** odd ******** *** **** live *******. **** ************ is **** **** ***** are **** **** ** cameras *** *** ******* wants ** **** **** features ** *********** **** their ******** ***/** ****** control."
  • "*** ****** ** ****** systems, * **** **** ended *** **** ******* to *** *** **** fit *** *** ********. Salient,Exacq, ********* ****,*******/******, *** small ******* * **** end ** *** ** keep ** **** *** simple. *********,*******/******, **********"
  • "*** ******* ******* ************* open *** ********* ******* of *** *********** *** price *****. ** ****** commercial ************* *** ***-**-*** is ********* ******* ** the ********* ******* *** warranty ********."
  • "****** ******* ** *** customer/integrator - *** ** end ** *** **** answer *** *** *** more ***** ********/********** **** architecture ** *** *** to **."
  • "*** **** *** ***** Avigilon *** ** ***. Mid ***** ********* *** + ******** ***. *** end ********* ********* + Hikvision ***. ********* ***'* seam ****** ********** ** value, ******* ********* *** still *** ****** ******. Therefore *** ********."

Most ******* ************ ********

*** **** *****, ********* was *** **** ********** mentioned, **** ******* *** Exacq ******* ****** *******.  Other ***'* *** *** have ********** *******.

*** ****** ****** **** preferred ** **** *******, Axis *** *** ************ winner, *** ********* *** a ******* ******. 

Beware ***-**-*** ******** ****

***** ******* *** ******** to *** ******** ***** of *************, ***** *** led **** ** ******* that ***-**-*** ********* *** overall *********. **** *** not.

****** ******** ** *** most ***** ******* ** end-to-end ******** *******, **** are ** *******. ***, Avigilon's ******* *************** ** extraordinary. ** *** ******* and ********** *******, ** other ***-**-*** ******** ***** ******** close ** ********'* ******* product ********, ** **** focused ********* ******** *********** ****************** *****. ******, ** **** survey's *******, ******* ********, end-to-end ********* ***** ****** **** any *******. ***, ******* important, ********'* ******* ****** share *** ******* ** execute *** **** ******** limits ** ***** ************ ********* ********* ******* show.

** *** ***** ****, there ** **** ********* rationale *** ************* ****** to ***-**-*** *********. ***** the ******** *** ****** always ***** ** **** ****** the *****, ** ** generally ****** ** **** more **** ******** * manufacturer '****' **** *** more *** ******** *** only * **** ** the **** / *******, especially ** *** ******* is *** *** **** on *** ********** ****. To **** ***, *** number ** ***-**-*** ************* may ******** ** ****, but ** ****** ****** all ** **** ** struggle **** ******* *************** and ****, ** ****, mediocre ********* *******.

** ***** **** *** integrators ** **** ****** that *** **** ******* solution **** ************* **** ***** ******** manufacturer's ******** ** ** open ******. ***, ******* what *** **** ** recently, **** ** *** changing.

Comments (8)

These results run contrary to the industry trend of consolidation, which has led many to believe that end-to-end solutions are overall preferred. They are not.

I know some serious M&A talks are going on in the industry based on this believe... maybe those participating should take a deep breath and look at the possible ways to improve their own technology instead

Aren't a lot of integrators selling Hik or Dahua kits (cameras/nvr)?

Would those be considered an end-to-end solution?

Those kits are definitely end-to-end, though (1) evidently it is not what integrators prefer and (2) what's driving that is clearly the super low price. A Vicon or Verint or March or whomever end-to-end solution is probably better but at 5x the price, that's the difference maker.

Indeed, in this survey's results, without Avigilon, end-to-end solutions would hardly have any support.

Yet since, IMHO, such kits seem to be selling quite well, (i.e., do you think more Hik kits were sold than Milestone systems in the last year?), are we to conclude that what integrators are preferring is not strongly correlated to what they are actually purchasing?

Among IPVM integrators, who are generally focused on selling to commercial/ industrial / government, I think more Milestone systems were sold than Hik kits. And, as you pointed out, Hik is now a Milestone super / elite partner and, as our results pointed out, Hikvision is frequently used as an open component with third party VMSes.

Kits are real player in the overall video surveillance market, but they are clearly primarily for residential and SMB and they win because the price is much less. The lesson remains, for manufacturers who want end-to-end commercial solutions, unless they can sell it for $500 for 8 Full HD camera system, open is preferred.

[Kits] win because the price is much less...

Yes, I agree. So, even if a given integrator did primarily sell them, they may not prefer them. Take the well known J.D.; sells a lot of Dahua recorders, but prefers Digital Watchdog.

Some of this "preferring" but not necessarily "purchasing" might explain part of the Axis landslide victory here. Based on a admittedly subjective impression based on general sentiment expressed on the forum, I would say it's unlikely that Axis is selling ~2x the cameras that Hik is to IPVM integrators.

So, (if you agree that integrators on this forum buy at least as much Hik as Axis), then Hik's non-correlated results above might best be explained by them being purchased but not preferred to Axis (in the Open) or Avigilon (in the e-to-e).

Having worked for a number of integrators down the years I think that the open vs end to end question will always be answered by the sales imperative. Having run design teams with the best intentions of delivering as open a solution as possible when designing systems for bids there was always an overriding economic driver when it came to the final decision on what would be offered.

When working on a large bid it is difficult to argue points of principle with a business development team who are getting prices from every manufacturer on the planet in an attempt to increase margin through manufacturer discount. This often results in integrators who provide bids around an end to end solution being more competitive and winning projects.

It is a fact of commercial life and although the intentions might be there to deliver systems that do not lock end users in it is usually economics that wins the day.

often results in integrators who provide bids around an end to end solution being more competitive and winning projects.

Warren, that's a good point. I think that ties into the sales advantage that end-to-end providers. It's a lot easier to give steeper discounts if you are selling the servers, the VMS, the cameras and the analytics than if you are just selling one of those four.

I do wonder what percentage of bids go end-to-end. We've never studied a large set of bids but reviewing a fair number of them (at least in the US) indicates that mixed manufacturer combinations typically win.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Axis HD Analog Encoder Tested on Oct 11, 2019
Two years after declaring "Everything is IP", Axis has released their first HD analog encoder, the P7304, with support for AHD, CVI, TVI, and SD...
Network Optix NxWitness 4.0 Tested on Oct 10, 2019
Network Optix released Nx Witness 4.0, proclaiming new features like a deep learning analytics metadata SDK, increased H.265 support, and UX...
Crisis At China's Largest VMS Provider, Netposa, Now State-Controlled on Oct 07, 2019
NetPosa, which bills itself as the PRC's largest VMS provider, is in a crisis. The firm is pursuing huge unpaid bills from clients, and its...
Vivotek 4K S-Series Camera Tested on Sep 30, 2019
Vivotek's highest-end S-series camera claims "Supreme Night Visibility", "Smart IR II", "Smart Stream II", "WDR Pro for unparalleled visibility in...
RealNetworks SAFR Facial Recognition Profile on Sep 25, 2019
RealNetworks entered the surveillance market by giving away their analytics to schools for free, and is now targeting large commercial users with...
Hikvision Acusense Analytics Tested on Sep 23, 2019
Hikvision touts "The Magic Behind It All" in their new Acusense line are 'deep learning algorithms' inside these cameras and recorders. But how...
Axis Perimeter Defender Improves, Yet Worse Than Dahua and Wyze on Sep 19, 2019
While Axis Perimeter Defender analytics improved from our 2018 testing, the market has improved much faster, with much less expensive offerings...
Directory of 70 Video Surveillance Startups on Sep 18, 2019
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known. 2019...
Vivotek "Neural Network-Powered Detection Engine" Analytics Tested on Sep 17, 2019
Vivotek has released "a neural network-powered detection engine", named Smart Motion Detection, claiming that "swaying vegetation, vehicles passing...
Panasonic 4K Camera Tested (WV-S2570L) on Sep 13, 2019
Panasonic has released their latest generation 4K dome, the WV-S2570L, claiming "Extreme image quality allows evidence to be captured even under...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Axis HD Analog Encoder Tested on Oct 11, 2019
Two years after declaring "Everything is IP", Axis has released their first HD analog encoder, the P7304, with support for AHD, CVI, TVI, and SD...
Dahua Celebrates PRC 70th Wearing Communist Party Hammer and Sickle on Oct 11, 2019
Dahua celebrated the PRC's 70th anniversary with a video of various Dahua employees wearing China Communist Party hammer and sickle pins as shown...
Last Chance - Register Now - October 2019 IP Networking Course on Oct 10, 2019
Last Chance - Register Now - Fall 2019 IP Networking Course. The course starts next week. This is the only networking course designed...
Network Optix NxWitness 4.0 Tested on Oct 10, 2019
Network Optix released Nx Witness 4.0, proclaiming new features like a deep learning analytics metadata SDK, increased H.265 support, and UX...
HID Fingerprint Reader Tested on Oct 09, 2019
HID has released their first access reader to use Lumidigm optical sensors, that touts it 'works with anyone, anytime, anywhere'. We bought and...
ONVIF Suspends Dahua and Hikvision on Oct 09, 2019
Dahua and Hikvision have been 'suspended', and effectively expelled, from ONVIF, immediately following US sanctions being placed on the 2 mega...
Hikvision And Dahua Sanctioned For Human Rights Abuses on Oct 07, 2019
In a groundbreaking move that will have drastic consequences across the video surveillance market, Dahua and Hikvision have been sanctioned by the...
Avigilon H5A Analytic Cameras Tested on Oct 07, 2019
Avigilon has released its H5A analytic cameras, claiming to "detect more objects with greater accuracy even in crowded scenes." We tested the...
Crisis At China's Largest VMS Provider, Netposa, Now State-Controlled on Oct 07, 2019
NetPosa, which bills itself as the PRC's largest VMS provider, is in a crisis. The firm is pursuing huge unpaid bills from clients, and its...
Knightscope Sells Just 1 Net New Robot In 6 Months on Oct 04, 2019
For the first half of 2019, US government records show that Knightscope has sold just 1 net new robots ('machines-in-network'), inching up from 52...