Disruputing Smoke Detectors: Nest vs. Roost

By: Brian Rhodes, Published on Jul 08, 2015

A startup has an idea that will make any smoke detector 'smart' - a WiFi connected battery. Instead of replacing existing units with a Nest Detector costing a hundred dollars or more, Roost sells a replacement battery for 65% less that claims to bring 'dumb' smoke detectors into the cloud.

However, Roost does not offer the full range of features that Nest does. Are those shortcomings that will chance prospective customers away? We take a deeper look at Roost smoke detector batteries inside.

* ******* *** ** idea **** **** **** any ***** ******** '*****' - * **** ********* battery. ******* ** ********* existing ***** **** * Nest ******** ******* * hundred ******* ** ****, Roost ***** * *********** battery *** **% **** that ****** ** ***** 'dumb' ***** ********* **** the *****.

*******, ***** **** *** offer *** **** ***** of ******** **** **** does. *** ***** ************ that **** ****** *********** customers ****? ** **** a ****** **** ** Roost ***** ******** ********* inside.

[***************]

Gunning *** ****

***** ****** ** ***** much ** **** **** Protect ****, *** *** existing ***** ********* *** for * ******** ** the *****. ******* ** marketing ** ******** *** device, *** ******* ** built **** *** *********** battery.  

*** ******* ** ******** that **'* $** ********* will ** **** ********* than *** **** ********'* $99 *****, ******** ********** to ******* ***** ******** smoke ********* *** *** cost ** *** **** unit.

*** ** ** **** consumers *** ******* ***? While *** ********* **** appears *****, ** *** not ** * ********** success.  **** ****, ***** launched * *********** **** earned *** ******* **** under $**** ******* **** about **** ******* - hardly * *********** ******** when ******** *** ****** by ***** ********** *** residential ****** *****.  ***** the ******** *****, *** company *** **** ********** design *** **********, *** expects ** ***** ******** product ** ** ****.  Batteries *** ** ********** *** $** **** **** *** *******'* ******* or **** ******.

*** *******

*** **** ********* ** using ***** ** **** it ******** ************* **** the ******** *** ***** them ** ***** *** smartphone ***.  ******* ** is * ******** '*** battery' ***** ** * valid ***** ********* *****, Roost ******* *** ****** the *****.

***** ** * ******** product ********** **** *** smoke ** ****** ******** detector **** **** ** batteries.  **** *** ******** *********** standardizing ** **** ******* size, * *********** ******** of ********* ***** *** use *****.

*** ***** ***** ******** an ******** ** *** concept:

***** **** ****** ***** notifications, *** ******* *** be ****** **** ***** app *****.  ** ** the **** ** * user *********, **** *** configure ****** ** **** to * ****** ******** or ****** ******.

Product ******

*** **** ****** **** battery ******** ***** ***** 10% *** **** ****** the ******** **** **** the *** *******.  **** for ** ****** ***** - *** *** ****** a ****** ** * specific ****, *********** ********* response *** ******** **** to * ******** **** rather **** ******* ****** for *** ******. ***** claims *******:

  • **** *********:***** ***** *** ********** via *** ******* * residential **** ****** ****** installation. **********, **** *** inserted **** * ******** just **** *** ***** 9V *******, *** **** remain ****** *** **** coverage **** ** ****.
  • * **** ****:*** ******* ****** **'* lithium ***** **** **** longer **** * *****. Given **** **** ***** detectors ****** ** ******** after ** *****, **** users ****** ****** ** swap ********* ** ***** once ** ****** ***.
  • *** ************: *** ******* ****** is *** ************. *******, the ******* ****** *** lithium ***** **** ** field ********* **** *********** cores ******* ***** $**. Over *** ******* **** of * ****** ***** detector, ***** **** ***** about $** *** ******** for ********* *** *****.
  • ********* **: **** *********** *****/** detectors ** *** *** the ** ******* *** primary *****, ******* *** hardwired **** ***** ******* and **** *** *** 9V *** ******. ***** says **** ** ** problem, *** ***** ****** will ******* ** *** same *** ** **** as *** **** **** uses ** *********.

Next ******* ** *****

*** *** ******** ********* in **** *** ********* ** Roost.  ***** **** ********* claim ** ***** *** remotely ****** ** '***** detected' *** '*** ******* alerts', **** ******* ******** additional *****, ***********, *** motion ******* **** ***** does ***. ***** ********** sensors ******* ***** *********** that ***** ******, ********* the ******* ** ****** smoke ****** **** *********** detection ** **** *** '1st **********' ******* **** disarms **** * **** of *** ****.

***** **** *** ******* integration **** ***** ******* like *** **** **** claims ******. ***** ******* is ********** **** **** Cameras *** *********** ** a ******* ******, ***** is * ****** ****** closed ** ****** ** other *******. *** ******* claims ** ***** *********** is ** *** *****, but **** ** **** release ****.

**********

***** ***** ** ***** 30% *** **** ** Nest, ***** *** ******* strategic ********** **** ***** spell ********** *******:

  • ************: **** ****** *** batteries ***** * * year **** ****, *** user's **** ***** ** likely ** ****** ****** that ****. ***** ******* over *** ********* **** to *** ****** ********* happens, ** ** *** likely ***** **** ******** with ***** ********* *** may ********* ******* ** with ****** **** *** novelty ***** ***.  ** is ********* ** ***** to ******** ******** *********** for ****** *******. ****** that, ***** **** **** to ******** ****** ******** apps *** *** ***** units ** ** **** than ********* **** ******** happen.
  • ******** ********: ****** ******* ****, the **** ****** ****** has * ********. **** codes ******** *** '******* length' ** * *********** smoke ******** ** ** years ** **** [**** no ****** *********] (**** **-****/**** 14.4.8), ** ***** ***** may **** **** **** to ******* *** ****** anyway *** ********* ********* a ****** ****. ****** Nest, ***** **** *** include *** ******* ** detect ********* **** ** a ********* ******.

**********

Comments (2)

I backed this and have found the more "features" Roost adds or plans to add the less interested I am. I simply want to know if my smoke detector is going off. That is it. They have plans to add about a bazillion different “features” (that I find to be an overreach) which could kill the Roost before it even gets off the ground. Stick to the one simple feature and add as you go. I have received multiple surveys about what I would like to see added and while none of the additional features come to my mind at the moment, none of them seemed necessary or even feasible.

I don’t trust the Nest detector right now, but if it is still around five or so years from now when I need to swap my detectors I may go with it. Until Nest has a much longer track record I won’t go for it.

I'm in full agreement Ross. I only want to know 3 things from an alert:

1) That the smoke detector went off

2) Which detector went off

3) When the battery is low

If I could get all of that for $25-$35 AND a 5-year guaranteed battery life, I'd absolutely buy this product.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

CES 2019 Show Report on Jan 10, 2019
IPVM was at CES 2019 for the second year (see our CES 2018 Show Final Report) and is reporting on announcements and interesting news from the show...
Bad: Dahua Villa Video Doorbell Tested on Jan 11, 2019
Doorbells are one of the hottest segments in the residential market but Dahua's Villa Video Doorbell is the worst we have tested.   We bought and...
Camera Disruptor Wyze Enters Sensor / Security Market on Mar 28, 2019
Wyze, the company that has disrupted consumer IP cameras, combining American marketing and Chinese manufacturer, has just announced its expansion...
Alarm.com Favorability Results 2019 on Apr 15, 2019
The once dot com startup has evolved to become a core provider for home security and is now expanding into commercial. In their first entry in...
Amazon Marketing Pro Installs of Amazon Security Systems on Apr 25, 2019
Is Amazon a threat to conventional providers like ADT, Vivint and Brinks Home Security? Many say no. Now, Amazon is advertising free in-home...
Risk of Amazon Alexa Guard: No Battery Or Cell Backup on Jun 20, 2019
Amazon positions its Alexa Guard Service as a "smart home security system" and says it can help you "keep your home safe". However, the...
Commend ID5 Intercom Tested on Sep 12, 2019
Commend touts the new ID5 intercom as 'timelessly elegant' and the slim body, glass front touchscreen indeed looks better than common, but ugly,...
Disruptor Wyze Releases Undisruptive Smartlock on Dec 06, 2019
While Wyze has disrupted the consumer IP camera market with ~$20 cameras, its entrance into smart locks is entirely undisruptive. We have...
"Good Market, Bad Business Models" - Residential Security on Dec 11, 2019
Industry banker John Mack, at his company's annual event, took aim squarely at the problems in the residential security...
ADT CEO Not Worried About DIY: "2 Discrete Markets" on Dec 13, 2019
ADT's CEO is not worried about DIY, characterizing DIY and ADT's DIFY as "2 discrete markets" at the Imperial Capital Security Investor's...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Intersec 2020 Show Report on Jan 20, 2020
IPVM is in Dubai for Intersec, the Middle East's largest security conference. In this report, we cover the main booths and issues out of the...
Clearview AI Alarm - NY Times Report Says "Might End Privacy" on Jan 20, 2020
Over the weekend, the NY Times released a report titled "The Secretive Company That Might End Privacy as We Know It" about a company named...
Favorite Camera Manufacturer 2020 on Jan 20, 2020
The past 2 years of US bans and sanctions have shaken the video surveillance industry but what impact would this have on integrators' favorite...
Severely Impacted Mercury Security 2020 Leap Year Firmware Issue on Jan 17, 2020
One of the largest access controller manufacturers has a big problem: February 29th. Mercury Security, owned by HID, is alerting partners of the...
Apple Acquires XNOR.ai, Loss For The Industry on Jan 16, 2020
Apple has acquired XNOR.ai for $200 million, reports GeekWire. This is a loss for the video surveillance industry. XNOR.ai stunned the industry...
Installation Course January 2020 - Last Chance on Jan 16, 2020
Thursday, January 16th is your last chance to register for the Winter 2020 Video Surveillance Installation Course. This is a unique installation...
Halo Smart Vape Detector Tested on Jan 16, 2020
The Halo Smart Sensor claims to detect vaping, including popular brand Juul and even THC vapes. But how well does it work in real world...
PRC Government Entity Now Controlling Shareholder of Infinova / March Networks on Jan 16, 2020
A PRC government entity is now the controlling shareholder of US security manufacturer Infinova as well as its wholly-owned subsidiary March...
Network Cabling for Video Surveillance on Jan 15, 2020
In this guide, we explain the fundamentals of network cabling for video surveillance networks, how they should be installed, and the differences in...
ONVIF [Un]Trashed Statement, Confirms Dahua and Hikvision Still Suspended on Jan 15, 2020
ONVIF has 'trashed' the suspension statement for Dahua, Hikvision, Huawei, etc. but confirms to IPVM that those companies are all still...