Disruputing Smoke Detectors: Nest vs. Roost

By: Brian Rhodes, Published on Jul 08, 2015

A startup has an idea that will make any smoke detector 'smart' - a WiFi connected battery. Instead of replacing existing units with a Nest Detector costing a hundred dollars or more, Roost sells a replacement battery for 65% less that claims to bring 'dumb' smoke detectors into the cloud.

However, Roost does not offer the full range of features that Nest does. Are those shortcomings that will chance prospective customers away? We take a deeper look at Roost smoke detector batteries inside.

* ******* *** ** idea **** **** **** any ***** ******** '*****' - * **** ********* battery. ******* ** ********* existing ***** **** * Nest ******** ******* * hundred ******* ** ****, Roost ***** * *********** battery *** **% **** that ****** ** ***** 'dumb' ***** ********* **** the *****.

*******, ***** **** *** offer *** **** ***** of ******** **** **** does. *** ***** ************ that **** ****** *********** customers ****? ** **** a ****** **** ** Roost ***** ******** ********* inside.

[***************]

Gunning *** ****

***** ****** ** ***** much ** **** **** Protect ****, *** *** existing ***** ********* *** for * ******** ** the *****. ******* ** marketing ** ******** *** device, *** ******* ** built **** *** *********** battery.  

*** ******* ** ******** that **'* $** ********* will ** **** ********* than *** **** ********'* $99 *****, ******** ********** to ******* ***** ******** smoke ********* *** *** cost ** *** **** unit.

*** ** ** **** consumers *** ******* ***? While *** ********* **** appears *****, ** *** not ** * ********** success.  **** ****, ***** launched * *********** **** earned *** ******* **** under $**** ******* **** about **** ******* - hardly * *********** ******** when ******** *** ****** by ***** ********** *** residential ****** *****.  ***** the ******** *****, *** company *** **** ********** design *** **********, *** expects ** ***** ******** product ** ** ****.  Batteries *** ** ********** *** $** **** **** *** *******'* ******* or **** ******.

*** *******

*** **** ********* ** using ***** ** **** it ******** ************* **** the ******** *** ***** them ** ***** *** smartphone ***.  ******* ** is * ******** '*** battery' ***** ** * valid ***** ********* *****, Roost ******* *** ****** the *****.

***** ** * ******** product ********** **** *** smoke ** ****** ******** detector **** **** ** batteries.  **** *** ******** *********** standardizing ** **** ******* size, * *********** ******** of ********* ***** *** use *****.

*** ***** ***** ******** an ******** ** *** concept:

***** **** ****** ***** notifications, *** ******* *** be ****** **** ***** app *****.  ** ** the **** ** * user *********, **** *** configure ****** ** **** to * ****** ******** or ****** ******.

Product ******

*** **** ****** **** battery ******** ***** ***** 10% *** **** ****** the ******** **** **** the *** *******.  **** for ** ****** ***** - *** *** ****** a ****** ** * specific ****, *********** ********* response *** ******** **** to * ******** **** rather **** ******* ****** for *** ******. ***** claims *******:

  • **** *********:***** ***** *** ********** via *** ******* * residential **** ****** ****** installation. **********, **** *** inserted **** * ******** just **** *** ***** 9V *******, *** **** remain ****** *** **** coverage **** ** ****.
  • * **** ****:*** ******* ****** **'* lithium ***** **** **** longer **** * *****. Given **** **** ***** detectors ****** ** ******** after ** *****, **** users ****** ****** ** swap ********* ** ***** once ** ****** ***.
  • *** ************: *** ******* ****** is *** ************. *******, the ******* ****** *** lithium ***** **** ** field ********* **** *********** cores ******* ***** $**. Over *** ******* **** of * ****** ***** detector, ***** **** ***** about $** *** ******** for ********* *** *****.
  • ********* **: **** *********** *****/** detectors ** *** *** the ** ******* *** primary *****, ******* *** hardwired **** ***** ******* and **** *** *** 9V *** ******. ***** says **** ** ** problem, *** ***** ****** will ******* ** *** same *** ** **** as *** **** **** uses ** *********.

Next ******* ** *****

*** *** ******** ********* in **** *** ********* ** Roost.  ***** **** ********* claim ** ***** *** remotely ****** ** '***** detected' *** '*** ******* alerts', **** ******* ******** additional *****, ***********, *** motion ******* **** ***** does ***. ***** ********** sensors ******* ***** *********** that ***** ******, ********* the ******* ** ****** smoke ****** **** *********** detection ** **** *** '1st **********' ******* **** disarms **** * **** of *** ****.

***** **** *** ******* integration **** ***** ******* like *** **** **** claims ******. ***** ******* is ********** **** **** Cameras *** *********** ** a ******* ******, ***** is * ****** ****** closed ** ****** ** other *******. *** ******* claims ** ***** *********** is ** *** *****, but **** ** **** release ****.

**********

***** ***** ** ***** 30% *** **** ** Nest, ***** *** ******* strategic ********** **** ***** spell ********** *******:

  • ************: **** ****** *** batteries ***** * * year **** ****, *** user's **** ***** ** likely ** ****** ****** that ****. ***** ******* over *** ********* **** to *** ****** ********* happens, ** ** *** likely ***** **** ******** with ***** ********* *** may ********* ******* ** with ****** **** *** novelty ***** ***.  ** is ********* ** ***** to ******** ******** *********** for ****** *******. ****** that, ***** **** **** to ******** ****** ******** apps *** *** ***** units ** ** **** than ********* **** ******** happen.
  • ******** ********: ****** ******* ****, the **** ****** ****** has * ********. **** codes ******** *** '******* length' ** * *********** smoke ******** ** ** years ** **** [**** no ****** *********] (**** **-****/**** 14.4.8), ** ***** ***** may **** **** **** to ******* *** ****** anyway *** ********* ********* a ****** ****. ****** Nest, ***** **** *** include *** ******* ** detect ********* **** ** a ********* ******.

**********

Comments (2)

I backed this and have found the more "features" Roost adds or plans to add the less interested I am. I simply want to know if my smoke detector is going off. That is it. They have plans to add about a bazillion different “features” (that I find to be an overreach) which could kill the Roost before it even gets off the ground. Stick to the one simple feature and add as you go. I have received multiple surveys about what I would like to see added and while none of the additional features come to my mind at the moment, none of them seemed necessary or even feasible.

I don’t trust the Nest detector right now, but if it is still around five or so years from now when I need to swap my detectors I may go with it. Until Nest has a much longer track record I won’t go for it.

I'm in full agreement Ross. I only want to know 3 things from an alert:

1) That the smoke detector went off

2) Which detector went off

3) When the battery is low

If I could get all of that for $25-$35 AND a 5-year guaranteed battery life, I'd absolutely buy this product.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Resideo AlarmNet Has Major Outage on Mar 12, 2020
AlarmNet suffered a major outage yesterday, impacting Total Connect, Resideo, and Honeywell / Ademco alarm customers. Inside we examine what...
Halo Smart Vape Detector Tested on Jan 16, 2020
The Halo Smart Sensor claims to detect vaping, including popular brand Juul and even THC vapes. But how well does it work in real world...
ADT CEO Not Worried About DIY: "2 Discrete Markets" on Dec 13, 2019
ADT's CEO is not worried about DIY, characterizing DIY and ADT's DIFY as "2 discrete markets" at the Imperial Capital Security Investor's...
"Good Market, Bad Business Models" - Residential Security on Dec 11, 2019
Industry banker John Mack, at his company's annual event, took aim squarely at the problems in the residential security...
"Stress in the Residential Market" - Major Lender Exits on Nov 06, 2019
The residential security / 'alarm' market is getting worse, at least for traditional players. Now, one of the biggest lenders in the industry has...
Alarm.com Acquires OpenEye on Oct 21, 2019
Alarm.com is targeting commercial expansion and now they have a commercial cloud VMS with the acquisition of OpenEye. In this note, based on...
Alarm.com Suffers Outage on Jul 26, 2019
Alarm.com suffered a major outage this week, impacting its 5+ million customers. Inside, we examine what happened, what Alarm.com told IPVM and...
Risk of Amazon Alexa Guard: No Battery Or Cell Backup on Jun 20, 2019
Amazon positions its Alexa Guard Service as a "smart home security system" and says it can help you "keep your home safe". However, the...
Alarm.com Favorability Results 2019 on Apr 15, 2019
The once dot com startup has evolved to become a core provider for home security and is now expanding into commercial. In their first entry in...
Camera Disruptor Wyze Enters Sensor / Security Market on Mar 28, 2019
Wyze, the company that has disrupted consumer IP cameras, combining American marketing and Chinese manufacturer, has just announced its expansion...

Most Recent Industry Reports

YCombinator AI Startup Visual One Tested on Apr 02, 2020
Startup Visual One, backed by Silicon Valley's powerful Y Combinator, aims to be "Your 24/7 Watchman" with advanced analytics and object...
Free IPVM Memberships For The Unemployed on Apr 02, 2020
IPVM is giving 3-month free memberships (regular price $99) for the unemployed, no questions asked. To get it, just contact us, your request...
Dahua Faked Coronavirus Camera Marketing on Apr 01, 2020
Dahua has conducted a coronavirus camera global marketing campaign centered around a faked detection. Now, Dahua has expanded this to the USA,...
Video Surveillance Trends 101 on Apr 01, 2020
This report examines major industry factors and how they could impact video surveillance in the next 5 - 10 years. This is part of our Video...
USA's Seek Scan Thermal Temperature System Examined on Apr 01, 2020
This US company, Seek, located down the road from FLIR and founded by former FLIR employees is offering a thermal temperature system for the...
Terrible Convergint Coronavirus Thermal Camera Recommendation on Apr 01, 2020
A week after Convergint disclosed falling revenue, pay and job cuts, Convergint is touting 'extensive research' that is either grossly incompetent...
The IPVM New Products Online Show April 2020 Opens With 40+ Manufacturers on Mar 31, 2020
IPVM is excited to announce the first New Products Online show, with 40+ manufacturers, to be held April 14 to the 16th, free to IPVM members,...
USA's Feevr Thermal Temperature System Examined on Mar 31, 2020
This US company has burst on to the scene, brashly naming itself 'feevr' and branding itself as a "COVID 19 - AI BASED NON CONTACT THERMAL...
JCI Coronavirus Cuts on Mar 31, 2020
JCI has made coronavirus cuts, the company told employees in an email that IPVM has reviewed. Inside this note, we examine the cuts made, the...
Add Door Operators To Fight Coronavirus on Mar 31, 2020
IPVM recommends that integrators advocate and end-users consider adding door operators to fight the spread of coronavirus. This delivers...