The Most Secure Lock Ever? (Hint: Nope)

By Brian Rhodes, Published Dec 03, 2014, 12:00am EST

High security locks are big business, but even the most advanced examples are vulnerable to simple exploits.

Now, a new lock from a small Taiwanese company claims to be 'incapable of exploitation". And sure enough, the design is so exotic, it does not resemble other locks:

But does this lock really have what it takes to be a commercial success? We examine in this note.

Product Overview

The reseller's demo video below is quite informative. The reviewer does a good job describing the product and the 'high security' features it contains:

Key Features

Among the major claims that contrast Xpuzmag from other locks are:

Unpickable

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Usually locks have one keyway to pick. Xpuzmag essentially has 23, exponentially adding difficulty to traditional lock picking methods. Of the 23 pins available, only 6 are active, but mistakenly depressing an inactive pin adds a new barrier. Simultaneously depressing the right pins to the proper length without also confusing it with inactive pins is a tall order, and essentially not a risk.

Bump Proof

Likewise, 'bumping the lock', or vibrating all the pins to the right shear line and twisting it open, is not a likely risk either. With 23 potential pins, simply moving the right 6 without disturbing the other is very unlikely, much less aligning them to the proper depth at the same time.

Highly Complex Bitting

Not only is the key a random combination of 6 out of 23 pins, the depth of the pins vary to 5 places. This results in tens of thousands of potential combinations even if the correct 6 pins are known.

Cost

At $125 per lock, Xpuzmag is already on the cheaper side of high-security locks that can cost $200 or more. However, the $125 also includes an adjustable latch bolt, trim strike plates, and six 'precut' keys.

Drawbacks

However, the lock carries with it some big issues that will keep it a novelty and nothing more. The big ones:

  • Huge Keys: The design of the lock makes the key so big, it cannot simply be crammed into a pocket. It is huge, really. Ping-pong ball sized diameter or bigger makes carrying on key a chore, much less multiple keys on a ring.
  • Difficult to Turn: If inserting a normal key into a single keyway is tough, getting Xpuzmag lined up correctly might be impossible. The precision required mean those with subprime eyesight or dexterity impairment will have tremendous trouble.
  • Lockouts: Standard practice when you forget or lose a key typically means calling a locksmith to pick open your door, or even hitting a kiosk to have replacement keys made. Xpuzmag users can forget all that. No locksmith will be familiar with the lock enough to open it, much less cut a key for it. Replacement keys must be ordered from the vendor. If a locked-out user needs in, they are likely faced with breaking a door or window.

Even if commercial users were willing to accept the relative risk of using the product from a small, unproven vendor, the logistical problems in using and keeping keys doom it.

The Name

Door hardware is dominated by huge companies with long histories. However, the 'Xpuzmag' lock harkens from a new company named Ever Dignity Industry based in Asia, that describes the name as an amalgam for 'X' and 'puzzle' and 'magic':

 UPDATE: Lock Already Exploited 

A reader pointed out the following video, where a well-known member of the 'locksport' community has already picked the lock:

Comments (4) : Members only. Login. or Join.
Loading Related Reports