HD Analog DVRs With Exacq, Milestone and Genetec VMSes Tested

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Aug 23, 2016

HD analog offerings have proven to deliver HD video at radically lower prices.

However, the main limitation for professional applications is their recorders / VMS software. The advanced features and usability of Dahua and Hikvision's DVR / VMSes are not close to that of the Favorite VMS Manufacturers 2016.

In this test report, we share results of integrating Dahua and Hikvision HD Analog DVRs with VMS software from Avigilon, Exacq, Genetec and Milestone. Essentially, we made the DVRs act as encoders feeding video into the VMSes.

Some combinations worked, some did not, and one crippled a VMS.

** *************** **** ****** ** deliver ** ***** ** radically ***** ******.

*******, *** **** ********** for ************ ************ ** their ********* / *** software. The ******** ******** *** ********* of ***** *** *********'* DVR / ***** *** not ***** ** **** of the******** *** ************* ****.

** **** **** ******, we ***** ******* ** integrating ***** *** ********* HD ****** **** **** VMS ******** **** ********, Exacq, ******* *** *********. Essentially, ** **** *** DVRs *** ** ******** feeding ***** **** *** VMSes.

**** ************ ******, **** did ***, *** *** crippled * ***.

[***************]

New **** *******

***** *** ******** ***** in ****, *** *** improvements **** **** **** to *** ******* *** HD ****** *********:

********* ******** *******

********* ******** *** ******** support *** *********/***** *********, with ****** ********* ** device **** *** ****** driver *********. **********, ****** discovery *** *******, *** XProtect ***** ***** ******* beyond *** ****** ** actual ****** ********.

******* ***** ***/*** ******

******* ******** ****** *** offers * ***** ***/*** driver ***** ********* ** multiple ****** (**** ***** and *** ******* *****). 

Key ******** 

**** *** *** *** findings **** **** ****:

  • *** ****** **** (*****, HDTVI, ***) ****** ******* RTSP ********* *** ** third ******* ** **** main *** *** ******* for **** *******.
  • **** ********* ****** **** all ****** *****, ****** offered ** ************* ** the ****** **** *** VMS ******, ********* ***** to ****** ******** ** the *** *** *********.
  • ***** ***** *** ********* HDTVI **** ******* ********** ONVIF *******, **** ***** Device ******* **** ** connect, ******, *** ********* them ** **** ***** ONVIF ******* *** ********.
  • ********* ******** *** **** to ******* **, *********, and ****** **** ***** and ********* **** *** its ***** *-** ******* device ******.
  • ******* ******** ****** ******** a ***** ***/*** ****** which ********* ** ******** models ******* *****. ********* DVRs *** ***********.
  • ***** *** **** ** connect ************ ** ***** HDCVI **** *** *** major ****** **** ********** to ********* ***** *** ********* restarting ********, *******, ** reinstallation ** ******.
  • ******** ******* ****** **** not ******* ** ****** ************'* DVR, ********** **** *** first ******* ** ***** DVRs, *** ****** *** when ********* ** *********.

***************

***** ****** ** **** as ******** ******** *** benefits ** ***** ************ (reusing ******** *****, **** lower ****** *** ******* costs) ***** ******** ***** to ****** *** *** of ***** ******, *********** the **** ** **** worlds. 

*******, ***** ****** *** ****** ONVIF ************* ** ***** DVRs **** ***** ****** VMS, *** ******* *** spotty ** **** ***** when ***** ******* *****, with *** ********* ** Milestone, ***** ********* ** both ***** *** ********* DVRs ******* ***** (*** using **** * ****** license *** *** ********) and *******, ***** ****** a ***** *** ******.

** *** **** *****, testing ** *** ***/*** combination ****** ** **** before **********, ** **** streaming (*** *** ********** drawbacks) *******.

Connecting *** ****

****** *** ** *** DVRs *** **** ** have ****** ** *** past *-* ***** **** streamed **** ******* *** via ****. **** *************(****-***),*********, *** **** ********** *** **** *** DVR*.

**** ********* ******* ****** the ******** ** ***** to ******* ** ****** streams **** ***** ********* simply ** ******** *** RTSP ****** ***. **** simple ******* ** ****** universal, ******* ***** *** two *** *********:

  • ** ****** ************* ** supported **** *** *** unlike ******** ********** *** ONVIF ** ****** ************. This ******** *** **** to *** **** *** individual *** ** ****** CODEC ********.
  • **** ***** *** ******* ******* license ****** *** ********, such ** *** ******* per **** ******** ** one ******* *** *** or ** *******. **** streams ***** *** *** this ********* ** ********* cost ** **** *** seen ** ********** *******.

**** ***** ***** *** basic ******* *** ****** RTSP **** ** *** VMS:

RTSP ****** ****

*** **** ****** **** are ****** ******* ******* by ****** *************. ** have ******** ******* *** recorders ***** ** **** tested ***** *** ***** reference.

*****

***** ********* *** *** following ****** ******:

****://:@/***/***********?*******=*&*******=*

***** * ** *** channel ******, *** * is ****** ****: * for *** **** **** resolution ******, *** * for *** *** ********** sub ******. ** * sample *** *** ******* 1's **** ********** ****** would ****** **:

****://*****:*****@***.**.***.***/***/***********?*******=*&*******=*

*********

********* ********* *** **** URL:

****://:@/*********/********/***

* ** **** **** is *** ******* ******, while * ********** *** stream ****: * *** main (**** **********), *** 2 *** ********* (*** res).

** * ****** *** for ******* *, **** resolution ******, *** **** like ****:

****://*****:*****@***.**.***.**/*********/********/*** 

***** *************

***** *************' **** ******* may ** *********, *** the ***** ******* ******** for **** **** ******, and ** **** *** tested ***** ***********. ******* are ***** ****** ********** using*********** ***** ****** ******** to ***** ****** **** while ********* *** ***'* web *********.

ONVIF *******

*** ****** **** ***** and ********* **** ******* non-official ***** ********* *******, allowing **** ***** ** connect ** **** ** they ***** *** ***** ONVIF ******. ***** ***** ************* changes (*****, ***** ****, resolution, ***.) *** ** performed **** *** *** instead ** ********* ***** to ****** *** ****** web *********, **** ** preferable ** **** *********.

******* ** ***** *************' DVRs ********** * ************ **** ** *** support *****, ***** ** required ** *** *******. However, **** ****** ******* ****** *******, **** *** ****** as ***** *.* *** video *** ** ******** and ********** ** *** other ***** ******.

**** ***** ***** **** ONVIF ******* ******* ***** DM, ********* ******* *** all ******** ** ********* video.

VMS *** ***** *******

******* **** ******* *** connection *** ***** ****** Manager, *** ******* *** these **** *** ***** is *******. ** ********* to ******* ******** ***** to ***** ****, ******** below:

  • ***** ********* *-******* ***** DVR
  • ***** ********* **-******* ******* DVR
  • ********* **-********-** *-******* ***** DVR

Milestone ********

**** ********* ******** *** able ** *******, ******, and ********* ***** **** without ***** ** ******* configuration. ***** *** *** points ** ** ***** of **** **** **** Milestone:

  • ******** *** *******:********* "**** *** ********" will ***** ****** ** the ***** ****** ***** selected. *******, ***** ****** manually *** *** *** and ****** "***** ********** Device (*-** ********)" ** the ******.
  • *** *** **** ******* than ********: ** **** ******** ** Milestone, ****** **** *** the *-** ******* ****** added ** ******* ** XProtect ********** ** ****** channel *****. **** ******* to ** ***** ** recent ********, ****** *** still ***** ** ***** releases.

**** ***** ***** * Hikvision **-********-** *** *** (top, **** *******) *** a ***** ******** *** DVR (******, * *******) added ** ********, **** cameras, *****, *** ******* available. 

**** ***** ******* *** process ** ****** ***** DVRs ** *********:

 

Genetec: ***** ***/*** ******

******* ******** ****** *** includes * ***** ***/*** driver, ***** ******** ********* multiple ***** ********* ** tested.

**** **** ***** **** manually ****** *** **** to ***** ***** ********'* management **** (********* *****), instead ** *** ******* port ** **** ** most ******* *******.

**** *****, *** ***** channels, ** **** ** I/O *** ***** *** available, ** ** ********* XProtect:

**** **** ******* ******** a ******* *** ****** channel, ****** ********. ************, Hikvision **** *** *** supported.

ExacqVision: ********* *** ***** ******* *** *****

*********** ** **** ** connect ** *** ***** DVRs (*** *** *********, see *****) *** ******** **** channel ** *** *** to ** ***** ********** using * ************* ****** in *** ****** ***, formatted **:

#*******=*

***** * ** *** channel ******, **** * to **. **** **** unlike ********, **** ******* requires * ****** *******.

**** ***** ***** *** process ** ****** ***** DVRs ** *****:

*********** ********** ** *** the ********* *** ** Exacq ***** *** **** method, ** *********** ******** errors ********* ******** ** be ********* ** ****** reboots ** ***** ** remove *** *** **** the ******. ** *** extreme ****, *** **** server ****** ****** ********** and ******** **************. ** such, ** ** *** recommend ****** ** *** these ****** ** ***********.

Avigilon ** **********

** **** ****** ** add ****** *** ** Avigilon ******* ****** *.* and ******* ******** ****** 5.2. ***** ***** (**** Profile * **********) *** not ********* ***** ****** as ***** ***, *** simply ***** *** **** trying ** *******.

******* ******** * ***** DVR/NVR ****** (*****), *** still *** *** ******* in *** *****. 

Firmware/Software ********

***** *** *** *** firmware ******** **** ** this ****:

  • ***** *********: *.***.****.*
  • ***** *********: *.***.****.*
  • ********* **-********-**: **.*.*

*** ********:

  • ******** ******* ****** ****: 5.8.4.22
  • *********** **********: *.*.*.*****
  • ******* ******** ******: *.* SR * (*.*.***.**)
  • ********* ******** **********: **** R2 (**.** , ****** pack *.*)

Comments (25)

Does un/non-official ONVIF support mean a)product not listed as complicant or b)maker wil not give the support? How did you know to find it out works?

Is this Onvif Vms spec or Onvif JBOC?

About encoder licenser, dont all streams have same ip/mac too?

Not listed as conformant. Hikvision DVRs don't support MJPEG which is required for Profile S. The Dahua DVRs simply haven't been listed as conformant. Whether they will be in the future is unknown.

We found it works by accident, as they were discovered automatically by ONVIF DM. Exacq also detects both DVRs when you search for cameras.

I don't know what you mean by JBOC, but these devices are ONVIF devices (cameras/encoders/etc.) as opposed to clients (VMS/NVR). Also known as NVTs.

Yes, all streams have the same IP and MAC address. How each VMS chooses to handle licensing is up to them.

Thx. Good answer.

JBOC = Just Bunch of Cameras, seperated not tied up in bundle

Did every camera channel require a lic?

Has Milestone officially commented on HD Analog licensing? I know that their stance with traditional analog cameras is one license per IP encoder but did they intend for this to extend to HD Analog? Even though the software allows it, I'd like to make sure that is compliant with the license agreement before bidding any jobs.

Good question.

In our test, all the channels in the DVR only required one license.

I sent an email to Milestone askng for clarifiication / confirmation. I will post their feedback when received.

Milestone confirmed policy is 1 license per encoder, regardless of whether it is SD or HD analog.

The policy is the same for DVRs, however, Milestone noted, "DVR licensing is currently under review and may be changed in 2015."

Will the Milestone server store the footage locally?

Is there anyway that the camera footage is stored on the DVR, and streamed back through Milestone - so Milestone is ultimately acting as client software?

Have a site with 80 analogs that wants to move to HD solution gradually!

TC, that is an interesting approach.

I don't think that you can do this because Milestone would have to be able to retrieve video recorded and stored in the DVR.

The ONVIF integration only covers streaming video in, not accessing recorded video on another device.

I asked the same question of VI's developers, and got a similar answer as John gave. While the DVRs have recording capability, the streams are one-way only and do not support storage read/write or search functions ... that's really the core function of the VMS working with the server's .Net and SQL technologies (in VI's case).

As a related side-note, I could not find a setting inside the Dahua firmware to turn-off it's incessant 'missing harddrive' trouble beeps, so I resorted to installing a scrap HDD just to populate the SATA port and answer the trouble. If there is any local recording happening to that drive, it's of no use to the VMS.

Haven't yet tested HIK's HD-TVI units, but that's next on my 'to-do' list.

I've got four HD-CVI test systems in the field using a mix of 1080p and 720p Dahua DVRs as encoders, tied to Video Insight v5.5. The setup is just like an analog encoder, with a shared IP address feeding separate streams to the VMS.

Pictures are great, with all VMS features intact and fully-functional using server-side motion detection. I'm still playing with optimization of the camera streams by adjusting the DVR settings via Dahua "SmartPSS" interface. There are some camera-local adjustments available via OSD, but so far I've left the cameras' default settings in place. I have yet to test PTZ control via the VMS, but will do so once sample cameras arrive.

Video Insight accepts the streams beautifully. My target market for All Campus Security is small business- and home-owners of out-dated analog systems who are up to swapping out their dusty DVR and cameras on a DIY-basis.

Michael,

Have you had a chance to try the PTZ control?

Not yet. Expecting delivery of the PTZ by mid-January.

Michael,

Have you found that VI allows you to use server side motion detection on all of the RTSP streams? I have been playing around with Exacq and have not been able to use server side motion at all.

Yes, server-side was the easy part. All cameras are triggering and recording properly in the VI/HD-CVI systems that I have running in customer settings. The server is seeing the RTSP streams like any other camera feed.

I'll test camera-side and let you know. BTW, my PTZ arrived recently, and I should know soon how it performs through the DVR-as-encoder arrangement.

Michael,

Can you tell me what settings you used to see the Dahua DVR in VI? I am playing with it right now and VI found the DVR immediately. It shows it as Dahua and Dahua IP Camera. I only have 2 HD-CVI cameras currently connected and when I manually added the second camera as port 2, I am seeing the same image as port 1?

You'll need to be running one of the later versions (5.5.22 and on). The use the Dahua drivers, and then Dahua IP Camera. Check the 'shared IP address' box, and then set the first to stream 1, next to stream 2, etc. That should do it.

BTW, you need only one open licensed camera 'available' b/c the encoder is only on IP address.

Thanks for the clarification. I had originally set it up just as you described and was getting the same live image on port 1 & 2(on VI side). I deleted both from VI and then re entered them, seems to work fine now.

Thanks!

That sounds great. It must just be the difference between VI & Exacq.

I am not sure if maybe I am missing something in the configuration on the Exacq side. The VMS sees the cameras with no problem, but absolutely no option for motion detection. based on the article above, it looks like it all depends on the DVR/FW version, etc.

We have also installed many VI servers, I have not had an opportunity to test with the HD-CVI.

I am anxious to see what you find with the PTZ.

  • Avigilon Control Center does not connect to either manufacturer's DVR, displaying only the first channel of Dahua DVRs, but timing out when connected to Hikvision.

We have be able to get ACC to connect to both Hikvisions TVI encoders and TVI DVRs.

I have tested the the option to connect Hikvision HD TURBO DVR to OnSSI Ocularis 5.2 and it works great!

(ONVIF Profile S)

Thanks for posting this article as it triggered me to figure out a way to get a cheap No Name Brand 4 channel DVR enrolled in to Genetec so I can view all 4 channels. Before reading this article I had enrolled it using the ONVIF Profile but was only getting video streams 2 of the 4 channels. I would get the Main and Sub Stream of 2 of the 4 channels only.

After reading this article I used the CAM File Editor for Genetec and created a custom driver in which I was able to identify 4 channels using the RTSP Stream syntax which was provided for the DAHUA DVRs and I was able to enroll the DVR and get both the Main and Sub Streams in H.264 format for all four channels. Thanks again.

Would I be wrong in assuming that Xprotect offers access to both Live and Playback when integrating a Hik DVR? Does the same apply to other VMS's? I often see reports of "integration" with the major VMS's, however the detail drops off when it comes to Playback and other functionality, like alarm integration and audio + I/O. I accept that ONVIF doesn't accommodate playback (yet, I guess....Profile-G....), however, having the ability to stream Live and obtain Playback + the vital VMS search functionality is vital to achieving true integration. I suspect that only the VMS's that offer API/SDK integration are those that will be able to truly integrate.

Hello John, would be great to have an updated test report

does anyone know if this works for any other DVR/NVR? I have 2 Speco NVR that this solution would work great to add them into my Milestone Corporate.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Directory of 68 Video Surveillance Startups on Sep 18, 2019
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known. 2019...
Vivotek "Neural Network-Powered Detection Engine" Analytics Tested on Sep 17, 2019
Vivotek has released "a neural network-powered detection engine", named Smart Motion Detection, claiming that "swaying vegetation, vehicles passing...
Panasonic 4K Camera Tested (WV-S2570L) on Sep 13, 2019
Panasonic has released their latest generation 4K dome, the WV-S2570L, claiming "Extreme image quality allows evidence to be captured even under...
Commend ID5 Intercom Tested on Sep 12, 2019
Commend touts the new ID5 intercom as 'timelessly elegant' and the slim body, glass front touchscreen indeed looks better than common, but ugly,...
ONVIF Exposure To "Devastating DDoS Attacks" Examined on Sep 06, 2019
ZDnet reported "Protocol used by 630,000 devices can be abused for devastating DDoS attacks", citing exposure of ONVIF devices. And after an...
Genetec Stratocast VSaaS Tested on Sep 05, 2019
The VSaaS market is rapidly expanding in 2019, with Verkada, Meraki, Eagle Eye, Avigilon and numerous startups growing their market share. When we...
Scylla AI Video Analytics Company Profile on Aug 29, 2019
Scylla, an AI analytics startup, says they are targeting 1 Billion dollar valuation in 5 years and it "is not rocket science" to detect weapons and...
Uniview Pro 4K Camera Tested (IPC3238ER3-DVZ) on Aug 29, 2019
In our 8MP / 4K Fixed Lens Camera Shootout, Uniview's low end 8MP was firmly in the middle of the pack. Does their higher end Pro Series 4K camera...
Warning: Windows 7 Update Crashing NVRs on Aug 26, 2019
Windows 7 updates are causing VMS servers to fail to boot. After running the update, impacted systems do not boot as normal, instead display this...
Anyvision Facial Recognition Tested on Aug 21, 2019
Anyvision is aiming for $1 billion in revenue by 2022, backed by $74 million in funding. But does their performance live up to the hype they have...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Open Access Controller Guide (Axis, HID, Isonas, Mercury) on Sep 19, 2019
In the access control market, there are many software platforms, but only a few companies that make non-proprietary door controllers. Recently,...
Axis Perimeter Defender Improves, Yet Worse Than Dahua and Wyze on Sep 19, 2019
While Axis Perimeter Defender analytics improved from our 2018 testing, the market has improved much faster, with much less expensive offerings...
Directory of 68 Video Surveillance Startups on Sep 18, 2019
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known. 2019...
Uniview Prime Series 4K Camera Tested on Sep 18, 2019
Is the new Uniview 'Prime' better than the more expensive existing Uniview 'Pro'? In August, IPVM tested Uniview 4K 'Pro' but members advocated...
US Army Base To Buy Banned Honeywell Surveillance on Sep 17, 2019
The U.S. Army's Fort Gordon, home to their Cyber Center of Excellence, has issued a solicitation to purchase Honeywell products that are US...
Vivotek "Neural Network-Powered Detection Engine" Analytics Tested on Sep 17, 2019
Vivotek has released "a neural network-powered detection engine", named Smart Motion Detection, claiming that "swaying vegetation, vehicles passing...
Schmode is Back, Aims To Turn Boulder AI Into Giant on Sep 16, 2019
One of the most influential and controversial executives in the past decade is back. Bryan Schmode ascended and drove the hypergrowth of Avigilon...
Manufacturers Unhappy With Weak ASIS GSX 2019 And 2020 Shift on Sep 16, 2019
Manufacturers were generally unhappy with ASIS GSX, both for weak 2019 booth traffic and a scheduling shift for the 2020 show, according to a new...
How Cobalt Robotics May Disrupt Security on Sep 13, 2019
While security robots have largely become a joke over the last few years, one organization, Cobalt Robotics, has raised $50+ million from top US...
Panasonic 4K Camera Tested (WV-S2570L) on Sep 13, 2019
Panasonic has released their latest generation 4K dome, the WV-S2570L, claiming "Extreme image quality allows evidence to be captured even under...