Covert IP Camera Shootout - Axis, Hanwha, Hikvision, March, Vivotek

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Mar 20, 2019

Covert cameras were one of the last holdout areas for analog cameras. However, in the past few years, IP / HD covert cameras have become commonplace across many major manufacturers.

However, which ones are better or worse? We bought 5 covert camera systems with a total of 10 imager / lenses to understand this.

image

We tested image quality in four separate scenarios, as the graphic below demonstrates:

convert-pinhole-camera-shootout-scenes

We tested at ranges from 2' to 40' to see how cameras capture both close range details common in ATM applications and further distances needed for general covert surveillance, as the graphic below shows:

convert-pinhole-camera-shootout-distance

Models tested:

Inside, we provide recommendations on which models are best and worst for the most common use cases and for installability plus bandwidth consumption testing and VMS integration.

****** ******* **** *** of *** **** ******* areas *** ****** *******. However, ** *** **** few *****, ** / HD ****** ******* **** become *********** ****** **** major *************.

*******, ***** **** *** better ** *****? ** bought * ****** ****** systems **** * ***** of ** ****** / lenses ** ********** ****.

image

** ****** ***** ******* in **** ******** *********, as *** ******* ***** demonstrates:

convert-pinhole-camera-shootout-scenes

** ****** ** ****** from *' ** **' to *** *** ******* capture **** ***** ***** details ****** ** *** applications *** ******* ********* needed *** ******* ****** surveillance, ** *** ******* below *****:

convert-pinhole-camera-shootout-distance

****** ******:

******, ** ******* *************** on ***** ****** *** best *** ***** *** the **** ****** *** cases *** *** ************** plus ********* *********** ******* and *** ***********.

[***************]

Shootout *******

****** **** ** *** shootouts, ** *** *** see * ***** "****" overall ******. *******, ** have ******* ******* **** these **********:

Recommendations: **** *** ****/***** ********

***** ** *** *****, the ***** ****** *** series ****** **** *** advantages *** *** ************ not ***** ** ***** models.

  • ****** ***:*** ****** *** ******* produced ***** ******* ** the *******'* **** ******* strong *********, ****** **** to *** **** ****, but ****** **** *** other ****** ******. **** performance ** * *** factor ** **** **** are ******* ******** ***** they *** ** ******* to ****** ******** ** in ******* **** ***** doors/windows.
  • ***-******** ******** *******:*****'* ******* ****** ***** includes ****** ******** ** the *** ****, * very ****** *** *****, and ***** ****** ******** options *** ***** ****** upon *******. ***** ************* do *** ***** ***** options.

** *** ******** ****, both ***** ****** *** models' ******* ***** ***** of *****, **** ******** out ** ***** ****** ~5', ****** **** ********** for ******* ****** ************ where ***** ****** ******* better.

****** ***** ** *** Axis ****, ***** ****** strong *** ** **** as ******* ********* ******** options. *******, **** ** not ***** *** **** "out ** *** ***" mounting ************* ** ****** mounting *** ******** ******.

Recommendations: **** *** ****** ******** (~**'+)/******* ************

*** ****** *** ********* models ******** *** ********* details ** ******* ****** at ****** ********* (>**') in **** *****. **** produced ****** ******* ** ~20' ********, *** ******** soft *** ****** ****** at ******* ********* ** the ****** *** ******* more ****** ******** ** the **** ***** ** view, ** *** *****.

Recommendations: **** *** *** ***** (~* *** *** *****)

** *** *****, *** Hikvision **-**********-** *** ** cameras ******** *** ******** details ** *** *****, ~1 ***, **** ***** facial *** **** ******* to ***** ~**' ********. The ****** ***-**** **** 3.6mm ****** ******** ****** details ** **** ***** (~10') *** *** ******* and **** ********.

***** ****** ******** *********** level ******* ** **** close ***** (~*') *** not ** ****** *********.

Recommendations: **************

*** ******* ******* ** install ****** **** *** Axis **** *** ****** XNB-6001 *** ** ***** detachable ******. **** ****** users ** ***** *** camera *** *** *** cable **********, ***** ***** cable ********** ******* *** reduces *** *********** ** damaging *** ****** ****** install.

**** **** *** ******** ATMs, ***** *** ***** stronger ************, ** **** offer ****** ******** ******* for ******** ******, ********* above, *** ** ******* installation, **** *** ****** were *******.

Pricing **********

******* ****** **** ***** ~$300 (*******) ** **** $500 (****) *** * camera **** (~$***) **** plus ****** (~$***), **** average ***** $***.

***** **** ** **** expensive *** * ****** camera, *** **** ******** up ** **** ****** modules, ***** ****** ******* only * ****** ******. For ************ **** ******** covert ******* ** *** same ********, **** ***** be **** ********* *** at * ** * covert ******* ** * location, **** ***** ** the ***** *********.

**** ******* ***** ** applications ********* ******** *******, though ***** *** ****** less ****** **** ****** imager *************.

WDR ***** ******* **********

*******, *** *********** *** poor ******** ** "*******" (non-covert) *******, **** **** moderate ********* ******* *** the ******* ** **** cameras, **** *** **********: Axis *** ***** ********

** *** *****, *** Axis *** ***** ******** cameras **** *** **** models **** ** ******* discern ******* ****** ******* backlight. *** ******* ****** shows **** *******, ****** less ******* **** **** or *****, ***** ****** and ********* **** ** details, ******* *** ****** being ********* ** "**** ***."

WDR Performance Comparison

Moderate *** ***** ***********

****, ** ****** ** moderately *** *****, ******* to * *** **** street ** *****, ***** 5-10 *** ********* ** distance. *********** ** **** light ***** ****** ************* with ********.

2

** ***** *****, *** cameras ******* ***** ****** of *** *******, **** facial ******** ****** ************ despite *** ***** *****, with **** ****** ******** in *** ***** ******** cameras.

Moderate Low Light Performance

*******, ** ~**', *********** differs *************, ** **** and ********* ***** ******* clear ******* ** *** subject, ***** *** ***** Networks ****** ** ********** darker *** ****, ******* clear ****** ** *** subject.

Bigger Differences At Longer Range_2

Low ***** (~* ***) ***********

** *** *****, ***** 1 ***, *********** ****** significantly, **** ***** ***** significantly ********* ***********.

3

** **** *****, *** to **** **** ***, all ******* ******* ****** images ** *** *******'* face **** ***** *******.

Very Low Light Performance

*******, ** ~**', ********* and ****** ***** ***, with ***** ****** ******* and ******* ****, ***** Axis *** ******* ******* rougher *******. *** ***** camera ******** ******* ****, but ******* ****** ******* are *******.

Bigger Differences At Longer Range1

Longer ******** *******

** *** *****, ** found ******** *********** ** how **** ******* ********* at ****** *********, ****** ~10', **** ***** **** and ***** **********.

5

*** ********, ** ~**' distance, ******* *** ********** softer ** *** **** and ***** ****** **** in *********, ******, *** Vivotek, ***** ******* **** legible **** *** ******* facial *******.

Mid Range Detail Comparison

*** ** **', ******* details *** ***** ** only *** ********* *** Vivotek *******, ***** ****** do *** ******* ****** images, **** **** ******* text.

Long Range Detail Comparison

Bandwidth **********

*** ******* ****** ******** smart ****** ****** *** the ***** ******** ****** ATM ******, ***** **** standard *.***. **** *** Hanwha ***-**** ******** *.*** streaming.

8

*** **** ** ****** averaged *** ****** ******** of ******* ******, ***** 1,600 **/* ****** *** day *** *,*** ** night, ~* **/* **** than *********, *** **** lowest. *********, ******, *** Vivotek ********* ****** *********, but ******** ******, *,*** Kb/s ** ~*,*** **/* day *** ~*,***-*,*** **/* at *****.

*** ***-***** ***** ***** camera ******** *** ******* bitrates ** **** ****, over * **/* ***/* Mb/s *****.

Bitrate Comparison

VMS ***********

** *** *******, *** Axis, ******, *********, *** Vivotek ******* ******* ****** similar ***** ***** *** integration, **** ***** ******** more *******.

Basic ***********: *.*** ********* / *************

*.*** ********* *** ************* worked ** ****** ***** combination, **** *** ********* of ***** ******** ** Avigilon ******* ******, ***** simply ***** *** *******. Note **** **** *** Hanwha ***-**** ******* *.*** streaming, ***** ********** ** all ***** ****** ********.

Camera **** *** *******

****** **** *** ******* was ******* ****** *******, with *****, *******, *********, and ******* ***** ********** events **** ****, ******, Hikvision, *** *******, ****** March *** ********* **** in ***** *** *******. Note **** ******** ******* Center *** *** ******* camera **** ****** ** any ************.

March *** ** *** ******

***** ** ** **** limited **** ****** ****** in *** ***********, **** that ***** ********' ******* are **** ****** ** be ********* ** *** to *** ***** ******* using***** ************* ******* ******, ***** ************* integrate **** ***** ***** VMS **** *****. ******* of ****, ***** *********** limitations *** **** ****** to ** * ********* negative **** ** **** cases.

**************

**** ** ************ ******, with *** **** ********* factors ***** ******* ******* used ********** ***** ** fixed *** **** ** the ********** *****, *** the **** ** ***** included ******.

9

**** *** ****** ******* the ****** ****** ** be ******** **** *** cables *** ** *** base *****. **** ********** installation ** *** ****** could ** ********** *******/****** without ************** ******** *** attached *****.

Removable Vs  Non-Removable Camera Heads

** **** ** **** and ****** *** ***** installation ********** ** **** video:

***** **** *** ********* heads ** ****/******, **** cameras ****** ********* ** a ******* *******, **** a ***** ***** ***** circled *** ****** **** attached ** *** ******** surface **** *** **** and ********* ** **** it ** *****. **** models' ****** ******** ****** stick **** ** ******** mounting, ****** **** *** not ** ******** *** long **** *** ** it *** *** *** and **** ******** ******** over ****.

ATM ******** ***********

*** ***** ********** ******* in ****, ***** *** hold * ******** *********, as **** ***** ************* with ******** *** *** models, *** ***** ****** mounts *** ***** ****** as ******.

**** ****** **** ********* mounts ***** *** ** shaped ** *** ******* applications, *** **** *** offer ****** ****** *** specific *** ******. *******, they ***** **** **** have ****** **** ******** manufacturers ** ******* ****** for ***** *******, *** models ****** *** ******* to ****** ****** ******.

*******, ****** **** ****** an *** *** **** a **** ********** *** adaptable ***** **** ** included ** *** **** XNB-6001 *******. **** ****, they ** *** **** which **** ** *** been ****** ****.

Hanwha ********* ******

** *** *****, *** Hanwha ***-**** ********* ****** stability ******, **** *** camera's ****** ******** ********** and ******* ********* ********* randomly. ***** ******** *********** with ****** **** ******* and ******* **********, ** determined *** ******** ******:

  • ****** *************:**** ****** ***-**** **** units **** ******** **** connected ** *** ******** EdgeSwitch ** **** ** testing, ****** ** ***** cameras ********* ******* ******. After ****** *** ******* to * ***** ******, they ****** ******* *****.
  • ****** ****** ******:*** ****** ***** *** a *********-***** ******* ****** ******, ***** ************ ********* to ****/******, **** ****** sent ************, *** *** camera **** ***** **** completely.

Camera ********* *****

*** **** ****, ** included *** ****** ********* models **** *** *************, with ***** **** **** regarding ***** ****** ******* were **** ******* *** suitable *** **** ****.

***** *** **** ******* were ********* *** ******* began, ********* *** ******** a ***** *****, *****-*********** **** ***** ** the *****, *** *** yet ***** *******. **** model ****** ******** *** light *********** *** *.***, but ******* *** *****.

Country ** ******

******* *** ******* ** the ********* ********* ** origin:

  • **** ****: ********
  • ****** ***-****: *******
  • ********* **-*******: *****
  • ***** ******: ******
  • ***** ******: *****
  • ******* ******: ******

Firmware ******** ****

*** ********* ******** ******** were **** ** **** test. **** **** **** models **** **** ************ (pinhole *** ***-*******) **** the **** ********.

  • ****: *.**.*
  • ******: *.**.**
  • *********: **.*.** ***** ******
  • *****: *.*.*
  • *******: *****

Comments (26)

*** *** ***** *** Dahua ****** ******* ** Hanwha. **** ******* ** make ***** **** ***** so **** *****

******, ***** ****. ** initially ******* ** ******* Dahua, *** ***** ***** was *** ******** ** us ** *** **** of *******. **'** ***** in *** *** **** it's ******* ** ** released.

******* *********

 

****** *** ** *** kit **** ****** *** camera ** ****** ***** and ****** *** **** ATMs, *** *** **** tested **** ******* ****** ones. 

*****://***.**************.***/***-******.****

*** ****** *** *********** with *** *** *** lenses *** **** *******. I **** ***** *********** this  * **** *********** as ***** ****** *** not ******.

******* *** ******** **** out. **'* **** ***** to *** ******. ** there *** ************* ** which ****** **'* **** tested ****?

****** ******** ******, *** come **** ****** *-****** cam ** ***** ** 120 ** *** *** not *** ***** *** db?

*****,

*** *** ******* **** sensor *****, *** *** SSDR ******** **** **** in *** ****** *** test? 

*/*** ******** *******; *** on, ****; **** **, Wide, **.

********** **** ** ****** 20-25, **** ******'* **** should ** ******* **** better ** *** ****** of ******. 

*** ** ***** *** downside ** **** ******* ******?

*** ******** ** **** it ***, ** **** bright *********, **** *** the **********. ** *** scene ***** **'* *** bright ****** ** **** out (~*,*** ***, ****), but ** ** **** sunny *** *****-******, ***'* see **** ** *** effects ** **** ****.

**** ** ******* ** "fake ***", ********** *** brightness ** ******* ** a ****-*******.
*** ******** ** **** there **** ** **** noise ********* ** *** shadows.

** **** ******** **** with **** *** ** 25 ** *******. ** did *** ******* **** much. **'* ******* ****** to *** ******* ** our ***********, *** **** not ******** *** ***** or **** ******.

** *** *** ******* very ****.

*** ****, **’* ****.  but ****** ** **** it’s ***, *****?

 

**'** ***** ******** **** Axis ** ***** *** compatibility. **** ****** **** they **** ****** **** specific ************* ** ******* mounts *** ***** *******, but ****** ****** *** quickly ** ****** ****** mounts.

 

**** ********** ******'* (*** the *********'*) *** *********** is ************ ****. ****** appears non-functional. **** *** ***** ****** **** toggled **/***?

*'* ****** *** *********** on *** *** ****** I **** ** **** on *** *** *******.  The ****** *** * have ****** *** ** WDR, *** ** **** worse **** **** ****** that **** *** ***** 120 ** *** *****.  It **** **** *** matching ** ** ** setting ****** ********** ***** that ***** * **** change **** ** ***** one ***** *****.

***** **** *** ***** hum-4231 ** ***** * pin **** **** **** not **** ** ******** base *******? 

** * *********** ****** form ******, *** ********.

***** ** * ***** CVI ******* **** ** square *** **** *** have * ******** **** as *** *** ******. I'm ******* ** ** IP ***.

***** ** * ***** CVI ******* **** ** square *** **** *** have * ******** **** as *** *** ******. I'm ******* ** ** IP ***.

** **** ** **** still **** **** ** sell ** ** *.*., but **** *** ** **-***-********.

**** ** *** *** that *** **** ******** by *** **-*** ***-**** that * **** ****.

***** ***** *********. * was **** ******* ** any ***** ************* **** one. * **** ***** out *** **** *** too *** *** ***** is *.* **** *** I ***** **** * 3.6 ** ***.

***** * **** *** to **** *** ** series but ** **** **** F ****** *** *** series ******* **** *** including ** *** ******** ******.   Surprised to *** **** ****** and ******** ****** ** *** work **** *** **.  What ******* ** *** did *** **** ****?

***** *** **** *********** in *** ******* ******* tested, ******** *** ***** was * **** *** to **** ***********.

**** ****** *****, **** presented *** ***** ****-***** methodology.

***** *** *** *** country ** ****** ** the ******* ** **** seems ** **** ******* off ** ****** **** reports ** * **** when ***** ** * real ***** ** "********" manufacturers ********** ******* ****** markets ***** *** ******* First *****?

**'** ***** **** ** the ******:

Country ** ******

******* *** ******* ** the ********* ********* ** origin:

  • **** ****: ********
  • ****** ***-****: *******
  • ********* **-*******: *****
  • ***** ******: ******
  • ***** ******: *****
  • ******* ******: ******

**** *** ******* *** points ** ********:

*****, ** ******** ** the **** ******* ****, they ***** *** ******-********* ******, ***** ** * more **** ********* ****** for ***-*** ******* (~$*** online **. $***). ******* P12 ****** *** *** same ******* ** *** FA ******, **** ******* performance. *******, **** ********, such ** *** ****** depend **** *** **** unit, *** **** ******* somewhat ****** ** *** FA ****** ***** **** a ***** *******.

**** **** ******* *** that *** ****** ** the ** ****** ******* are ****** ***********, *** may ** ********* ** the *****. *** ***** needing ** ******* ***** cameras *** ****** *********, contact **** *** * lens ********** **** ***** fits **** ***** ** either **** ** *** FA ****** **** *** adjustment. **** ** ******* to ***** ******** ** past ******, **** ** the ******** **** **** optional ****** ***** ****** lenses.

** *** ** ** but * ***'* **** which ****** *** *** using ** **** ****** picture *** ****. *** you ***** **** *** please?

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Pelco GFC 4K Dome Camera Tested (IMP831-1ERS) on Mar 12, 2019
Pelco has finally released their first 4K IP camera, after years of competitors' releases. Is this move too late? Or is their new GFC Professional...
Vivotek 20MP Multi-Imager Tested on May 30, 2019
Vivotek has released their latest repositionable multi-imager camera, the MA9321-EHTV, a 20 MP model claiming "Supreme Night Visibility", "Optimal...
Axis ARTPEC-7 P1375-E Camera Tested on Jul 12, 2019
Axis claims the new P1375-E box camera with ARTPEC-7 chip delivers "clear, sharp images in any lighting condition." But how well does it do? We...
Hikvision 4K Camera Shootout on Aug 02, 2019
With their latest Smart Series 5 cameras, Hikvision is claiming cameras "fully loaded" with "state-of-the-art technology for high performance and...
Hanwha 4K Wisenet P Camera Tested on Jul 30, 2019
Hanwha claims "premium performance" and to "deliver the best in high resolution performance and efficiency" with their Wisenet P series 4K models,...
Dahua 4K Camera Shootout on Aug 20, 2019
Dahua's new Pro Series 4K N85CL5Z claims to "deliver superior images in all lighting and environmental conditions", but how does this compare to...
Axis 4K Camera Shootout 2019 on Aug 14, 2019
Axis' 4K Q3518-LVE claims the "best video quality possible", with Lightfinder super low light performance, Axis' high end Forensic WDR, and...
Uniview Pro 4K Camera Tested (IPC3238ER3-DVZ) on Aug 29, 2019
In our 8MP / 4K Fixed Lens Camera Shootout, Uniview's low end 8MP was firmly in the middle of the pack. Does their higher end Pro Series 4K camera...
Uniview Prime Series 4K Camera Tested on Sep 18, 2019
Is the new Uniview 'Prime' better than the more expensive existing Uniview 'Pro'? In August, IPVM tested Uniview 4K 'Pro' but members advocated...
Vivotek 4K S-Series Camera Tested on Sep 30, 2019
Vivotek's highest-end S-series camera claims "Supreme Night Visibility", "Smart IR II", "Smart Stream II", "WDR Pro for unparalleled visibility in...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Motorola / Avigilon Drops ISC West on Feb 26, 2020
Motorola Solutions has pulled out of ISC West 2020 effective immediately, because of coronavirus concerns, IPVM has learned. This is done amidst...
Cancel or Not? Industry Split Over ISC West on Feb 26, 2020
The industry is split, polarized, over whether ISC West 2020 should run or be canceled. New IPVM survey results of 400+ respondents show heated...
Coronavirus Hits Sony, Bosch Says Switch on Feb 26, 2020
Sony's fall in video surveillance has been severe over the past decade. Now, they may be done. In this note, we examine Bosch's new...
Video Surveillance Cameras 101 on Feb 25, 2020
Cameras come in many shapes, sizes and specifications. This 101 examines the basics of cameras and features used in 2020. In this report, we...
Favorite Video Analytic Manufacturers 2020 on Feb 25, 2020
Video analytics is now as hot as ever, driven by the excitement of advancing deep learning offers. But what are actually integrator's...
Latest London Police Facial Recognition Suffers Serious Issues on Feb 24, 2020
On February 20, IPVM visited another live face rec deployment by London police, but this time the system was thwarted by technical problems and...
Masks Cause Major Facial Recognition Problems on Feb 24, 2020
Coronavirus is spurring an increase in the use of medical masks, which new IPVM test results show cause major problems for facial recognition...
Every VMS Will Become a VSaaS on Feb 21, 2020
VMS is ending. Soon every VMS will be a VSaaS. Competitive dynamics will be redrawn. What does this mean? VMS Historically...
Video Surveillance 101 Course - Last Chance on Feb 20, 2020
This is the last chance to join IPVM's first Video Surveillance 101 course, designed to help those new to the industry to quickly understand the...
Vulnerability Directory For Access Credentials on Feb 20, 2020
Knowing which access credentials are insecure can be difficult to see, especially because most look and feel the same. Even insecure 125 kHz...