Camera Selection Guide 2013

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Nov 14, 2013

UPDATE: This has been replaced by Camera Application Selection Guide 2017

Entrances, hallways, rooms and parking lots are perhaps the 4 most common areas where surveillance is deployed. But what is the best type of camera for each? What resolution, form factors and FoV are best? Where do special features like WDR, integrated IR, super low light fit? Where is the best place to position the cameras?

In this report, we share test findings and recommendations showing tradeoffs of different camera options in each of these 4 fundamental spots - entrance, hallways, rooms and parking lots.

Below is an image of the FOVs used in our four different scenes.

Free Example

Inside, we have more than 20 comparisons. Here's a free example:

This comparison demonstrates the difference between mounting a single imager panoramic in the center of the room vs. a super wide angle camera at one end. 

Below is that same scene, just zoomed in on our subject.

More than 20 others inside.

******: **** *** **** replaced ******** *********** ********* ***** 2017

*********, ********, ***** *** parking **** *** ******* the * **** ****** areas ***** ************ ** deployed. *** **** ** the **** **** ** camera *** ****? **** resolution, **** ******* *** FoV *** ****? ***** do ******* ******** **** WDR, ********** **, ***** low ***** ***? ***** is *** **** ***** to ******** *** *******?

** **** ******, ** share **** ******** *** recommendations ******* ********* ** different ****** ******* ** each ** ***** * fundamental ***** - ********, hallways, ***** *** ******* lots.

***** ** ** ***** of *** **** **** in *** **** ********* scenes.

Free *******

******, ** **** **** than ** ***********. ****'* a **** *******:

**** ********** ************ *** difference ******* ******** * single ****** ********* ** the ****** ** *** room **. * ***** wide ***** ****** ** one ***. 

***** ** **** **** scene, **** ****** ** on *** *******.

**** **** ** ****** inside.

[***************]

Key ********

**** *** *** *** findings **** **** ******:

*********/*******

  • *** ******* *** ********* in ********* **** ****** backlighting, * ****** **********. 
  • ** ******* ********* (*-* doors) ******** ********** ******* provide ********** ****** ** identify * *******
  • *********** ***** **** *** unnecessary ** **** ********* and ***** ******** ********* and ******* ***** ******* adding ** ****** ******* delivered. ***** ****** **** rarely ******* ***.

********

  • ** ********, **** *:* and **:* *********** ***** much ** *** *** on ***** **** *****, though *:* **** *** scene ********** ****** *** to *** ****** ***********.
  • ******** ******* ** ******* and ***** *:** ******** mode ******** ******* ******* the ***** ****** ** unneeded ***** *** ******** coverage ** **** ** the ****.
  • ********** *** ** ******** mode ******** ***** ** more **** ******* *** camera ***** *** **** to **** ********* ** subjects. *******, **** ******** results ** * **** of *** ** *** hallway ******, *********** ** recognition **********.

******** *****

  • ******* * ****** ***** wide ***** ****** (***° FOV) ** *** ****** of *** **** ******** approximately *** **** ******* as * ******* ********** panoramic ******. *******, ** our *****, **** ***** cameras ******** ****** ***** handling **********, ********* ** less ************ ** *** subject *** *****, ***** still ******** *** ****** room, ****** **** ********** to ********* *******.
  • *** ******* **** ********** rooms (**'***' *** *****), resolutions ****** **** ***** offer *** ********** *******. 720p ********** ******** ******** less **** ************** ******* video, ****** * ***** subject *** ***** ** recognized.
  • ********** ** ******* ******** higher ******* *** ***** images **** ***-** ******, providing ******* ** *** subject *** ***** ***** 1 *** ***** ****** produced ** ****** ******.
  • ********* ** ***** ** rear ** **** ******** purely ** **** ******** was **** ******* ** be ********: *****/**** ** general ********.

******* ****

  • * *** ** ********* cameras ******** ******* ******** in ******* ****** *** to ******* ***** ******** capabilities. ********* ***** ****** areas ** *** ***** to ** ****** ***, including ********, ********, *** our **** *****.
  • *** ******* ** **** details *** *******. **** angle ***** ******** ******** of ********** ** *** parking ***, *** * reduction ** *********** ** subjects *** ******* ******. Reducing *** *** ** about **** ******** ****** recognition ************, *** * full ******** ** ******** (cars *** ****** ****** and *****) *** ****, possibly ********* ********** ******* in *** **** *****.
  • ***** **** ******* **** have **** **** ** outdoor ******** *** ********* safety, ***** *** ***** cameras ******* ******* ******* to ********** ** *******. In ***** ** **** dimly *** ******* ****, integrated ** ****** ******* better ***********.

***************

***** ** ***** ************ we **** *** ********* key *************** *** **** of ***** *****:

********* 

** ******* *********, ** recommend ** ** **** cameras **** **** *** performance (** ****** ************ exists). ******* ****** ***** resolutions *** *** ********* unless *** *********** ** very *****, ********* ** wasted ******* *** *********. Cameras ******* *** **** lose ****** *** ** backlighting, ******** ***** ******* to ******** ********.

********

** ********, **** ********** is *** ****** ******. While ****** ********** ******** more ****** *** ****, these ******* **** ********* handle ***** ***** **** 720p ** ***** ******, reducing ****** ***** *******. If ***** ** ****** and ****, *** ******* space ** *** * major *******, *** *** be * **** ********.

***** ********, ** ********* corridor **** ** ****, shifting *** ****** ***** from **:* ** *:**. This ********** **** ** the **** ***** **** when ***** ******** *:* or **:* *******. *******, this ********** *** ** limited ** ****** ** VMS ******.

******** *****

** ******* ******** ****** such ** ********** *****, we ********* ** ***** 720p ********** ** ****. Lower *********** **** ** provide ****** *****. ** contrast, **** *********** **** as * *** ** megapixel *** ****** ***** space ****** **** ******* of ******** *** ********** are ********** *********.

***** **** ***** ******* are *********** ** *** entire **** **** ********** be *******, ******* ** simply *** *** ** the *****, *** ** their ******** ***** ******** capabilities ******** ** ********* models ********* *******.

********** ** ******* *** recommended ** ******** ** expected **** ****** *** low. ***-** ******* ******* little ** *** *** of ********* ** *********** of ********.

******* ****

***** ******* ******** *** best ******** ******* ***** handling *** ********** ** this *****. **** ********* ******* may ******* **** ****** per **** ** ******* lot ******, *** ***** should ** ***** ** possible ************ ****** ****** in ***** ******. *** light *********** ** ******* above ***** ** **** poor.

** ********* ***** **** be **** ** ******* lots, ** ******* ** the ****** ******** ********* in ***** ***** *** low. ********* *** *** by ****** **% **** little ** ******** ******* on ****** ** ****** ranges, *** ******* *** camera's ******* ** ******* an ******** ** ******** throughout *** *****.

***** **** ******* **** are ***, *** ******** of ******* ** *** integrated ** ** ***** low ***** ******* ***** down ** *** *******:

  • *****:** ***** ** * key **** ** *** scene, ** ***** ** identify ******** ** ********, low ***** ******* ****** be ****.
  • ****:** ***** ** *** needed, ********** ** ******* may ********* ** ********* for * ***** *****, while ***** ********* ******* on *** **** *** light ******.

*********

*****, ** ****** *** of *** **** ****** locations *** ******* ** any ********, ** ******** lobby. *** *********, **** the *** ******** *****, we ****** *** *********:

  • *** **. *** ***
  • ** **. ** **. Multi-Megapixel

*** **. ***-*** *******

**** ******* ********** ** essential ** ******** ****** to ********** *** ****** backlighting ****** ** *** sun ******* *** ********. In *** ********** *****, with *** **, *** subject, *****, *** **** outside *** ******** *** all ******* *******. **** WDR ****** ***, *** subject's **** ** ********* obscured, *** ******* ***** are ********** ****** ***.

** **. **** **. 1080p

** * ***** ** view **** ****** (~**'), even ******** ********** (******* in **** ****) ** sufficient ** ******* *********** quality ****** ** *** subject *** *****. ****** resolutions ** *** ******* a ********* ******** ** usable *******.

*** **** ** **** outside *** ****, ** well. **** **** ** this ****, *** * and ** ********* *******' lower *********** ***** ******** negatively ****** ***** *******, with *** ******* *** chart **** **** ****** out.

********

*** ********, **** *** one ******** *****, ** tested *** *********:

  • ** **. *** **. 10MP
  • *:* ** **:* **. Corridor ****
  • ******** **** ******** **. Wide **. ***** **** FOV

** **. *** **. 10MP

**** *** ******* ** the **** *** ** the *******, *** ************, all *********** *** **** to ******* ******* *****. Even ***** ** **** range ** ********.

** *** *** ***** of *** *******, ~**' from *** ****** ********, details ***** ** ****, though *** **** ****** still ******** ******* ******** to ********* *** *******. **** that *** ***** ****** in **** **** *** 1080p *** **** ******* started ** ****** **** greater ******* ***** *** artifacting **** **** *** 5MP ******, ******** ***** quality.

** *** *** *** of *** *******, **** 720p *** ***** ******* PPF *** *** ** identify *** ******* ** make *** *** *****. Digital ***** ****** *** more ********** ** **** range.

*:* **. **:* **. Corridor ****

***** ******** *** **** longer **** **** *** wide, **** *:* *** 16:9 ****** ****** ****** in *********** ******* ** space ** *** *** wasted ** ******* ***** such ** ***** ***** (highlighted ** *** *** boxes *****). ******** **** shifts **** ****** ***** to *:**, ********* **** coverage ** ****** *****, as *** ** **** highlighted ** ***** *****. 

************, ***** ** ****** rotates *** ****** ** degrees, ******** **** ********* the **** *** ** standard ****** ******, ** can ** **** ** a ********** ** *** two *****:


**** **** ******** **** is *** ********* ** many ******* ** ****, limiting *** *******. ***** should ****** **** ** **** Corridor ********* **** *********** ** the ********* ** ***** 9:16 ****** *****. 

******* ** *** ** Corridor ****

** *** *** ****** field ** **** *** on ******** **** *******, we ****** ** ** four ********* ****** ** view, ******* **** ********** narrow ** ***** **** (134°). ** *** ******** FOV *****, *** ****** maintained * ***** ** view ******* ** *** 16:9 ******* *****, ***** 65-70°, *** *** ******* into ******** ****. *** was ************* *******, ** ~90°, ***°, *** ***° in ****** ** *** right.

**** **** *** **** beneath *** ****** ******* more *** **** ******* as *** *** ** increased, ***** *** ** useful ** *********** ********* subjects ******** ** **** move ******* *** ***. However, *** **** **** (118/134°) ****** ** **** offer ****** **** ********* value, ** ********* *** be ********** **** ** the ********* ***** ** view.

************, ******* **** ******* as *** *** ** widened, ** *** ** seen ** *** ***** below. ** **** ****, ability ** ******** *** subject ****** **** *** hall ******* **** ** 90° *** ******.

*****

*** *****, **** ** the ********** **** *****, we ****** *** *********:

  • ****** ********: ***** **. rear
  • ****** ******* **** ***** vs ****** ******* ******* panoramic
  • ** ** **** ** 1080p
  • ******** ** ***
  • ********** ** ** ***** only

***** **. **** ********

*** ***** ******** ** locating ******* ** ******** rooms **** ** ***** is *** ******'* ******* purpose.

  • ******* ** *** ****, the ****** *** ** used ** **** ******* activity ** *** ****, but * **** ** entries/exits ******* *** **** may ** ****.
  • ******* ** *** ***** of *** ****, *** camera *** **** ****** capture ******** ******** *** exiting, *** ******** ** the ***** ** *** room *** ** ******.

***** *** ***** **** the ********** ******* ***** and **** ********:

***** *********** *** ** mitigated ** ***** ***** wide ***** ** ********* cameras, ****** ** * loss ** *** ********** the ***.

** **. *****-*********

** **** ******* ********** room (~**' * **'), we ***** ***** ** be *** *********** "***** spot" ** ***********. **** was *** ***** ********** for *********** ***** ** our *******'* ****. ********** resolution ** * ** 10 ********* ***** *** practical ******* *** **** in *** ***** ******, but ******* *** ***** performance *************, ** **** below.

** **** *****, *** 720p *** ***** ******* offered ** *** *** best ***********. *** **** model *** ******** **** able ** ******* ******* on *** **** ***** compared ** *** ***** camera, *** ** ********* digital *****. ******* *** 5MP *** **** ******* provided ****** ****** ** our ******* ** *****.

***** **** ***** **. Panoramic

**** ********** ************ *** difference ******* ******** * single ****** ********* ** the ****** ** *** room **. * ***** wide ***** ****** ** one ***. 

***** ** **** **** scene, **** ****** ** on *** *******.

********** ** **. ***** Only

*******, ** ****** *** 720p *******, *** ***** only, *** *** **** built-in **, ** *** what ********, ** ***, IR ************ ****** ** this *****. **** ***** compares *** ***** ** view ** ****. ** the ***-** ******, ***** is **** ********** ********* our *******, ****** *** chart *** ** ****** seen. *** ** ****** makes ********* **** ******.

******* ** ** *** subject, ** *** *** that ******* ****** ******** recognition ******* ***** ** this ********. 

Parking ****

*** ******* ****, **** the *** ******** *****, we ****** *** *********:

  • ** ** *** ** 10MP
  • ***** **** ** ********** wide
  • ********** ** ** ***** low *****

** **. ***

** **** ********, ****** an ************* **' ***** of ****, **** ********** does *** ******* ****** sufficient *** *********** ** our *******. ************, *** chart ** ****** ******* past *** ***** ****. 1080p *** ***** ******* better *********** ** **** subject *** *****. *******, the * *** ** megapixel ******* *** ****** out ******** ** **** four, ***** *** ***** camera ** ***.

**** *** **. ***

** **** ****, ** narrowed *** *** **** about **', ***** ******** the ****** ***** ** our ******* ***, ********* the ******** ** *** right ** *** ****, to ***** **', ********** PPF ****** ***** * parking *****. **** ********* removes *** ******* ** observe ******** ******** *** exiting, ***** ** ******** in *** ***** ***.

************, ******** *** **** not ****** ** **** practical **** ** *******, with *** ******* *** chart **** ******** **** discernable.

********** ** **. ***** Low *****

*******, ** ****** ** integrated ** ****** ******* two *** ***** ********* models ** *** ********* in *********** ** *****. Note **** ** **** scene, *** ******* *** was *********** ** ***** 2 *** ** ******, typical ** **** ******* lots. **** ***** ***** the ********** ** *********** across *** ***, **** the ** ******'* ************ pattern ****** ****** **********.

** ~**', *********** ******* low ***** ******* *** the ** ****** ** similar, **** ****** *** chart ******* ****** ***********. The ***** ****** ** this **** ** ******** washed *** *** ** the ******* *****, ********* in **** **** ** detail.

** **** ********, *** cameras **** ***** ***** similar ***********, ****** *********** ** ******* **** detail *** ** ********* in *** *** ******* noise ****** ** ********* gain.

Comments (15)

I really like this, thank you. Would you have had an opportunity to do situations like large workfloors like parts assembly areas. High ceilings open plan type arrangements.

Hi Vasiles, thanks, we are planning to do more of these. These areas were the most common and the simplest to take care of first. We're looking at maybe doing warehouses, loading docks, etc., because they're also readily available to us in our building. Other specific areas like you mention are definitely possible, but we'll need to find somewhere to shoot, so it'll take a bit longer.

Wow that's an excellent review John & team. Think you hit a lot of pertinent points and very graphical for us people with short attention spans.

Great reference gude!

"Corridor mode" is a great thing for indoor video surveillance. And not only for corridors.

Excellent guide .

Excellent guide! If possible, please list the camera make & models used in the testing.

Great content thanks

Nice tests. Comparision of images at 1/2/5/10MP resolution, at day and night conditions tell much.

Very useful! Re: Brandon's comment- I am interested in how you selected which cameras to use. Not as much in the make and model (although that is certainly important), but in whether you tried to pick the best of class for each type of camera, the average or just whatever camera came first to hand.

We tried to pick an average of professional models we have tested over the last 10 months. As for the specific models, the only one that's notable because it's rare is the 10MP and that's an Arecont - see our new 10MP vs 5MP vs HD Shootout

i appreciated seeing the differences on the side by side comparisons. Gives me a great perspective!

Great Job

Looking forward to more of these type's of comparisons

Thanks

Why is the 5MP camera for the hallway displays the eyechart significantly yellower than the other cameras?

That's a function of the sensor and/or white balance in that specific camera. Even trying to compensate for it by adjusting color gains, it was still yellow.

Four years later would you come to the same results? Panoramic fisheye imagers have developed with more features. Panoramic multi-imager cameras have continued to develop, low light cameras detect better at lower light levels and thermal has continued to price drop making them a real choice to the market.

 

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Camera Focusing Tutorial on Oct 14, 2019
Camera focus is fundamental to quality imaging. Mistakes can significantly reduce details, making cameras less effective. In this guide, we...
Last Chance - Register Now - October 2019 IP Networking Course on Oct 10, 2019
Last Chance - Register Now - Fall 2019 IP Networking Course. The course starts next week. This is the only networking course designed...
Network Optix NxWitness 4.0 Tested on Oct 10, 2019
Network Optix released Nx Witness 4.0, proclaiming new features like a deep learning analytics metadata SDK, increased H.265 support, and UX...
Avigilon H5A Analytic Cameras Tested on Oct 07, 2019
Avigilon has released its H5A analytic cameras, claiming to "detect more objects with greater accuracy even in crowded scenes." We tested the...
Hikvision ColorVu is Smart Marketing on Oct 03, 2019
Hikvision ColorVu (see IPVM test results) is smart marketing, a lesson to be learned by competitors and a rising trend. Inside this note, we...
Camera Cable Whip Guide on Oct 02, 2019
Cable whips are one of integrator's least favorite camera features but seem to be unavoidable, now commonplace on dome, turret, and bullet cameras...
Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) Guide on Oct 01, 2019
Understanding wide dynamic range (WDR) is critical to capturing high quality images in demanding conditions. However, with no real standards, any...
Access Control Mustering Guide on Sep 30, 2019
In emergencies, determining where employees are located can be critical for knowing whether they are in danger. Access systems can be used for...
Vivotek 4K S-Series Camera Tested on Sep 30, 2019
Vivotek's highest-end S-series camera claims "Supreme Night Visibility", "Smart IR II", "Smart Stream II", "WDR Pro for unparalleled visibility in...
Access Control Mantraps Guide on Sep 26, 2019
One of access's primary goals is keeping people out of places they should not be, but slipping through open doors (ie: Tailgating) is often...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Altronix Claims Tango 'Eliminates Electricians' on Oct 15, 2019
Power supply provider Altronix claims its new Tango power supply 'eliminates the need for an electrician, dedicated conduit and wire runs'. In...
Hikvision Dissolves North American Business Unit, Splits Canada and USA on Oct 15, 2019
Hikvision has dissolved its North American Business Unit, splitting up US and Canada operations as the PRC-government owned manufacturer faces...
Camera Focusing Tutorial on Oct 14, 2019
Camera focus is fundamental to quality imaging. Mistakes can significantly reduce details, making cameras less effective. In this guide, we...
"UL Has Blood On Their Hands" Alleges The Interceptor / Keith Jentoft on Oct 14, 2019
"UL has blood on their hands" alleges Keith Jentoft of "The Interceptor Project". We examined The Interceptor in-depth last year, see: The...
Access Control Course Fall 2019 - Save $50 Last Chance on Oct 14, 2019
Register Now - Fall 2019 Access Control Course. Save $50 through October 10th. Thursday, October 17th is the last day to register. IPVM offers...
Axis HD Analog Encoder Tested on Oct 11, 2019
Two years after declaring "Everything is IP", Axis has released their first HD analog encoder, the P7304, with support for AHD, CVI, TVI, and SD...
Dahua Celebrates PRC 70th Wearing Communist Party Hammer and Sickle on Oct 11, 2019
Dahua celebrated the PRC's 70th anniversary with a video of various Dahua employees wearing China Communist Party hammer and sickle pins as shown...
Last Chance - Register Now - October 2019 IP Networking Course on Oct 10, 2019
Last Chance - Register Now - Fall 2019 IP Networking Course. The course starts next week. This is the only networking course designed...
Network Optix NxWitness 4.0 Tested on Oct 10, 2019
Network Optix released Nx Witness 4.0, proclaiming new features like a deep learning analytics metadata SDK, increased H.265 support, and UX...
HID Fingerprint Reader Tested on Oct 09, 2019
HID has released their first access reader to use Lumidigm optical sensors, that touts it 'works with anyone, anytime, anywhere'. We bought and...