Camera Analytics Tested: Axis vs. Bosch vs. Sony

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Sep 17, 2013

With the move to IP and HD now commonplace, companies are looking for new ways to compete. While analytics has long disappointed, many still hold out hope for it being the next big thing.

Many major camera manufacturers offer analytics built-in or for a minimal additional charge. However, skepticism of their performance is commonplace.

The Test

In this report, we tested 3 camera manufacturers analytics - Axis cross line detection, Bosch's Intelligent Video Analytics and Sony's Video Motion Filter (VMF).

The test focuses on tripwire / perimeter violation analytics as this is most common type used in security to alert against intruders entering into a restricted area.

We tested in 3 different scenes.

To start, we did a simple indoor tripwire at an entrance:

Then we progressed to an outdoor scene of moderate complexity and distance:

Finally, we tried a very long area with vegetation and shadows to maximize the challenge:

**** *** **** ** ** *** ** *** ***********, ********* are ******* *** *** **** ** *******. ***** ********* *** long ************, **** ***** **** *** **** *** ** ***** the**** *** *****.

**** ***** ****** ************* ***** ********* *****-** ** *** * minimal ********** ******. *******, ********** ** ***** *********** ** ***********.

The ****

** **** ******, ** ****** * ****** ************* ********* -**** ***** **** *********,*****'* *********** ***** ************ ****'* ***** ****** ****** (***).

*** **** ******* ** ******** / ********* ********* ********* ** this ** **** ****** **** **** ** ******** ** ***** against ********* ******** **** * ********** ****.

** ****** ** * ********* ******.

** *****, ** *** * ****** ****** ******** ** ** entrance:

**** ** ********** ** ** ******* ***** ** ******** ********** and ********:

*******, ** ***** * **** **** **** **** ********** *** shadows ** ******** *** *********:

[***************]

Key ********

**** *** *** *** ******** **** ***** *****:

******* **************

  • ***** **** ********* ******** **** **** *** ***** ** ********* is ** **** ** ********. **** ******* ***** ** ***** activations *** ** ******* ** ******* ***********. 
  • ***** ***** ******* **** **** ********** *** *******-** ********, *** inside-out, **** *** ****** ****** ****** *** ******. 
  • ***** ****** **** ********** ******* **** ** ****** ******* *** headlights **** ********, *** *** ******. ***** ****** ** ***** to ***** **** ***** ***** ********.
  • *** ** *** ***** ******** **** **** ******* ****** ********* may *** ****** *********** *********** *** ***** **** *********.

 *********** ***********

  • **** ***** ***** **** ********* ******** ******* ** **** ****** in **** ****** ***** ******* ******** **** ****** ***** ***-**** or **** ***-*****. *******, ** ******** **** ***** ***********, ****** by ******* ** ******* ***** ** *********, *** ***** ********* multiple *****.
  • ***** ***-****'* *** ********* ******** ** **** *** ******, *** better **** ****** **** ***-***** ** **** ***** , **** ** ***** or ******** ***********. *******, ** *** ***** ********* ***** *** drastically *******, *** ****** *********** *********.
  • **** ***-*****'* *****-** *** ****** ** *** *****, **** **** to ******** ****** ****** ** **** ***** *****. ******** **** detectable ** ****** *********, ****** ***** ** ***** *** ****. This ** *** ** ***** ** **** ** ****** **** settings ** **** ***-*****'* ********* *** ******** ** ***** *******, which ****** ** ****** ******* ** *** ** *****, *** detected ****** ******* ** ******** ** *** *** *****, ******* detections.

*****

**** ** *** ***** ** ********* ** **** **** **** by ************:

  • **** *****  ***** **** *********:~$** ***, **** ********* ** **-***** ** ********.
  • ***** ***-**** ***: *** ****** ******* **** **** *** ********* ** no ********** ******. *** *** *** ****** ****** *** ** licensed ** ** ********** **** ** ~$***.
  • **** ***-***** ***: **** ***-*****'* *****-** ********* *** ********* ** ** additional **** ** *** ********** *******. ***** ********** ******* ********** shipped **** **** *********.

***************

***** **** ********* *** ***** **** ****** **********, *** **** be ******* *********, ** ******** ********* *** *** ** ******* cameras *** *** ****** ** *****. ***** ****** ********* ******** these ******* *** **** ********* ** ***** ****** ******* **** them ** *** *****.

** **** ******, **** *** ********* ** **** *** *****, Bosch ***-****'* *** *** **** ********, **** ****** ** ***** or ****** ***********. ***** ****** ** ***** ** *** *** light *********** ****** *********, *******.

**** *****  ***** **** ********* *** ******** ** **** ******, *** performed ****** ** **** *** ***** **** ***** ***-****. *******, users ****** ** ***** ** *** ***** *********** *** ** headlights, *******, *** ****** *******, ****** *********.

** ** *** ********* **** ***-*****'* *** ********* ** ****** aside **** **** *** ****** ***** *** ** *** ****** detecting *******.

************* 

** ***** ***********, ** ****** ************* *** **** ** *** three ************* ******.

*****, **** ***** ***** **** *********. ************* ** **** ******, **** including *** **** (* ** * ********) ************* *********, **** ** ***** *****.

****, ***** ***-**** ***. *** ***-**** ******* *** **** ************* *******, ********* multiple *****, **** ****** *******, ****, ********, *** ***** **********. ** **** ********* *********** regarding ******* ******** *** ***** **** ******* *** *****, ****** troubleshooting ****** ******** ** ****** ***** *** *** ******* ****.

*******, **** ***-*****'* *** ***** ******** ********** *** ****** **** and *****, ** **** ** ******** ******** **** ** **** length *** *********. ** ** ***** ***** *** ** *** per ******, *** ******** **** ******. ***** ****** ** ******* when ************* ****** ****, ** ** *** *********** ****** ********* performance.

Outdoor ************

** ****** *** ***** **** ********* ** ******* ****** ******* scenarios.

********/******* ***

*****, ** ***** **** * ******* ***/******** ***** ** ****** up ** ***', ***** ** **** ******** ****:

****** *** ***, ********* ** **', *** ******* *** ********.

****** ***** ******* **** *** ******* *** ** ~***', **** P3354 and ***** ***-**** **** ***** ******* ******** ** *** *******. ** this ******** *** ******, **** ***** ************************** ** **** ** ***** **********, ** *** ******* ********** and ******* *** ****. ***** ***-**** ********* **** ****. *** ***** was ****** ** ******** ****** ******* ** **** *****, ** did *** *******.

*******, **** *** **** ******* *** *** *** ** *** entrance ** *** *** **** *** ****, **** **** ***** *** Bosch ***-**** **** ***** ********, ****** **** *****  ***** ********* ******** ***** as ** *** ** ***'. 

** *****, ** ***** *****, **** ***** *** ***** ***-**** **** *******, while **** ***-***** **** ***. ***** ***-**** ********* ****** **** *** ******* was ****** **** **** *** ******, *** ******, ** ** detected *** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** **********.

** ~***' *** ******, **** **** *****  ********. **** *********** **** slightly ***** *** ** *** ********** ** ********** ****** ****** the ******.

** **** ********, ~***', **** ***** ***** ********. *******, ********** ***** alarms **** ****** ** **** ******* ** *** ******* ****** the ******* ***. ****** *** **** **** **** *** **** partway ******** ****.

**** ***** ********

** **** ****** *** ******* ** *** **** ** *** office, ******* * ******* ******** ****** *** ********** ** *** perimeter, ******* ****** *********** *** ***** **** *********.

 

** ***', **** **** *****  *** ***** ***-**** *********, ***** **** ***-***** *** not (*** *** ** ** *** ****** ******):

 

** ***', ***** ***-**** ********* ** ***** *** ***** ** *** subject, ***** **** *****  *** ****** **:

 

** ***', **** ** *** ******* *********, **** *** ******* simply *** ***** ** ********:

 ** *****, **** *** ******* ******** **, ************* *-* ***, both **** ***** *** ***** ***-**** ********* ******** ** **' *****.

** **', ***** ***-**** ***** *********, ***** **** *****  *** ***. ****** this, ** ******* **** **** ** ****** *** *******.

********* *** *** ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** ***** * lux. ********* ***** ** ***** ***-**** ***** ** **** **', ***** here.

**** ***** *** **** ** ****** *** ******* ******** ** ** 75', *******.

Indoor ************

*** *** *********** ***** ***** ********************* ** ********* ** ******** ******** * *******. ** *** up *** ******* ** ***** ** *** ****** ***** ** simulate ****, ******* *** ******** ** *** ****** ** *** door, **** *** ******* ***** **' ****. ** **** *****, Axis *****  *** **** ***-***** ****** ********, *** ***** ***-**** *** *** *******:

**** ** *** ** *** *** ***** ***-**** ****** *******, **** the ****** **** ***** ******, ******* *** *******'* ***** *** waist. ** *** ***** *****, *** *******'* **** ****** ***** crossed *** ****. ****** ** ******* ** *** *******, ***** NBN-733V triggers ********, ** **** **** ***** . *******, ********* ** *** exact ************ ********, **** **** ******** *** ***** ***** ******** on ****** ****** ******* *** ****. ***** ****** ** ******* to ***** ****.

********** ****

******* *** * ****** *** *** ***** **** *********, ** performed **** ***** ** *** ********** ********** **** ** ***** to *********** **** ****** ****** ********** *** *****.

*****, **** ***** ***** **** *****  ***** **** *********'* *********** ** shadows. ** **** ****, ****** *** **** *** *** ** trigger **** **** *** ******* ***** ****** *** ******, *** motion ** *** ****** ** *** ***** ****** ***** *********** as ** ***** ****** *** **** ** *** ******** *********:

 **** ******** ** ** ***** ****** *** ****, ** ****. 

** **** ****, *** **** *** ***** ** ******* ** the ******* ***** *** ** *** **** ** *** ***** end ** *** ****. *******, *** ***** ******* ****** ** activate ** ** ***** ******** *** ** *** **** ************* to *** *******.

********* *** **** ******** ** ** ***** ** **** ** an ***** ** ****** *** ******. 

*******, ***** *** ****** ****** ***** * ****** ******** **** next ** *** ****, ** *** ******* ******* ** ****** what ***** **** **** ** *** ****.

Test **********

** **** *** ********* ******* *** ******** ******** *** **** test:

  • **** *****, ******** *.**.**
  • ***** ***-****, ******** *.** ***** **
  • **** ***-*****, ******** *.*.*

*** ******* **** ******* ********, **** ********* ************ ** */*** maximum.

 

Comments (19)

** *** *** ***** ******* ***** ********* ****. ****************** *** ******** ****** ** **** **** ******** ********* ******.

** ** **** ** **** **** ***** ********* - **** from '*******' ****** ************ ** **** ** ***** ******** *********** (VideoIQ, *******, ***.). ** ********, ** **** ** **** ***** aspects ** *****'* *** (**** ***** *********) ** * ******** report.

**** *** *** **** ** **** ***** ******-***** ********?

**** ******* ** *********** *********** **** ** *** ** *** common ********** ** ***** *********: ******** *** ***** ******* ******* probability ** ********* *** *** ***** ***** ****.

***** *** ******** ** *****, * ***** *** ***** ******* it ** ****** **** ************ ******** ** *********** *********** **** factors ** **** *********** ** ********* *** *** **** ** false ******.

*** ** ********** *-**** ****** **** * **-****** '**' ****** that ***** * ****** ****** ********* ** **** ** ***** issues. **** ******* ** ***-**** **** ***.

****,********* ** ** ****** *** *** ***** * ********** ***** so *** ********** ******* ********* ************* ** **********. **** *** be ******* **** ***** ******* *** *** *********** **'** *** **** **** ** ******** ******* ** * monitor ***** * ***** *****.

** ******** ******* ** **** ******* **** ** **** ** F1 ***** ** > .** *** **** ** ** ********* useful ** ** ***** ********* ********.

***, ****** *** *** ******** ** ************ ******* *** ********** scenes.

** * ******* ****, **** ****** ************ ******* ** **** are *** ************** *** ***** ** ****** ******. ** * say ****** * ****** * .**, ****** * ****** * .95 *** ****** * ****** * .**, **** **** **** really ****? *********, ** ***** ****** * ** *** **** but ** *** **********? *** ** *** ****? ****, ** we *** ************ *******/******** *** ********** *** ************* ** ****** this ** ********** ***** ** ******* *** ****.

** *** *************, ** **** *** ******* ** *** ***** same **** *** ***** ** **** ***** ******. *** ****, Bosch *** **** ******* *** *** ****** **** **** ***** on * ****** *** ***** ** **** ********. ******* ** that, ** **** **** *** ******* *** *** ******* ** and ******* **** *** ***** **** **********.

****, * ***** ****’* ***** **** ‘**** ********** ******’. *******, IPVM’s ***** *** *** ************ *** ** *** *** ***** do *** **** **** ***** *** *** ***’* ******* *** results ** * *** ****** **** ***** ******* ******. ******** the ***** ** ********* ****** ** **** *****. ********* *** to **** **/*, ** ***** * **** ******* **** ***** with ******** ******* ** ********* ** *** *** ** *** test. * **** **** **** ******** ** ********* **** ****** well *** * ***** **** ** ******* * ******* ***** later ** *** ** ** ************* ******. **** ****** ** looking *** ***** ***** ** ********. *** ******** ** *** IPVM ** ***** ** * ******* ** **** ****** **** are ***** ** ******* ******** *** **** *** ******* ** a *** *********** ***** * **** ***** ** **** **********. The *-**** **** ******* **** *** ***** ********* *** **** 100 **** ***** *** **** *** ******** *** ** ******** many ******** ** ****** **** ***** ***** ***** ****** – here *** **** * *** ** ****: **** ******* *** camera, ***** ******* ** *** ********* ****, ********* *********** **** flicking ** ** *** ** *****, ***** ****, ***** ******** change *** ** ******* *****. **** ******** * ******** ******* and *** ******* ****** * *** ** ********* *** *******, but **** **** ***** * ************** ** ** *** ***** well.

*** *** ** ***** ** **** ** ******* **** ******** video ***** - ***** *** ******* ** * *******? * await **** ******** ** **** **** **** *** ********* *** own ***** ***** / ********.

* ***** ** *** '*****' ** ******'* *********** ** *** it ******** ***** - *** *****, ***, ****** ******, ***. Using ******** ***** ********** *** **** ***** ************* ** ** cameras.

*****'* **** ** ** **** / *** **** ******** '*******' ** *******. **'* *** ********* ** * *** series ** **** ******** ** *********. ** **** ******** ************* ** ***** **** **** ****** **** *** ***** ** to *** *** *** ** ******** *** **.

***** ******, *****, *** *** *'** **** ******* ******* *** for ******.

** ****

****'* *** ******* *** ***** ** ******** ******** ***** ** ... ***** ****** ** **.

****** ** **** **** ** ***** ** ** ******* ************ on ***** ***. **** ****** ** **** *** "****" ****** short ***** *********. **** *** **** "*****" ************ ... **** rain, ****, *******, ****, *******, ******** ******** *** **** ***** positive ***/***** *** ********** *****'* ***** * ***** ******** **'* time ** ** ** ********.

** *** *** **** ****** ******* *** *** ** *** with *** ** ***** ********* **** ** *** ****** *******. (like *******/***/**** **** ******** ******* ** ***** **** *** **** t * ******** *** ****** ****)

** ****** ********* ****, *** ** ****** ** ***** ** night, ** **** ********* ******** *** ** **** *** ***** at ***** ...

"****** ** **** **** ** ***** ** ** ******* ************ on ***** ***."

** (*******) **** ******** **** *********, *** ********** ***** ******* areas ** */* **** ** **** **** * ****** ******. Yes, **'* *** **** ******** **** **** *** *** *** free (** $**), *** *** ********** **** *****.

**** ******* ****, ********** ******* ** ******. ** ******* **** all ** ***** ******* **** ****** ** ********* ******** *******. Rain, ** ** ********** ** *******, **** ****** ***** *******. It ***** ** ***** ** *** * ********** ** ***** manufactures ** *** *******.

****,

* *** *** ****** **** ******. *** **** *** **** Ethan's **** ** ***** *** ******, *** ****.

**** ****** *** **** ** ************ ** *****, ***** *** Derek. ** ** ****** ** *** ******* ** ****** *** the ***** ** ************ **** ** ***** ** **** **** their ***** ***** **** ****** :)

**** ** * **** ************* (**** ** ****). ** **** do **** ************* ***** ** *** **** (****) *** **** winter (****).

****** *** *** ********.

****

****,

***, **** *** ******* *** ** ** ******* ** ** astute ****** *** ****** ** ****. ****** **** ****, ***** upon *** ********** ** *** ******* **********, **** *** ******** have ****** *********: ******* *** *** *****.

***** *** '****' / ********** *********. ** ** ******** *** shootouts, **'** **** '**' *** **** **** *** ***** ******* VideoIQ, ***** **, ***.

******.

*** ***** **** *** * "**** ** ***** *** **** data ****"

**** **** ** ******* *** * ******** (******* ** ** rule) *** ** *** ****** **, *** *** * *** advanced ****** ** ** ***/*** ****** ** *** ********* **** data?

(** *************** ***'* **** *** ...)

*** (***) *** *** ....*****, ** **** ****** ********* :-)

***** *** ************* **. **' ******* ***** ****** *********. **** people **** ** *********.. *** *** ** **'* ******** ****** detection, *** **** **** *** **** ******* ********** ** *****.

**** *** *** ** * ***** ** **** (** ** Fov), *** *** ****** * *****, * *****, ********** *** object ******** *** ****** **** / **** / ******* *** Tree ***** **** *****, **'* ********* **** ******** ** ** mind

**** ***** ** **** ****** ******* ** *** ****** *** we *** ******* ***** ***** ***** ******.

******** ****** ***** *** ** ******* ** *** **** *** end, ***** *******. (*'* ***** ******** ******** **** *** ***** people *** ** **** ** *** ******* ********** ...)

**** -

**, * *** **** *** ****. ***, * ***** **** these ****** ****** **** *** *** **** **** ****** ***** consider "***** *********" ** *** ******* ***** ** *** ********.

** ** ******** *******, * ***** ***** ** "***** **** detection" ** * **** **** ********, ********** ********, ****** ** seems ** ** *** **** ****** *******.

**** *** ****** *** **** **, "***** **** *********" ***** to ** * *** ** *** *** ****** *** *** majority ** ***** ******. ***** ***** ******* ****** **** ***** classify ** ******, **** *** ** ****** *** ****** ** the ***** **** ** *** ***** **** **** **** **** for "*****" **** *******, ****** ****** * ******* ******** ****. That *********** ******** *** ****** ******** ** ******** ** *********, or ********, ** ****** **** ** * **** ***** *****. Then **** **** **** ** ****** ****** ** * ***** direction. *** ******* (***), ** **** *** **** **** * VERY ****** **** ** *** *** ***** *** *** ******* for ********. ** ******** ** *** ***** ******** *** ******* from "******" ** ****** ** ** ******* *** **** (**** lighting, **** ********, ***** **** ** ***, ******* ****** (****** car, ***.) ***** **** ** *** *********) *** **** * high **** **** ***'** ***** ** **** ***** ******.

** ******* ********* * ****** ** ******** (***) **** ****** the ******** ******* ****, **** * ***** ******* ***. **** we **** *** *** ****** ** ******* ******** ** **** area **** *** ****** ** *****. ** ** ***** ****, this ***** ******* **** *** **** ***** *********, ** **** as * ****** ***** **** *** **** **** *** ****** property ** ***** ** *********. *** *** *** ***** ***** the ****** ******** *** ******** ***** *** ** **** *** classified *********** (** ********* *****) *** ***** *** ** ***** 10 ******* "****", **** ****'** ******* **** **** *** ****** area. **** ** *** ****** **** ** ***** ** ***, because **** ******* ** **** ***** ******* ***** ***** **** the **** ****** **** ** *** *****-**** ********* ******.

**, ****, ** *** ******* ***** *** **** ****** !

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Top 2017 Trends - Cyber and Analytics on Nov 09, 2017
The 2 clear top 2017 trends, according to IPVM integrator statistics are: Cyber Security Video Analytics This is a change from 2016...
Avigilon H4 Mini Dome IR Tested on Oct 24, 2017
Avigilon has released their successor to the aging Micro Dome, the H4 Mini Dome, claiming easy install, a patent-pending surface/recessed...
Axis 'Sold Out' P3707-PVE Multi-Imager Tested on Oct 18, 2017
Axis faced significant product shortages over the summer. Perhaps the most notorious and significantly sold out model was the Axis P3707-PE 8MP...
Deep Learning Tutorial For Video Surveillance on Oct 17, 2017
Deep learning is a growing buzzword within physical security and video surveillance. But what is 'deep learning'? In this tutorial, we explain...
Geovision GV-EDR2100 Tested Vs Hikvision on Oct 16, 2017
A number of ADI's top selling IP cameras are, at least surprisingly to us, from Geovision. We recently bought and tested the Geovision EDR2100...
Hanwha 20MP Multi-Imager Tested (PNM-9081VQ) on Oct 09, 2017
Hanwhwa has introduced the latest in their multi-imager camera line, the PNM-9081VQ, a Wisenet 5 20MP model with four repositionable 5MP camera...
Last Chance October Camera Course Registration on Oct 05, 2017
This is the last chance to register for the October Camera Course. Register now. Learn video surveillance and get certified. IPVM provides live...
Geovision 4MP Super Low Cost Turret Tested (EBD-4700) on Sep 29, 2017
~$100 cameras, even for 4MP, are now expected by many dealers, as price cuts and ongoing sales have set this expectation. At the same time, many...
SkyBell Trim & Slim Models Tested on Sep 25, 2017
Given continued growth of video doorbells and the central role Skybell plays in smarthome packages like Alarm.com and Honeywell Total Connect, we...
Startup Turing Video Segway-Based Security Robot Profile on Sep 13, 2017
If security robots can not replace guards, perhaps the next best thing is a robot the guard can actually ride.  Turing Video has raised $5...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Panasonic Unified Surveillance Strategy Analyzed on Nov 17, 2017
Panasonic is now a "Unified Surveillance" offering, as their ASIS 2017 booth proclaimed: Looking to make a comeback in the security industry,...
Amazon Cloud Cam Is Poor (Tested) on Nov 17, 2017
Retail behemoth Amazon has entered the surveillance market with the Amazon Cloud Cam, the eyes of its just-announced Amazon Key delivery...
Nest Secure Alarm System Tested on Nov 16, 2017
Google's expansion continues, this time into home security with their Nest subsidiary's move into alarm systems. They paid more than a...
Dahua Forbes 'Next Web Crisis' Vulnerability Dispute on Nov 16, 2017
The buffer overflow vulnerability in Dahua products is not in dispute, in fact we covered it when it was first published. What is in dispute is...
Isonas Cofounders Split, Launch Partner/Competitor on Nov 16, 2017
Breaking up is hard to do, especially when door access security is at stake. But that is exactly what has happened at Isonas. Senior employees...
Hikvision China Criticizes The WSJ on Nov 15, 2017
Hikvision, through the Chinese government's authoritative news service, has criticized the WSJ investigation into Hikvision. In this...
PoE UPS Tested (Energy Reconnect) on Nov 15, 2017
In security, backup power is important, but most often requires UPS systems or extra cabling to devices for low voltage power. Now, some have...
Axis Commits To Long-Term Firmware Support on Nov 15, 2017
With the rise of cyber security awareness, and a general increase in hardware reliability, "software warranties" may prove more valuable than...
Hikvision NVR 4.0 Improvements Tested on Nov 14, 2017
Hikvision has released firmware version 4.0 for select NVRs, touting two years of research and development, and claiming "the new generation GUI...
Vivotek Remote Stack Overflow Vulnerability on Nov 14, 2017
A stack overflow vulnerability in Vivotek cameras has been discovered by bashis, the security researcher who has also found vulnerabilities in...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact