Camera Analytics Tested: Axis vs. Bosch vs. Sony

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Sep 17, 2013

With the move to IP and HD now commonplace, companies are looking for new ways to compete. While analytics has long disappointed, many still hold out hope for it being the next big thing.

Many major camera manufacturers offer analytics built-in or for a minimal additional charge. However, skepticism of their performance is commonplace.

The Test

In this report, we tested 3 camera manufacturers analytics - Axis cross line detection, Bosch's Intelligent Video Analytics and Sony's Video Motion Filter (VMF).

The test focuses on tripwire / perimeter violation analytics as this is most common type used in security to alert against intruders entering into a restricted area.

We tested in 3 different scenes.

To start, we did a simple indoor tripwire at an entrance:

Then we progressed to an outdoor scene of moderate complexity and distance:

Finally, we tried a very long area with vegetation and shadows to maximize the challenge:

**** *** **** ** ** *** ** *** ***********, ********* are ******* *** *** **** ** *******. ***** ********* *** long ************, **** ***** **** *** **** *** ** ***** the**** *** *****.

**** ***** ****** ************* ***** ********* *****-** ** *** * minimal ********** ******. *******, ********** ** ***** *********** ** ***********.

The ****

** **** ******, ** ****** * ****** ************* ********* -**** ***** **** *********,*****'* *********** ***** ************ ****'* ***** ****** ****** (***).

*** **** ******* ** ******** / ********* ********* ********* ** this ** **** ****** **** **** ** ******** ** ***** against ********* ******** **** * ********** ****.

** ****** ** * ********* ******.

** *****, ** *** * ****** ****** ******** ** ** entrance:

**** ** ********** ** ** ******* ***** ** ******** ********** and ********:

*******, ** ***** * **** **** **** **** ********** *** shadows ** ******** *** *********:

[***************]

Key ********

**** *** *** *** ******** **** ***** *****:

******* **************

  • ***** **** ********* ******** **** **** *** ***** ** ********* is ** **** ** ********. **** ******* ***** ** ***** activations *** ** ******* ** ******* ***********. 
  • ***** ***** ******* **** **** ********** *** *******-** ********, *** inside-out, **** *** ****** ****** ****** *** ******. 
  • ***** ****** **** ********** ******* **** ** ****** ******* *** headlights **** ********, *** *** ******. ***** ****** ** ***** to ***** **** ***** ***** ********.
  • *** ** *** ***** ******** **** **** ******* ****** ********* may *** ****** *********** *********** *** ***** **** *********.

 *********** ***********

  • **** ***** ***** **** ********* ******** ******* ** **** ****** in **** ****** ***** ******* ******** **** ****** ***** ***-**** or **** ***-*****. *******, ** ******** **** ***** ***********, ****** by ******* ** ******* ***** ** *********, *** ***** ********* multiple *****.
  • ***** ***-****'* *** ********* ******** ** **** *** ******, *** better **** ****** **** ***-***** ** **** ***** , **** ** ***** or ******** ***********. *******, ** *** ***** ********* ***** *** drastically *******, *** ****** *********** *********.
  • **** ***-*****'* *****-** *** ****** ** *** *****, **** **** to ******** ****** ****** ** **** ***** *****. ******** **** detectable ** ****** *********, ****** ***** ** ***** *** ****. This ** *** ** ***** ** **** ** ****** **** settings ** **** ***-*****'* ********* *** ******** ** ***** *******, which ****** ** ****** ******* ** *** ** *****, *** detected ****** ******* ** ******** ** *** *** *****, ******* detections.

*****

**** ** *** ***** ** ********* ** **** **** **** by ************:

  • **** *****  ***** **** *********:~$** ***, **** ********* ** **-***** ** ********.
  • ***** ***-**** ***: *** ****** ******* **** **** *** ********* ** no ********** ******. *** *** *** ****** ****** *** ** licensed ** ** ********** **** ** ~$***.
  • **** ***-***** ***: **** ***-*****'* *****-** ********* *** ********* ** ** additional **** ** *** ********** *******. ***** ********** ******* ********** shipped **** **** *********.

***************

***** **** ********* *** ***** **** ****** **********, *** **** be ******* *********, ** ******** ********* *** *** ** ******* cameras *** *** ****** ** *****. ***** ****** ********* ******** these ******* *** **** ********* ** ***** ****** ******* **** them ** *** *****.

** **** ******, **** *** ********* ** **** *** *****, Bosch ***-****'* *** *** **** ********, **** ****** ** ***** or ****** ***********. ***** ****** ** ***** ** *** *** light *********** ****** *********, *******.

**** *****  ***** **** ********* *** ******** ** **** ******, *** performed ****** ** **** *** ***** **** ***** ***-****. *******, users ****** ** ***** ** *** ***** *********** *** ** headlights, *******, *** ****** *******, ****** *********.

** ** *** ********* **** ***-*****'* *** ********* ** ****** aside **** **** *** ****** ***** *** ** *** ****** detecting *******.

************* 

** ***** ***********, ** ****** ************* *** **** ** *** three ************* ******.

*****, **** ***** ***** **** *********. ************* ** **** ******, **** including *** **** (* ** * ********) ************* *********, **** ** ***** *****.

****, ***** ***-**** ***. *** ***-**** ******* *** **** ************* *******, ********* multiple *****, **** ****** *******, ****, ********, *** ***** **********. ** **** ********* *********** regarding ******* ******** *** ***** **** ******* *** *****, ****** troubleshooting ****** ******** ** ****** ***** *** *** ******* ****.

*******, **** ***-*****'* *** ***** ******** ********** *** ****** **** and *****, ** **** ** ******** ******** **** ** **** length *** *********. ** ** ***** ***** *** ** *** per ******, *** ******** **** ******. ***** ****** ** ******* when ************* ****** ****, ** ** *** *********** ****** ********* performance.

Outdoor ************

** ****** *** ***** **** ********* ** ******* ****** ******* scenarios.

********/******* ***

*****, ** ***** **** * ******* ***/******** ***** ** ****** up ** ***', ***** ** **** ******** ****:

****** *** ***, ********* ** **', *** ******* *** ********.

****** ***** ******* **** *** ******* *** ** ~***', **** P3354 and ***** ***-**** **** ***** ******* ******** ** *** *******. ** this ******** *** ******, **** ***** ************************** ** **** ** ***** **********, ** *** ******* ********** and ******* *** ****. ***** ***-**** ********* **** ****. *** ***** was ****** ** ******** ****** ******* ** **** *****, ** did *** *******.

*******, **** *** **** ******* *** *** *** ** *** entrance ** *** *** **** *** ****, **** **** ***** *** Bosch ***-**** **** ***** ********, ****** **** *****  ***** ********* ******** ***** as ** *** ** ***'. 

** *****, ** ***** *****, **** ***** *** ***** ***-**** **** *******, while **** ***-***** **** ***. ***** ***-**** ********* ****** **** *** ******* was ****** **** **** *** ******, *** ******, ** ** detected *** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** **********.

** ~***' *** ******, **** **** *****  ********. **** *********** **** slightly ***** *** ** *** ********** ** ********** ****** ****** the ******.

** **** ********, ~***', **** ***** ***** ********. *******, ********** ***** alarms **** ****** ** **** ******* ** *** ******* ****** the ******* ***. ****** *** **** **** **** *** **** partway ******** ****.

**** ***** ********

** **** ****** *** ******* ** *** **** ** *** office, ******* * ******* ******** ****** *** ********** ** *** perimeter, ******* ****** *********** *** ***** **** *********.

 

** ***', **** **** *****  *** ***** ***-**** *********, ***** **** ***-***** *** not (*** *** ** ** *** ****** ******):

 

** ***', ***** ***-**** ********* ** ***** *** ***** ** *** subject, ***** **** *****  *** ****** **:

 

** ***', **** ** *** ******* *********, **** *** ******* simply *** ***** ** ********:

 ** *****, **** *** ******* ******** **, ************* *-* ***, both **** ***** *** ***** ***-**** ********* ******** ** **' *****.

** **', ***** ***-**** ***** *********, ***** **** *****  *** ***. ****** this, ** ******* **** **** ** ****** *** *******.

********* *** *** ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** ***** * lux. ********* ***** ** ***** ***-**** ***** ** **** **', ***** here.

**** ***** *** **** ** ****** *** ******* ******** ** ** 75', *******.

Indoor ************

*** *** *********** ***** ***** ********************* ** ********* ** ******** ******** * *******. ** *** up *** ******* ** ***** ** *** ****** ***** ** simulate ****, ******* *** ******** ** *** ****** ** *** door, **** *** ******* ***** **' ****. ** **** *****, Axis *****  *** **** ***-***** ****** ********, *** ***** ***-**** *** *** *******:

**** ** *** ** *** *** ***** ***-**** ****** *******, **** the ****** **** ***** ******, ******* *** *******'* ***** *** waist. ** *** ***** *****, *** *******'* **** ****** ***** crossed *** ****. ****** ** ******* ** *** *******, ***** NBN-733V triggers ********, ** **** **** ***** . *******, ********* ** *** exact ************ ********, **** **** ******** *** ***** ***** ******** on ****** ****** ******* *** ****. ***** ****** ** ******* to ***** ****.

********** ****

******* *** * ****** *** *** ***** **** *********, ** performed **** ***** ** *** ********** ********** **** ** ***** to *********** **** ****** ****** ********** *** *****.

*****, **** ***** ***** **** *****  ***** **** *********'* *********** ** shadows. ** **** ****, ****** *** **** *** *** ** trigger **** **** *** ******* ***** ****** *** ******, *** motion ** *** ****** ** *** ***** ****** ***** *********** as ** ***** ****** *** **** ** *** ******** *********:

 **** ******** ** ** ***** ****** *** ****, ** ****. 

** **** ****, *** **** *** ***** ** ******* ** the ******* ***** *** ** *** **** ** *** ***** end ** *** ****. *******, *** ***** ******* ****** ** activate ** ** ***** ******** *** ** *** **** ************* to *** *******.

********* *** **** ******** ** ** ***** ** **** ** an ***** ** ****** *** ******. 

*******, ***** *** ****** ****** ***** * ****** ******** **** next ** *** ****, ** *** ******* ******* ** ****** what ***** **** **** ** *** ****.

Test **********

** **** *** ********* ******* *** ******** ******** *** **** test:

  • **** *****, ******** *.**.**
  • ***** ***-****, ******** *.** ***** **
  • **** ***-*****, ******** *.*.*

*** ******* **** ******* ********, **** ********* ************ ** */*** maximum.

 

Comments (19)

** *** *** ***** ******* ***** ********* ****. ****************** *** ******** ****** ** **** **** ******** ********* ******.

** ** **** ** **** **** ***** ********* - **** from '*******' ****** ************ ** **** ** ***** ******** *********** (VideoIQ, *******, ***.). ** ********, ** **** ** **** ***** aspects ** *****'* *** (**** ***** *********) ** * ******** report.

**** *** *** **** ** **** ***** ******-***** ********?

**** ******* ** *********** *********** **** ** *** ** *** common ********** ** ***** *********: ******** *** ***** ******* ******* probability ** ********* *** *** ***** ***** ****.

***** *** ******** ** *****, * ***** *** ***** ******* it ** ****** **** ************ ******** ** *********** *********** **** factors ** **** *********** ** ********* *** *** **** ** false ******.

*** ** ********** *-**** ****** **** * **-****** '**' ****** that ***** * ****** ****** ********* ** **** ** ***** issues. **** ******* ** ***-**** **** ***.

****,********* ** ** ****** *** *** ***** * ********** ***** so *** ********** ******* ********* ************* ** **********. **** *** be ******* **** ***** ******* *** *** *********** **'** *** **** **** ** ******** ******* ** * monitor ***** * ***** *****.

** ******** ******* ** **** ******* **** ** **** ** F1 ***** ** > .** *** **** ** ** ********* useful ** ** ***** ********* ********.

***, ****** *** *** ******** ** ************ ******* *** ********** scenes.

** * ******* ****, **** ****** ************ ******* ** **** are *** ************** *** ***** ** ****** ******. ** * say ****** * ****** * .**, ****** * ****** * .95 *** ****** * ****** * .**, **** **** **** really ****? *********, ** ***** ****** * ** *** **** but ** *** **********? *** ** *** ****? ****, ** we *** ************ *******/******** *** ********** *** ************* ** ****** this ** ********** ***** ** ******* *** ****.

** *** *************, ** **** *** ******* ** *** ***** same **** *** ***** ** **** ***** ******. *** ****, Bosch *** **** ******* *** *** ****** **** **** ***** on * ****** *** ***** ** **** ********. ******* ** that, ** **** **** *** ******* *** *** ******* ** and ******* **** *** ***** **** **********.

****, * ***** ****’* ***** **** ‘**** ********** ******’. *******, IPVM’s ***** *** *** ************ *** ** *** *** ***** do *** **** **** ***** *** *** ***’* ******* *** results ** * *** ****** **** ***** ******* ******. ******** the ***** ** ********* ****** ** **** *****. ********* *** to **** **/*, ** ***** * **** ******* **** ***** with ******** ******* ** ********* ** *** *** ** *** test. * **** **** **** ******** ** ********* **** ****** well *** * ***** **** ** ******* * ******* ***** later ** *** ** ** ************* ******. **** ****** ** looking *** ***** ***** ** ********. *** ******** ** *** IPVM ** ***** ** * ******* ** **** ****** **** are ***** ** ******* ******** *** **** *** ******* ** a *** *********** ***** * **** ***** ** **** **********. The *-**** **** ******* **** *** ***** ********* *** **** 100 **** ***** *** **** *** ******** *** ** ******** many ******** ** ****** **** ***** ***** ***** ****** – here *** **** * *** ** ****: **** ******* *** camera, ***** ******* ** *** ********* ****, ********* *********** **** flicking ** ** *** ** *****, ***** ****, ***** ******** change *** ** ******* *****. **** ******** * ******** ******* and *** ******* ****** * *** ** ********* *** *******, but **** **** ***** * ************** ** ** *** ***** well.

*** *** ** ***** ** **** ** ******* **** ******** video ***** - ***** *** ******* ** * *******? * await **** ******** ** **** **** **** *** ********* *** own ***** ***** / ********.

* ***** ** *** '*****' ** ******'* *********** ** *** it ******** ***** - *** *****, ***, ****** ******, ***. Using ******** ***** ********** *** **** ***** ************* ** ** cameras.

*****'* **** ** ** **** / *** **** ******** '*******' ** *******. **'* *** ********* ** * *** series ** **** ******** ** *********. ** **** ******** ************* ** ***** **** **** ****** **** *** ***** ** to *** *** *** ** ******** *** **.

***** ******, *****, *** *** *'** **** ******* ******* *** for ******.

** ****

****'* *** ******* *** ***** ** ******** ******** ***** ** ... ***** ****** ** **.

****** ** **** **** ** ***** ** ** ******* ************ on ***** ***. **** ****** ** **** *** "****" ****** short ***** *********. **** *** **** "*****" ************ ... **** rain, ****, *******, ****, *******, ******** ******** *** **** ***** positive ***/***** *** ********** *****'* ***** * ***** ******** **'* time ** ** ** ********.

** *** *** **** ****** ******* *** *** ** *** with *** ** ***** ********* **** ** *** ****** *******. (like *******/***/**** **** ******** ******* ** ***** **** *** **** t * ******** *** ****** ****)

** ****** ********* ****, *** ** ****** ** ***** ** night, ** **** ********* ******** *** ** **** *** ***** at ***** ...

"****** ** **** **** ** ***** ** ** ******* ************ on ***** ***."

** (*******) **** ******** **** *********, *** ********** ***** ******* areas ** */* **** ** **** **** * ****** ******. Yes, **'* *** **** ******** **** **** *** *** *** free (** $**), *** *** ********** **** *****.

**** ******* ****, ********** ******* ** ******. ** ******* **** all ** ***** ******* **** ****** ** ********* ******** *******. Rain, ** ** ********** ** *******, **** ****** ***** *******. It ***** ** ***** ** *** * ********** ** ***** manufactures ** *** *******.

****,

* *** *** ****** **** ******. *** **** *** **** Ethan's **** ** ***** *** ******, *** ****.

**** ****** *** **** ** ************ ** *****, ***** *** Derek. ** ** ****** ** *** ******* ** ****** *** the ***** ** ************ **** ** ***** ** **** **** their ***** ***** **** ****** :)

**** ** * **** ************* (**** ** ****). ** **** do **** ************* ***** ** *** **** (****) *** **** winter (****).

****** *** *** ********.

****

****,

***, **** *** ******* *** ** ** ******* ** ** astute ****** *** ****** ** ****. ****** **** ****, ***** upon *** ********** ** *** ******* **********, **** *** ******** have ****** *********: ******* *** *** *****.

***** *** '****' / ********** *********. ** ** ******** *** shootouts, **'** **** '**' *** **** **** *** ***** ******* VideoIQ, ***** **, ***.

******.

*** ***** **** *** * "**** ** ***** *** **** data ****"

**** **** ** ******* *** * ******** (******* ** ** rule) *** ** *** ****** **, *** *** * *** advanced ****** ** ** ***/*** ****** ** *** ********* **** data?

(** *************** ***'* **** *** ...)

*** (***) *** *** ....*****, ** **** ****** ********* :-)

***** *** ************* **. **' ******* ***** ****** *********. **** people **** ** *********.. *** *** ** **'* ******** ****** detection, *** **** **** *** **** ******* ********** ** *****.

**** *** *** ** * ***** ** **** (** ** Fov), *** *** ****** * *****, * *****, ********** *** object ******** *** ****** **** / **** / ******* *** Tree ***** **** *****, **'* ********* **** ******** ** ** mind

**** ***** ** **** ****** ******* ** *** ****** *** we *** ******* ***** ***** ***** ******.

******** ****** ***** *** ** ******* ** *** **** *** end, ***** *******. (*'* ***** ******** ******** **** *** ***** people *** ** **** ** *** ******* ********** ...)

**** -

**, * *** **** *** ****. ***, * ***** **** these ****** ****** **** *** *** **** **** ****** ***** consider "***** *********" ** *** ******* ***** ** *** ********.

** ** ******** *******, * ***** ***** ** "***** **** detection" ** * **** **** ********, ********** ********, ****** ** seems ** ** *** **** ****** *******.

**** *** ****** *** **** **, "***** **** *********" ***** to ** * *** ** *** *** ****** *** *** majority ** ***** ******. ***** ***** ******* ****** **** ***** classify ** ******, **** *** ** ****** *** ****** ** the ***** **** ** *** ***** **** **** **** **** for "*****" **** *******, ****** ****** * ******* ******** ****. That *********** ******** *** ****** ******** ** ******** ** *********, or ********, ** ****** **** ** * **** ***** *****. Then **** **** **** ** ****** ****** ** * ***** direction. *** ******* (***), ** **** *** **** **** * VERY ****** **** ** *** *** ***** *** *** ******* for ********. ** ******** ** *** ***** ******** *** ******* from "******" ** ****** ** ** ******* *** **** (**** lighting, **** ********, ***** **** ** ***, ******* ****** (****** car, ***.) ***** **** ** *** *********) *** **** * high **** **** ***'** ***** ** **** ***** ******.

** ******* ********* * ****** ** ******** (***) **** ****** the ******** ******* ****, **** * ***** ******* ***. **** we **** *** *** ****** ** ******* ******** ** **** area **** *** ****** ** *****. ** ** ***** ****, this ***** ******* **** *** **** ***** *********, ** **** as * ****** ***** **** *** **** **** *** ****** property ** ***** ** *********. *** *** *** ***** ***** the ****** ******** *** ******** ***** *** ** **** *** classified *********** (** ********* *****) *** ***** *** ** ***** 10 ******* "****", **** ****'** ******* **** **** *** ****** area. **** ** *** ****** **** ** ***** ** ***, because **** ******* ** **** ***** ******* ***** ***** **** the **** ****** **** ** *** *****-**** ********* ******.

**, ****, ** *** ******* ***** *** **** ****** !

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Axis Lowest Cost Outdoor IR Camera M2025-LE Tested on Apr 24, 2017
Axis has lagged offering low cost IR cameras while their Asian competitors have made IR standard even in their most entry level cameras. Recently,...
PureTech Video Analytics Examined on Apr 21, 2017
PureTech's analytics were chosen for a US border protection system (see related post), which the company claims no other analytics vendor was able...
US Border RVSS / Video Analytics System Examined on Apr 21, 2017
US Customs and Border Protection has been rolling out a video analytics-based detection system along the US/Mexico border, with detection ranges...
Ring Floodlight Cam Tested on Apr 20, 2017
Ring has released their latest entry, the Floodlight Cam, calling it the "Evolution of Outdoor Security", touting motion activated floodlights,...
Hanwha Lowest Cost WiseNet X Camera (XND-6010) Tested on Apr 13, 2017
IPVM bought and tested the lowest-cost WiseNet X model, the indoor 2MP fixed focal XND-6010 dome, continuing our testing of Hanwha's new WiseNet X...
Pelco Surevision 3 Tested on Apr 12, 2017
Pelco has released generation 3 of its Surevision cameras, claiming improved performance in both super low light and WDR performance. We bought...
Best and Worst - ISC West 2017 Show Report on Apr 10, 2017
IPVM went to Las Vegas, examining what vendors are showcasing and what is new. Attendance was up, according to the show, and was certainly well...
Deep Science - Active Threat Cloud Monitoring Startup on Apr 03, 2017
Deep learning for $2 a day for a system that automatically detects guns and masks, alerting the police to robberies and threats? A US startup is...
Hanwha Wisenet X Tested on Mar 27, 2017
Hanwha has released their latest generation, the Wisenet X series, powered by their new Wisenet 5 processor. This new series claims improvements...
ObjectVideo Acquired by Alarm.com on Mar 14, 2017
Once potentially the most recognized name in video analytics, ObjectVideo has effectively been sold for pieces. Alarm.com has now acquired what...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Instant Cloud For Hikvision - Manything on Apr 28, 2017
One ISC West exhibitor had a very specific and clear pitch - cloud for Hikvision: In this note, we examine their offering, key differentiators,...
Milestone GPU Enhanced VMD Tested on Apr 28, 2017
In their 2017 XProtect release, Milestone announced support for hardware accelerated video motion detection, touting a 2X increase in server...
Burglar Alarm Zoning Guide on Apr 28, 2017
The function of an alarm panel is to gather information from sensors and respond to this information by triggering actions. While it is possible to...
Avigilon Discontinuing Rialto Analytics Line on Apr 27, 2017
Avigilon is informing dealers/partners that the legacy VideoIQ Rialto products have been discontinued, recommending the newer ACC ES Analytics...
A Marketing Home Run For Knightscope - Man Attacks Robot on Apr 27, 2017
We criticize Knightscope regularly - their lack of revenue, their trying to fool mom 'n pop investors, their associating themselves with a clueless...
The World's First Fashion IP Camera From Amazon on Apr 27, 2017
Some analytics cameras can tell you if a person is jumping a fence, or loitering in a secure area, but none of them can tell you if the person...
Last Day - IP Networking Course May 2017 on Apr 26, 2017
Today is the last day to register for the May IP Networking Course. This is the only networking course designed specifically for video...
Hikvision EZVIZ Amazon Scam Revealed on Apr 26, 2017
Hikvision is violating US Federal Trade Commission guidelines and Amazon rules with a "Honest" Review Program scheme that provides gift cards to...
Anixter CEO Admits Price Deflation and Non-Exclusive Integrator Sales on Apr 26, 2017
Anixter's CEO has admitted to (1) price deflation impacting IP camera sales and (2) not always being 'exclusive' with security integrators. In...
Xandem Next Gen Intrusion Tested on Apr 26, 2017
Xandem's "full coverage motion tracking technology" is unlike any intrusion technology we have seen. We bought their new system and tested it...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact