Camera Analytics Tested: Axis vs. Bosch vs. Sony

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Sep 17, 2013

With the move to IP and HD now commonplace, companies are looking for new ways to compete. While analytics has long disappointed, many still hold out hope for it being the next big thing.

Many major camera manufacturers offer analytics built-in or for a minimal additional charge. However, skepticism of their performance is commonplace.

The Test

In this report, we tested 3 camera manufacturers analytics - Axis cross line detection, Bosch's Intelligent Video Analytics and Sony's Video Motion Filter (VMF).

The test focuses on tripwire / perimeter violation analytics as this is most common type used in security to alert against intruders entering into a restricted area.

We tested in 3 different scenes.

To start, we did a simple indoor tripwire at an entrance:

Then we progressed to an outdoor scene of moderate complexity and distance:

Finally, we tried a very long area with vegetation and shadows to maximize the challenge:

**** *** **** ** ** *** ** *** ***********, ********* are ******* *** *** **** ** *******. ***** ********* *** long ************, **** ***** **** *** **** *** ** ***** the**** *** *****.

**** ***** ****** ************* ***** ********* *****-** ** *** * minimal ********** ******. *******, ********** ** ***** *********** ** ***********.

The ****

** **** ******, ** ****** * ****** ************* ********* -**** ***** **** *********,*****'* *********** ***** ************ ****'* ***** ****** ****** (***).

*** **** ******* ** ******** / ********* ********* ********* ** this ** **** ****** **** **** ** ******** ** ***** against ********* ******** **** * ********** ****.

** ****** ** * ********* ******.

** *****, ** *** * ****** ****** ******** ** ** entrance:

**** ** ********** ** ** ******* ***** ** ******** ********** and ********:

*******, ** ***** * **** **** **** **** ********** *** shadows ** ******** *** *********:

[***************]

Key ********

**** *** *** *** ******** **** ***** *****:

******* **************

  • ***** **** ********* ******** **** **** *** ***** ** ********* is ** **** ** ********. **** ******* ***** ** ***** activations *** ** ******* ** ******* ***********. 
  • ***** ***** ******* **** **** ********** *** *******-** ********, *** inside-out, **** *** ****** ****** ****** *** ******. 
  • ***** ****** **** ********** ******* **** ** ****** ******* *** headlights **** ********, *** *** ******. ***** ****** ** ***** to ***** **** ***** ***** ********.
  • *** ** *** ***** ******** **** **** ******* ****** ********* may *** ****** *********** *********** *** ***** **** *********.

 *********** ***********

  • **** ***** ***** **** ********* ******** ******* ** **** ****** in **** ****** ***** ******* ******** **** ****** ***** ***-**** or **** ***-*****. *******, ** ******** **** ***** ***********, ****** by ******* ** ******* ***** ** *********, *** ***** ********* multiple *****.
  • ***** ***-****'* *** ********* ******** ** **** *** ******, *** better **** ****** **** ***-***** ** **** ***** , **** ** ***** or ******** ***********. *******, ** *** ***** ********* ***** *** drastically *******, *** ****** *********** *********.
  • **** ***-*****'* *****-** *** ****** ** *** *****, **** **** to ******** ****** ****** ** **** ***** *****. ******** **** detectable ** ****** *********, ****** ***** ** ***** *** ****. This ** *** ** ***** ** **** ** ****** **** settings ** **** ***-*****'* ********* *** ******** ** ***** *******, which ****** ** ****** ******* ** *** ** *****, *** detected ****** ******* ** ******** ** *** *** *****, ******* detections.

*****

**** ** *** ***** ** ********* ** **** **** **** by ************:

  • **** *****  ***** **** *********:~$** ***, **** ********* ** **-***** ** ********.
  • ***** ***-**** ***: *** ****** ******* **** **** *** ********* ** no ********** ******. *** *** *** ****** ****** *** ** licensed ** ** ********** **** ** ~$***.
  • **** ***-***** ***: **** ***-*****'* *****-** ********* *** ********* ** ** additional **** ** *** ********** *******. ***** ********** ******* ********** shipped **** **** *********.

***************

***** **** ********* *** ***** **** ****** **********, *** **** be ******* *********, ** ******** ********* *** *** ** ******* cameras *** *** ****** ** *****. ***** ****** ********* ******** these ******* *** **** ********* ** ***** ****** ******* **** them ** *** *****.

** **** ******, **** *** ********* ** **** *** *****, Bosch ***-****'* *** *** **** ********, **** ****** ** ***** or ****** ***********. ***** ****** ** ***** ** *** *** light *********** ****** *********, *******.

**** *****  ***** **** ********* *** ******** ** **** ******, *** performed ****** ** **** *** ***** **** ***** ***-****. *******, users ****** ** ***** ** *** ***** *********** *** ** headlights, *******, *** ****** *******, ****** *********.

** ** *** ********* **** ***-*****'* *** ********* ** ****** aside **** **** *** ****** ***** *** ** *** ****** detecting *******.

************* 

** ***** ***********, ** ****** ************* *** **** ** *** three ************* ******.

*****, **** ***** ***** **** *********. ************* ** **** ******, **** including *** **** (* ** * ********) ************* *********, **** ** ***** *****.

****, ***** ***-**** ***. *** ***-**** ******* *** **** ************* *******, ********* multiple *****, **** ****** *******, ****, ********, *** ***** **********. ** **** ********* *********** regarding ******* ******** *** ***** **** ******* *** *****, ****** troubleshooting ****** ******** ** ****** ***** *** *** ******* ****.

*******, **** ***-*****'* *** ***** ******** ********** *** ****** **** and *****, ** **** ** ******** ******** **** ** **** length *** *********. ** ** ***** ***** *** ** *** per ******, *** ******** **** ******. ***** ****** ** ******* when ************* ****** ****, ** ** *** *********** ****** ********* performance.

Outdoor ************

** ****** *** ***** **** ********* ** ******* ****** ******* scenarios.

********/******* ***

*****, ** ***** **** * ******* ***/******** ***** ** ****** up ** ***', ***** ** **** ******** ****:

****** *** ***, ********* ** **', *** ******* *** ********.

****** ***** ******* **** *** ******* *** ** ~***', **** P3354 and ***** ***-**** **** ***** ******* ******** ** *** *******. ** this ******** *** ******, **** ***** ************************** ** **** ** ***** **********, ** *** ******* ********** and ******* *** ****. ***** ***-**** ********* **** ****. *** ***** was ****** ** ******** ****** ******* ** **** *****, ** did *** *******.

*******, **** *** **** ******* *** *** *** ** *** entrance ** *** *** **** *** ****, **** **** ***** *** Bosch ***-**** **** ***** ********, ****** **** *****  ***** ********* ******** ***** as ** *** ** ***'. 

** *****, ** ***** *****, **** ***** *** ***** ***-**** **** *******, while **** ***-***** **** ***. ***** ***-**** ********* ****** **** *** ******* was ****** **** **** *** ******, *** ******, ** ** detected *** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** **********.

** ~***' *** ******, **** **** *****  ********. **** *********** **** slightly ***** *** ** *** ********** ** ********** ****** ****** the ******.

** **** ********, ~***', **** ***** ***** ********. *******, ********** ***** alarms **** ****** ** **** ******* ** *** ******* ****** the ******* ***. ****** *** **** **** **** *** **** partway ******** ****.

**** ***** ********

** **** ****** *** ******* ** *** **** ** *** office, ******* * ******* ******** ****** *** ********** ** *** perimeter, ******* ****** *********** *** ***** **** *********.

 

** ***', **** **** *****  *** ***** ***-**** *********, ***** **** ***-***** *** not (*** *** ** ** *** ****** ******):

 

** ***', ***** ***-**** ********* ** ***** *** ***** ** *** subject, ***** **** *****  *** ****** **:

 

** ***', **** ** *** ******* *********, **** *** ******* simply *** ***** ** ********:

 ** *****, **** *** ******* ******** **, ************* *-* ***, both **** ***** *** ***** ***-**** ********* ******** ** **' *****.

** **', ***** ***-**** ***** *********, ***** **** *****  *** ***. ****** this, ** ******* **** **** ** ****** *** *******.

********* *** *** ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** ***** * lux. ********* ***** ** ***** ***-**** ***** ** **** **', ***** here.

**** ***** *** **** ** ****** *** ******* ******** ** ** 75', *******.

Indoor ************

*** *** *********** ***** ***** ********************* ** ********* ** ******** ******** * *******. ** *** up *** ******* ** ***** ** *** ****** ***** ** simulate ****, ******* *** ******** ** *** ****** ** *** door, **** *** ******* ***** **' ****. ** **** *****, Axis *****  *** **** ***-***** ****** ********, *** ***** ***-**** *** *** *******:

**** ** *** ** *** *** ***** ***-**** ****** *******, **** the ****** **** ***** ******, ******* *** *******'* ***** *** waist. ** *** ***** *****, *** *******'* **** ****** ***** crossed *** ****. ****** ** ******* ** *** *******, ***** NBN-733V triggers ********, ** **** **** ***** . *******, ********* ** *** exact ************ ********, **** **** ******** *** ***** ***** ******** on ****** ****** ******* *** ****. ***** ****** ** ******* to ***** ****.

********** ****

******* *** * ****** *** *** ***** **** *********, ** performed **** ***** ** *** ********** ********** **** ** ***** to *********** **** ****** ****** ********** *** *****.

*****, **** ***** ***** **** *****  ***** **** *********'* *********** ** shadows. ** **** ****, ****** *** **** *** *** ** trigger **** **** *** ******* ***** ****** *** ******, *** motion ** *** ****** ** *** ***** ****** ***** *********** as ** ***** ****** *** **** ** *** ******** *********:

 **** ******** ** ** ***** ****** *** ****, ** ****. 

** **** ****, *** **** *** ***** ** ******* ** the ******* ***** *** ** *** **** ** *** ***** end ** *** ****. *******, *** ***** ******* ****** ** activate ** ** ***** ******** *** ** *** **** ************* to *** *******.

********* *** **** ******** ** ** ***** ** **** ** an ***** ** ****** *** ******. 

*******, ***** *** ****** ****** ***** * ****** ******** **** next ** *** ****, ** *** ******* ******* ** ****** what ***** **** **** ** *** ****.

Test **********

** **** *** ********* ******* *** ******** ******** *** **** test:

  • **** *****, ******** *.**.**
  • ***** ***-****, ******** *.** ***** **
  • **** ***-*****, ******** *.*.*

*** ******* **** ******* ********, **** ********* ************ ** */*** maximum.

 

Comments (19)

** *** *** ***** ******* ***** ********* ****. ****************** *** ******** ****** ** **** **** ******** ********* ******.

** ** **** ** **** **** ***** ********* - **** from '*******' ****** ************ ** **** ** ***** ******** *********** (VideoIQ, *******, ***.). ** ********, ** **** ** **** ***** aspects ** *****'* *** (**** ***** *********) ** * ******** report.

**** *** *** **** ** **** ***** ******-***** ********?

**** ******* ** *********** *********** **** ** *** ** *** common ********** ** ***** *********: ******** *** ***** ******* ******* probability ** ********* *** *** ***** ***** ****.

***** *** ******** ** *****, * ***** *** ***** ******* it ** ****** **** ************ ******** ** *********** *********** **** factors ** **** *********** ** ********* *** *** **** ** false ******.

*** ** ********** *-**** ****** **** * **-****** '**' ****** that ***** * ****** ****** ********* ** **** ** ***** issues. **** ******* ** ***-**** **** ***.

****,********* ** ** ****** *** *** ***** * ********** ***** so *** ********** ******* ********* ************* ** **********. **** *** be ******* **** ***** ******* *** *** *********** **'** *** **** **** ** ******** ******* ** * monitor ***** * ***** *****.

** ******** ******* ** **** ******* **** ** **** ** F1 ***** ** > .** *** **** ** ** ********* useful ** ** ***** ********* ********.

***, ****** *** *** ******** ** ************ ******* *** ********** scenes.

** * ******* ****, **** ****** ************ ******* ** **** are *** ************** *** ***** ** ****** ******. ** * say ****** * ****** * .**, ****** * ****** * .95 *** ****** * ****** * .**, **** **** **** really ****? *********, ** ***** ****** * ** *** **** but ** *** **********? *** ** *** ****? ****, ** we *** ************ *******/******** *** ********** *** ************* ** ****** this ** ********** ***** ** ******* *** ****.

** *** *************, ** **** *** ******* ** *** ***** same **** *** ***** ** **** ***** ******. *** ****, Bosch *** **** ******* *** *** ****** **** **** ***** on * ****** *** ***** ** **** ********. ******* ** that, ** **** **** *** ******* *** *** ******* ** and ******* **** *** ***** **** **********.

****, * ***** ****’* ***** **** ‘**** ********** ******’. *******, IPVM’s ***** *** *** ************ *** ** *** *** ***** do *** **** **** ***** *** *** ***’* ******* *** results ** * *** ****** **** ***** ******* ******. ******** the ***** ** ********* ****** ** **** *****. ********* *** to **** **/*, ** ***** * **** ******* **** ***** with ******** ******* ** ********* ** *** *** ** *** test. * **** **** **** ******** ** ********* **** ****** well *** * ***** **** ** ******* * ******* ***** later ** *** ** ** ************* ******. **** ****** ** looking *** ***** ***** ** ********. *** ******** ** *** IPVM ** ***** ** * ******* ** **** ****** **** are ***** ** ******* ******** *** **** *** ******* ** a *** *********** ***** * **** ***** ** **** **********. The *-**** **** ******* **** *** ***** ********* *** **** 100 **** ***** *** **** *** ******** *** ** ******** many ******** ** ****** **** ***** ***** ***** ****** – here *** **** * *** ** ****: **** ******* *** camera, ***** ******* ** *** ********* ****, ********* *********** **** flicking ** ** *** ** *****, ***** ****, ***** ******** change *** ** ******* *****. **** ******** * ******** ******* and *** ******* ****** * *** ** ********* *** *******, but **** **** ***** * ************** ** ** *** ***** well.

*** *** ** ***** ** **** ** ******* **** ******** video ***** - ***** *** ******* ** * *******? * await **** ******** ** **** **** **** *** ********* *** own ***** ***** / ********.

* ***** ** *** '*****' ** ******'* *********** ** *** it ******** ***** - *** *****, ***, ****** ******, ***. Using ******** ***** ********** *** **** ***** ************* ** ** cameras.

*****'* **** ** ** **** / *** **** ******** '*******' ** *******. **'* *** ********* ** * *** series ** **** ******** ** *********. ** **** ******** ************* ** ***** **** **** ****** **** *** ***** ** to *** *** *** ** ******** *** **.

***** ******, *****, *** *** *'** **** ******* ******* *** for ******.

** ****

****'* *** ******* *** ***** ** ******** ******** ***** ** ... ***** ****** ** **.

****** ** **** **** ** ***** ** ** ******* ************ on ***** ***. **** ****** ** **** *** "****" ****** short ***** *********. **** *** **** "*****" ************ ... **** rain, ****, *******, ****, *******, ******** ******** *** **** ***** positive ***/***** *** ********** *****'* ***** * ***** ******** **'* time ** ** ** ********.

** *** *** **** ****** ******* *** *** ** *** with *** ** ***** ********* **** ** *** ****** *******. (like *******/***/**** **** ******** ******* ** ***** **** *** **** t * ******** *** ****** ****)

** ****** ********* ****, *** ** ****** ** ***** ** night, ** **** ********* ******** *** ** **** *** ***** at ***** ...

"****** ** **** **** ** ***** ** ** ******* ************ on ***** ***."

** (*******) **** ******** **** *********, *** ********** ***** ******* areas ** */* **** ** **** **** * ****** ******. Yes, **'* *** **** ******** **** **** *** *** *** free (** $**), *** *** ********** **** *****.

**** ******* ****, ********** ******* ** ******. ** ******* **** all ** ***** ******* **** ****** ** ********* ******** *******. Rain, ** ** ********** ** *******, **** ****** ***** *******. It ***** ** ***** ** *** * ********** ** ***** manufactures ** *** *******.

****,

* *** *** ****** **** ******. *** **** *** **** Ethan's **** ** ***** *** ******, *** ****.

**** ****** *** **** ** ************ ** *****, ***** *** Derek. ** ** ****** ** *** ******* ** ****** *** the ***** ** ************ **** ** ***** ** **** **** their ***** ***** **** ****** :)

**** ** * **** ************* (**** ** ****). ** **** do **** ************* ***** ** *** **** (****) *** **** winter (****).

****** *** *** ********.

****

****,

***, **** *** ******* *** ** ** ******* ** ** astute ****** *** ****** ** ****. ****** **** ****, ***** upon *** ********** ** *** ******* **********, **** *** ******** have ****** *********: ******* *** *** *****.

***** *** '****' / ********** *********. ** ** ******** *** shootouts, **'** **** '**' *** **** **** *** ***** ******* VideoIQ, ***** **, ***.

******.

*** ***** **** *** * "**** ** ***** *** **** data ****"

**** **** ** ******* *** * ******** (******* ** ** rule) *** ** *** ****** **, *** *** * *** advanced ****** ** ** ***/*** ****** ** *** ********* **** data?

(** *************** ***'* **** *** ...)

*** (***) *** *** ....*****, ** **** ****** ********* :-)

***** *** ************* **. **' ******* ***** ****** *********. **** people **** ** *********.. *** *** ** **'* ******** ****** detection, *** **** **** *** **** ******* ********** ** *****.

**** *** *** ** * ***** ** **** (** ** Fov), *** *** ****** * *****, * *****, ********** *** object ******** *** ****** **** / **** / ******* *** Tree ***** **** *****, **'* ********* **** ******** ** ** mind

**** ***** ** **** ****** ******* ** *** ****** *** we *** ******* ***** ***** ***** ******.

******** ****** ***** *** ** ******* ** *** **** *** end, ***** *******. (*'* ***** ******** ******** **** *** ***** people *** ** **** ** *** ******* ********** ...)

**** -

**, * *** **** *** ****. ***, * ***** **** these ****** ****** **** *** *** **** **** ****** ***** consider "***** *********" ** *** ******* ***** ** *** ********.

** ** ******** *******, * ***** ***** ** "***** **** detection" ** * **** **** ********, ********** ********, ****** ** seems ** ** *** **** ****** *******.

**** *** ****** *** **** **, "***** **** *********" ***** to ** * *** ** *** *** ****** *** *** majority ** ***** ******. ***** ***** ******* ****** **** ***** classify ** ******, **** *** ** ****** *** ****** ** the ***** **** ** *** ***** **** **** **** **** for "*****" **** *******, ****** ****** * ******* ******** ****. That *********** ******** *** ****** ******** ** ******** ** *********, or ********, ** ****** **** ** * **** ***** *****. Then **** **** **** ** ****** ****** ** * ***** direction. *** ******* (***), ** **** *** **** **** * VERY ****** **** ** *** *** ***** *** *** ******* for ********. ** ******** ** *** ***** ******** *** ******* from "******" ** ****** ** ** ******* *** **** (**** lighting, **** ********, ***** **** ** ***, ******* ****** (****** car, ***.) ***** **** ** *** *********) *** **** * high **** **** ***'** ***** ** **** ***** ******.

** ******* ********* * ****** ** ******** (***) **** ****** the ******** ******* ****, **** * ***** ******* ***. **** we **** *** *** ****** ** ******* ******** ** **** area **** *** ****** ** *****. ** ** ***** ****, this ***** ******* **** *** **** ***** *********, ** **** as * ****** ***** **** *** **** **** *** ****** property ** ***** ** *********. *** *** *** ***** ***** the ****** ******** *** ******** ***** *** ** **** *** classified *********** (** ********* *****) *** ***** *** ** ***** 10 ******* "****", **** ****'** ******* **** **** *** ****** area. **** ** *** ****** **** ** ***** ** ***, because **** ******* ** **** ***** ******* ***** ***** **** the **** ****** **** ** *** *****-**** ********* ******.

**, ****, ** *** ******* ***** *** **** ****** !

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Camera Course - Last Day - Save $50 on Jan 18, 2018
Today is the last day to save $50 - register now. Learn video surveillance and get certified. Save $50 on the course, ending this Thursday the...
Hanwha ExtraLux Camera Tested on Jan 11, 2018
Hanwha has released the latest in their Wisenet X line, the "extraLUX" series, claiming to "capture crystal clear, true-color images in low-light...
Canon Launches World's Most Expensive IP Camera (ME20F-SHN) on Jan 09, 2018
Canon has launched the ME20F-SHN , likely the world's most expensive single imager, non-thermal, IP camera at ~$20,000. And Canon subsidiary...
Hikvision IR Bullet Camera Shootout on Jan 08, 2018
Hikvision's widely used Value Plus line claims 30m/~98' IR illumination range, on multiple lens options ranging from wide angle (100°+) to...
Directory Of 92 Video Analytics Suppliers on Jan 04, 2018
This directory provides a list of video analytics providers to help you see and research what options are available. Video...
Resolution Tutorial on Dec 28, 2017
Understanding video surveillance resolution can be surprisingly difficult and complex. While the word 'resolution' seems self-explanatory, its use...
Repositionable Multi-Imager Camera Guide on Dec 22, 2017
Multi-imager usage has been growing strongly over the past few years. Now, a new segment of multi-imagers has taken off, with many manufacturers...
2018 Top Sales Interest For Integrators on Dec 20, 2017
130+ integrators answered: This is a key question, especially for manufacturers, as it impacts what areas to focus more on and what...
Failed Retail Video Analytics Startup Analyzed on Dec 19, 2017
Most manufacturers in this industry try hard to cover up failure. But an industry startup backed by Silicon Valley's most prestigious accelerator...
Axis Network Radar Tested (D2050-VE) on Dec 19, 2017
Axis is expanding into a new market - radar. The company has released their D2050-VE Network Radar Detector, claiming to minimize false alarms, in...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Chinese Government Hikvision Surveillance System On US Government Network on Jan 18, 2018
Hikvision, the Chinese government-owned manufacturer, has publicly claimed that their products are running on a US government network. Moreover,...
Camera Course - Last Day - Save $50 on Jan 18, 2018
Today is the last day to save $50 - register now. Learn video surveillance and get certified. Save $50 on the course, ending this Thursday the...
VSaaS Usage Statistics 2018 on Jan 18, 2018
VSaaS has been a 'next big thing' for more than a decade. The prospect of managing, storing and streaming video from the cloud rather than...
Vivint Streety Video Strengthens Door Knocking on Jan 17, 2018
Vivint is famous (or infamous depending on your perspective) for mastering large scale door to door selling. The company has skyrocketed from a...
Axis: "It’s A Question Of Trust And Who You Want To Be Associated With" on Jan 17, 2018
Who do you trust? Who do you want to be associated with? Axis is raising hard questions to start 2018. In this note, we examine these questions,...
Software House Vulnerability Allows Inside Attacker To Open Doors on Jan 17, 2018
A vulnerability in Software House IP-ACM modules allows an attacker to potentially unlock doors, or perform other actions, on affected systems....
'Defiant' Hikvision 'Strikes Back' At WSJ And US on Jan 16, 2018
The fight is on. Hikvision and their owner, the Chinese government, 'strikes back' against the Wall Street Journal and US politicians raising...
The 2018 Surveillance Industry Guide on Jan 16, 2018
The 300 page, 2018 Video Surveillance Industry Guide, covering the key events and the future of the video surveillance market, is now available,...
Edward Snowden Haven App Tested on Jan 16, 2018
Global coverage followed the December 2017 announcement that Edward Snowden was leading a team developing Haven, an app "that leverages on-device...
This High Schooler Is Excited About His Future Security Career on Jan 15, 2018
A common lament is that smart, young people have little interest in surveillance systems. In fact, discussions like Should Talented Young People...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact