Axis, Sony, Cisco, 11 More Sued

By: Carlton Purvis, Published on Mar 13, 2013

Patent lawsuits continue to gain momentum throughout the world and in the surveillance industry. Though most of its suits were dismissed last fall, Puerto Rico-based Canatelo [link no longer available], LCC is back in court again suing more than a dozen surveillance manufacturers for patent infringement. Here's a look at who Canatelo really is, what their new suits are about and an update on the ones still in court. 

New Suits 

In early February, Canatelo filed complaints against 14 companies, including Axis Communications, Toshiba, Canon, Cisco Systems, TrendNet and Sony claiming the companies ripped off its motion detection capabilities. For example, see the complaint against Axis. All complaints make similar claims. 

Canatelo’s complaints say the companies violate a patent on “detecting motion in a video signal; compressing a portion of the video signal that includes the detected motion; and transmitting the compressed portion of the video signal that includes the detected motion as part of an e-mail.”

The Patents

The first patent in question, filed in August 1999 by inventors Luis G. Ramirez Diaz, Pedro Cruz-Burgos and Dan Rodriguez, was for a computer-based video security system designed to capture motion detection and send alerts via email, beeper or phone. It included a feature that would allow users to monitor camera remotely. The patent was issued in November 2002 (U.S. Patent number 6,476,858).

In October 2002 the inventors filed a second patent for computer technology that could read electronic video signals for indications of motion and transmit those alerts through a network connection. That patent was approved in December 2007 (U.S. Patent number 7,310,111)

Essentially, if a surveillance product detects motion and then compresses video, it violates Canatelo's patent, we noted in a post last June

Who Is Canatelo

Canatelo, LLC, formerly called I Care Medical Direct, LLC, is a “biomedical products distributor” based just outside of San Juan, according to documents filed with the Puerto Rico State Department. Here's an excerpt:

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

The address we found in state documents is a unit in a hi-rise condo on the beach -- Condominio Plaza Del Condado -- however, a receptionist at Del Condado said that unit didn't exist. 

"We have a 1401, 1402, 1403 on the fourteenth floor, but no unit 14," she said. 

Repeated messages left for the company through its lawyers have not been returned. 

Despite there being little information about the company available online, (the domain name Canatelo.com was created two months prior to the first litigation with registration details hidden) Canatelo has been very active in the courts.  

Update on Old Suits 

In June, Canatelo sued Avigilon, Hikvision, Vivotek, UTC/Interlogix, and Nuvico saying the companies infringed on a patent on motion detection capability. It sued Office Max for carrying the “infringing” cameras.

All but two of the cases were dismissed "with prejudice" by the fall. This type of dismissal usually means a plaintiff failed to support its claims with evidence and that a plaintiff can't re-file the case. In at least one of the cases, an undisclosed settlement was involved in the dismissal. 

 “Our client settled the case. The lawsuit was dismissed as a result of the settlement agreement,” was the word from Vivotek counsel, who would not disclose the details of the agreement.  

Open Cases - Avigilon, Nuvico

The cases that remain open are Canatelo’s case against Avigilon (which it amended last month at the same time it filed complaint against the 14 other companies) and its case against Nuvico (which has been held up by motions to file/translate parts of the case in Spanish). 

Avigilon declined to comment on pending litigation, but in a motion to dismiss the case last September, Avigilon said it did not know about the patents until Canatelo filed a complaint so it "could not have possessed an intent to cause someone else to infringe the patents." 

IPVM Analysis

We suspect Canatelo will have a hard time winning. Their broad, generally applicable, patent was filed in October 2002, fairly late compared to the development of early IP cameras. Moreover, unless Canatelo has far deeper pockets then we can find so far, unlike ObjectVideo, they may not be able to fund the multi-million dollar legal campaign necessary in such a contest.

Comments (2) : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports on Lawsuits

Crisis At China's Largest VMS Provider, Netposa, Now State-Controlled on Oct 07, 2019
NetPosa, which bills itself as the PRC's largest VMS provider, is in a crisis. The firm is pursuing huge unpaid bills from clients, and its...
Cisco Settles False Claims Act Suit For Video Surveillance Vulnerabilities on Aug 01, 2019
Cisco entered the video surveillance market in 2007 and suffered for many years through a variety of its own errors and arrogance. The conclusion...
Nortek and SDS Fight Over Failed Settlement on Jun 05, 2019
Distributor SDS said they reached a deal with Nortek but Nortek says no settlement was reached and the suit is still on. In this post, based on...
ADT's Top Dealer "The Defenders" Sued 20+ Times on May 07, 2019
ADT's largest authorized dealer, The Defenders, has been sued more than 20 times since 2012, IPVM has verified through analyzing legal...
US City Sued For Hiding Surveillance Camera Map on Mar 08, 2019
UPDATE: The judgment is now in and updated information is at the bottom of the post. Should maps of public surveillance camera locations be kept...
Mysterious Patent Troll 'Secure Cam' Targets Industry, Sues Hanwha, Hikvison, JCI, Panasonic, More on Oct 11, 2018
A company named "Secure Cam," who is actively hiding their ownership, has acquired a slew of video patents and is systematically suing video...
Wave Retorts: SDS 'Desperate' And 'Defeated' on Aug 01, 2018
Distributor SDS has sued Nortek and distributor Wave Electronics alleging bribery, conspiracy, antitrust violations and violations of state laws...
UK VSaaS Startup Ocucon on Jul 03, 2018
Decreasing exposure to fraudulent slip-and-fall insurance claims and lawsuits is one of the oldest selling points of video surveillance for retail....
Chinese Government Attacks Western Reports on Jan 03, 2018
The Chinese government is angry at the BBC and WSJ's reporting on Chinese video surveillance (see BBC Features Dahua and WSJ Investigates China's...
Avigilon / Canon New Lawsuits, No Settlement on Oct 11, 2017
In July, Canon sued Avigilon, a notably rare move amongst major players in the industry, including Canon's subsidiaries Axis and Milestone. At...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Hikvision Global News Reports Directory on Oct 17, 2019
Hikvision has received the most global news reporting of any video surveillance company, ever, ranging from the WSJ, the Financial Times, Reuters,...
Camera Calculator V3.1 Release Improves User Experience on Oct 17, 2019
IPVM has released a new version of our Camera Calculator, V3.1, with significant user experience improvements, a new development plan, and an...
Securing Access Control Installations Tutorial on Oct 17, 2019
The physical security of access control components is critical to ensuring that a facility is truly secure. Otherwise, the entire system can be...
Access Control Course Fall 2019 - Last Chance on Oct 17, 2019
Register Now - Fall 2019 Access Control Course. Thursday, October 17th is the last day to register. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access...
US DoD Comments on Huawei, Hikvision, Dahua Cyber Security Concerns on Oct 16, 2019
A senior DoD official said the US is "concerned" with the cybersecurity of Hikvision, Dahua, and Huawei due to "CCP" (China Communist Party)...
Pelco Sarix Pro3 Camera Tested on Oct 16, 2019
Pelco has released their Sarix Professional Series 3 cameras, claiming "more security detail in challenging scenes with excellent low light and...
IPVM Camera Calculator User Manual / Guide on Oct 16, 2019
Learn how to use the IPVM Camera Calculator. The guide below includes instructions, images, gifs, and videos demonstrating and explaining the...
Altronix Claims Tango 'Eliminates Electricians' on Oct 15, 2019
Power supply provider Altronix claims its new Tango power supply 'eliminates the need for an electrician, dedicated conduit and wire runs'. In...
Pelco CEO Out, New CEO Found on Oct 15, 2019
Just 2 months after Pelco was sold, Pelco's CEO is out, with Pelco bringing in an outside President and searching for a new CEO from the industry,...