Mobotix's 2011 Challenges and Future Plans Examined

Author: John Honovich, Published on Mar 20, 2011

While Mobotix's growth continued and accelerated at the end of 2010, we believe the company faces new challenges as competitors catch up to a number of key Mobotix differentiators and Mobotix's product development appears to slow. In this note, we examine the key factors, risks and competitive positioning. Included is extensive direct feedback from Mobotix regarding: H.264 support, multi-megapixel offerings and new product development.

Over the last few years, a number of key differentiators has made Mobotix stand out:

  • On-board storage / recording or as Mobotix calls it a 'Decentralized' Architecture
  • Free VMS software / no licenses for recording
  • MxPEG where most megapixel vendors only had the less efficient MJPEG
  • 3MP cameras when most vendors where stuck on SD
  • Hemispheric / 360 immersive cameras (e.g., the Q24)

However, recently a number of those advantages have been eroded as competitors expanded their offerings:

  • HD resolution cameras are now commonplace and numerous vendors now have equal or higher resolution cameras than Mobotix (e.g., 5MP cameras)
  • Almost all new MP cameas (outside of Mobotix) now support H.264 - widely held to be superior to MxPEG (and even if one disagrees that it is superior, it is clearly far better than MJPEG, closing the gap, if not turning this into a Mobotix disadvantage)
  • Free or very low cost VMS offerings have rapidly expanded, eroding the price savings of using an all Mobotix solution
  • VMS support for on-board storage is growing with the best example coming from Genetec's recent trickling feature

We find 3 key areas where Mobotix's advantages have remained or gained: (1) outdoor deployments (high resolution, low light, environmental durability), (2) hemispheric cameras (where offerings are still very limited) and (3) the introduction of the T24 Door Station / video intercom system. Unfortunately for Mobotix, the later two are relatively niche applications. 

We shared our concerns with Mobotix and asked them 3 questions. Below are their responses in full:

IPVM: Will you release support for H.264 for megapixel resolution? If not, can you briefly explain why?

Mobotix: At this juncture, we have no immediate plans to support H.264. H.264 is a multimedia codec that is not optimized for video surveillance and because of this fact we have invested significant resources in the development of MxPEG. This codec is developed specifically for use in video surveillance applications in which the quality of still images needs to be as crystal clear as live video. Although very efficient, H.264 can distort or reduce the quality of captured or still images. In the surveillance world, customers rely on still video clips to prove a crime occurred or identify a particular individual, and therefore maximum image quality is paramount. Our MxPEG codec enables users to gather the most data from their still images as possible, without distortion or reduced image quality. 

The other predominant issue with H.264 with higher resolution cameras is that more servers are needed on the back-end to decode video streams when using H.264 compared to MxPEG and therefore the approach is more costly. 

We feel that MOBOTIX addresses these issues with the combination of MxPEG, the decentralized approach and high-resolution surveillance cameras. 

We do support H.264 for video-SIP connections and I think this demonstrates that we will provide support for such standards where it makes sense. We do recognize that there is significant market support for the use of H.264 for megapixel cameras and we continue to monitor the industry’s need for this specific compression technology. If our customers and partners begin to demand support for H.264, we will certainly look closely at how we can best meet their needs.

Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox
Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox

Summarized: The benefits of MxPEG in comparison with H.264:

  • Better images
  • Less artifacts
  • Shorter latency
  • Easier access to intermediate frames

Optimized for multiples video streams with different frame rates and different resolutions – This is absolutely necessary for the hemispheric technology, because usually the live image is displaying the corrected image for the operator and the original 3MP full-image is stored in high resolution for research. 

When coupled with the decentralized approach to surveillance, we feel MxPEG is most efficient for use in video surveillance applications.

IPVM: Do you have plans to increase maximum resolution beyond 3MP?

Mobotix: At this time, we are focused on maximizing and upgrading our current line of megapixel cameras with 3MP sensors because research demonstrates that a majority of the market isn’t demanding resolution beyond that range. Although there are applications that require higher resolution cameras, this market is still quite limited. As a company, we’ve decided to focus on mainstream demand to maximize business opportunities and meet current market needs. As demand for these types of megapixel cameras grow, we will certainly re-evaluate the situation as the market dictates.

As you know, higher resolution does not always mean better video because the image quality depends on the entire total system, i.e. lens, sensor, image processing etc. and of course, frame rate, network bandwidth and storage requirements. The true image quality of the camera rests on the interaction of all these separate components and we continue to educate the industry on how these components can be ideally used together to enhance video quality. 

Furthermore, the increase in the number of pixels on the same sensor can lead to lesser light quantity per pixel, causing the camera to be less light sensitive, and therefore, image noise and motion blurring can increase. 

IPVM: What are the main new product developments planned for 2011? If you can overview your analytics, that would be helpful.

Mobotix: We are planning on announcing innovations to our product line in 2011 and are excited to share these with the market. We are currently evaluating the value that video analytics on board of e.g. hemispheric cameras may bring to the company and our customers, but we cannot provide additional details on that specific initiative at this time. We will also announce the redesign of our dual camera board with e.g. increased processing power and additional features in 2011, and will continue to look for new ways to upgrade and enhance our existing product lines while developing new ideas for technology development in the future.

At ISC West, we are demonstrating our new T24 IP Video Door Station to the Americas market. The new T24 IP Video Door Station is an integrated access control and megapixel video solution. With 3.1 megapixels and internal memory, the hemispheric door camera records the entire entrance area — 180 degrees — with no blind spots, from wall to wall and from floor to ceiling. It also features recording with sound, keyless entry and integrated message function. 

While Mobotix certainly has a clear and contrarian vision, we think some important aspects of the approach are problematic:

  • Re: H.264 - H.264 has already won the battle for mindshare. Cameras that do not have it are now generally considered to be at least somewhat antiquated. Moreover, in our testing and conversations with integrators, the real world problems that Mobotix claims of H.264 are not typical. Indeed most of Mobotix's H.264 criticisms are theoretical and without actual proof (e.g., MxPEG: The Only Codec Made for Video Surveillance). The lack of H.264 will be detrimental both from a specification process (only allowing H.264 cameras) and for users looking to reduce storage/bandwidth consumption.
  • Re: 3MP - The concerns of 5MP+ quality are certainly worthy. On the other hand, Mobotix has been offering 3MP cameras for years and when Mobotix first released 3MP cameras, such claims could have equally been made for the state of technology for 3MP cameras at that time. With numerous manufacturers offering 1080P and 3MP cameras, those looking for other options have a lot more choice now.
  • Re: the IP Video Door Station: Whether or not the IP Video Door Station is a success, it does little to strengthen 'regular' surveillance systems. While the Door Station may expand Mobotix into new verticals and new markets, for those looking for surveillance systems of dozens or hundreds of cameras, we expect this to be of minimal benefit.

Undoubtedly, Mobotix leverages a strong historical position and like all early entrants into the IP camera market now has to determine how to withstand the thrust of new entrants and legacy players moving into the market. We believe that Mobotix's recent steps and plans are insufficient to keep pace with ongoing competitive developments in the industry.

2 reports cite this report:

Mobotix's Q2 2011 Strong Results Examined on Aug 25, 2011
In this note, we we examine the detailed financial performance of megapixel camera manufacturer Mobotix for the Q2 2011 calendar quarter including...
Winners and Losers Spring 2011 on Apr 12, 2011
Now that the dust has settled from the numerous new announcements of the last month, we can better understand the impact on the overall video...
Comments : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

Network Racks For Surveillance Guide on Mar 21, 2018
In this guide, we look at network rack infrastructure, one of the fundamentals of IP video surveillance. Inside, we cover: What is a rack unit...
Rack Mounting NVRs Tutorial on Mar 14, 2018
Rack mounting recorders is common in professional systems, but manufacturers are making it difficult, with simple design failures causing multiple...
Network Addressing for Video Surveillance Guide on Mar 14, 2018
The goal of this guide is to explain addressing devices on IP networks, focusing on how IP cameras and recorders are used in those networks. For...
Panasonic Selling Off Security Camera Factory on Mar 14, 2018
Panasonic is OEMing cameras from Dahua, as IPVM testing confirmed in 2017. Now, Panasonic is selling their security camera factory, according to...
Favorite Camera Manufacturers 2018 on Mar 12, 2018
A number of major moves in integrator's favorite camera rankings for 2018: Two manufacturers make major moves up One major manufacturer moves...
ADI W-Box Dropping Hikvision (Tested) on Mar 05, 2018
The next generation of ADI's W-Box (ADI's competition against their manufacturing partners) is here. And unlike the previous generation, which was...
ONVIF Usage Statistics 2018 on Mar 05, 2018
ONVIF has long 'won' the standards battle for video surveillance. But has the now 10-year-old ONVIF 'won' vs direct integrations? Undoubtedly,...
Dynamic vs. Static IP Addresses Tutorial on Mar 01, 2018
While many cameras default to DHCP out of the box, that does not mean you should use it. This may seem basic for some, but those new to the...
Top Video Surveillance Service Call Problems (Statistics) on Feb 28, 2018
In our most recent statistics series, over 150 integrators told IPVM the most common problem their customers have with their video systems....
Video Privacy Mask Tutorial on Feb 27, 2018
Privacy has historically been hotly debated in the surveillance industry, especially in public surveillance systems where cameras may be located in...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Top 4 Biggest Problems Selling Access Control on Mar 23, 2018
We received 150+ responses from integrators when we asked them "What is the biggest problem you face when selling electronic access control?...
US / China Tariffs Impact on Video Surveillance on Mar 23, 2018
On March 22, 2018, the US issued a Presidential Memorandum on the Actions by the United States Related to the Section 301 Investigation, with 3...
Final Day - Save $50 - April 2018 IP Networking Course on Mar 22, 2018
Today, March 22nd is the last day to save $50. Register now and save. NEW - 2 sessions per class, 'day' and 'night' to give you double the chance...
Favorite Access Control Credentials 2018 on Mar 22, 2018
In this 2018 access integrator statistics result, which credential type holds the favored spot to unlock access doors? More than 150 integrators...
ISC West Bans Booth Babes on Mar 22, 2018
Booth babes, goodbye. Technically, ISC West banned them 2 years ago with a 'staffing attire' requirement but it looks like ISC West is going to...
Network Racks For Surveillance Guide on Mar 21, 2018
In this guide, we look at network rack infrastructure, one of the fundamentals of IP video surveillance. Inside, we cover: What is a rack unit...
Security Robot Sales Struggle on Mar 21, 2018
2 year ago, PSA Security CEO Bill Bozeman called security robots one of “the biggest game changers” in decades for security integrators. Just over...
Dahua Global Launch LeChange on Mar 20, 2018
Dahua is getting into the consumer video surveillance market globally, with "LeChange", an offering long available inside of China is now being...
Axis Z-Wave IP Camera Tested Poorly on Mar 20, 2018
Z-Wave is drawing notable interest for video surveillance use. In IPVM's initial coverage, 84% expressed interest in it, with nearly half being...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact