Genetec Criticizes Milestone

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Feb 26, 2012

Genetec and Milestone are fierce rivals in the VMS market, continuously competing for similar large scale surveillance projects. In that space, advanced technical features are key differentiators. To this end, Genetec recently published a list of functionalities that it believes VMS systems should have. Interestingly, quite a number of these are obvious criticisms of Milestone specific implementation issues.

In this note, we review the 5 main points, providing an assessment of how significant each one is for practical use.

Here are the 5 core criticisms Genetec implicitly makes of Milestone's VMS:

  • Must license by MAC address of camera/encoder
  • Requires restarting server services to make configuration changes
  • No ability to upgrade camera firmware from VMS client
  • No ability to configure the key frame rate of each camera
  • No support for multicasting from camera

Licensing Differences

Claim 1: Video Management Software(VMS) must be licensable per total number of camera connections, not by MAC

Milestone requires users to submit MAC addresses for each camera to be licensed on a system, activating the licenses only for these MAC addresses. Comparatively, Genetec licenses Omnicast and Security Center by total number of camera connections, regardless of MAC address. Cameras may be removed and replaced without any change in licensing. 

When a camera goes down and must be replaced, the Milestone method of licensing will slow service. The technician must remove the old camera, install a new on in its place, and then wait to receive an updated license before it can be activated. If the replacement camera is a "loaner" unit, this must be done twice. Genetec users do not have this issue.

Counterpoint: Unless the installation has a large number of cameras, the time penalty for licensing by MAC address is not significantly more than licensing by connection. While connection licensing may simplify maintenance for larger deployments, this will not be a major factor for most surveillance systems.

Configuration Changes without Services Restart

Claim 2: Any configuration changes do not require the server services to be restarted

Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox
Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox

Milestone requires that services be restarted after making configuration changes, while Genetec does not. This means that after many settings are altered, recording will stop momentarily, while the services restart. For some users, especially in critical infrastructure and municipal markets, this interruption will simply be unacceptable. For other customers, it may not be as serious. However, restarting services introduces the possibility that one or more may not properly restart, which may lead to increased troubleshooting.

Counterpoint: Previous Milestone versions required an admin to remember to restart services which was a problem. However, now, when exiting the management application, all Milestone versions explicitly prompt admins to restart any time configuration changes have been made. This makes it unlikely that an admin will forget or make an error. For most users, a brief restart is not a practical problem.

Ability to update firmware of IP camera or encoder

Genetec Omnicast and Security Center offer the capability to update a unit's firmware directly from their config tools, while Milestone users must go directly to the camera's web interface or use manufacturer-specific configuration tools. While this is not necessarily a large timesink, it simplifies firmware updates, since users only need to work in the Genetec interface, instead of looking up and entering each camera's address. For users with multiple camera manufacturers, this may have more impact, as it eliminates the need to learn multiple manufacturer's web interfaces.

Counterpoint: Mass firmware updates can often be accomplished by using camera manufacturer's free management applications (e.g., Axis Camera Management).

To minimise network traffic, the VMS must have ability to configure the key frame interval (I-frame) per second

Milestone does not allow users to adjust key frame interval, while Genetec does. This was discussed in an earlier Genetec Blog entry, also ostensibly a knock against Milestone. In this article, they claim that Omnicast and Security Center's ability to configure I-frames reduces bandwidth and storage needs 2-3x versus "Product X", which uses a set key frame interval of one second.

Counterpoint: Our testing shows changing I-frame rates may not really save much storage. For instance, longer I-frame intervals are often offset in an increased P-Frames size. Specifying longer I-frame intervals may negatively impact video quality and increase indexing (search/retrieving) difficulties. The I-frame interval is best left at defaults unless the user has tested and validated the use of specific I frame internals with the selected camera in the camera's actual location.

Video Management Software(VMS) must have the ability to manage multicast directly from the camera

Lastly, one of Genetec's key marketing claims is their multicast support. Multicast is supported in Omnicast and Security Center directly from the camera, or from the server, while Milestone only supports multicast from the server, and only in their XProtect Corporate version. When multicast is supported only from the server, each resolution that must be streamed to clients may increase server load.

In many cases, this is a non-issue, as it is rare that numerous viewers require multiple resolutions. However, in some large applications, this may be a key feature. For example, in a municipal setting, multiple resolutions and framerates are desirable, such as one stream for clients in the operations center, one for clients elsewhere on the network, one for recording, and one for remote clients on mobile devices or in-car mobile data terminals. Creating all these stream types on the VMS server will most likely increase load, so it is therefore preferable to configure these distinct streams on the camera, to avoid this reduction in performance.

Counterpoint: As stated above, the ability to multicast directly from cameras, rather than servers, offers little to no benefit for the vast majority of surveillance deployments. Additionally, multicast in general is not applicable as multicasting requires appropriate hardware and network design to accomodate this.

Comments : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports on VMS

Panasonic 32MP Multi Imager Camera Tested (WV-X8570N) on May 16, 2019
Panasonic has released their first multi imager models including the 32MP (4x4K) WV-X8570N, claiming "Extreme image quality for evidence capturing...
Bank Security Manager Interview on May 15, 2019
Bank security contends with many significant threats - from fraudsters to robbers and more. In this interview, IPVM spoke with bank security...
Milestone XProtect 2019 R1 Tested on May 15, 2019
For the past few years, Milestone has released quarterly software updates XProtect VMS platform. What is new and how much impact do the updates...
Bluecherry Open Sources Entire VMS on May 13, 2019
Bluecherry announced they have "released the entire Bluecherry software application open source with a GPL license". We spoke to Bluecherry's...
Mining Company Security Manager Interview on May 10, 2019
First Quantum Minerals Limited (FQML) is a global enterprise with offices on 4 continents and operations in 7 countries with exploratory operations...
Aegis AI Gun Detection Video Analytics Startup on May 07, 2019
Gun detection analytic startups are increasing as the promise of AI and the threats of active shooters grow.  One company, Aegis AI, is being led...
Restaurant Security Manager Interview on May 06, 2019
Wright’s Gourmet House in Tampa, Florida has been around for over 50 years. During most of that time, there were no security measures in place. Now...
Ranking Manufacturer Favorability 2019 on May 06, 2019
24 manufacturer's favorability was ranked based on 170+ integrators feedback. Voting plus in-depth comments revealed insights on which brands were...
Verkada Cloud VMS/Cameras Tested on May 02, 2019
Verkada is arguably the most ambitious video surveillance startup in many years. The company is developing their own cameras, their own VMS, their...
Camera Configuration Manager Shootout - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision on May 01, 2019
Which camera manufacturer has the best management tool? We tested 6 manufacturers - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision to find...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Amazon Ring Public Subsidy Program Aims To Dominate Residential Security on May 20, 2019
Amazon dominates market after market. Quitely, but increasingly, they are doing so in residential security, through a combination of significant...
LifeSafety Power NetLink Vulnerabilities And Problematic Response on May 20, 2019
'Power supplies' are not devices that many think about when considering vulnerabilities but as more and more devices go 'online', the risks for...
Facial Recognition Systems Fail Simple Liveness Detection Test on May 17, 2019
Facial recognition is being widely promoted as a solution to physical access control but we were able to simply spoof 3 systems because they had no...
Inside Look Into Scam Market Research on May 17, 2019
Scam market research has exploded over the last few years becoming the most commonly cited 'statistics' for most industries, despite there clearly...
Maglock Selection Guide on May 16, 2019
One of the most misunderstood yet valuable pieces of electrified hardware is the maglock. Few locks are stronger, but myths and confusion surround...
Panasonic 32MP Multi Imager Camera Tested (WV-X8570N) on May 16, 2019
Panasonic has released their first multi imager models including the 32MP (4x4K) WV-X8570N, claiming "Extreme image quality for evidence capturing...
Trump Signs 'Huawei Ban' - Executive Order Targeting Foreign Adversary Technology on May 16, 2019
US President Donald Trump has signed an executive order targeting technology provided by 'foreign adversaries', in what is widely being called a...
Bank Security Manager Interview on May 15, 2019
Bank security contends with many significant threats - from fraudsters to robbers and more. In this interview, IPVM spoke with bank security...
Milestone XProtect 2019 R1 Tested on May 15, 2019
For the past few years, Milestone has released quarterly software updates XProtect VMS platform. What is new and how much impact do the updates...
San Francisco Face Recognition Ban And Surveillance Regulation Details Examined on May 14, 2019
San Francisco passed the legislation 8-1 today. While the face recognition 'ban' has already received significant attention over the past few...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact