Secret Surveillance Approved Inside Patient's Room

By: Carlton Purvis, Published on Mar 26, 2014

The family of an elderly man found a hidden camera in his hospital room. Already frustrated from what they felt was substandard care, they were outraged when they noticed the camera in a fake smoke detector mounted to the ceiling.

It prompted both a VA investigation and the creation of a bill aimed at restricting cameras in veteran’s hospital rooms. The investigation uncovered emails and hospital records that show the hospital was concerned that his family members interfering with his care.

In this post we review the investigation and its impact on the use of surveillance cameras.

*** ****** ** ** elderly *** ***** * hidden ****** ** *** hospital ****. ******* ********** **** what **** **** *** substandard ****, **** **** outraged **** **** ******* the ****** ** * fake ***** ******** ******* to *** *******.

** ******** **** * VA ************* *** *** creation ** * **** aimed ** *********** ******* in *******’* ******** *****. The ************* ********* ****** and ******** ******* **** show *** ******** *** concerned **** *** ****** members *********** **** *** care.

** **** **** ** review *** ************* *** its ****** ** *** use ** ************ *******.

[***************]

**********

** ****, *** ****** of **** **-****-*** ****** Carnegie, ***** * ****** camera ** *** **** at ***** *. ***** VA ******* ******. ********’* ***-**-*** was *** ***** ** spot *** ******. *** family ********* *** ******** installed *** ****** ******* they **** *********** ***** for **********. ****'* ***:

***** ***** **** * hospital *** * ***** sugar-related ******* ***** ** vacation ** ********* ** IV *********. ***** ********* and ************ ** * VA ******** ****** ** home, *** ****** **** he ******** ***** ****** after **** *****-** **** a ******* **** *** off *** ****** ******* brain ****** ********** **** lack ** ******.

*** ****** ********** ** sue *** ********, *** shortly ***** *** ****** went **.

*** ** ******** **** it ********* *** ****** to ** **** ** monitor *********’* ****** ** all ***** *** ****** suggest *** ****** *** to **** *** ***, if ******, *** *********** with ******’* ******. ******* was ******** ******* ********* changing ******** ** ********* with *** ******* ****.

*** ******** ****** ** know “*** ** **** was ... ******** *** incline ******** ** *** patient’s ***, ******** *** rate ** ******** ** the *******’* ******* *** medication *****, ***/** ************* the *******.”

*** **** ***** *** them **** ***** * June * ********:


The ******

*** ****** ********* *** a***********.

******** ************** ********** **** it *** *** ***** to ** * ****** camera “****** **** ***** not ******* *** **** selected **** ********** *****,”******** *** ***** *** Times. *** ****** *** live-monitored *** ******** *** 43 **** ****** ** was *******.

****** ******** ** **** of * ** ************* would ***** **** *** hospital ****’* **** *** family ** ****.

VA ********

***** *** ***** ****** on ** *** *****, the ** ****** ** Inspector **************** ** *************. ** **** ***** in *** *******'* ******* record **** ******* ** “supplies ******* *** ******** changed ** **** *******, bed ********, **********/****** ******** which **** ******* **** done ** *** ******.”

***** ********** ************** *** ****** ****** was ********* *** **** patient ******* *** *** needed ******* ** *** being **** *** *********. It **** ********** **** overall ******** ******** ****-******* care **** *** ******** staff.

Other ********

** *** **** ** the *************, ** ***** VA ********* ******** ***** covert *******, *** ***** admitted ** ***** **** in *** ****, *** in *********** **** *** enforcement **************.

*** ************* **** ******** the ***** ********* ** VA *********. *** *******, VA ********* ********* *** are ********* ******** ** have ******* ** ******* areas, **** ********* *** exits, ******** ***** *** places ***** ********** ********** are ******. ** ****** all ***** ***** *** signage **** ********* ******* were *******.

** ******** *** ** hospitals *** ***** **** 75 ******* ** **** have ******* ** ******** areas ** **** **** are ***** ********* ** medical *****. *** ******* reported ********* **** ***** and *****. ***** ******** jail **********, ****** ****** seclusion ***** *** ***** labs.

***********

*** ***** ********* **** led ** *********** ** ********************** *** *** ** camera’s ** ** ******** rooms. *** *********** *** drawn ** ****** *** same **** *** *** released **** ******. ** the **** ** *** report, ***** ****** *** hospitals ******** ***** *** family, ******* **** ** **** committee.

****

**** ** *** *****?

Comments (4)

Yes. Especially for older patients who are more susceptible to getting infections in hospitals and who may not be in their right minds. Someone suffering dementia may very likely fiddle with their own feeding tubes, IV drips, etc. Having a camera in a patient room also allows one nurse to monitor multiple rooms and is hardly an uncommon practice in non-VA hospitals.

What is curious about this case is the reason the VA installed the camera in the first place. It looks like they were trying to gather evidence of family misbehavior to use in their defense in a lawsuit, but it's just as easy to spin it into a case where the hospital administration was concerned about a specific patient's safety based on incidents and inventory counts.

Case by case basis, and they should run their reasons by a lawyer first.

Maybe one day there will be clearly defined paramters that cover special circumstances where, as Kathleen pointed out, the patient may intentionaly or unintentionaly harm themselves, that allows a hospital to automatically video monitor a patient. Then for other cases where nefarious activity is suspected, a procedure the hospital can follow to get approval from a 3rd party, impartial entity for surveillance, similar to the way law enforcement is required to justify a warrant or injunction from a judge.

Where I think the hospital made a mistake was using a covert camera. A camera in plain view could be argued that safety was the only concern of the hospital. A covert camera means the hospotal went beyond the concern for safety into the realm of criminal investigation. If they suspected the man's family of interferering with his care, they should have notified police and left it up to police to justify and run a covert camera.

Actually, it should not be hidden and should be required for all patients and video provided to hopital and the patient upon request.

I have installed a hidden camera in a labor delivery wing where there was suspected ongoing family issues. Don't know of they actually ever used it. Was 10 years ago.

I just finished installing 28 cameras in patient rooms feeding three dvrs with the monitors located in the stations where the vital signs are monitored. They are for baker act patients, but many times the rooms are used for other patients. The dvrs have no hard drives, recording is against Hippa regulations. A patient has already complained and we now have to train the staff on how to mask views. This is a cost saver as a staff member has to sit in those rooms 24 hours unless there is another way to monitor the patient. I have done this probably 15 times in hospitals over the years.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Most Recent Industry Reports

Alarm Veteran "Demands A Criminal Investigation" Of UL on Oct 18, 2019
The Interceptor's Project pressure against UL continues to rise. Following Keith Jentoft's allegation that "UL Has Blood On Their Hands", Jentoft...
Camect "Worlds Smartest Camera Hub" Tested on Oct 18, 2019
Camect is a Silicon Valley startup that claims the "Smartest AI Object Detection On The Market", detecting not only people and vehicles, but...
Hikvision Global News Reports Directory on Oct 17, 2019
Hikvision has received the most global news reporting of any video surveillance company, ever, ranging from the WSJ, the Financial Times, Reuters,...
Camera Calculator V3.1 Release Improves User Experience on Oct 17, 2019
IPVM has released a new version of our Camera Calculator, V3.1, with significant user experience improvements, a new development plan, and an...
Securing Access Control Installations Tutorial on Oct 17, 2019
The physical security of access control components is critical to ensuring that a facility is truly secure. Otherwise, the entire system can be...
Access Control Course Fall 2019 - Last Chance on Oct 17, 2019
Register Now - Fall 2019 Access Control Course. Thursday, October 17th is the last day to register. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access...
US DoD Comments on Huawei, Hikvision, Dahua Cyber Security Concerns on Oct 16, 2019
A senior DoD official said the US is "concerned" with the cybersecurity of Hikvision, Dahua, and Huawei due to "CCP" (China Communist Party)...
Pelco Sarix Pro3 Camera Tested on Oct 16, 2019
Pelco has released their Sarix Professional Series 3 cameras, claiming "more security detail in challenging scenes with excellent low light and...
IPVM Camera Calculator User Manual / Guide on Oct 16, 2019
Learn how to use the IPVM Camera Calculator. The guide below includes instructions, images, gifs, and videos demonstrating and explaining the...
Altronix Claims Tango 'Eliminates Electricians' on Oct 15, 2019
Power supply provider Altronix claims its new Tango power supply 'eliminates the need for an electrician, dedicated conduit and wire runs'. In...