Are You Smarter than a Security Trade Magazine?Author: John Honovich, Published on Aug 25, 2011
If you have any IP video surveillance skills, you should easily spot at least 1 of 2 fundamental errors from a single page 'test report' published by GIT security magazine and VMS manufacturer Seetec's 'Hardware Competency Center'.
Here is the key excerpt from a test of the Axis M1104:
"On average, the frame rate was approx. 1.6 MB/s. A frame rate of 3.31 MB/s was achieved as a temporary maximum."
Did you spot the errors?
- Confusing frame rate and bit rate: Frame rates are measured in frames per second (e.g. fps) while bit rate is measured in bits per second (e.g. bps). This should be easy to spot for even a novice.
- Confusing bits with bytes: The measurement is in Bytes (denoted by a capital B). Since 8 bits is equal to a byte, the statement implies that the average bit rate is 12.8 Mb/s - way too high for a 720p H.264 camera. (We've tested the Axis M11 series and the average for 30fps/720p is roughly 1.6 Mb/s - note small b for bits). This is a little more advanced but should be easy to find for any mid level technician / engineer.
If you know the answer to this question, you likely have an advanced knowledge of Axis IP cameras and IP cameras in general:
Question: Why would the frame rate of the Axis M1104 drop at lower light levels?
The answer is that Axis, by default, typically sets the maximum exposure speed to 1/6s. When lighting is insufficient, Axis slows the exposure simultaneously decreasing the frame rate. This makes the imager brighter than keeping the exposure at 1/30s for a full 30fps image. However, it silently drops your frame rate by 80%.
Take a look at how this happens in our 7 camera office shootout including multiple Axis cameras and contrast to the performance of rival manufacturers.
Related Reports on Trade Magazine
Most Recent Industry Reports
The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.