Access: IP Readers vs. Control Panels

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Jun 16, 2012

Should you continue to use traditional centralized, panel-based access control or does it make sense to use IP readers? Let's overview the 2 key options:

  • Control panels: Traditional access control systems have used control panels, typically controlling two, four, either, or more doors each. In these configurations, door devices are typically homerun to centrally located panels, though in larger facilities, panels may be distributed throughout. The panels, in turn, typically connect to the access control server via IP, though older or low-end systems may still use serial data connections.
  • IP readers: In the second, more recent, approach, intelligence is moved to the door, with a small (1-2 door) control panels located throughout a facility. While some readers now accept a direct IP connection, many deployments move the controller to the edge connecting to a traditional reader very close by. To that end, 'IP reader' is a misnomer, but expresses the intent of this shift.

The traditional approach of larger control panels has caused some problems:

  • Often, customers were forced to install four-door control panels to control one or two doors, which drove cost for these small systems up drastically.
  • Adding a door here or there, out of reach of existing the existing panel or panels, required a new multi-door panel to be installed.
  • IT staff is less comfortable with traditional security wiring. As security systems have become more IP-based, they have fallen more and more under control of network engineers and RCDDs. IP readers allow these designers to follow more familiar cabling topologies, making them more attractive.

While the traditional panel approach has issues, concerns about moving to IP readers also raised concerns including issues with sufficient power, manufacturer support, economics and scalability.

For background, we recommend you review HID makes the case for the edge to see how manufacturers pitch the idea of IP to skeptics.

Inside the Pro section, we examine the tradeoffs, key issues involved and make recommendations on best fits.

****** *** ******** ** *** *********** ***********, *****-***** ****** ******* or **** ** **** ***** ** *** ** *******? ***'* overview *** * *** *******:

  • ******* ******: *********** ****** ******* ******* **** **** ******* ******, ********* *********** two, ****, ******, ** **** ***** ****. ** ***** **************, door ******* *** ********* ******* ** ********* ******* ******, ****** in ****** **********, ****** *** ** *********** **********. *** ******, in ****, ********* ******* ** *** ****** ******* ****** *** IP, ****** ***** ** ***-*** ******* *** ***** *** ****** data ***********.
  • ** *******: ** *** ******, **** ******, ********, ************ ** ***** ** the ****, **** * ***** (*-* ****) ******* ****** ******* throughout * ********. ***** **** ******* *** ****** * ****** IP **********, **** *********** **** *** ********** ** *** **** connecting ** * *********** ****** **** ***** **. ** **** end, '** ******' ** * ********, *** ********* *** ****** of **** *****.

*** *********** ******** ** ****** ******* ****** *** ****** **** problems:

  • *****, ********* **** ****** ** ******* ****-**** ******* ****** ** control *** ** *** *****, ***** ***** **** *** ***** small ******* ** ***********.
  • ****** * **** **** ** *****, *** ** ***** ** existing *** ******** ***** ** ******, ******** * *** *****-**** panel ** ** *********.
  • ** ***** ** **** *********** **** *********** ******** ******. ** security ******* **** ****** **** **-*****, **** **** ****** **** and **** ***** ******* ** ******* ********* *** *****. ** readers ***** ***** ********* ** ****** **** ******** ******* **********, making **** **** **********.

***** *** *********** ***** ******** *** ******, ******** ***** ****** to ** ******* **** ****** ******** ********* ****** **** ********** power, ************ *******, ********* *** ***********.

*** **********, ** ********* *** ********* ***** *** **** *** *** **** ** *** *** ************* ***** *** **** ** ** ** skeptics.

****** *** *** *******, ** ******* *** *********, *** ****** involved *** **** *************** ** **** ****.

[***************]

****: ****** *** ******, ** **** *** *** **** '**** controllers' ****** **** '** *******' *** ******* ********* ******** ** describing *** *** ** ** ** *** **** *** ****** control.

***************

*********** *** ** **** *********** **. *********** ****** ******* ** 3 *********** *********:

  • **** **** ****** ******* ********** ****** ******* **?
  • **** **** ***** ******* **?
  • **** ** *** *****/****** ******* ** *** ******?

*** ***** ***** ** *** ********: **** *** ****** ********** system ** *** ** ******* ******* ***** ***** ** *******? While **** *********** **** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** past ****** ** ***** (********** *** *********), * ****** ** systems ***** **** *******, ** ******* **** **-*** ********* ********. 

*** ****** ********* ************* **** ********* ** *********** ** ******* PoE **** ******* ****** ******* ** ***** *** ****** *****. Be **** ** ***** *** ******* ******** ***** *** ****** and ******** *******, ** **** **** *** ********** ****** **** be **********. ****** *** ******** ***** ********** ******* ** **** holding ******** ******** **** ******* **** ***** **** ***-******* *********** will *******, ** ** ***** ***** * ******** ***** ****** must ** ********, ****** *********** **** ******* ********* ** ***** to *** ****.

********* ****** ****, ***** ** ** **** *** **** **** as ** ***** **** *********** *** ***********, *** ** ********* the *********:

  • ** **** ***** ******* (*-* *****):******* *********** ** *** **** ***** * *** ** *****. ******* and ************ ******** *** **** *******, *** ********** * ****** door *****'* ******* *** ******** ** * ****-**** *****, **** three ****** *****. *******, ***** ******-**** *********** ******* ** ****** ******* system ** ****** *** ** **** *** ****** ******* ** frequent ******* *** ****, ** **** ********** **** ** ********** individually. For * ****** ** ***** ** * ***** ********, **** most ****** **** *** ** **** ** * ********.
  • ** ******-***** ******* (*-** *****):**** *********** **** **** * *** ** ***** ** ******* of **** ****, ** ****'** *** ** *** **** *********** hundreds ** ***** ******** ** ******-**** *********** ****** * ******** or ****** ******* **********. ****** **** ****** ** ***** ** * network ** ******** *** **** ** ** *****, ******, ** it ****** ****** ***** **********, *** **** **** ** *** switches *** ** ******** *** ********** ****** ****.
  • ** *****-***** *******:**** ****** ** **** ** ****** ** ****** ********-**** ******* panels ** ******* ** ******-**** ***********. *********** * ******* ** ******* only *** ****** *********** **** *** *********** ****. *******, ********* ****** management ******** **** ******** **** *********** **** ***** ****** ***** may ** ***** ** *** ********* ***** ** * **** lower *** **** *********** ****.

Basics ** ***** **** ***********

***** ***** *** **** ********* ******* ************* ** **** ***********, there *** **** ****** ************ **** *****:

  • *****-****-********: *** ** *** ******* ******* ******* ***** ** **** controllers ** *****-****-******** **********. **** ****** *** *** ********** ** be ******* **** *** ****, ******** *** ***** **** *** traditionally *** **** * *********** ******* *****. ** **** ********** power ************, ***** ** ********** ***** ******** **** ** ** installed *** **** *******. *** *** *** ** * **** choice *** ***** ****, *******, ***** **’** ******* *****.
  • ********** *******: ******* *** ********** ** *** **** ******** **** *****-**** cable ** ** ***. ******* *****-***** ******* ******* *********** *******, typically * *-********* *** *** ******, *** ********* *** *** door ******** ******, **** ********* *** *** *******-**-**** ******, *** two ** **** ********** *** *** ****. ***** ****** *** either *** **********, ** *** * ********* ***** ***** **** all **** ******** ****** ** *** **** ******. *** ********* cable ***** **** ***** ** ***** *******, *** ****** ****** is *********.
  • ***** ******** ******: **** *********** **** ****** ******** ****** ** *** ****. Each ********** ***** *** ****** ******** *** ********* ****** ******* at *** ****(*) ** ********. **** ******* *****-**** *********** ** a ****** ***** ** ******* ** *** ******. ** *** controller ****** ** ****, **** **** ********** ** ****, *** two, ** ****, ** **** *****.

Cost ***********

*** ****** ***** *** ***** ** ****** *******, ******** ******* building ************: *’ **** ******* **** ******* *****. ****** *** based ** ***** ***’ **** **** *** ***, ******** **** ********, *** ** ******* **** ** ******** *************’ ****-**** ******* panels. ** ***** ***’ *** *** *******: *. ** ** the ******* ***** ****** **** ***** **** *********** ** ** is ********* *****-****, *** *. **** ******* **** ********* ***** limited ** ***’, ** **** ** *** * **** ****** ground. 

 

 ****-********
*****************
**********
***** *********/*
*************
*************
***** *** **** *****$****$****

** *** *******, * *********** *******. **** ** ****, *******, that *** **** ***** ******* ******** *** ******** *** ** place, *** ** ******** ***** ** ******. **** *** ******** must ** ********, *** **** *********.

******** * ***** *** ****** ******, ***** ** ***** ********* as *** ******-**** ***** **** ****** ** **** ** **** scenario, *** ****** $*** ****. **** ** *********** *** ****** a ******-***** ** ******, ***** *** ****** *** * *** hundred ******* ****. ***** ********* *** ****** ** ********* **** savings.

******* **** ***** *** **** ****** ** **** ** *** access ********** ********. **** ****** ******* ****** ** *** **** built-in ********** *** **-***** **********; ********* ****** **** *** *** HID **** *** *** ****** **********. ****** ** *** ********, which ** ********* *** ****, *** * ** ** **** mix ***** *** ******* ****.

Should * *** ***?

***** *** ** ** ********* ******* *** **** ********** *******, using ** ******* ** *** *** *****:

  • ***** ****** ************: ***** ** ****** ******* ** ************ *** **** ** locking ********, ** ***** ******** **** **-**% ** **** ** the ***** ** *** ****** *** ********** *** *** **** edge ***********. ** * ***** ****** ** **** *************’ *************** locks *** ******** **** ******* ** *** **** **** ******** more ***** **** **** **** *********** **** ****** (>***-*****). ********* speaking, **** ****** ** ***** **** ******** *******, *** ***-*******-***** mag ***** (*** ***. ** *****) **** ** **** **** many **** ***********. ******* ****-***** *** *********** ***** ******** ** almost ********** ** **** *** **** *****. **** * ***** standpoint, *** ********** *** ******* ** ** *** **** ***** brands (***,**********) **** ***** ***-******* ***********, ** **** **** ** ***** heaviest-duty ***** **** ***** *** ******* ***** ** **** * PoE ********** *** ******. ************-********** (*** ******, **********, ***.) **** ** ** **** ***** hungry *** **** ****** ** ****. ****, ***** **** ******* should *** **** **** ***** **** *** ********** **** ******, biometric ******* **** ** **** ******** *** **** ******* ***.
  • ***** ******* ********: ** *** **** ** ** *** **** ** ******, it ********* **** ****** ** **** ** ***** *******. *******, in *** **** ** ***** ******** **** ***** ********, ***** electric *******, *** **** *** ****** ******. ** ***** ***** outages, **** ** ******* *** * *******, ** *** ******** powering *** **** ********** **** ********* ** ****** **. **** large ***** ********* ** *** *** *** **** **** *-* hours, *******. ** *** **** ** ******** ***** *******, *******, once *** *** *** ******, *** *** ********** *** **** power, ***** **** ** ** *** ** ************** **** *** doors **** **** ****** ****. ** ***** *****, **** **** be ****, ** *** **** ****** ****. ** ****** ****, it ** *********** **** ******** ***** ** ******* *** * separate *******-****** ***** ****** **** ** **** *** **** ** budget ******.

Mercury “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”

** **** *******, ** ****** ******* ******** ********** “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”. ***** *** ********** ****-**** ****** *******, ** **** ***** some ********* ******* **, *********:

******* ********* *** ******* *********: ** *****, **** ********* *** ****** ************* **** ******** networks *** **********, **** ****** **** ******* ** ** ******** for ******* ************. **** **** ** *** ******* ** **** industries -- ** ************ ***** ****** *** ** ** ****.

  • ******* ********: ********* ** *******, ***** *** **** ******* ** play ****: *. ********* ******* ***** *** *** *********** ********* ***** the **** ** *******. *. *** *** ******** ******* ***. *. *** all ******** *** ********** ** ** ** *** **** ****. 4. The ****** *********** *** ******* * **** ** ******* ********.
  • *** ********: ** ***** ***** **** *** ** *** ***** are ***** ********. ******* **** *** ************ **** ** ***** on * ****-**-**** *****. ****, ******* ***** *** *** ** available. *******, ****** ******* ******* ** ****** ********** *** ** be *********, *** ** ********* ** *** **** *********** *****, is **** ********* **** ******* * ****** *** ** *** door. ******** ********** *** *** ** * *******. ********* ** the **** ******** ***** ****, *******, ** *** ** * problem, ******, ** *** ***’* ****** *** ***** ******** *** the ******* ******. ******* * ****** ***** ***** *** ********* a *** ******* ***** ******, ** ********* * *** *******, are ********** ******* **** ** *** **** ****. *** **** issue ** **** ********* ** *****. ** ******** *** ********* for ******** *******, ******* ** ** ********** ** **** ***** in ***** ******** ** ***** ********* ***********. *** ****** ** compromising ** **** ********** *** ** ********* ******** ** ****** VLANs, ** **** ****** ******** * ******** **** *** ***** it **** ***** ** ****** ** *** *** ******* ***** than **** ** ** *** ****** ******* ****.

***** **** ** *********: *** ***** ******* ** *** **** ** **** ******** cabling *** ********* ******** ******* ************** **** ** **** ***** TCO **** ***** *********** **-*** ********* ***********.

  • ******* ********: ***** ******** **** *** ******* ** ** ******** to ****** ** ********** ******** *******, ******* ** ** **** or ******** *****. ******* ** ***** ** ********** * ******** LAN *** ** ***** *********** (** ***** *** ********** *** attest). ************, ** ********, **** ** ********* ******* ******** ******** to ** ** **** ** *** ****** *******, ******* **** to ** ****, ***., *** ********* ****** ******** ********* *********** (which ** *** **** ****** **).
  • *** ********: ** *****. ** **** **********, ***** ** ****** advantage ** ******* * *** *** ***** ** * ****. Also ******** **** ** **** *******, *******-***** ******* *** *** example, * ***** ****** ******: ********* **-***-***** ******-**** ***********. **** reduces *******, **** ****** ** *** ***** ***** ** * loop *************, ******* ** *******.

******** *** ** ***** *** **** ********: **** **** ****** ** ********* ************ ** ** *** security ********.

  • ******* ********: ************, *** ********** ****** ** *** “***% ******” is ***********. ** *** ** *****, **.*% ****** *** ** acceptable. ** *** ******** *****, **** ******* ** * **** workday (*.** *****) *** **** ** ********, ***** ******** ***** would **** ************. ** **** ****** ** *** **** **** IT *** *** ***** ****** ** ******* ******* ** ******** staff, ** ******** ***** *** **** ** **** ****** * problem ***** ** *** ******** *******.
  • *** ********: *** ********** ** ****** ** * ***** *******. Even ** **** ******* *** **** **** ****** ***, ** would ***** ****** ** *** ******* ** ******** ***** ****. We ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** **** **** ************. *******, most ******* ***** ** *** *** ****** *** **** ** five ***** ** ****** (**.**% ** **.***%), ***** ******* **** drastically. ************, *** ****** ** *** ******* ***** **** *** vary. ** **** ********** ***** *** ********** ******** *******, *** does *** **** ** *********** ** * ******* ****** ** other *********** ****** ** ***** ******, *** **** ******* **** still ********. ** *** ****** ** ***** ********* ** ********, however, ** **** ** * ***** *******, ***** ***** ***** will **** ** **** **** ** ********* ** ***** *****. Access ** ** ****** ** **** ** * *******. ******* may *****, *** ** ***** ** ***** ** ** ** extreme ***** **** ***** *********** ****** ****** ***********.

***-**-***, *** ******* ********** ********** ******* *** *********** ** *** network *** ********** ****** ******* ****** ****** *********** ******** **** edge-based ***********. **** *** ***** ******** ********, ***+, ********* ************* between *********** *** *** ****, *** ****** ******* (********** ** some ****-***** *** **** *********** ** *********), ** ********* ************** in ****** ******. **’* ***** **** ***** *** ** *********** recommendations.

Manufacturer *********

**** ********** ****-***** ****** *******, ***** *** *** ***** ************* providing **** ******** *********:

  • ***:*** ******** *** **** *** ***** *********, ***** *** **** **** ** ***** **** *** *******, *** ******** ** **** ***-***** ********* *** ********. **** are ********* *** *** ** ****-***** *******, *** *** **** is ********* ** *** **** *******, * ***-********** ****** **** standalone ****.
  • *******:******* **** ******** ******** ****-***** ********: *** ****** ** * *****-**** ********** **** * ******-**** ********* ***** **** it. ** ** ******* ** *********** ** ***** ******* ****** the ***** ** **** ******-**** **********, ** *** **** ***-**** *********. *** **** *** **** **** ********** ***** **** to *** ****** *** **-***. *** ***** ** ****** ****** - ** ********-***** “****” **** ********* **** ** ********** **-*****. It ****** ************ **** *** ****** *** ********, ***** *** access ******* ********* *** ****.

************, *********** ******* ***** **** **** ** *** ***** ************* such **: ** (*********)********* (******-***)******** (*******-*)** (*********), *** ******** ***** (***** ****)

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Final Day Save $50 - IP Networking Course September 2017 on Aug 17, 2017
Today, Thursday, August 17th is the last day to save $50 on the September IP Networking Course. This is the only networking course designed...
Cat 5e vs Cat 6 vs Cat 6a Network Cable Usage Statistics on Aug 16, 2017
Cat 5e? Cat 6? Cat 6a? What do integrators use in practice, today? 140+ integrators told IPVM. Here are the results: For those who want to...
Vulnerability Directory For Access Control Cards on Aug 14, 2017
Knowing which access credentials are insecure can be unclear, especially because most look and feel the same. Even the most insecure 125 kHz types...
IP Camera Specification / RFP Guide 2017 on Aug 14, 2017
RFPs are hard. Do them 'right' and it takes a lot of knowledge and time. Do them 'wrong' and you can be (a) unwittingly locked into a specific...
Rebooting IP Camera Statistics And Practices on Aug 10, 2017
Dahua cameras automatically reboot weekly, by default. Is this an innovation by the Chinese mega-manufacturer or a sign of a problems? 125...
Most Common Network Termination Usage Statistics on Aug 09, 2017
How do integrators decide which brand of patch panel or keystone jack to buy?  140+ integrators told IPVM which manufacturers they trust and what...
Competing Against G4S on Aug 09, 2017
G4S Secure Solutions is a global company, operating in multiple countries and offering a suite of products and services from guards to their AMAG...
ONVIF Releases Profile A for Access on Aug 08, 2017
ONVIF has struggled so far in access control. In 2014, ONVIF released Profile C for access control, but in the 3 years since, only 2 companies...
Hikvision Releases Network Cabling on Aug 04, 2017
Hikvision's expansion continues. From cameras to analytics to thermal to intrusion to access to... network cabling. Hikvision explained: A...
Access Control Commissioning / Install Checklist on Aug 03, 2017
This 80+ point checklist helps end users, integrators and consultants verify that access control installation is complete. It covers the following...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Final Day Save $50 - IP Networking Course September 2017 on Aug 17, 2017
Today, Thursday, August 17th is the last day to save $50 on the September IP Networking Course. This is the only networking course designed...
Directory Of Consumer Security Cameras on Aug 16, 2017
The consumer camera segment continues to grow, with new startups and models from existing players released seemingly every month. In this report we...
Cat 5e vs Cat 6 vs Cat 6a Network Cable Usage Statistics on Aug 16, 2017
Cat 5e? Cat 6? Cat 6a? What do integrators use in practice, today? 140+ integrators told IPVM. Here are the results: For those who want to...
Hikvision Responds To Cracked Security Codes on Aug 15, 2017
Hikvision has responded to IPVM's report on Hikvision's security code being cracked, both with a 2 page update to dealers and communication...
Stolen Video NVR / DVR Statistics on Aug 15, 2017
"But what happens if someone steals my recorder?" Anyone who has done more than a handful of jobs has probably heard this question several times....
Hikvision Europe Cutting Out Unauthorized End User Sales on Aug 15, 2017
The days of anyone buying Hikvision from anywhere off the Internet are numbered, at least in Europe, if Hikvision's plan comes to fruition. In...
Axis Laser Focus PTZ Tested on Aug 14, 2017
Axis has been touting its new Q6155-E laser focus PTZ as 'always in focus' and 'always in color'. Does it really deliver? We bought and tested...
Vulnerability Directory For Access Control Cards on Aug 14, 2017
Knowing which access credentials are insecure can be unclear, especially because most look and feel the same. Even the most insecure 125 kHz types...
IP Camera Specification / RFP Guide 2017 on Aug 14, 2017
RFPs are hard. Do them 'right' and it takes a lot of knowledge and time. Do them 'wrong' and you can be (a) unwittingly locked into a specific...
Cellphone Usage Issues For Integrators (Statistics) on Aug 11, 2017
Cellphones clearly offer significant advantages in communication and problem solving. But they can also be a major pain point if employees...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact