Access: IP Readers vs. Control Panels

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Jun 16, 2012

Should you continue to use traditional centralized, panel-based access control or does it make sense to use IP readers? Let's overview the 2 key options:

  • Control panels: Traditional access control systems have used control panels, typically controlling two, four, either, or more doors each. In these configurations, door devices are typically homerun to centrally located panels, though in larger facilities, panels may be distributed throughout. The panels, in turn, typically connect to the access control server via IP, though older or low-end systems may still use serial data connections.
  • IP readers: In the second, more recent, approach, intelligence is moved to the door, with a small (1-2 door) control panels located throughout a facility. While some readers now accept a direct IP connection, many deployments move the controller to the edge connecting to a traditional reader very close by. To that end, 'IP reader' is a misnomer, but expresses the intent of this shift.

The traditional approach of larger control panels has caused some problems:

  • Often, customers were forced to install four-door control panels to control one or two doors, which drove cost for these small systems up drastically.
  • Adding a door here or there, out of reach of existing the existing panel or panels, required a new multi-door panel to be installed.
  • IT staff is less comfortable with traditional security wiring. As security systems have become more IP-based, they have fallen more and more under control of network engineers and RCDDs. IP readers allow these designers to follow more familiar cabling topologies, making them more attractive.

While the traditional panel approach has issues, concerns about moving to IP readers also raised concerns including issues with sufficient power, manufacturer support, economics and scalability.

For background, we recommend you review HID makes the case for the edge to see how manufacturers pitch the idea of IP to skeptics.

Inside the Pro section, we examine the tradeoffs, key issues involved and make recommendations on best fits.

****** *** ******** ** *** *********** ***********, *****-***** ****** ******* or **** ** **** ***** ** *** ** *******? ***'* overview *** * *** *******:

  • ******* ******: *********** ****** ******* ******* **** **** ******* ******, ********* *********** two, ****, ******, ** **** ***** ****. ** ***** **************, door ******* *** ********* ******* ** ********* ******* ******, ****** in ****** **********, ****** *** ** *********** **********. *** ******, in ****, ********* ******* ** *** ****** ******* ****** *** IP, ****** ***** ** ***-*** ******* *** ***** *** ****** data ***********.
  • ** *******: ** *** ******, **** ******, ********, ************ ** ***** ** the ****, **** * ***** (*-* ****) ******* ****** ******* throughout * ********. ***** **** ******* *** ****** * ****** IP **********, **** *********** **** *** ********** ** *** **** connecting ** * *********** ****** **** ***** **. ** **** end, '** ******' ** * ********, *** ********* *** ****** of **** *****.

*** *********** ******** ** ****** ******* ****** *** ****** **** problems:

  • *****, ********* **** ****** ** ******* ****-**** ******* ****** ** control *** ** *** *****, ***** ***** **** *** ***** small ******* ** ***********.
  • ****** * **** **** ** *****, *** ** ***** ** existing *** ******** ***** ** ******, ******** * *** *****-**** panel ** ** *********.
  • ** ***** ** **** *********** **** *********** ******** ******. ** security ******* **** ****** **** **-*****, **** **** ****** **** and **** ***** ******* ** ******* ********* *** *****. ** readers ***** ***** ********* ** ****** **** ******** ******* **********, making **** **** **********.

***** *** *********** ***** ******** *** ******, ******** ***** ****** to ** ******* **** ****** ******** ********* ****** **** ********** power, ************ *******, ********* *** ***********.

*** **********, ** ********* *** ********* ***** *** **** *** *** **** ** *** *** ************* ***** *** **** ** ** ** skeptics.

****** *** *** *******, ** ******* *** *********, *** ****** involved *** **** *************** ** **** ****.

[***************]

****: ****** *** ******, ** **** *** *** **** '**** controllers' ****** **** '** *******' *** ******* ********* ******** ** describing *** *** ** ** ** *** **** *** ****** control.

***************

*********** *** ** **** *********** **. *********** ****** ******* ** 3 *********** *********:

  • **** **** ****** ******* ********** ****** ******* **?
  • **** **** ***** ******* **?
  • **** ** *** *****/****** ******* ** *** ******?

*** ***** ***** ** *** ********: **** *** ****** ********** system ** *** ** ******* ******* ***** ***** ** *******? While **** *********** **** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** past ****** ** ***** (********** *** *********), * ****** ** systems ***** **** *******, ** ******* **** **-*** ********* ********. 

*** ****** ********* ************* **** ********* ** *********** ** ******* PoE **** ******* ****** ******* ** ***** *** ****** *****. Be **** ** ***** *** ******* ******** ***** *** ****** and ******** *******, ** **** **** *** ********** ****** **** be **********. ****** *** ******** ***** ********** ******* ** **** holding ******** ******** **** ******* **** ***** **** ***-******* *********** will *******, ** ** ***** ***** * ******** ***** ****** must ** ********, ****** *********** **** ******* ********* ** ***** to *** ****.

********* ****** ****, ***** ** ** **** *** **** **** as ** ***** **** *********** *** ***********, *** ** ********* the *********:

  • ** **** ***** ******* (*-* *****):******* *********** ** *** **** ***** * *** ** *****. ******* and ************ ******** *** **** *******, *** ********** * ****** door *****'* ******* *** ******** ** * ****-**** *****, **** three ****** *****. *******, ***** ******-**** *********** ******* ** ****** ******* system ** ****** *** ** **** *** ****** ******* ** frequent ******* *** ****, ** **** ********** **** ** ********** individually. For * ****** ** ***** ** * ***** ********, **** most ****** **** *** ** **** ** * ********.
  • ** ******-***** ******* (*-** *****):**** *********** **** **** * *** ** ***** ** ******* of **** ****, ** ****'** *** ** *** **** *********** hundreds ** ***** ******** ** ******-**** *********** ****** * ******** or ****** ******* **********. ****** **** ****** ** ***** ** * network ** ******** *** **** ** ** *****, ******, ** it ****** ****** ***** **********, *** **** **** ** *** switches *** ** ******** *** ********** ****** ****.
  • ** *****-***** *******:**** ****** ** **** ** ****** ** ****** ********-**** ******* panels ** ******* ** ******-**** ***********. *********** * ******* ** ******* only *** ****** *********** **** *** *********** ****. *******, ********* ****** management ******** **** ******** **** *********** **** ***** ****** ***** may ** ***** ** *** ********* ***** ** * **** lower *** **** *********** ****.

Basics ** ***** **** ***********

***** ***** *** **** ********* ******* ************* ** **** ***********, there *** **** ****** ************ **** *****:

  • *****-****-********: *** ** *** ******* ******* ******* ***** ** **** controllers ** *****-****-******** **********. **** ****** *** *** ********** ** be ******* **** *** ****, ******** *** ***** **** *** traditionally *** **** * *********** ******* *****. ** **** ********** power ************, ***** ** ********** ***** ******** **** ** ** installed *** **** *******. *** *** *** ** * **** choice *** ***** ****, *******, ***** **’** ******* *****.
  • ********** *******: ******* *** ********** ** *** **** ******** **** *****-**** cable ** ** ***. ******* *****-***** ******* ******* *********** *******, typically * *-********* *** *** ******, *** ********* *** *** door ******** ******, **** ********* *** *** *******-**-**** ******, *** two ** **** ********** *** *** ****. ***** ****** *** either *** **********, ** *** * ********* ***** ***** **** all **** ******** ****** ** *** **** ******. *** ********* cable ***** **** ***** ** ***** *******, *** ****** ****** is *********.
  • ***** ******** ******: **** *********** **** ****** ******** ****** ** *** ****. Each ********** ***** *** ****** ******** *** ********* ****** ******* at *** ****(*) ** ********. **** ******* *****-**** *********** ** a ****** ***** ** ******* ** *** ******. ** *** controller ****** ** ****, **** **** ********** ** ****, *** two, ** ****, ** **** *****.

Cost ***********

*** ****** ***** *** ***** ** ****** *******, ******** ******* building ************: *’ **** ******* **** ******* *****. ****** *** based ** ***** ***’ **** **** *** ***, ******** **** ********, *** ** ******* **** ** ******** *************’ ****-**** ******* panels. ** ***** ***’ *** *** *******: *. ** ** the ******* ***** ****** **** ***** **** *********** ** ** is ********* *****-****, *** *. **** ******* **** ********* ***** limited ** ***’, ** **** ** *** * **** ****** ground. 

 

 ****-********
*****************
**********
***** *********/*
*************
*************
***** *** **** *****$****$****

** *** *******, * *********** *******. **** ** ****, *******, that *** **** ***** ******* ******** *** ******** *** ** place, *** ** ******** ***** ** ******. **** *** ******** must ** ********, *** **** *********.

******** * ***** *** ****** ******, ***** ** ***** ********* as *** ******-**** ***** **** ****** ** **** ** **** scenario, *** ****** $*** ****. **** ** *********** *** ****** a ******-***** ** ******, ***** *** ****** *** * *** hundred ******* ****. ***** ********* *** ****** ** ********* **** savings.

******* **** ***** *** **** ****** ** **** ** *** access ********** ********. **** ****** ******* ****** ** *** **** built-in ********** *** **-***** **********; ********* ****** **** *** *** HID **** *** *** ****** **********. ****** ** *** ********, which ** ********* *** ****, *** * ** ** **** mix ***** *** ******* ****.

Should * *** ***?

***** *** ** ** ********* ******* *** **** ********** *******, using ** ******* ** *** *** *****:

  • ***** ****** ************: ***** ** ****** ******* ** ************ *** **** ** locking ********, ** ***** ******** **** **-**% ** **** ** the ***** ** *** ****** *** ********** *** *** **** edge ***********. ** * ***** ****** ** **** *************’ *************** locks *** ******** **** ******* ** *** **** **** ******** more ***** **** **** **** *********** **** ****** (>***-*****). ********* speaking, **** ****** ** ***** **** ******** *******, *** ***-*******-***** mag ***** (*** ***. ** *****) **** ** **** **** many **** ***********. ******* ****-***** *** *********** ***** ******** ** almost ********** ** **** *** **** *****. **** * ***** standpoint, *** ********** *** ******* ** ** *** **** ***** brands (***,**********) **** ***** ***-******* ***********, ** **** **** ** ***** heaviest-duty ***** **** ***** *** ******* ***** ** **** * PoE ********** *** ******. ************-********** (*** ******, **********, ***.) **** ** ** **** ***** hungry *** **** ****** ** ****. ****, ***** **** ******* should *** **** **** ***** **** *** ********** **** ******, biometric ******* **** ** **** ******** *** **** ******* ***.
  • ***** ******* ********: ** *** **** ** ** *** **** ** ******, it ********* **** ****** ** **** ** ***** *******. *******, in *** **** ** ***** ******** **** ***** ********, ***** electric *******, *** **** *** ****** ******. ** ***** ***** outages, **** ** ******* *** * *******, ** *** ******** powering *** **** ********** **** ********* ** ****** **. **** large ***** ********* ** *** *** *** **** **** *-* hours, *******. ** *** **** ** ******** ***** *******, *******, once *** *** *** ******, *** *** ********** *** **** power, ***** **** ** ** *** ** ************** **** *** doors **** **** ****** ****. ** ***** *****, **** **** be ****, ** *** **** ****** ****. ** ****** ****, it ** *********** **** ******** ***** ** ******* *** * separate *******-****** ***** ****** **** ** **** *** **** ** budget ******.

Mercury “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”

** **** *******, ** ****** ******* ******** ********** “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”. ***** *** ********** ****-**** ****** *******, ** **** ***** some ********* ******* **, *********:

******* ********* *** ******* *********: ** *****, **** ********* *** ****** ************* **** ******** networks *** **********, **** ****** **** ******* ** ** ******** for ******* ************. **** **** ** *** ******* ** **** industries -- ** ************ ***** ****** *** ** ** ****.

  • ******* ********: ********* ** *******, ***** *** **** ******* ** play ****: *. ********* ******* ***** *** *** *********** ********* ***** the **** ** *******. *. *** *** ******** ******* ***. *. *** all ******** *** ********** ** ** ** *** **** ****. 4. The ****** *********** *** ******* * **** ** ******* ********.
  • *** ********: ** ***** ***** **** *** ** *** ***** are ***** ********. ******* **** *** ************ **** ** ***** on * ****-**-**** *****. ****, ******* ***** *** *** ** available. *******, ****** ******* ******* ** ****** ********** *** ** be *********, *** ** ********* ** *** **** *********** *****, is **** ********* **** ******* * ****** *** ** *** door. ******** ********** *** *** ** * *******. ********* ** the **** ******** ***** ****, *******, ** *** ** * problem, ******, ** *** ***’* ****** *** ***** ******** *** the ******* ******. ******* * ****** ***** ***** *** ********* a *** ******* ***** ******, ** ********* * *** *******, are ********** ******* **** ** *** **** ****. *** **** issue ** **** ********* ** *****. ** ******** *** ********* for ******** *******, ******* ** ** ********** ** **** ***** in ***** ******** ** ***** ********* ***********. *** ****** ** compromising ** **** ********** *** ** ********* ******** ** ****** VLANs, ** **** ****** ******** * ******** **** *** ***** it **** ***** ** ****** ** *** *** ******* ***** than **** ** ** *** ****** ******* ****.

***** **** ** *********: *** ***** ******* ** *** **** ** **** ******** cabling *** ********* ******** ******* ************** **** ** **** ***** TCO **** ***** *********** **-*** ********* ***********.

  • ******* ********: ***** ******** **** *** ******* ** ** ******** to ****** ** ********** ******** *******, ******* ** ** **** or ******** *****. ******* ** ***** ** ********** * ******** LAN *** ** ***** *********** (** ***** *** ********** *** attest). ************, ** ********, **** ** ********* ******* ******** ******** to ** ** **** ** *** ****** *******, ******* **** to ** ****, ***., *** ********* ****** ******** ********* *********** (which ** *** **** ****** **).
  • *** ********: ** *****. ** **** **********, ***** ** ****** advantage ** ******* * *** *** ***** ** * ****. Also ******** **** ** **** *******, *******-***** ******* *** *** example, * ***** ****** ******: ********* **-***-***** ******-**** ***********. **** reduces *******, **** ****** ** *** ***** ***** ** * loop *************, ******* ** *******.

******** *** ** ***** *** **** ********: **** **** ****** ** ********* ************ ** ** *** security ********.

  • ******* ********: ************, *** ********** ****** ** *** “***% ******” is ***********. ** *** ** *****, **.*% ****** *** ** acceptable. ** *** ******** *****, **** ******* ** * **** workday (*.** *****) *** **** ** ********, ***** ******** ***** would **** ************. ** **** ****** ** *** **** **** IT *** *** ***** ****** ** ******* ******* ** ******** staff, ** ******** ***** *** **** ** **** ****** * problem ***** ** *** ******** *******.
  • *** ********: *** ********** ** ****** ** * ***** *******. Even ** **** ******* *** **** **** ****** ***, ** would ***** ****** ** *** ******* ** ******** ***** ****. We ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** **** **** ************. *******, most ******* ***** ** *** *** ****** *** **** ** five ***** ** ****** (**.**% ** **.***%), ***** ******* **** drastically. ************, *** ****** ** *** ******* ***** **** *** vary. ** **** ********** ***** *** ********** ******** *******, *** does *** **** ** *********** ** * ******* ****** ** other *********** ****** ** ***** ******, *** **** ******* **** still ********. ** *** ****** ** ***** ********* ** ********, however, ** **** ** * ***** *******, ***** ***** ***** will **** ** **** **** ** ********* ** ***** *****. Access ** ** ****** ** **** ** * *******. ******* may *****, *** ** ***** ** ***** ** ** ** extreme ***** **** ***** *********** ****** ****** ***********.

***-**-***, *** ******* ********** ********** ******* *** *********** ** *** network *** ********** ****** ******* ****** ****** *********** ******** **** edge-based ***********. **** *** ***** ******** ********, ***+, ********* ************* between *********** *** *** ****, *** ****** ******* (********** ** some ****-***** *** **** *********** ** *********), ** ********* ************** in ****** ******. **’* ***** **** ***** *** ** *********** recommendations.

Manufacturer *********

**** ********** ****-***** ****** *******, ***** *** *** ***** ************* providing **** ******** *********:

  • ***:*** ******** *** **** *** ***** *********, ***** *** **** **** ** ***** **** *** *******, *** ******** ** **** ***-***** ********* *** ********. **** are ********* *** *** ** ****-***** *******, *** *** **** is ********* ** *** **** *******, * ***-********** ****** **** standalone ****.
  • *******:******* **** ******** ******** ****-***** ********: *** ****** ** * *****-**** ********** **** * ******-**** ********* ***** **** it. ** ** ******* ** *********** ** ***** ******* ****** the ***** ** **** ******-**** **********, ** *** **** ***-**** *********. *** **** *** **** **** ********** ***** **** to *** ****** *** **-***. *** ***** ** ****** ****** - ** ********-***** “****” **** ********* **** ** ********** **-*****. It ****** ************ **** *** ****** *** ********, ***** *** access ******* ********* *** ****.

************, *********** ******* ***** **** **** ** *** ***** ************* such **: ** (*********)********* (******-***)******** (*******-*)** (*********), *** ******** ***** (***** ****)

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Paxton Hosted Access - Disruptive Low Dealer Pricing on Jan 19, 2017
Paxton is entering the hosted access game, with BLU, at a cost that is a fraction of key competitors. The different approach could be very...
Smart Power Tools For Security Installs on Jan 18, 2017
Installing a smart camera? Perhaps you should use a 'smart' drill. The intelligent appliance / IoT trend has hit power tools. In this note, we...
Cut in Half, Everfocus Shifts Strategies on Jan 17, 2017
The race to the bottom impact continues. Now, Everfocus, who used to be one of the larger budget providers, is shifting strategies after years of...
Genetec Favorability Results on Jan 16, 2017
In the race to the bottom and flight to 'solutions', Genetec has taken a contrary path. The company remains independent, focusing up market,...
IP Networking Course January 2017 on Jan 12, 2017
This is the only networking course designed specifically for video surveillance professionals plus it includes live training, personal help and...
Honeywell Ademco Vista Intrusion System Tested on Jan 11, 2017
One of the biggest brands in security holds one of the most common intrusion lines. We bought and tested a Honeywell Vista 15P intrusion...
HD Analog Usage Rising But Barriers Growing on Jan 09, 2017
The good news for HD analog is that its usage is rising, fairly significantly since our 2015 HD analog usage statistics. The bad news for HD...
Introduction To Burglar Alarm Systems on Jan 04, 2017
While alarm systems are popular, balancing between the right level of protection, the appropriate components and an acceptable price can be very...
Bosch Blue Line Intrusion Motion Detector Tested on Jan 03, 2017
False alarms from motion sensors are one of the most aggravating parts of intrusion detection.   Bosch says their sensors are better, even...
IP Networking 2017 Book Released on Jan 02, 2017
The new IP Networking Book 2017 is a 197 page in-depth guide that teaches you how IT and telecom technologies impact modern security systems. The...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Vivotek Favorability Results on Jan 20, 2017
Financially, Vivotek is doing relatively well. The company did ~$130 million in 2015 revenue and 2016 revenue (through Q3 reported) was up more...
PR Firm Pleads Don't Scrap PR Spending on Jan 20, 2017
PR is not dying, warns pleads PR firm. Take 40+ year old industry PR firm LRG, who recently lamented the 'misconceptions' that: Traditional PR...
Getting Started With Your IPVM Membership on Jan 20, 2017
Here's how to get started and get the most out of your IPVM membership. Books for Members All members can download the 3 member-only books below...
Jim Cramer Sucks Up To Knightscope on Jan 19, 2017
Credit must be given to Knightscope. They are raising money right now and despite their $80 million pre-money valuation against a lowly sub $1...
ADT Launches Canopy - Professional Monitoring For DIY Devices on Jan 19, 2017
The intrusion industry has criticized DIY security systems for years, claiming systems like Canary or Scout cannot match professionally installed...
Dahua UnFavorability Results on Jan 19, 2017
Dahua, the mega-Chinese surveillance manufacturer not primarily owned by the Chinese government has been trying to break out of the shadow of...
Paxton Hosted Access - Disruptive Low Dealer Pricing on Jan 19, 2017
Paxton is entering the hosted access game, with BLU, at a cost that is a fraction of key competitors. The different approach could be very...
Geovision Launches Direct Cloud Offering on Jan 18, 2017
Add cloud, subtract integrator. Geovision has launched myGVcloud, an offering that allows consumers to buy cameras and cloud services directly...
Anixter / Bosch Sells Direct to Amazon on Jan 18, 2017
Anixter regularly says they do not sell direct to end users or that they do not do it anymore. However, over the past year, Anixter has sold Bosch...
Smart Power Tools For Security Installs on Jan 18, 2017
Installing a smart camera? Perhaps you should use a 'smart' drill. The intelligent appliance / IoT trend has hit power tools. In this note, we...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact