Access: IP Readers vs. Control Panels

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Jun 16, 2012

Should you continue to use traditional centralized, panel-based access control or does it make sense to use IP readers? Let's overview the 2 key options:

  • Control panels: Traditional access control systems have used control panels, typically controlling two, four, either, or more doors each. In these configurations, door devices are typically homerun to centrally located panels, though in larger facilities, panels may be distributed throughout. The panels, in turn, typically connect to the access control server via IP, though older or low-end systems may still use serial data connections.
  • IP readers: In the second, more recent, approach, intelligence is moved to the door, with a small (1-2 door) control panels located throughout a facility. While some readers now accept a direct IP connection, many deployments move the controller to the edge connecting to a traditional reader very close by. To that end, 'IP reader' is a misnomer, but expresses the intent of this shift.

The traditional approach of larger control panels has caused some problems:

  • Often, customers were forced to install four-door control panels to control one or two doors, which drove cost for these small systems up drastically.
  • Adding a door here or there, out of reach of existing the existing panel or panels, required a new multi-door panel to be installed.
  • IT staff is less comfortable with traditional security wiring. As security systems have become more IP-based, they have fallen more and more under control of network engineers and RCDDs. IP readers allow these designers to follow more familiar cabling topologies, making them more attractive.

While the traditional panel approach has issues, concerns about moving to IP readers also raised concerns including issues with sufficient power, manufacturer support, economics and scalability.

For background, we recommend you review HID makes the case for the edge to see how manufacturers pitch the idea of IP to skeptics.

Inside the Pro section, we examine the tradeoffs, key issues involved and make recommendations on best fits.

****** *** ******** ** *** *********** ***********, *****-***** ****** ******* or **** ** **** ***** ** *** ** *******? ***'* overview *** * *** *******:

  • ******* ******: *********** ****** ******* ******* **** **** ******* ******, ********* *********** two, ****, ******, ** **** ***** ****. ** ***** **************, door ******* *** ********* ******* ** ********* ******* ******, ****** in ****** **********, ****** *** ** *********** **********. *** ******, in ****, ********* ******* ** *** ****** ******* ****** *** IP, ****** ***** ** ***-*** ******* *** ***** *** ****** data ***********.
  • ** *******: ** *** ******, **** ******, ********, ************ ** ***** ** the ****, **** * ***** (*-* ****) ******* ****** ******* throughout * ********. ***** **** ******* *** ****** * ****** IP **********, **** *********** **** *** ********** ** *** **** connecting ** * *********** ****** **** ***** **. ** **** end, '** ******' ** * ********, *** ********* *** ****** of **** *****.

*** *********** ******** ** ****** ******* ****** *** ****** **** problems:

  • *****, ********* **** ****** ** ******* ****-**** ******* ****** ** control *** ** *** *****, ***** ***** **** *** ***** small ******* ** ***********.
  • ****** * **** **** ** *****, *** ** ***** ** existing *** ******** ***** ** ******, ******** * *** *****-**** panel ** ** *********.
  • ** ***** ** **** *********** **** *********** ******** ******. ** security ******* **** ****** **** **-*****, **** **** ****** **** and **** ***** ******* ** ******* ********* *** *****. ** readers ***** ***** ********* ** ****** **** ******** ******* **********, making **** **** **********.

***** *** *********** ***** ******** *** ******, ******** ***** ****** to ** ******* **** ****** ******** ********* ****** **** ********** power, ************ *******, ********* *** ***********.

*** **********, ** ********* *** ********* ***** *** **** *** *** **** ** *** *** ************* ***** *** **** ** ** ** skeptics.

****** *** *** *******, ** ******* *** *********, *** ****** involved *** **** *************** ** **** ****.

[***************]

****: ****** *** ******, ** **** *** *** **** '**** controllers' ****** **** '** *******' *** ******* ********* ******** ** describing *** *** ** ** ** *** **** *** ****** control.

***************

*********** *** ** **** *********** **. *********** ****** ******* ** 3 *********** *********:

  • **** **** ****** ******* ********** ****** ******* **?
  • **** **** ***** ******* **?
  • **** ** *** *****/****** ******* ** *** ******?

*** ***** ***** ** *** ********: **** *** ****** ********** system ** *** ** ******* ******* ***** ***** ** *******? While **** *********** **** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** past ****** ** ***** (********** *** *********), * ****** ** systems ***** **** *******, ** ******* **** **-*** ********* ********. 

*** ****** ********* ************* **** ********* ** *********** ** ******* PoE **** ******* ****** ******* ** ***** *** ****** *****. Be **** ** ***** *** ******* ******** ***** *** ****** and ******** *******, ** **** **** *** ********** ****** **** be **********. ****** *** ******** ***** ********** ******* ** **** holding ******** ******** **** ******* **** ***** **** ***-******* *********** will *******, ** ** ***** ***** * ******** ***** ****** must ** ********, ****** *********** **** ******* ********* ** ***** to *** ****.

********* ****** ****, ***** ** ** **** *** **** **** as ** ***** **** *********** *** ***********, *** ** ********* the *********:

  • ** **** ***** ******* (*-* *****):******* *********** ** *** **** ***** * *** ** *****. ******* and ************ ******** *** **** *******, *** ********** * ****** door *****'* ******* *** ******** ** * ****-**** *****, **** three ****** *****. *******, ***** ******-**** *********** ******* ** ****** ******* system ** ****** *** ** **** *** ****** ******* ** frequent ******* *** ****, ** **** ********** **** ** ********** individually. For * ****** ** ***** ** * ***** ********, **** most ****** **** *** ** **** ** * ********.
  • ** ******-***** ******* (*-** *****):**** *********** **** **** * *** ** ***** ** ******* of **** ****, ** ****'** *** ** *** **** *********** hundreds ** ***** ******** ** ******-**** *********** ****** * ******** or ****** ******* **********. ****** **** ****** ** ***** ** * network ** ******** *** **** ** ** *****, ******, ** it ****** ****** ***** **********, *** **** **** ** *** switches *** ** ******** *** ********** ****** ****.
  • ** *****-***** *******:**** ****** ** **** ** ****** ** ****** ********-**** ******* panels ** ******* ** ******-**** ***********. *********** * ******* ** ******* only *** ****** *********** **** *** *********** ****. *******, ********* ****** management ******** **** ******** **** *********** **** ***** ****** ***** may ** ***** ** *** ********* ***** ** * **** lower *** **** *********** ****.

Basics ** ***** **** ***********

***** ***** *** **** ********* ******* ************* ** **** ***********, there *** **** ****** ************ **** *****:

  • *****-****-********: *** ** *** ******* ******* ******* ***** ** **** controllers ** *****-****-******** **********. **** ****** *** *** ********** ** be ******* **** *** ****, ******** *** ***** **** *** traditionally *** **** * *********** ******* *****. ** **** ********** power ************, ***** ** ********** ***** ******** **** ** ** installed *** **** *******. *** *** *** ** * **** choice *** ***** ****, *******, ***** **’** ******* *****.
  • ********** *******: ******* *** ********** ** *** **** ******** **** *****-**** cable ** ** ***. ******* *****-***** ******* ******* *********** *******, typically * *-********* *** *** ******, *** ********* *** *** door ******** ******, **** ********* *** *** *******-**-**** ******, *** two ** **** ********** *** *** ****. ***** ****** *** either *** **********, ** *** * ********* ***** ***** **** all **** ******** ****** ** *** **** ******. *** ********* cable ***** **** ***** ** ***** *******, *** ****** ****** is *********.
  • ***** ******** ******: **** *********** **** ****** ******** ****** ** *** ****. Each ********** ***** *** ****** ******** *** ********* ****** ******* at *** ****(*) ** ********. **** ******* *****-**** *********** ** a ****** ***** ** ******* ** *** ******. ** *** controller ****** ** ****, **** **** ********** ** ****, *** two, ** ****, ** **** *****.

Cost ***********

*** ****** ***** *** ***** ** ****** *******, ******** ******* building ************: *’ **** ******* **** ******* *****. ****** *** based ** ***** ***’ **** **** *** ***, ******** **** ********, *** ** ******* **** ** ******** *************’ ****-**** ******* panels. ** ***** ***’ *** *** *******: *. ** ** the ******* ***** ****** **** ***** **** *********** ** ** is ********* *****-****, *** *. **** ******* **** ********* ***** limited ** ***’, ** **** ** *** * **** ****** ground. 

 

 ****-********
*****************
**********
***** *********/*
*************
*************
***** *** **** *****$****$****

** *** *******, * *********** *******. **** ** ****, *******, that *** **** ***** ******* ******** *** ******** *** ** place, *** ** ******** ***** ** ******. **** *** ******** must ** ********, *** **** *********.

******** * ***** *** ****** ******, ***** ** ***** ********* as *** ******-**** ***** **** ****** ** **** ** **** scenario, *** ****** $*** ****. **** ** *********** *** ****** a ******-***** ** ******, ***** *** ****** *** * *** hundred ******* ****. ***** ********* *** ****** ** ********* **** savings.

******* **** ***** *** **** ****** ** **** ** *** access ********** ********. **** ****** ******* ****** ** *** **** built-in ********** *** **-***** **********; ********* ****** **** *** *** HID **** *** *** ****** **********. ****** ** *** ********, which ** ********* *** ****, *** * ** ** **** mix ***** *** ******* ****.

Should * *** ***?

***** *** ** ** ********* ******* *** **** ********** *******, using ** ******* ** *** *** *****:

  • ***** ****** ************: ***** ** ****** ******* ** ************ *** **** ** locking ********, ** ***** ******** **** **-**% ** **** ** the ***** ** *** ****** *** ********** *** *** **** edge ***********. ** * ***** ****** ** **** *************’ *************** locks *** ******** **** ******* ** *** **** **** ******** more ***** **** **** **** *********** **** ****** (>***-*****). ********* speaking, **** ****** ** ***** **** ******** *******, *** ***-*******-***** mag ***** (*** ***. ** *****) **** ** **** **** many **** ***********. ******* ****-***** *** *********** ***** ******** ** almost ********** ** **** *** **** *****. **** * ***** standpoint, *** ********** *** ******* ** ** *** **** ***** brands (***,**********) **** ***** ***-******* ***********, ** **** **** ** ***** heaviest-duty ***** **** ***** *** ******* ***** ** **** * PoE ********** *** ******. ************-********** (*** ******, **********, ***.) **** ** ** **** ***** hungry *** **** ****** ** ****. ****, ***** **** ******* should *** **** **** ***** **** *** ********** **** ******, biometric ******* **** ** **** ******** *** **** ******* ***.
  • ***** ******* ********: ** *** **** ** ** *** **** ** ******, it ********* **** ****** ** **** ** ***** *******. *******, in *** **** ** ***** ******** **** ***** ********, ***** electric *******, *** **** *** ****** ******. ** ***** ***** outages, **** ** ******* *** * *******, ** *** ******** powering *** **** ********** **** ********* ** ****** **. **** large ***** ********* ** *** *** *** **** **** *-* hours, *******. ** *** **** ** ******** ***** *******, *******, once *** *** *** ******, *** *** ********** *** **** power, ***** **** ** ** *** ** ************** **** *** doors **** **** ****** ****. ** ***** *****, **** **** be ****, ** *** **** ****** ****. ** ****** ****, it ** *********** **** ******** ***** ** ******* *** * separate *******-****** ***** ****** **** ** **** *** **** ** budget ******.

Mercury “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”

** **** *******, ** ****** ******* ******** ********** “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”. ***** *** ********** ****-**** ****** *******, ** **** ***** some ********* ******* **, *********:

******* ********* *** ******* *********: ** *****, **** ********* *** ****** ************* **** ******** networks *** **********, **** ****** **** ******* ** ** ******** for ******* ************. **** **** ** *** ******* ** **** industries -- ** ************ ***** ****** *** ** ** ****.

  • ******* ********: ********* ** *******, ***** *** **** ******* ** play ****: *. ********* ******* ***** *** *** *********** ********* ***** the **** ** *******. *. *** *** ******** ******* ***. *. *** all ******** *** ********** ** ** ** *** **** ****. 4. The ****** *********** *** ******* * **** ** ******* ********.
  • *** ********: ** ***** ***** **** *** ** *** ***** are ***** ********. ******* **** *** ************ **** ** ***** on * ****-**-**** *****. ****, ******* ***** *** *** ** available. *******, ****** ******* ******* ** ****** ********** *** ** be *********, *** ** ********* ** *** **** *********** *****, is **** ********* **** ******* * ****** *** ** *** door. ******** ********** *** *** ** * *******. ********* ** the **** ******** ***** ****, *******, ** *** ** * problem, ******, ** *** ***’* ****** *** ***** ******** *** the ******* ******. ******* * ****** ***** ***** *** ********* a *** ******* ***** ******, ** ********* * *** *******, are ********** ******* **** ** *** **** ****. *** **** issue ** **** ********* ** *****. ** ******** *** ********* for ******** *******, ******* ** ** ********** ** **** ***** in ***** ******** ** ***** ********* ***********. *** ****** ** compromising ** **** ********** *** ** ********* ******** ** ****** VLANs, ** **** ****** ******** * ******** **** *** ***** it **** ***** ** ****** ** *** *** ******* ***** than **** ** ** *** ****** ******* ****.

***** **** ** *********: *** ***** ******* ** *** **** ** **** ******** cabling *** ********* ******** ******* ************** **** ** **** ***** TCO **** ***** *********** **-*** ********* ***********.

  • ******* ********: ***** ******** **** *** ******* ** ** ******** to ****** ** ********** ******** *******, ******* ** ** **** or ******** *****. ******* ** ***** ** ********** * ******** LAN *** ** ***** *********** (** ***** *** ********** *** attest). ************, ** ********, **** ** ********* ******* ******** ******** to ** ** **** ** *** ****** *******, ******* **** to ** ****, ***., *** ********* ****** ******** ********* *********** (which ** *** **** ****** **).
  • *** ********: ** *****. ** **** **********, ***** ** ****** advantage ** ******* * *** *** ***** ** * ****. Also ******** **** ** **** *******, *******-***** ******* *** *** example, * ***** ****** ******: ********* **-***-***** ******-**** ***********. **** reduces *******, **** ****** ** *** ***** ***** ** * loop *************, ******* ** *******.

******** *** ** ***** *** **** ********: **** **** ****** ** ********* ************ ** ** *** security ********.

  • ******* ********: ************, *** ********** ****** ** *** “***% ******” is ***********. ** *** ** *****, **.*% ****** *** ** acceptable. ** *** ******** *****, **** ******* ** * **** workday (*.** *****) *** **** ** ********, ***** ******** ***** would **** ************. ** **** ****** ** *** **** **** IT *** *** ***** ****** ** ******* ******* ** ******** staff, ** ******** ***** *** **** ** **** ****** * problem ***** ** *** ******** *******.
  • *** ********: *** ********** ** ****** ** * ***** *******. Even ** **** ******* *** **** **** ****** ***, ** would ***** ****** ** *** ******* ** ******** ***** ****. We ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** **** **** ************. *******, most ******* ***** ** *** *** ****** *** **** ** five ***** ** ****** (**.**% ** **.***%), ***** ******* **** drastically. ************, *** ****** ** *** ******* ***** **** *** vary. ** **** ********** ***** *** ********** ******** *******, *** does *** **** ** *********** ** * ******* ****** ** other *********** ****** ** ***** ******, *** **** ******* **** still ********. ** *** ****** ** ***** ********* ** ********, however, ** **** ** * ***** *******, ***** ***** ***** will **** ** **** **** ** ********* ** ***** *****. Access ** ** ****** ** **** ** * *******. ******* may *****, *** ** ***** ** ***** ** ** ** extreme ***** **** ***** *********** ****** ****** ***********.

***-**-***, *** ******* ********** ********** ******* *** *********** ** *** network *** ********** ****** ******* ****** ****** *********** ******** **** edge-based ***********. **** *** ***** ******** ********, ***+, ********* ************* between *********** *** *** ****, *** ****** ******* (********** ** some ****-***** *** **** *********** ** *********), ** ********* ************** in ****** ******. **’* ***** **** ***** *** ** *********** recommendations.

Manufacturer *********

**** ********** ****-***** ****** *******, ***** *** *** ***** ************* providing **** ******** *********:

  • ***:*** ******** *** **** *** ***** *********, ***** *** **** **** ** ***** **** *** *******, *** ******** ** **** ***-***** ********* *** ********. **** are ********* *** *** ** ****-***** *******, *** *** **** is ********* ** *** **** *******, * ***-********** ****** **** standalone ****.
  • *******:******* **** ******** ******** ****-***** ********: *** ****** ** * *****-**** ********** **** * ******-**** ********* ***** **** it. ** ** ******* ** *********** ** ***** ******* ****** the ***** ** **** ******-**** **********, ** *** **** ***-**** *********. *** **** *** **** **** ********** ***** **** to *** ****** *** **-***. *** ***** ** ****** ****** - ** ********-***** “****” **** ********* **** ** ********** **-*****. It ****** ************ **** *** ****** *** ********, ***** *** access ******* ********* *** ****.

************, *********** ******* ***** **** **** ** *** ***** ************* such **: ** (*********)********* (******-***)******** (*******-*)** (*********), *** ******** ***** (***** ****)

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Access Control Course Winter 2018 on Jun 11, 2017
The Winter 2018 IPVM Access Control Course is now open; save $50 on early registration. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access control course...
RMR Integrator Importance Statistics on Jun 08, 2017
How do integrators feel about offering RMR / recurring revenue services? For many, their business revolves around RMR, while others see no...
HID Edge EVO Tested on Jun 07, 2017
HID Edge controllers have been one of most common offerings in IP door controllers for years. The new generation is called Edge EVO. We tested...
Access Control AHJ Nightmares on Jun 01, 2017
For access control jobs, a single person can be the difference between finishing a job, costing thousands in extra dollars, and being profitable...
US States Security Licensing Guide on May 30, 2017
In the US, many states require integrators to be licensed to install burglar alarms, CCTV, electronic access control, or all three, and...
Anti-Hack Access Card Shields Tested on May 26, 2017
Keeping your access control card information secure is becoming a big priority, especially since cheaper copiers can hack details easily. Multiple...
Arlo Go Cellular Cloud Camera Tested on May 23, 2017
Totally wireless surveillance cameras are growing but almost all typically depend on a hub and local Internet access. However, many outdoor...
Hackable 125kHz Access Control Migration Guide on May 19, 2017
Despite being one of the most popular credentials, 125 kHz credentials are easily copied and insecure as we showed in our test results, video...
Alarm Circuits Guide on May 09, 2017
Alarm circuits are a fundamental element of wired burglar systems. Designing the alarm circuit greatly affects its performance. In particular,...
Smartphone Controlled Kevo Lock Tested on May 04, 2017
Smartlocks are a growing market, with millions sold. Kwikset's Kevo is one of the most common choices, using the Unikey smart phone access control...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Importance of Sales To Integrators - Statistics on Jun 23, 2017
One of the top trends in the industry over the past few years has been the rise of across-the-board sales (e.g.: Hikvision Sales, Dahua Sale,...
Deep Learning Surveillance Startups Deep Problem on Jun 23, 2017
The undeniably good news for the video surveillance market is that we are seeing the rise of more startups than in many years. The cause of this...
Avigilon Announces RADAR-Based Presence Detector on Jun 22, 2017
RADAR is gaining momentum within physical security. Two months after Axis announced a network radar detector, Avigilon has announced a RADAR-Based...
Covert Cloud Camera Service Launching (KJB) on Jun 22, 2017
Cloud IP cameras, for consumers, has become increasingly commonplace. However, covert cameras, lag there, with few options. Now, North America's...
Manufacturers Shipping Unlicensed H.265 Products on Jun 22, 2017
While H.265 support in video surveillance is growing, IPVM's research shows that most surveillance manufacturers are shipping H.265 products with...
Uniview Low-Cost Bullet PTZ Tested on Jun 21, 2017
Uniview is offering a HD zoom bullet camera, the IPC742SR9-PZ30-32G, with an integrated pan / tilt positioner, for the price of a low-cost...
QSR Video Surveillance Best Practices on Jun 21, 2017
Fast food restaurants or QSRs (quick service restaurants), are frequent victims of crime and fraud. Because they are open late, deal with cash, and...
45 Drives 'Lowest Cost' Enterprise Storage Company Profile on Jun 21, 2017
45 Drives claims the "lowest cost per Hard Drive Slot in the industry." But who or what is '45 Drives'? What started as a product design to...
No Hack, Still Liable, Court Finds ADT on Jun 20, 2017
Recently, ADT has been in the news for a $16 million settlement for a cyber security vulnerability class action suit. One of the most important...
Resolver / PPM 2000 Incident Management Platform Profile on Jun 20, 2017
You might have seen the company whose employees wear hockey jerseys at trade shows and wondered "what do they do?" PPM 2000 has been active in...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact