Access: IP Readers vs. Control Panels

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Jun 16, 2012

Should you continue to use traditional centralized, panel-based access control or does it make sense to use IP readers? Let's overview the 2 key options:

  • Control panels: Traditional access control systems have used control panels, typically controlling two, four, either, or more doors each. In these configurations, door devices are typically homerun to centrally located panels, though in larger facilities, panels may be distributed throughout. The panels, in turn, typically connect to the access control server via IP, though older or low-end systems may still use serial data connections.
  • IP readers: In the second, more recent, approach, intelligence is moved to the door, with a small (1-2 door) control panels located throughout a facility. While some readers now accept a direct IP connection, many deployments move the controller to the edge connecting to a traditional reader very close by. To that end, 'IP reader' is a misnomer, but expresses the intent of this shift.

The traditional approach of larger control panels has caused some problems:

  • Often, customers were forced to install four-door control panels to control one or two doors, which drove cost for these small systems up drastically.
  • Adding a door here or there, out of reach of existing the existing panel or panels, required a new multi-door panel to be installed.
  • IT staff is less comfortable with traditional security wiring. As security systems have become more IP-based, they have fallen more and more under control of network engineers and RCDDs. IP readers allow these designers to follow more familiar cabling topologies, making them more attractive.

While the traditional panel approach has issues, concerns about moving to IP readers also raised concerns including issues with sufficient power, manufacturer support, economics and scalability.

For background, we recommend you review HID makes the case for the edge to see how manufacturers pitch the idea of IP to skeptics.

Inside the Pro section, we examine the tradeoffs, key issues involved and make recommendations on best fits.

****** *** ******** ** *** *********** ***********, *****-***** ****** ******* or **** ** **** ***** ** *** ** *******? ***'* overview *** * *** *******:

  • ******* ******: *********** ****** ******* ******* **** **** ******* ******, ********* *********** two, ****, ******, ** **** ***** ****. ** ***** **************, door ******* *** ********* ******* ** ********* ******* ******, ****** in ****** **********, ****** *** ** *********** **********. *** ******, in ****, ********* ******* ** *** ****** ******* ****** *** IP, ****** ***** ** ***-*** ******* *** ***** *** ****** data ***********.
  • ** *******: ** *** ******, **** ******, ********, ************ ** ***** ** the ****, **** * ***** (*-* ****) ******* ****** ******* throughout * ********. ***** **** ******* *** ****** * ****** IP **********, **** *********** **** *** ********** ** *** **** connecting ** * *********** ****** **** ***** **. ** **** end, '** ******' ** * ********, *** ********* *** ****** of **** *****.

*** *********** ******** ** ****** ******* ****** *** ****** **** problems:

  • *****, ********* **** ****** ** ******* ****-**** ******* ****** ** control *** ** *** *****, ***** ***** **** *** ***** small ******* ** ***********.
  • ****** * **** **** ** *****, *** ** ***** ** existing *** ******** ***** ** ******, ******** * *** *****-**** panel ** ** *********.
  • ** ***** ** **** *********** **** *********** ******** ******. ** security ******* **** ****** **** **-*****, **** **** ****** **** and **** ***** ******* ** ******* ********* *** *****. ** readers ***** ***** ********* ** ****** **** ******** ******* **********, making **** **** **********.

***** *** *********** ***** ******** *** ******, ******** ***** ****** to ** ******* **** ****** ******** ********* ****** **** ********** power, ************ *******, ********* *** ***********.

*** **********, ** ********* *** ********* ***** *** **** *** *** **** ** *** *** ************* ***** *** **** ** ** ** skeptics.

****** *** *** *******, ** ******* *** *********, *** ****** involved *** **** *************** ** **** ****.

[***************]

****: ****** *** ******, ** **** *** *** **** '**** controllers' ****** **** '** *******' *** ******* ********* ******** ** describing *** *** ** ** ** *** **** *** ****** control.

***************

*********** *** ** **** *********** **. *********** ****** ******* ** 3 *********** *********:

  • **** **** ****** ******* ********** ****** ******* **?
  • **** **** ***** ******* **?
  • **** ** *** *****/****** ******* ** *** ******?

*** ***** ***** ** *** ********: **** *** ****** ********** system ** *** ** ******* ******* ***** ***** ** *******? While **** *********** **** ****** **** **** ****** ** *** past ****** ** ***** (********** *** *********), * ****** ** systems ***** **** *******, ** ******* **** **-*** ********* ********. 

*** ****** ********* ************* **** ********* ** *********** ** ******* PoE **** ******* ****** ******* ** ***** *** ****** *****. Be **** ** ***** *** ******* ******** ***** *** ****** and ******** *******, ** **** **** *** ********** ****** **** be **********. ****** *** ******** ***** ********** ******* ** **** holding ******** ******** **** ******* **** ***** **** ***-******* *********** will *******, ** ** ***** ***** * ******** ***** ****** must ** ********, ****** *********** **** ******* ********* ** ***** to *** ****.

********* ****** ****, ***** ** ** **** *** **** **** as ** ***** **** *********** *** ***********, *** ** ********* the *********:

  • ** **** ***** ******* (*-* *****):******* *********** ** *** **** ***** * *** ** *****. ******* and ************ ******** *** **** *******, *** ********** * ****** door *****'* ******* *** ******** ** * ****-**** *****, **** three ****** *****. *******, ***** ******-**** *********** ******* ** ****** ******* system ** ****** *** ** **** *** ****** ******* ** frequent ******* *** ****, ** **** ********** **** ** ********** individually. For * ****** ** ***** ** * ***** ********, **** most ****** **** *** ** **** ** * ********.
  • ** ******-***** ******* (*-** *****):**** *********** **** **** * *** ** ***** ** ******* of **** ****, ** ****'** *** ** *** **** *********** hundreds ** ***** ******** ** ******-**** *********** ****** * ******** or ****** ******* **********. ****** **** ****** ** ***** ** * network ** ******** *** **** ** ** *****, ******, ** it ****** ****** ***** **********, *** **** **** ** *** switches *** ** ******** *** ********** ****** ****.
  • ** *****-***** *******:**** ****** ** **** ** ****** ** ****** ********-**** ******* panels ** ******* ** ******-**** ***********. *********** * ******* ** ******* only *** ****** *********** **** *** *********** ****. *******, ********* ****** management ******** **** ******** **** *********** **** ***** ****** ***** may ** ***** ** *** ********* ***** ** * **** lower *** **** *********** ****.

Basics ** ***** **** ***********

***** ***** *** **** ********* ******* ************* ** **** ***********, there *** **** ****** ************ **** *****:

  • *****-****-********: *** ** *** ******* ******* ******* ***** ** **** controllers ** *****-****-******** **********. **** ****** *** *** ********** ** be ******* **** *** ****, ******** *** ***** **** *** traditionally *** **** * *********** ******* *****. ** **** ********** power ************, ***** ** ********** ***** ******** **** ** ** installed *** **** *******. *** *** *** ** * **** choice *** ***** ****, *******, ***** **’** ******* *****.
  • ********** *******: ******* *** ********** ** *** **** ******** **** *****-**** cable ** ** ***. ******* *****-***** ******* ******* *********** *******, typically * *-********* *** *** ******, *** ********* *** *** door ******** ******, **** ********* *** *** *******-**-**** ******, *** two ** **** ********** *** *** ****. ***** ****** *** either *** **********, ** *** * ********* ***** ***** **** all **** ******** ****** ** *** **** ******. *** ********* cable ***** **** ***** ** ***** *******, *** ****** ****** is *********.
  • ***** ******** ******: **** *********** **** ****** ******** ****** ** *** ****. Each ********** ***** *** ****** ******** *** ********* ****** ******* at *** ****(*) ** ********. **** ******* *****-**** *********** ** a ****** ***** ** ******* ** *** ******. ** *** controller ****** ** ****, **** **** ********** ** ****, *** two, ** ****, ** **** *****.

Cost ***********

*** ****** ***** *** ***** ** ****** *******, ******** ******* building ************: *’ **** ******* **** ******* *****. ****** *** based ** ***** ***’ **** **** *** ***, ******** **** ********, *** ** ******* **** ** ******** *************’ ****-**** ******* panels. ** ***** ***’ *** *** *******: *. ** ** the ******* ***** ****** **** ***** **** *********** ** ** is ********* *****-****, *** *. **** ******* **** ********* ***** limited ** ***’, ** **** ** *** * **** ****** ground. 

 

 ****-********
*****************
**********
***** *********/*
*************
*************
***** *** **** *****$****$****

** *** *******, * *********** *******. **** ** ****, *******, that *** **** ***** ******* ******** *** ******** *** ** place, *** ** ******** ***** ** ******. **** *** ******** must ** ********, *** **** *********.

******** * ***** *** ****** ******, ***** ** ***** ********* as *** ******-**** ***** **** ****** ** **** ** **** scenario, *** ****** $*** ****. **** ** *********** *** ****** a ******-***** ** ******, ***** *** ****** *** * *** hundred ******* ****. ***** ********* *** ****** ** ********* **** savings.

******* **** ***** *** **** ****** ** **** ** *** access ********** ********. **** ****** ******* ****** ** *** **** built-in ********** *** **-***** **********; ********* ****** **** *** *** HID **** *** *** ****** **********. ****** ** *** ********, which ** ********* *** ****, *** * ** ** **** mix ***** *** ******* ****.

Should * *** ***?

***** *** ** ** ********* ******* *** **** ********** *******, using ** ******* ** *** *** *****:

  • ***** ****** ************: ***** ** ****** ******* ** ************ *** **** ** locking ********, ** ***** ******** **** **-**% ** **** ** the ***** ** *** ****** *** ********** *** *** **** edge ***********. ** * ***** ****** ** **** *************’ *************** locks *** ******** **** ******* ** *** **** **** ******** more ***** **** **** **** *********** **** ****** (>***-*****). ********* speaking, **** ****** ** ***** **** ******** *******, *** ***-*******-***** mag ***** (*** ***. ** *****) **** ** **** **** many **** ***********. ******* ****-***** *** *********** ***** ******** ** almost ********** ** **** *** **** *****. **** * ***** standpoint, *** ********** *** ******* ** ** *** **** ***** brands (***,**********) **** ***** ***-******* ***********, ** **** **** ** ***** heaviest-duty ***** **** ***** *** ******* ***** ** **** * PoE ********** *** ******. ************-********** (*** ******, **********, ***.) **** ** ** **** ***** hungry *** **** ****** ** ****. ****, ***** **** ******* should *** **** **** ***** **** *** ********** **** ******, biometric ******* **** ** **** ******** *** **** ******* ***.
  • ***** ******* ********: ** *** **** ** ** *** **** ** ******, it ********* **** ****** ** **** ** ***** *******. *******, in *** **** ** ***** ******** **** ***** ********, ***** electric *******, *** **** *** ****** ******. ** ***** ***** outages, **** ** ******* *** * *******, ** *** ******** powering *** **** ********** **** ********* ** ****** **. **** large ***** ********* ** *** *** *** **** **** *-* hours, *******. ** *** **** ** ******** ***** *******, *******, once *** *** *** ******, *** *** ********** *** **** power, ***** **** ** ** *** ** ************** **** *** doors **** **** ****** ****. ** ***** *****, **** **** be ****, ** *** **** ****** ****. ** ****** ****, it ** *********** **** ******** ***** ** ******* *** * separate *******-****** ***** ****** **** ** **** *** **** ** budget ******.

Mercury “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”

** **** *******, ** ****** ******* ******** ********** “*** **** ** ****** ** *** ****”. ***** *** ********** ****-**** ****** *******, ** **** ***** some ********* ******* **, *********:

******* ********* *** ******* *********: ** *****, **** ********* *** ****** ************* **** ******** networks *** **********, **** ****** **** ******* ** ** ******** for ******* ************. **** **** ** *** ******* ** **** industries -- ** ************ ***** ****** *** ** ** ****.

  • ******* ********: ********* ** *******, ***** *** **** ******* ** play ****: *. ********* ******* ***** *** *** *********** ********* ***** the **** ** *******. *. *** *** ******** ******* ***. *. *** all ******** *** ********** ** ** ** *** **** ****. 4. The ****** *********** *** ******* * **** ** ******* ********.
  • *** ********: ** ***** ***** **** *** ** *** ***** are ***** ********. ******* **** *** ************ **** ** ***** on * ****-**-**** *****. ****, ******* ***** *** *** ** available. *******, ****** ******* ******* ** ****** ********** *** ** be *********, *** ** ********* ** *** **** *********** *****, is **** ********* **** ******* * ****** *** ** *** door. ******** ********** *** *** ** * *******. ********* ** the **** ******** ***** ****, *******, ** *** ** * problem, ******, ** *** ***’* ****** *** ***** ******** *** the ******* ******. ******* * ****** ***** ***** *** ********* a *** ******* ***** ******, ** ********* * *** *******, are ********** ******* **** ** *** **** ****. *** **** issue ** **** ********* ** *****. ** ******** *** ********* for ******** *******, ******* ** ** ********** ** **** ***** in ***** ******** ** ***** ********* ***********. *** ****** ** compromising ** **** ********** *** ** ********* ******** ** ****** VLANs, ** **** ****** ******** * ******** **** *** ***** it **** ***** ** ****** ** *** *** ******* ***** than **** ** ** *** ****** ******* ****.

***** **** ** *********: *** ***** ******* ** *** **** ** **** ******** cabling *** ********* ******** ******* ************** **** ** **** ***** TCO **** ***** *********** **-*** ********* ***********.

  • ******* ********: ***** ******** **** *** ******* ** ** ******** to ****** ** ********** ******** *******, ******* ** ** **** or ******** *****. ******* ** ***** ** ********** * ******** LAN *** ** ***** *********** (** ***** *** ********** *** attest). ************, ** ********, **** ** ********* ******* ******** ******** to ** ** **** ** *** ****** *******, ******* **** to ** ****, ***., *** ********* ****** ******** ********* *********** (which ** *** **** ****** **).
  • *** ********: ** *****. ** **** **********, ***** ** ****** advantage ** ******* * *** *** ***** ** * ****. Also ******** **** ** **** *******, *******-***** ******* *** *** example, * ***** ****** ******: ********* **-***-***** ******-**** ***********. **** reduces *******, **** ****** ** *** ***** ***** ** * loop *************, ******* ** *******.

******** *** ** ***** *** **** ********: **** **** ****** ** ********* ************ ** ** *** security ********.

  • ******* ********: ************, *** ********** ****** ** *** “***% ******” is ***********. ** *** ** *****, **.*% ****** *** ** acceptable. ** *** ******** *****, **** ******* ** * **** workday (*.** *****) *** **** ** ********, ***** ******** ***** would **** ************. ** **** ****** ** *** **** **** IT *** *** ***** ****** ** ******* ******* ** ******** staff, ** ******** ***** *** **** ** **** ****** * problem ***** ** *** ******** *******.
  • *** ********: *** ********** ** ****** ** * ***** *******. Even ** **** ******* *** **** **** ****** ***, ** would ***** ****** ** *** ******* ** ******** ***** ****. We ******* ******** ***** ***** ****** **** **** ************. *******, most ******* ***** ** *** *** ****** *** **** ** five ***** ** ****** (**.**% ** **.***%), ***** ******* **** drastically. ************, *** ****** ** *** ******* ***** **** *** vary. ** **** ********** ***** *** ********** ******** *******, *** does *** **** ** *********** ** * ******* ****** ** other *********** ****** ** ***** ******, *** **** ******* **** still ********. ** *** ****** ** ***** ********* ** ********, however, ** **** ** * ***** *******, ***** ***** ***** will **** ** **** **** ** ********* ** ***** *****. Access ** ** ****** ** **** ** * *******. ******* may *****, *** ** ***** ** ***** ** ** ** extreme ***** **** ***** *********** ****** ****** ***********.

***-**-***, *** ******* ********** ********** ******* *** *********** ** *** network *** ********** ****** ******* ****** ****** *********** ******** **** edge-based ***********. **** *** ***** ******** ********, ***+, ********* ************* between *********** *** *** ****, *** ****** ******* (********** ** some ****-***** *** **** *********** ** *********), ** ********* ************** in ****** ******. **’* ***** **** ***** *** ** *********** recommendations.

Manufacturer *********

**** ********** ****-***** ****** *******, ***** *** *** ***** ************* providing **** ******** *********:

  • ***:*** ******** *** **** *** ***** *********, ***** *** **** **** ** ***** **** *** *******, *** ******** ** **** ***-***** ********* *** ********. **** are ********* *** *** ** ****-***** *******, *** *** **** is ********* ** *** **** *******, * ***-********** ****** **** standalone ****.
  • *******:******* **** ******** ******** ****-***** ********: *** ****** ** * *****-**** ********** **** * ******-**** ********* ***** **** it. ** ** ******* ** *********** ** ***** ******* ****** the ***** ** **** ******-**** **********, ** *** **** ***-**** *********. *** **** *** **** **** ********** ***** **** to *** ****** *** **-***. *** ***** ** ****** ****** - ** ********-***** “****” **** ********* **** ** ********** **-*****. It ****** ************ **** *** ****** *** ********, ***** *** access ******* ********* *** ****.

************, *********** ******* ***** **** **** ** *** ***** ************* such **: ** (*********)********* (******-***)******** (*******-*)** (*********), *** ******** ***** (***** ****)

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Why 3VR Failed on Feb 16, 2018
3VR destroyed transformed ~$65 million in VC funding into a $6.9 million exit. The reason they failed is simple. They bet on analytics. They...
Mercury Releases New Series 3 Redboard Access Panels on Feb 15, 2018
Mercury Security has their first major product release post-HID buyout, and things literally look different. The Series 3 SIO boards now are red...
Assa's Lowest Power Draw Maglock: Securitron M680E Examined on Feb 14, 2018
Securitron produces some of the most extreme maglocks on the market, including massively strong maglocks and even ones with integrated CCTV cams...
Arlo, Bigger Than Avigilon, More Valuable Than Axis on Feb 08, 2018
Arlo, the wireless IP camera offering that Netgear bought ~5 years ago for a few tens of millions is now doing more revenue than Avigilon and...
Cold Weather Dome Test on Jan 25, 2018
Cameras frequently cite super low-temperature specs, with -30° or even -40° common. But to see how popular dome models actually handle real world...
Door Closer Startup Lifedoor Aims To Prevent Fire Deaths on Jan 24, 2018
A startup named Lifedoor has a device with one basic function: Close doors during a fire. Closing doors is so powerful, UL and FDNY Fire Chiefs say...
PoE Powered Access Control Tutorial on Jan 19, 2018
Powering access control with Power over Ethernet is becoming increasingly common.  However, access requires more power than cameras, and the...
CES 2018 Show Final Report on Jan 12, 2018
This is IPVM's final edition of our 2018 CES show report. Below are already numerous images and commentary, with more coming tomorrow.   CES is...
The Interceptor Aims To Fix Vulnerability In Millions of Alarm Systems on Jan 08, 2018
Security executive Jeffery Zwirn claims a 'catastrophic' flaw exists in 'millions of alarm systems', and dealers could be liable if not fixed. The...
Access Control Course Winter 2018 on Jan 04, 2018
Learn more below about the Winter 2018 IPVM Access Control Course. Register here. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access control course in the...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Why 3VR Failed on Feb 16, 2018
3VR destroyed transformed ~$65 million in VC funding into a $6.9 million exit. The reason they failed is simple. They bet on analytics. They...
"Fear Mongering": Hikvision USA Cybersecurity Director Dismisses Chinese Government Ownership Concerns on Feb 16, 2018
The facts are: The Chinese government created Hikvision and is Hikvision's controlling shareholder. Hikvision's Chairman, a Communist Party...
16:9 vs 4:3 Video Aspect Ratio Statistics on Feb 16, 2018
What aspect ratio do security integrators prefer? The 'standard' 4:3 or the 'wide' 16:9 one? 100+ integrators told us what they preferred, with...
Mercury Releases New Series 3 Redboard Access Panels on Feb 15, 2018
Mercury Security has their first major product release post-HID buyout, and things literally look different. The Series 3 SIO boards now are red...
Last Chance February 2018 Camera Course on Feb 15, 2018
This is the last chance to get into the Winter camera course, starts next Tuesday. Register now. IPVM provides the best education, live online...
Hikvision DeepInMind Tested Terribly on Feb 15, 2018
While Hikvision is heavily marketing deep learning and 'AI' as their next big thing, new IPVM test results of their DeepInMind NVR shows their deep...
Genetec CEO: You Cannot Buy Trust on Feb 14, 2018
Genetec's CEO, Pierre Racz, delivered a direct message at their channel partner conference: Racz has become a focal point in the industry debate...
Assa's Lowest Power Draw Maglock: Securitron M680E Examined on Feb 14, 2018
Securitron produces some of the most extreme maglocks on the market, including massively strong maglocks and even ones with integrated CCTV cams...
Hanwha Wisenet X 5MP Camera Tested (XNV-8080R) on Feb 13, 2018
Wisenet X is Hanwha's high-end camera line. We tested their Wisenet X 1080p camera last year. Now Hanwha is offering 5MP cameras listing super low...
Top Problems For Integrator Project Management on Feb 13, 2018
Security projects routinely encounter issues that jeopardize deadlines, create confusion, and shrink profits. Unfortunately, there are common...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact