Member Discussion

Replacing Aged Hard Drives, When And How?

End user here. I've been tasked with creating a 5 year road map to replace old security equipment.

 

My thought for the 'biggest' thing is my NVR, which is an S2 NetVR750 with 128TB of storage in a RAID.  It's 3 years old, which doesn't seem like a long time until you look at HDD fail rates. (we've been fine so far).

 

Couple of related questions:  

First, from the big picture, does anyone out there have customers that  preemptively replace VMS HDDs every so often? If so, how long between? 3 years?  Or, do they just wait for them to die and hope for the best?

 

Second, more specifically, should I replace the hard drives, or the entire box? This is a completely loaded question since we all know how rapidly technology changes. Again, this is looking 3 years out so who knows what sort of mergers or new products would be out.  But, assuming it happened today and money wasn't an issue, is there any real point in replacing the actual server, or just the hard drives?

 

 

 

Login to read this IPVM discussion.

* ** *** ******** with **** ** ** deploy ******* *** *** storage *** *** *****.  We ******** ******** ** monitoring ******** *** ******** in ***** ** ******** failed ** ******* ****** in *** **** ***** and *** **** ******* out ** **** **** with *** ***** ********** itself **** *** ***** is *********.  ** ** this **** ********** **** 8-300TB ******.

*'** **** ** ****** opinion **** (*** ******** not *******), *** ***** technical ************** *** ********* vague *** ***** ** no ******* ********* ****** documentation. ** ******* ** hardware ********** ** ********* vendors **** *** *********** hard ******. ** *** have * ***** ********** that's ****, *** ** you **** **** *** IT ***** *** * would *** ***** ** time. ** ** ** working **** ** ****** to ******* **.

** *** *********** ******** the ******* *** ******* of **** ****** ** most ** ***** ***** end ***'*.  (******, **** want * *** ** money *** **** * hard *****).  **, * know **** **'* ******** to ** '*******'.  *'* just ********* ** ***** is *** ********* ** that ** ********* *** whole ***. ****** ******** hard ****** **** ******* for *** *********** ** OS. 

 

*'* ****** ******* ** anyone **** *** **** planned *** **** ****, routine ************ **** *********** like **** ******

*** **** * **** of, * **** ***** could **** ** ***** or ** *******, ****** having *** ****** ** recommended.

*'* ****** ** *** edge **** **** *+ year *** ********:

**** ****,
*** ********* ** **** monthly ****** ********* *** health ** ***** ** NAS-Dev. *** *** **** check *** ****** ** individual ***** ** ******* Manager > ***/*** > Health ****.
**** *: **** ************ Count * *** ****** Count * **** **-************** Count *
**** *: **** ************ Count * *** ****** Count **** **** **-************** Count *
**** *: **** ************ Count * *** ****** Count *** **** **-************** Count *

**** *: **** ************ Count * *** ****** Count ** **** **-************** Count * **** *: Disk ************ ***** * Bad ****** ***** * Disk **-************** ***** *

* ***** *** ********* failure *****:

*****://***.*********.***/****/*********-****-*****-*****-**-****/

** ******* *** *** 'biggest' ***** ** ** NVR, ***** ** ** S2 ******** **** ***** of ******* ** * RAID. **'* * ***** old, ***** *****'* **** like * **** **** until *** **** ** HDD **** *****... ****** I ******* *** **** drives...

**** *** *** ***** drives ***** *************?

***** ** ******** ********* between *************, ****** *** class.

** **** * ****** based ** ***+ ********** responses **** ****:***** ************ **** ***** Failure ********** ****

****** **** ** *********** responded **** ****** **** at * ***** ** longer, **% ** ***** indicated ****** ******* ****** 5 *****, *** ** many ** ** *****. Just *% ********* ******** of ***** * *****.

*** **** ******** ***** reasons *** ******* **** environmental/heat-related *** ***** ******, so *** *** **** to ******* **** ** your ******** *** ***********.

******* ** ******* ** Backblaze **********, ***** ***'* anything ***** **** ********* as **** **** ** possible, *** **** ** mind *** ********/************* *** power ************ ***** ****** are ****** **. ** is **** ****** ** much ****** **** **** VMS/NVR ***********, *******, **** also ******* * *** of **** ** ******* at "***,*** ******** **** drives ** *** ***** storage ********* ****** ****** three **** *******."

******, **** * *** an **********, * *** definitely ** *** **** of "******* *** ******** before *** **** ****** fail", **** ****** ******** every *-* ***** *** few/no ***** ******** ****** that **** *****.

* ***** ***** *** two ***** ** ****; one ** **********, *** other ** *********.

*** **********, ****** **** clean *****, ******* ************, a ***** ************ ********* drive ** *** *** immediate ******** ** ****** drive, *** * ***** power ****** (******** *** have **** ***** ********) for ********* ********.

**** * ********* ***** point, **** ** ******* server ***** * *****. If *** *** **** than * ***** *** of **, *****. **** still *******. 

** ******* ** ******* occurs , **** * years **** * ******

******* ** *** *** guarantee ***** ***** **** perform ** *** ******** , ** *** ************ recommendations 

** *** ** ** the ************ ***** **** have ****** *** *********** reviews 

 ******* ** ******* *******

***.**************.*** 

*****://***.*******.***/

 

** ********* **** ******** units **** ******* ************* 

**** : *** *** what *** *** *** 

*** *** **** *** you *** *** **** results **** **** 

** *** ****** * 5 **** ****  ** a ** **** *********** rule , **** **** budgets **** *** ****** 

** *** ********** ** the ******** 

**** *** ******* , check *** *** ***** ,

** ***'* ********* *****  the ***** ***** ********

**** ** ****  

* **** ** **** tech ******* *** ** nvr ************. ** *** drives **** *** *** time *** **** *** drives ******* *** *-** years. ** ******* ** the *********** - ***** conditioning, ***********, ********, ***... 

*** **** ** **** at **** **** *****. If *** **** ****, would ** ** ************? If **, ******* ****** preventativly. * *** ***** people *** **** ***** system ****** *****, ** until **** ****** ** review ** ******** *** then *** ****** ******* or ***'* ********, ***. 

*** ****** **** ** hard ****** ** * consumable, **** **** ********* vcr ***** *** *** vcr *****. 

* ********** ***** ******* the ****** ******* *-* years ***. ** *** plan ** ********* *** system ** *-* *****, then ******* *** ****** at **** * ** extend *** **** ** the ******. 

**** ************* ********* ********* drives ** ***** *****. 

**** ****** ** ** NVR ***** * ****** will ** ******* **** to *** ***** ***** the ***** * ****** will ** ******** ** opposed ** ** *** using * ***** **** will **** **** ***** constantly ******* ** **.

******* *** *** ******* 4 ****** *****  **** each ***** ***** **** 25% ** *** ****, I ***** ***** **** all *** ****** ** a ***** ***** *** need ******** ** **** as * *** ******* 1 *****.

** ******* ** *** nvr ************. **** **** I **** **** **** all ****** ********. **** speeds ** ******** ***** recording. 

* **** ***** **** an **** ***** ******** that's *****'* ******** **** stress ******** *** ******** a ***** ****** **** letting ** **** **********. Curious ** *** ***** hard ***** ********* *** there ***** *********** **** statement.

**** ******* **** *** hard ****** ****.

***** **** ******** *********** or ******** * ********* to ******* **** ****** so *** *** ******** when **** ** ****.

****-***** ********** ****** ****** replace *** ****** ****** every * - * ***** anyway (********* ** **** budget). ****'* **** ** important *** **** ****.

 

** ******* ** *** acceptable **** ** *** customer.  ** ** ** a ****** *** *** footage ** ** ******* multi-million ****** ********, ** pays ** ******* * drive ****** ** *****, unless ** ** *** up ** ****.

** ** ** ********** or ******** ** *************, you ********** ***'* **** to **** ****** *** footage.  **** * ******* store ** ***** *** and *** - ** there ** * ***** in *** *** ****** are **** *** **** have ** *******, **** then **** ***** ****** as *********....

****....

*** ** ************ ****** RAID. **** *** * miss?

 

***! ***** * ****** about ****.... 

** ****** ***** ******* the ****. **** ********* will **** **** *** drives ** **** ** replace... 

** ** ** * high ****** ********, ***** such ** * ******. I ***** ********* ************ replacement ** ***** * massive ******* ** ******** drives ****** *** ****. 

** * ******* ****, we *** ** *** our ********* ** ******** extended ********** **** **** or ** ** ***** the **** ******** *** parts *********** ******** ** to * *****.  ****** that, ** **** ** approach **** ** ** up ** *** ********'* risk *********.  **** **** we **** *****:

* **** **** ****** that **** ** ** within *** ***** **** of *** ******* * year ******.

* ****** **** *** hard ***** ******** *** rare *** ** ******.

* ** **** **** motherboards *** **** **** on *******.  ** ***** instance, *** ****** *** either ** **** *** or ****, ** ** was **** *** *****-**** mark.

* ***** ******** **** failed *** **** ********* power ********, ** **** a **** ****** ** time ** ***** ** this ****.

* ** ** ******** to ****** *********** ********* from ****** **** ** serversupply.com ** ****** *** quite **** ****.  *******, after *** ******* ** EOL *** ********** ** find ************ ****** ** become ************ "***********" ******* only.  ** **** *****, it ** ***** **** to *** ***-**** ********* for ****.

* **** ******* **** are ********** ********* ***** failures (*****, ********, ***** manufacturing **********) *** ***** clients **** ***** **** half * ******** ******* without ******* ** (******* manufacturing **********).  ******* ** the ******** *** ***** product ** ** *** of **** **********, *** budgets ***'* ******* * replacement, **** ** ***** pushing **** ** ******** a ****** ****** ***** with ******** ** ********.  Those ***** *** **** after * ******* *** usually *** **** ********.