Options and Challenge for Video Surveillance Integration

Author: John Honovich, Published on Aug 26, 2008

It's tough and getting tougher to figure out the best approach to integrate video surveillance with other security systems. While the industry conversation centers on the value of integration, the real challenge is how to make this happen, effectively, cost-efficiently and simply.

This challenge is growing and is not simply the standard issues in technology selection and design. A few years ago, the options were fairly clear (if exceedingly limited). Or speaking more precisely, the option was fairly clear: The access control system functioned as the command center and the other systems, such as video feed into the access control's platform.

Today, we have three categories, contenders if you will, for the role of master application in security systems:

  1. The Access Control System: the classic approach
  2. The PSIM system: the emerging trend of deploying a dedicated application managing traditional security systems
  3. The Video Surveillance System: a growing movement by video vendors to manage other systems

Which one do you choose? Which one is best? Which one will win?

Access Control

Access control is the most well developed of the options available, having been fostered over the last decade. Most access control systems can interface with a variety of video management systems. Key advantages include the fact that almost everyone has access control and adding in the interfaces is fairly inexpensive. The main customer drawback of access control systems as the central platform is that they tend to limit 3rd party support to products that most help their immediate sales. The larges incumbents such as GE, Tyco (Software House) and Honeywell have all been cited on these issues. Also, access control systems almost never support other access control system so if you need to support multiple access control systems, this generally will not work.

PSIM System

While PSIM stands for the concept of managing physical security information, it also covers a group of companies that are building dedicated applications whose sole purpose is to manage security systems such as access control and video management systems. Notable vendors include Orsus, Proximex and Vidsys. Because they are not owned or controlled by access control or video vendors, they can and do offer a wide variety of support for different manufacturers. They also are optimizing their solution for large-scale security management rather than extending an existing access control system. The downside is that you have to buy a new product that is neither cheap nor trivial to implement ($100,000 USD - $1,000,000+ USD).

Video Management

More and more, video management vendors are adding in PSIM functionalities into their system. For instance, VideoNEXT, traditionally a video management vendor, is now marketing a video + PSIM solutuion. Verint's Nextiva and OnSSI's Ocularis are bringing in PSIM features such as mapping, third party system integration, workflow management, etc. A key advantage is that it can be cheap and easy to add functionalities into a User Interface that a customer may already be using. However, limited or no support of other video systems is an important downside. To make it even more confusing, two of the PSIM vendors, Orsus and Proximex, offer powerful video monitoring solutions that provide better large scale camera monitoring than many video management vendors.

What to Do?

At a high level, I do not see one clearly winning approach nor an approach that is destined to win. The segment that has the best chance to win is the PSIM companies however they are clearly a niche player until they can bring the cost and complexity of implementation down so that it can be rapidly deployed at cost minimally higher than today's video and access systems. Until that time, it will make sense for most users to strongly consider expanding the functionality of their video and acccess systems (even if it constrains the functions and systems they can support).

That being said, I find this to be a disappointing state of affairs. While the benefits of integration are so frequently cited, until integration can be done broadly and inexpensively, most users will opt for low levels of integration.

Other Reports on Video Surveillance

HD Analog vs IP Guide 2016 on May 09, 2016
For years, HD resolution was IP camera's greatest advantage. However, starting in 2013, analog cameras with HD resolution started shipping and,...
License Plate Capture 4K Test on Jan 11, 2016
License plate capture is one of the most popular surveillance applications. IPVM has done extensive testing in this area already...
33 New Products Directory - Fall 2015 on Sep 28, 2015
 New products or major tech isssues that IPVM has reported on this summer / fall: Axis Releases Their Own Video Analytics Axis Non-IP Camera /...
Axis Digital Autotracking Tested on Sep 16, 2015
As camera resolutions continues to climb, the likelihood that you will ever display any camera at full resolution on a monitor declines. This is...
Vote Results - Next Big Thing 2020 on Sep 14, 2015
Over 230 integrators and manufacturers told us what they believe will be the next big thing in video surveillance 5 years from now, in 2020. The...
5 Low Cost IR Illuminators Tested on Sep 03, 2015
IR illumination has increased in popularity, with built in IR becoming a common feature in low-cost models. But when low light needs exceed the...
HD Analog Four Way Cameras Tested on Aug 28, 2015
One camera that delivers AHD, HDCVI, HDTVI and 960H, all for as little as $15 a camera. Both on price and claimed support, that is pretty...
Vehicle Entrance Camera Selection Guide on Jul 21, 2015
When it comes to vehicle surveillance, the conversation regularly turns to license plate capture. But other information, such as identifying...
Ethernet over Coax (EoC) Shootout on Jul 16, 2015
Reusing existing coax for IP cameras can cut installation costs dramatically. However, there are endless numbers of Ethernet over coax adapters...
Super Low Light HD Lens Tested on Jun 26, 2015
A smaller F-number can make a big difference in how much light reaches an imager. For example, the difference even between a f/1.2 and f/1.0,...

Most Recent Industry Reports

"The Most Secure Door Contacts Available" Claims Magnaspehere on May 23, 2016
Magnasphere says they are "the most secure door contacts available", claiming that typical door contacts can be defeated with only a cheap magnet,...
Integrator Compensation Report 2016 on May 23, 2016
IPVM has determined how much salespeople, senior technicians, and entry level technicians are earning in our 2016 Integrator Salary Survey. We...
Universal Camera Tester Tested (IPC-8600) on May 20, 2016
Setting up cameras is often a pain. A number of test tools exist but are frequently limited on camera support or have a small screen, slow...
Hikvision Makes First Western Acquisition - Alarm Manufacturer on May 19, 2016
Hikvision has $1.5 billion, at least, to spend internationally. Now, they have done their first Western acquisition, acquiring UK alarm...
Access Control Specification Guide on May 19, 2016
This 15 page report provides the most in-depth guidance on specifying Access Control systems you will find. Specifying Access Control correctly...
Aimetis Co-Founder Explains Why He Left The Security Industry on May 19, 2016
Aimetis' Chief Software Architect and co-founder, Mike Janzen, made the acquisition of Aimetis not only his exit from the company, but from the...
Axis / Canon Conflict on May 18, 2016
Canon spent $2.8B to acquire Axis, and in doing so created one of the industries largest product line conflicts. Despite obvious benefits of...
Avigilon "Probably Going To Zero Within The Next Two Years" Charges Analyst on May 18, 2016
The analyst who blasted Avigilon 2 weeks ago as being a Cash Strapped, Commodity Company is not backing down one bit. Indeed, the original target...
360° Motion Detection Camera Tested (Zmodo Pivot) on May 18, 2016
The Zmodo Pivot trumpets "motion detection in 360 degrees", claiming to detect and capture intruders behind itself, a truly rare camera...
Top 10 IP Camera Troubleshooting Tips on May 18, 2016
Troubleshooting IP cameras can be tricky and frustrating. Despite everything looking correct, it can still take some extra effort to bring IP...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact