Subscriber Discussion

Integrators: Do You Pay Techs To Wash Take-Home Vehicles?

UI
Undisclosed Integrator #1
Feb 15, 2018

My installers get paid for time on the job site, no travel time unless the project is far. They also drive personal vans/trucks.

 

 My service tech drives a company van and gets to take it home. I have always thought he should get paid when he gets to the first service call, and leaves the last service call. The trick is our office is on the outskirts of the city, and he happens to live next to the office. He also needs to come to the office frequently to stage equipment, pick stuff up, etc.

 

When do techs go on the clock?

 

What about washing the van? Is that something they should do off the clock? I have always felt like a take-home vehicle is a huge bonus, the least a tech could do is take an hour every week or two and wash it. I know I can not enforce the off the clock washing but is there a way to do this without having to pay a tech wage to wash a van?

 

 

UI
Undisclosed Integrator #2
Feb 15, 2018

Everyone is expected to have a commute to work. From home to office shouldn't be paid. If your employee chooses to live an hour away, he/she accepted that commute when they applied for the job. If theres a job site outside of your typical area, and they need to add more than an hour to their typical work day to get to the site, i think compensation is fair, which you should first build into the cost to the customer.  

We have found that a cost effective yearly membership at a no frills drive through car wash has kept us pretty clean and it didn't break the bank. The most our guys should spend at the location is 15 minutes and it can be done on the way to or back from a job site, even during a quick run to grab lunch. The cost of a yearly membership was just a few labor hours. You may not have a local spot where this would work, but this method surely beats the hose, bucket, and shammy in the driveway on a Saturday afternoon route when theres obviously a million other enjoyable things to do on your time off. If this doesn't work, tell your guys that if they want the luxury of a company van, you gotta keep it clean, plain and simple. And in return, you take it in for detail once or twice a year. Just my two cents =)

(4)
(1)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #3
Feb 15, 2018

For contract jobs we don't pay our installers any travel to the job site within a 40 mile radius of our office. For jobs 40 miles up to 125 miles we pay them travel one way only.  Anything beyond 125 miles we pay full travel both ways and usually end up staying overnight anyways for multi day projects. We find this policy is a fair compromise, yet allows us to be competitive in a much broader area, allowing us to get more work. (would a tech rather not be paid travel just one way and work all day, or sit at home because there is no work?)

For service calls our techs are paid from the time they leave the shop to the time they get back. These costs are billable to the customer.

As far as washing the truck goes....any tech that has a company truck is allowed to take it home, and use it for reasonable personal use, evenings and weekends (running errands, driving the kids to soccer etc....), so our expectation is that they would wash it on their own time and expense every so often, and every so often I expect to see a timesheet and expense reimbursement for the same.

Our policies might not be perfect, however, we think they are at least "fair" to all.

 

 

(4)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #4
Feb 15, 2018

Sorry this may not be a complete answer to your question.

If he picks up any material and transports it, he's on the clock. If he uses the van in the morning to come to the shop he's not necessarily on the clock yet, but if he's en route and you call him, his time starts for the day. Same goes for email and text if you require a response, granted those things shouldn't be done while driving. 

As for washing the company vehicle, that is on-the-clock time in my opinion. 

Also, this is one of those gray areas that depends on what state you're in along with other factors, but employees using their personal vehicles for business can have some tricky legal ramifications when it comes to insurance. In some states, the employer can be held liable for any injuries incurred by employees using their personal vehicles while on business. If an employee runs a red light and kills someone while they're working for you, you could be the one liable for it. Again, this depends on a lot of factors. Just something to be aware of.

(2)
(1)
UM
Undisclosed Manufacturer #5
Feb 15, 2018

If he's driving somewhere at your request, you should pay him for it.  Commute to the office isn't paid.  If it's a 5 minute commute to the office, and an 60 minute drive to the customer, you owe him for 55 minutes.  If he's washing your van, you should also pay for it. Either pay him for the time and reimburse him for the expense, or give him a $50 a month "car wash per diem", with a company policy that the van must be washed once every two weeks, or more often as needed.

 

Personally, if my employer expected me to drive all over town for free and then wash his van on the weekend, I'd be looking for another job. 

(5)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #3
Feb 15, 2018

 90% of the time our techs are going right to a job site from home so, using your logic, they are driving somewhere at my request.....are you suggesting that they should be paid for that? Home to a site, is no different than a commute to the office in my opinion.

I notice you are representing a manufacturer and this brings to mind another mildly related scenario I'd love your opinion on. If I am troubleshooting issues with your product that are either firmware, hardware issues etc...should I be compensated for the time to do so? If my manufacturer expects me to work for free for them shouldn't I be looking for a new manufacturer?

 

 

(1)
(1)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #4
Feb 15, 2018

If I am troubleshooting issues with your product that are either firmware, hardware issues etc...should I be compensated for the time to do so? If my manufacturer expects me to work for free for them shouldn't I be looking for a new manufacturer?

Not related IMO. Free market logic dictates you can change manufacturers any time you wish, no one is making you sell one manufacturer's product or another. If you're spending too much time and money troubleshooting a product, by all means move on to another product, but that time wasted is the cost of doing business. But you do have to pay your employees for time worked. We have labor laws for a reason.

Just my two cents.

(1)
UM
Undisclosed Manufacturer #5
Feb 15, 2018

are you suggesting that they should be paid for that?

Yes.  You asked them to drive somewhere.  Home to the office is commute.  Home to wherever you are telling them to go is on you.

 

On the manufacturer issue, you bought the product as is, and you agreed to pay for it in it's current format, bugs and all.  If there are too many bugs for you to tolerate, you should find a different manufacturer.  If the manufacturer was maliciously negligent, that's a different story.  

(2)
(1)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #3
Feb 15, 2018

I have a job site right now where I have 27 people driving from home directly to the site and you are saying I should be paying them for their commute? 

With an average 30 minute commute, times 27 techs at an average of $45 per hour, I'd be out over $600 every morning and the crew hasn't even put their boots on yet! LOL! 

Are people really winning jobs with those kinds of costs built in, or carrying that much overhead?

 

 

 

 

(1)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #8
Feb 19, 2018

Yes and yes.

 

For us, we pay them for their drive time minus however long it would have taken them to get to the office.

(3)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #3
Feb 15, 2018

So you feel that driving from home to a job site is paid time, yet home to an office isn't? 

I don't think labor law cover commutes to either home, or job site do they?

 

Avatar
Ethan Ace
Feb 15, 2018

Labor law does cover this. Your local laws may vary, but generally in the US you do not have to pay techs for driving to the work site from home, whether that is an office or a project site. 

However, if you require them to come to the office and then go to the job site, you pay them from the time they get to the office.

Again, I'm not a labor lawyer, but I've worked for an employer who got sued for not paying this way and lost. So I'd check to make sure you're in compliance.

Also, from a personal standpoint, any time I was a manger, I paid people for drives to the job site from their house if the site was more than an hour. It's not required, but I think it's fair. 

(2)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #4
Feb 15, 2018

It get's fuzzy depending on certain factors. Generally, travel from home to the office or job site (within a reasonable distance) is unpaid. FLSA covers that. There are also some special exceptions, like if the employee returned home at the end of the day and then was called to respond to an emergency. That time travelling would then be compensated.

Avatar
Daniel S-T
Feb 16, 2018

My first job was unionized, so our contract stated we were to be at the first job, or at the office for 08:30, and use up to 30 minutes of personal time to get there in the company vehicle. Anything beyond 30 minutes was paid time. Basically it meant leave your house at 08:00. Same with going home, done at 17:00 (unless something happened and you're in OT) and if you're home later than 17:30, you get that extra time above the 30 minutes.

When I left there and started at another company, it was just expected to be at the first job or at the office for 08:00. Obviously if I was getting sent two hours out of town, that expectation was no longer there. We were not allowed any personal use of the van, so washing had to be done during the shift, because I wasn't getting paid while driving the van, then it was person time. Previous company was the same way, no personal use of the vehicle, so washing was to be done during business hours. Company gas card worked for some car washes.

Sometimes it was a pain, company obviously preferred we just worked all the time, but would then complain when the vans got too dirty.

I may have a bias because I am a tech, and my previous situations I was not allowed to wash company vehicles off the clock, but the van is yours (your company), if you don't want to pay your tech to wash the truck, then make them leave it at the office and you wash it. I mean really it shouldn't be taking that much time anyway, get gas and wash the van. I don't wash my own truck very often, I sure as heck wouldn't spend my own time and money to wash a company one regularly.

(5)
UE
Undisclosed End User #6
Feb 16, 2018

 

In the end, you get what you pay for.

If the vehicle is marked with Company info, it is basically a rolling bill board. Also the driver must drive differently then they might in their own or unmarked vehicle, so they should be on the clock, because you are asking them to behave a certain way, so if they comply, they are following your orders. 

If I follow your orders and your not paying me, what does that make me?

(1)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #1
Feb 17, 2018

When I worked for a company, I was given a van after some time, and I took it home. It was a rough time period, and I was able to let one of my kids drive my old car. It saved me insurance, fuel, a car payment, etc. I appreciated the hell out of that van and took pride in it. I made sure to wash it every week or two. That van saved me 10K a year plus.

 

If I could leave the van at the office, I would. Just not comfortable about leaving it in the parking lot at our office. But if I save 30-60 minutes of a techs pay every day, that savings adds up pretty quickly and would cover any broken windows or missing tools.

 

I told the tech my biggest pet peeve was keeping the van clean, 3 weeks later it has not been washed once.

 

 

Recent turn of events raises a new question. He got rear ended the other day. So what happens if a tech gets in an accident, while off the clock, in a company vehicle?

U
Undisclosed #7
Feb 17, 2018
IPVMU Certified

So what happens if a tech gets in an accident, while off the clock, in a company vehicle?

You pay for it this time.  

Tell him next time you’ll only pay if the van is clean at the time of the accident ;)

(1)
DR
Dennis Ruban
Feb 18, 2018

1. You get a car, you don’t get paid for a commute to the office or site. If a job site is outside a city, your work time starts at a city limit.

2. You use your own car for a daily commute. You get paid for your 8-4:30 shift.

3. Service call get paid from receiving a call/email to getting home (closing laptop lit) after finishing it.

DR
Dennis Ruban
Feb 18, 2018

And a car wash. It’s a company tool maintenance so it shall be paid.

when you say that car is a benefit itself, consider the fact that it’s typical to have that benefit for service technicians so I’d say it’s just a part of a standard package.  

It costs you maybe $2-3k a year (which you can write-off from your taxes) to provide a vehicle, but it saves your employee around $8-10k before taxes and you save on shop-site commute (around 200 paid hours per person a year). So who’s getting a benefit? I always thought it benefits both parties.

(1)
CJ
Christine Jackson
May 01, 2018

It's those types of splitting hairs that cause turnover.  Not only is it against labor laws, but will have employees looking for employers who don't will compensate them fairly.

If you have employees using their personal vehicle, they should be covered by company insurance and compensated with some sort of a car allowance.  If they get in a car accident on the clock (in their vehicle or yours) they will have to be covered under company insurance or you could be liable. 

We incorporate time to site with no problem whatsoever, and would do so whether a team of 4 or 30.  If we are asking an employee to travel somewhere and do work, we must of course pay them.  Getting to the office is a different matter, we don't have to tell them to do that. Traveling to and from the office is something hardly anyone is compensated for, unless it is negotiated before hire.  Anything over 125 miles we pay for their hotel, travel time and per-diem.

We pay our employees for their efforts (no matter what they are/training/down time/cleaning).  Any employee would reasonably expect to be compensated for their work, whether they take home a truck or not. It's a job, if your boss asks you to do something, you expect to be paid for it.

Having a subscription to a car washing service is well worth it, we just ask our employees to un-clutter vehicles once a week on the clock..not actually wash the vehicle.

Not every employee views company benefits in the same way.  I know one employee who doesn't want to take home a company vehicle.  Some techs feel like once they have one, they have extra responsibility...after hour calls, etc.  It is common in this market to have a take home vehicle, and it is the company responsibility to keep it maintained.  

 

(2)
(3)
OG
Oscar Gamez
May 01, 2018

Depending on your state, since the vehicle is owned by the company, any work done to the vehicle; maintenance or car wash should be on the clock.

(2)
(1)
New discussion

Ask questions and get answers to your physical security questions from IPVM team members and fellow subscribers.

Newest discussions