Subscriber Discussion

Layer 2 Or Layer 3 Type Switch As Core Switch For IP Video Surveillance Network

Avatar
Deepak Kajla
May 01, 2018
DEEPAK KAJLA SECURITY AGENCY

We have edge switches connected to the core switch in any IP video surveillance network. The edge switches are typically Layer 2. But what about the core switch. How do you decide on whether it should be Layer 2 or Layer 3?

Avatar
Sean Patton
May 01, 2018

As the simplest level, it would be hard to refer to any layer 2 switch as a "core" switch because of its lack of routing and control features.

That being said, if you had a standalone, flat (1 subnet), video only network, there's nothing that a layer 2 switch can't do to make the system function. (but I still would struggle to call it a "core" switch without routing capabilities)

In a mixed network usage environment, or complicated video network deployment, Layer 3 switches give you routing-functionality which will allow you to pass traffic between VLAN/Subnets, and potentially better control of broadcast traffic. Layer 3 switches also handle multicast traffic routing in a more efficient manner, if that matters to you.

UE
Undisclosed End User #1
May 01, 2018

Have been wondering myself about this. We are thinking about using a layer 2/3 smart switch that can create & monitor vlans, switch ports off and on all with remote capabilities.  Currently we use separate networks for building systems and do this thru the SonicWall .  but this is limiting. 

Avatar
Sean Patton
May 01, 2018

Its mostly going to depend on the types of systems and customers you're installing systems in. Many switch manufacturers offer some level of service or feature like Aruba Central, Netgear Insight, Meraki Cloud Networking; but those all come at a cost (some more premium than others)

UI
Undisclosed Integrator #2
May 01, 2018

It really depends on the scale of the project or the number of services - If you need routing (or multicast routing) then you will need a L3 switch. In reality the lines are pretty blurry - all but the cheapest managed switches from the tier 1 providers will have at least static L3 functionality.

The terminology is often thrown around too much.

 

How big is the project? Is it purely CCTV? What switches are you looking at?

(1)
UI
Undisclosed Integrator #3
May 01, 2018

One rule of thumb, you will know you need Layer 3 functionality right after you install the Layer 2 switch. 

(4)
New discussion

Ask questions and get answers to your physical security questions from IPVM team members and fellow subscribers.

Newest discussions