What 51 Members Want Us To Test

By: John Honovich, Published on Feb 05, 2015

Over 50 members submitted their requests for products / technologies for us to test.

We are looking to build on our industry leading 300+ tests based on your input.

We share all of them below including our feedback.

**** ** ******* ********* their ******** *** ******** / ************ *** ** to ****.

** *** ******* ** build ** *** *************** ***+ ***** ***** ** **** *****.

** ***** *** ** them ***** ********* *** feedback.

[***************]

***** *** ** *****-*** theme, ** ****** ******* or ********** **** *** more **** * ** 3 **********:

  • ******** **** **** **********.  We **** ** ** using ***** **** *** more. 
  • ******* ******* *** - why **** ******* ** much ********** ***** ******** to *** **** ** the ***'* *** *****. Very ***********. ******** **. Genetec **. ********* **. Nuuo **. ********* (***.) - *** ***** *** shootout ** ***** ** performance, ****-**-***, ******* **** (and *********** **** ***), integrator **********.
  • ********* **-****** ******* ** is *** ****** ** camera ******* ** ******* test **** ********* ************
  • *** ******** (****://***.***********.***/) ***** revenue ** ******* (****://***.*****.***/********/*******************.****) except ****. **** *** Grundig *** (***).
  • **, ***** *************.*** ***** solution *** ******* ** with *******.***. **** *** cons/pros, ************, ***. ******.
  • **** *** **** ******* Video ********
  • ****** *** ******* **** megapixel ******'* **** ** those **** ********. *'* quite ********** ** *** much *** ***** ********** affect ***** *** **** kind ** ******** ********** these ******** **** ** be *********.
  • *** ********* ** **/****** ip ******* *** ***** Analitycs ******* **** **** one *****://**.***-*******.***/*****/********/*******/*******-***-**-****/****/***.****
  • **** ** ****** ******* LINKED ** ***
  • ****** ***** ****. **** camera ********* (********** ***). Avtech ***** **** ********** app ***
  • **** ********* ***** ********** access *******, *********, *** video! * ** ******* more *** **** ******* for *** ***** *********
  • ***** ***** ********* **** are ******* **.
  • ** ****** ******** ***** CCure9000 **** ** ****** control ***** ***** - not ******* ** ******** of *****. **** ** it's *** * ******** test ** * **** testing ** ****** ******* includes ***** * ******* amount ** *********** *** servers ***, ** ******* listing ** ************/****** ************ differences ** **** ** pros *** **** ***** be *******.
  • ** **** *** **** Surveillance. ****** ** ***** back * *** * little ******** ****** *** could *** **** * HD *** **** ***** accurately ******* ******* . Recently ***** ********* ** the **** ****** ******* of ***** ******** ******* using ****** ****** **** old ***** ******* *****. Axis **** **** ****,*********,**,***** HD ****** ** **.
  • ********** ******* *** ***. I *** **** *********** and ***** **** ** independent ********** ** **** to *** ***** **** fall *** **** ***** and *****'*. ***** ** camera *********. **** *********** cameras *** ****** **** them ********. ** **** work? *** ** **** work? ****** ****** ********. Is ** ***** *****? New ** ************.
  • ****** **** ********'* **** and **** *******. * have ***** ********'* **** make ********** ****** ** its *** ***** ***********, long ******** ******* (*********** vehicles *** ******** **** 1500 **** ****), *** low ********* ***********. ** can ** ********* ** win **** **** ******** promises *** **** ** customers. ****, ** ***** be *********** ** *** those ******* ******** ** other ************* ***** ********* cameras **** ********** ****. Thank ***!
  • ******* ***.* **** **** using ***** ****.
  • * ***** **** ** see * ************* ****** that ******** *** ****** from ********* *******. ************ Milestone *** ***** **** with ****** ****** ********** from ********* *************.
  • ********* **-****** * ***** the **** ****** ****** 360 ******* **** **** have *** *********** ******* need ** ** ****** 10mp ** ******.
  • ***** ******** ***** *** / ********* / **** popular ***** *** *******-***** VMS ** ***** ******** countries; *** ******** *** Linux *****.
  • ********* *********** *** **** life *********.
  • ***** **-*** ********. * would **** ** **** if **** *** ***** compliant *** ***** **** well **** ** ********.
  • *** ** ***** *******/************ Axis *** *** ************* would ** *******/ *** true ***** *****/****** ********* to *** ***/** **** gaming ***********. ***** ***!
  • *** & ** ******* from ****** (**** **** good *** *****, *** are ****** ****?) **** from ***** ********-******** (*** are **** ******** **** NUUO, *****, *********) *********** between **** ****** ***** baluns *** *** ***** ones (***** **** *** me)
  • * **** **** ** more ********* ** ****, but * ***** **** to *** *** ******** tested ***. *** *** Zyxel ** ******* ******** as **** ** *** Cisco's. **** ***** ****** get *** ********? **** do **** ********** ***?
  • ***** ******* *.* ***. With *** *** ******* out *** **** **** a *** ****** *** I ** ******* ** see *** ** ****** up ** ***** ***'. It ***** ** ** a *** **** ** from *** ***** ********, but *** **** ** is ** *** ***** of *** ***** ***'.
  • * ********** **** ***** Hikvision **** ******* **** it's ********* ******* ***** in * ****** ********. I ******* **** **** Hikvision ******* **** **** tested *** ***** **** to ** **** ** compare **** ******* **** other.
  • *** *** ******* ** Series ******** **** ***** door ******* ******. ***** love ** **** *** good/bads ** *** ***** integration **** **** *** ONVIF ******* **** *** intercom.
  • **** ***** ** * little *** ** **** wheelhouse, *** * ***** like ** *** **** integration ******* ******* **** PSIM *** ****** ******* systems. *** ** ***** guys **** * **** game, *** ***** ** ZERO *********** *** ***** to **** **** *** experience ** ****** ****. I ***** **** **** to *** **** ***** (and ***********) ** *** lower *** *******/ ********* stuff. ** **** ** always ******** ** *** the ***** ** *** lower *** ** *** market, *** ** * had * ******** ****** from **** ** **** him, **** ***** **** me * *** *********.
  • *********** ****** ***** ******* wireless **** ******. ** the ****** *** ****** and ****** ********, *** works **** ***** ****, this ***** ** * solution * ***** **** in ******* **** *** save ******* ** ********* costs.
  • * **** **** ******* pressured ** * ***** VP ** **** ******** a ****. ***'* **** to **** **** ******** from ***** ******* *** would **** **** ***-****** feedback.
  • ***** *** **** *** NVR. ****://****.***/********** ***? ******* for *** ****/****** ****/**** performance/and ********* *** ******* to ****** ** ***** (outside **** *******) ******* and *** ******** *** home ***. ** *** "BlueIris" ** *** **** I ****** *** -******* home- ****** ******. *** or *** ***** ******* on **** ****** *** outside ******.
  • ******* ********'* ****** ******* system ***** ** ****
  • * ***** **** ** see * **** ********** the *********** *********** ******* the ********* **** **** series *** *** ******** Schlage ***** **** ******. One ***** *** *********** of **** *************; *** other ***** ***** *** stability ** * ********* 900MHz ************* **** ** the ***** ********* ******. I'd **** ** *** how *** ******** ****** to ***** *** ******* or *** ************ ** existing **** ************** ** a **** ****.
  • *** ***** ********** ** an ****** *******/********/**** ********** SaaS? ***** *** ***.*********************.**
  • *****, ****** *** ********** or ********** ************** ******* w/ ******, ****, **** or ***. ******** ********** Price *** *********** ***** are ********** ** *** claims ***** ** ** IPVM ********/*********. 
  • * ***** **** ** see *** *** **** IP ****** **** ***** up ** ***** ************* in *** **** ***** range. * **** ** see ** ***** *** some ****** ******* ******* out ***** *** *** residential ******
  • *********** *******/***********/ ******. **** organization ******* ** **** advantage ** ***** ******** virtual/servers *** *******. ********** in ****** **************, *********** and ******** ** ***** recording ** ******* ********.
  • * ***** **** ** see ***** ** ****** Encoders, ****** *****-******* ********, because ***** *** ***** a *** *** ***** and ** ***** **** crap ***, ******* ****'* necessarily ******* ** ** with * **** ** system ***********. * **** used *********, ****, **** (did *** **** *** ACTi), *** **** ********* a ****** ******* ********* to ****/*********. * ***** also **** ** *** some ***** ** *** long ***** ******** **** Coax *****, **** *** Veracity *** *******, ** see *** **** ******** perform ****** **** *** company ****. *** ****** is ******* ***** *** quite * *** ************ where *** ***** ** fiber ** *** ****, but ** ***** *** 100 ***** ******** ********** for *** ** *******.
  • **** ******* ***** **** HID ******** ********** ** vms/cameras *.*. ***, **********, etc.
  • *** **** *** **** could *********** ** **** but "***********" ** ********* seems ** ** * growing *******. **** ***** NVR's **** ***'* **** out ** *** *** to ******* ********* ******* firmware ******* ** **** properly. *** ******* **** is ******** * *** more *** ******** **** testing *** ********* "***" equipment ***** ** ************ in *** *****. *****, Sony, ****** *** **** of *** ***** *********.
  • ******* ******* *** *********. Our ******* ** * certified ******* ******* *** I'd **** ** ******* OpenEye ******** **** *** other **** ******** ***** analyzed
  • ******** ******** *********** ********** systems **** ********, ***** Command ******, *********, ***. My ******** *** * lot ** ******* *** sensors *** ******** ******** to *******, ** **** to **** ********* ***** provides ** ********** ******* but **** **** **** well **** ****** (** able ** ********** ********* a **** ***** ** IDS, ****** *******, *** VMS *******).
  • **** ******* */** **, low ***** *** ********* types ** ******* ****** a ****** **** (* don't **** *** ** you ****** ***** ***** in *** **, *** rooms ** ***** **** or *********** ** *** temperatures). ***** *** **** risk ** ****... ******* getting ****** *** *** visibility **** *** *** could **** **.

***********

** *** **** ****, given **** *** ********* were ** ****** *** many ******** ** ***** offerings, * ** ***** this ******** **** ** have ****** **** ** the *** ****** *** big ************ *** ***** (*** *** **** *********).

***** *** * *** things **** ** *** definitely ***** ** **** ***** on **** ********:

  • *** *******: ****** ******* ** is * ******** ** have ***** ****** *** should **** ** ***** one *********** ******
  • ** ********: **** ** above
  • ***** ********, **** *****, as **** ** **** come ***, ******* **** could ************* ******** ****** of ***** ****** ** with ** *** *******.
  • ********* ** *********, ***** it ***** ** *** of *** ******* ********** (non *****-******) ********** ** the ******.
  • ****** **** ** **** of *** ******** *** cost ******* ******** (** will *******).
  • ** ***** *** ******** access ******* ******* ***** it ** ********** ***** ** ****** right ***

*** ***** ***** ******** * few ***** - ******** 16 / **** *** PSIMs. **** **** ********** availability ***** **** ** more ***********. ** ****** wants ** **** ** an ******** ******, **'* pay ** **** **. As *** ****, ** are *** **** **** to ****** **** ** most *** ***** ********* and ********* **** **** will ** ******* *** being ******* / ***********, etc.

Comments (34)

Awesome. Great resource.

Would love to see the PoE switch tests. Is there really difference between a $50 PoE switch and a $500 one?

I would never trust a $50 PoE switch? LOL

That's fine, but lots of integrators do trust them for small installs. I know of at least one person who swears TrendNet PoE switches have worked without issue for them for several years.

Are they suited for enterprise installs? No. Can you run a four camera mom and pop shop on one? Quite possibly yes.

I can see where some integrators *cough slammers* might be fine using a $50 PoE switch, but I'm not. There is no way a $50 PoE switch is going to be a fully managed switch, supporting individual port power cycling via software. We have used that feature of a PoE switch more times than I can remember when troubleshooting remotely. In the cases where we used an unmanaged switch, we regretted it. I don't care if the customer doesn't understand the difference, I can. It allows me to do my job more efficiently.

And, a 4 cam mom and pop is getting analog from me, not IP.

Hey Jon, just curious what type of PoE switch you use? I've been trying to find one with the ability to remote power cycle individual ports.

Ubiquiti ToughSwitch Pro or EdgeSwitch

I would like to see this: Salient Systems VMS

An IndigoVision Ultra 2k camera, please. Let's see if it meets the advertised claims that IPVM criticized.

LOL. To whoever keeps marking my posts "Unhelpful": if you think that will have any effect on my posting frequency or content, you are sadly mistaken. In fact, it will just make me more resigned to post when and where I normally wouldn't...

Double LOL. And you call me a jerk?

Related: IndigoVision Rates Avigilon Worst In Class and IndigoVision UL Rating for 2K camera

There's just not enough interest in IndigoVision and we were not criticizing the camera, simply IndigoVision's marketing.

Seriously? I guess there must have been a huge amount of interest in ioimage? Scallop? Speco? March?

Speco claims industry best low light performance, which we debunked. And people have asked us about it for years.

Scallop is one of just a few multi-imager cameras and many people have asked for alternatives to Arecont.

ioimage is one of the few high end analytics on the market and, especially after the VideoIQ acquisition, a number of people asked for it.

March was requested by a very large end user, who did it politely.

IndigoVision 2K is a very late to market 1080p dome, and there's just not much interest in such products nor is there much in IndigoVision specifically.

"Please" isn't polite enough? More than 1,000 cameras isn't large enough?

No, a single 1,000 camera end user is not large / significant enough to justify doing a test.

Won't Indigo simply give you one of these cameras to test yourself? I would think if you put in so much of their stuff they could give, or loan, you a camera for testing.

Undisclosed,

They have but we have nothing to compare it to, no eye charts or young man to hold them, no variable lighting, etc..

Also, we can't keep installing/uninstalling cameras on the casino floor for testing purposes; especially multiple cameras for side-by-side shootouts.

So you're going to buy cameras for your casino based solely on the results of an IPVM test?

How did you select your current cameras for their applications?

They asked the question on Yahoo Answers.

A,

I'll answer your question with a question: would you buy a vehicle based solely on Car and Driver's recommendation? Edmunds? Motor Trend? Consumer Reports? Neither would I.

What I would do is use IPVM's testing as one factor among many. IPVM can't/won't test for every factor we use in determining which camera(s) best fit our rather far-ranging criteria but their tests do give me hints about what cameras are worth a second look. Then I would obtain an evaluation unit for testing in our casino.

Those tests cover factors that IPVM would not test typically for: ability to provide good image quality in low light, high light, back lit, high reflections and high contrast situations. I would also test the camera's ability to integrate with our VMS; its ability to provide multiple streams at 30fps; its ability to provide simultaneous TCP/IP Unicast and Multicast ONVIF streams; its ease of mounting in various locations; its weight; lens choices; aiming flexibility (pan/tilt/rotate) and other factors.

Then, I would compare its flaws and virtues to other cameras we have tested before deciding what camera(s) to buy.

I am known as a demanding client. I don't think I would even consider products from manufacturers and/or distributors who respond to my questions in a condescending manner.

One final factor: price. I want cameras that offer "the most bang for the buck".

In all honesty, I consider most of the camera tests IPVM does as targeted toward a mainstream use case. And while they are fairly thorough, they're not exhaustive. Basically, good to sort of say "If you're familiar with Camera X, here is how Camera Y might relate to it."

For you, and your application, I wouldn't expect the IPVM tests to have much value at all, unless they said the camera was just an outright failure or something. I would expect you to do your own tests, using criteria that YOU can define and duplicate and control.

My question was not condescending. But if you use the auto analogy, it's like trying to select a car for a cross-country road race that ends with a demolition derby. The mainstream magazines that test and rate cars are just not going to be that helpful, your use case is very different.

Granted, IPVM is not the be-all end-all to camera testing but as really the only game in CCTV town, they are a resource.

My analogy to Consumer Reports, is a valid example. I wouldn't buy a car based solely on what they say but I would use their ratings as a guide. For instance, if I was in the market for a mid-size sedan, I would consider one of their top picks (Subaru Legacy, Honda Accord, Toyota Camry) over one in their bottom picks (Chrysler 200, Kia Optima, Nissan Altima).

In the same vein, if IPVM said a product performed poorly, I would be far less likely to even ask the manufacturer or a distributor for an evaluation unit.

Do I wish IPVM or at least someone published tests that more closely aligned with our criteria? Of course! But since that is unlikely, I'll take what I can get.

And there are so many camera brands (yes, I know many are rebrandings) that it is vurtually impossible for us to test more than a small fraction of them. So how to weed the huge number down to a manageable level? Hopefully, diligent research and possibly the assistance of resources like IPVM.

I'd like to see an actual long term test performed on PoE switches to see if expensive ones perform better or if cheap ones have a higher failure rate. I'm convinced they are all made in the same factory and companies just OEM them and charge what they can get away with for their particular brand.

Yes and Axis cameras are probably made by Cantonk too...

To quickly address one of the notes above regarding IP PTZs for City Surveillance, Pelco’s line of HD PTZ cameras (Spectra HD, Esprit HD and Spectra Professional) can accurately mask scenes using the window blanking function effect.

Additionally, with the latest firmware release in early December 2014, Spectra HD now has 6 window blanking modes:

  • Gray blank
  • Smear Monochrome
  • Smear Color
  • Pixelate Monochrome (mosaic-like)
  • Pixelate Color (mosaic-like)
  • Posterize

This may be too specialized, but I would like to see a comparison on the integration of VMS's into Access Control systems. I am seeing more and more where camera manufacturers are limiting access to API's because they are pushing their own management product; and this is compounded when those same manufacturers start coming out with access control suites.

Low cost NVR shootout: Hikvision vs. Dahua

We've covered this in the Hikvision HDTVI VS Dahua HDCVI report. There's not a lot more to say about them as they are similarly basic.

Now, Hikvision says that they are coming out with Hikvision IVMS 5200 - A Competitor To Genetec And Milestone? but I am not sure if that is available outside of China yet. When that is, we'll test it.

Ok, that's good to know. I was most interested in the performance aspects of the devices, and had made the assumption that the NVR might be taxed a bit more than Analog HD by the demands to decode multiple h.264 streams for live viewing.

Perhaps this is roughly offset by the gain of not needing to not encode the streams before they go to media...

I would like to see a detailed review of the Salient Systems VMS

OnCam Graneye 360 - have several end users with these cameras and would like to see how IPVM rates them

Suddenly a test of Indegovision and thie SMART.core claims is very interesting for us.

Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 6,362 reports, 854 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now

Related Reports

Avigilon Opens Up Analytics And Cameras on Nov 06, 2018
Avigilon is opening up. The company historically famous for advocating its own end-to-end solutions and making it harder for 3rd parties to...
Most Wanted Improvements In Manufacturer Technical Support (Statistics) on Jun 21, 2018
5 key areas of improvement and 1 clear wanted support feature were voiced by 140+ integrator responses to: What improvement in manufacturer...
Toughest Manufacturer Competitors 2018 on May 07, 2018
150+ integrators answered: Which manufacturer, when offered by rival integrators, is toughest to compete against? Why? The overwhelming...
Favorite Software For Remotely Supporting Video Surveillance Systems on Feb 07, 2018
Being able to remotely support video surveillance systems is important both to reduce costs (eliminating truck rolls) and for...
2018 Top Sales Interest For Integrators on Dec 20, 2017
130+ integrators answered: This is a key question, especially for manufacturers, as it impacts what areas to focus more on and what...
Integrator GPS Vehicle Tracking Statistics and Success Examined on Dec 08, 2017
GPS vehicle tracking is a growing but somewhat controversial topic. On the plus side, tracking may increases productivity by providing greater...
The Milestone Personal Demo Marketing Campaign on Oct 30, 2017
Waste of money or emarketing innovation? In a program being heavily promoted on their social media channels Milestone is offering to...
Integrator Camera Optimization Preferences on Sep 27, 2017
How do integrators make cameras 'better'? What settings or optimizations do they change? ~150 integrators told IPVM what they do. First, they...
How Integrators Use IPVM on May 24, 2017
150 integrators explained how they use IPVM and how it helps them stay informed and improve their business.  The 4 main uses integrators cited for...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Access Control Online Show - July 2020 - With 40+ Manufacturers - Register Now on Jul 01, 2020
IPVM is excited to announce our July 2020 Access Control Show. With 40+ companies presenting across 4 days, this is a unique opportunity to hear...
Hanwha Face Mask Detection Tested on Jul 01, 2020
Face mask detection or, more specifically lack-of-face-mask detection, is an expanding offering in the midst of coronavirus. Hanwha in partnership...
UK Government Says Fever Cameras "Unsuitable" on Jul 01, 2020
The UK government's medical device regulator, MHRA, told IPVM that fever-seeking thermal cameras are "unsuitable for this purpose" and recommends...
Camera Course Summer 2020 on Jun 30, 2020
This is the only independent surveillance camera course, based on in-depth product and technology testing. Lots of manufacturer training...
Worst Over But Integrators Still Dealing With Coronavirus Problems (June Statistics) on Jun 30, 2020
While numbers of integrators very impacted by Coronavirus continue to drop, most are still moderately dealing with the pandemic's problems, June...
FLIR Screen-EST Screening Software Tested on Jun 30, 2020
In our FLIR A Series Test, the cameras' biggest drawback was their lack of face detection, requiring manual adjustment when screening each...
Dahua Buenos Aires Bus Screening Violates IEC Standards and Dahua's Own Instructions on Jun 30, 2020
Dahua has promoted Buenos Aires bus deployments as "solutions that facilitate community safety". However, they violate IEC standards and,...
UK Firm Markets False Fever Screening, Hikvision Disavows on Jun 30, 2020
A UK security firm falsely claimed its Hikvision-based thermal solution could be used for "accurately detecting fever in any person", even claiming...
Industry Study: 83% of US Temperature Screening Sellers Falsely Say Not Medical Devices on Jun 29, 2020
83% of US companies selling temperature screening devices, aka 'fever' detectors, claim they are not medical devices, contrary to FDA definition,...
Manufacturers on Virtual 'ISC West' 2020 and Potential ISC West 2021 on Jun 29, 2020
With the 2020 ISC West show now officially canceled, attention turns to Reed's new "ISC West 2020 Virtual Event" planned for October and for the...