WDR Camera Shootout 2015

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on May 04, 2015

This is the most comprehensive Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) IP camera shootout ever.

We tested 10 of the latest generation multiple-exposure true WDR cameras, including:

Even among these true WDR cameras, there were clear superior and inferior performers as this preview from out test inside shows:

In addition, we tested two non-WDR cameras to show the performance difference between cameras which use true WDR methods and those which do not:

The Test

We tested three key scenes representing common WDR use cases:

(1) Inside, with our subject entering a man door, showing how the cameras dealt with a quick and powerful burst of sunlight:

(2) Through an open overhead door in a warehouse:

(3) Finally, outside, against the setting sun:

Inside, we break down the results of who did the best and worst.

**** ** *** **** ************* **** ******* ***** (***) ** camera ******** ****.

** ****** ** ** *** ****** ********** ********-******** **** *** cameras, *********:

**** ***** ***** **** *** *******, ***** **** ***** ******** and ******** ********** ** **** ******* **** *** **** ****** shows:

** ********, ** ****** *** ***-*** ******* ** **** *** performance ********** ******* ******* ***** *** **** *** ******* *** those ***** ** ***:

The ****

** ****** ***** *** ****** ************ ****** *** *** *****:

(*) ******, **** *** ******* ******** * *** ****, ******* how *** ******* ***** **** * ***** *** ******** ***** of ********:

(*) ******* ** **** ******** **** ** * *********:

(*) *******, *******, ******* *** ******* ***:

******, ** ***** **** *** ******* ** *** *** *** best *** *****.

[***************]

Key ********

*** *********** *** ******** ************* ***** **** (******* *** ****), **** **** *************' *** ********** ****** ********** ****** ** ***** ****** than ******** *******. **** *** ***** ** ***** ****** ******* ****** backlighting ******** **** (**** *** ********* ** ******* ******* *** sunset).

*******, ***** *** ***** *** *********** *********** ** ****:

  1. *********** ** **** *****: ** *** ****** ***** ** *** scenes, *********** *********** *********** *****, **** **** ****** ********** ****** details, **** ****** **** ** *** ******** ** ***, *** the ******** ******* **** *******, ****** ******* ******.
  2. ******** ** ***** *******: *** ******* * ****** ******** ** light ******* *** ** ********* ** ****** **** ** **** doors, ***** ****** ******* ***** *** ************ * ****** *******, obscuring ******* ** *** ******* ********.
  3. ******* *** ***** ***********: *** *********** ** *********, *** ** no ****** ****** *** ******** **** *** *** **** **** or ****** ** ***, *** ****** ** *********** *****. **** this ** **** ** ******* *** ****** ** ***** ***** are *** *** **/*, **** ** ****** *********.

*** ****?

****** *** **** ********* (******/******* ****, ********* *** ******* *** outdoors), ** ****** *** ************ *** ****.

  • ** *** ******/******* **** ****, ******* *** ****** *** * number ** ***** ************* **** ***** ******.
  • ** *** ********* ****, ********* *** ******* **** ************* **** strong.
  • ** *** ******* *** ******** ****, **** *** ******* **** comparatively ******.

**** ** *** **** ***** *********** ***** *** ***** **** up ******* **** *** ******** *** *****. ******* ***********, **** / ****** **** ********** ** *** *********** ** ********.

*** *****?

*******, ****** **** ******* ****** *** ******** **** **** *********** by *** ********** ****** **** ***** *************, ** ***** ****** consistently ********* ****** ****** ******. ** ************ ** ***** ****** have **** ********.

True *** **. ***-*** *********** ***

***** ** ***** ** *********** *********** ******* **** *** ****** in **** ****** ** ** ********* ** ********** *** **** *** worst ** ***** ******* ******** ****** '****' *** *******. ** illustrate **** **********, ** **** ****** **** **** *** ***** against ********** / ******* **** *** ************, **** *****.

**** ***** *********** *** *********** ********** ** ********** ** *** full ***, **** *** **** **** ** *** ***** *********** black ** *** ***-*** *****, *** *** ******* ******* *******:

** ***-*** *******, *** *******'* ******** *** **** **** ******* due ** ******* ****** ** ****** *********, ***** ** *** area ****** *** ****, ** ** ****** ********** ** ***.

WDR *********** **********

** **** **** *** ****** *** ***********, ** ****** ** three ****** ******** * ******* ** ****** ************:

***** *: *********/******** ****

*** *** ***** **** ** **** * ****** *** *****, a ********* **** ** **** ******** ****. ***** ****** **** nearly *** ********* ****** *** ******* *** ** *** ****** sunlight.

******* *** ****** ********* ** *** **** ****, *** ******* perform ****, **** **** ****** ** ******** ********** ** ***********. Subject ******* *** ***** ** *** *******.

** *** **** **** ****** *** ****, *********** ****** *************, with *** ******* *******-** ********* ************* ****** ******* ** *** subject. ******, **** ** *** ********* **-*******, ******* ***-****, *** Axis *****, *** ***** ***-**** ******* ****, ****** ********** ***** than *******. *******, *** *******, ********, *********, *****, *** **** cameras ******* ***** ******* ** **** **** ** *** *****.

***** *: *** ****** *******

** **** *****, *** ******* **** ****** ******** ** ***** of *** *** ***** ** ******* ****** ******. ***** ***** ** our ******* *** ***** ~*,*** ***, ****** *** ****** ******** behind *** *** ****** **,***.

** **** *****, *** ********** *** *******, **** *** ******* appearing ** * **********, *** ****** ****** ******* ****** ***, with *** ***** ****** ********* ***** *** *****. ****** ******* the ***** ******, **** ******* ******* *******, ******

***** *: ******* ******** ****

** **** *****, *** ******* ****** * *** ****, **** the ***** ***** ******* *********** ** *** **** ***** *** closes. *********** ****** ******, ** ******* ****** ** *** ****** in ***** ** ********* *****.

** ****** *** *********** ** ********** ******* ** **** ***** screencast:

***** *** ******** *.*** **** ** ***** ***** (**.* **).

** **** *****, *** ******* ********** ********* *****, **** *** strong ***** **** ******* ******* *** *** ******** ** *** scene *** *** ******* ********* *********** ** * **********. 

** ********, *** ******* ***-**** *** *** ** *** **** performers ** **** *****, **** *** ********, ********, *** ******* all *******, ******* **** ********** **** *** ** *** ******* door.

*** ********** ***** ***** ******** *********** ** **** ****** ** the ******* ****** *** ****, ***** **** *** ***** *****:

Even ***** ***********

** **** ****** *** ******* ** *** ******* ****** ***** to ******* ******** ***** ******* ***********. ** **** *****, ***** quality ** ******* ***** *** *******, ****** *** ********* **** is ******* ****** **** ******.

** *** *****, ***** *.* ***, **** ** *** ******* produce ***** ******* ** **** ******* *** *****. **** *** Arecont ********** *** ******** ** ** ***.

*******, ** * **** **** ~*.** *** *****, **** *** ** equipped ********* *** ********* ******* ******* ******* ** *** *******. Others, **** ** *** ******* ***-**** *** ******* ******, ******* legible ***** ** *** **** *****, *** *** ******* *******.

***********

******* **** ****** ***** *** ********* ********:

  • ********: ******* ** */***
  • *****: *.***, ************ ~**, ** ***
  • ***: *** *** ****** ** *** *** ** *** ****** where ********** (*******, *******). **** ******* *** ** *** ******** aside **** **/***.

***** *** *** ******** ******** **** ** **** ****:

  • ******* ****** **********: *****
  • ******** *.**-**-**: *.*.*.**
  • **** *****: *.**.*
  • ***** ***-****: *.**.****
  • ********* **-**********: *.*.*
  • ********* **-*******: *.**
  • ***** ******: *.*.*.*.****
  • ******* ***-****: *.**
  • **** ********: *.*.*
  • ******* *******-**: ****

Comments (30)

Interesting results. I have recently been looking into using Arecont Vision's 12mp multi-imagers with WDR in an area that includes both windows and halways. I hope they do better than this test camera. I also have decided on four new PTZ's and have chosen Samsung SNP-6320H. WDR was one feature that steered me that way. Happy to see the brand perform so well in tests.

James.

I have had the arecont/avigilon manufacturer rep out and set up the camera in the area where I thought we would have issues. It was hallway intersection with glare on floor and open windows end of hallway at lobby entrance. Both did reasonable well. You can always ask your local rep for this service.

V/r

Kelly

No Mobotix tests?

No, Mobotix's market position has fallen over the last few years. Also, I don't believe they support multi-exposure WDR.

Mobotix also says HDR / WDR is 'inacceptable in security applications':

"Some manufacturers are using a combination of technologies like adding frames to generate a brighter image (e. g. Lightfinder, HDR, etc.). However, with this adding and overlaying of subsequent frames, small details or objects in the scene could be suppressed­ or distorted, which is inacceptable in security­ applications."

Oh, really?

To a power guy it's all about good pictures at a nice low wattage.

The how details of the camera form, fit and function are often lost on me.

We've a Rapid Deployment SES plant that's been development bullet proof with an AvaLan and MX combo running prior to winter. Seems to always take good pictures. RSES12012110 captures good neighbor Dan

Lots of manufacturers, including low-cost ones with broad 3rd party support can take good pictures. A lot of that has to do with much better sensors that all the camera manufacturers have fairly similar access to.

As for low power consumption, here are 130+ MP IP cameras with 3 watts or less power consumption, plus more than 340 MP IP cameras with 4 watts or less. Also, you might be interested in our IP Camera Power Consumption Guide.

Yep, I've seen all three of these site resources.

It sure is nice to have real power measurements available, it's way too often a challenge establishing the customer project LDL.

I'll bite, what's LDL? :)

Load, duty cycle and location.

Info triangle for off grid power solutions.

Is this the typical Dynamic Range of Mobotix cameras?

Uh don't know, power guy.

There seems to be some decent DR info here:

image dynamic range

The snapshots were a daytime live feed desktop capture, both using MX night lenses (we'd been testing a 3w National Mfg LED light). Valley was in white out but seemed to capture Dan's plowing pretty well. There's a platform shot taken with a Sony digital here:

winter pickup truck deployment

Perhaps MX daytime color lenses would provide different results.

It'd only have taken a few minutes to change out the MX lenses but it was pretty ugly weather conditions.

Great test! Thanks!

Pattern matchers are curious to know if (J) was actually Z. Dahua?

Interesting results!

We've been using Axis P3384-Vs mainly for their LightFinder feature... it would be really nice to use WDR in the day and switch to LF at night while remaining in color, but Axis has no way to do that based on light level - switching WDR mode is dependent on ICR mode switching first.

I've been benching a Samsung beside the Axis and found it measures up very well in both WDR and low-light, with the added bonus of actually being a little sharper overall. Unfortunately it has even less ability (as far as I've been able to determine) to switch WDR on and off based on light level. Both can do it on a schedule, but any schedule I set is only suitable for a month or so.

Can you share the bandwidth consumed of the cameras as tested?

Get a better model.

A better model than what?

Get a better model.

I say no, Derek is the best!

In any event he has become a defacto reference standard for the industry.

I'm a bit unclear. Was this intended to be a comparison of WDR performance? Or is this just a large camera shoot out with the qualifier for entry being WDR? There's a lot of additional variables present in some of these cameras that aren't necessarily serving for a fair comparison if our goal was to compare WDR. Of which, low-light color technologies (Starlight, lightfinder, etc.) and IR have the largest impact in the side by side comparison pictures.

You guys generally do great head to heads, but I feel that this one will only serve to muddy expectations. This is the equivalent of Car and Driver doing a comparison of V6 vehicles. The accord, the ford pick up, the twin turbo audi, and the supercharged mustang.

Kyle,

What specifically do you want to see tested that was not done here?

Are you objecting to our test scenes? Do you want different ones? Do you want different cameras? Different settings?

Please be more specific.

Thanks for the prompt reply, John.

I'd like to see a more apples to apples comparison when the results are confined to side by side photos. I cannot fairly and accurately judge one manufacturers technology against anothers when were putting 2 MP and 3 MP in the same race, or when cameras with IR on are being compared to night shots of cameras with no IR, or cameras that are designed to do low light color against those that aren't. If IPVM was doing a general camera shoot out then I think all of these things would be fair game, but in a case where we are aiming to compare WDR, I think our results get skewed by extraneous variables.

Kyle,

"I'd like to see a more apples to apples comparison when the results are confined to side by side photos."

These are exactly side by side photos.

"cameras with IR on are being compared to night shots of cameras with no IR"

The core of this report are the three WDR test scenes. Good, bad or indifferent IR / low light has NO impact on those three WDR test scenes.

"putting 2 MP and 3 MP in the same race"

Kyle, if you believe your Avigilon cameras will perform markedly better using the 2MP version than the 3MP WDR version we tested, we will buy one immediately and do a re-test just on the 2MP. Let me know if you would like us to proceed with that.

John, if someone has decided to be "Undisclosed B Manufacturer" while posting, I think that you should either respect the desire for anonymity or simply remove the option for participants to be anonymous.

Undisclosed B Manufacturer originally made both posts disclosed.

Some minutes after John's last post Undisclosed B Manufacturer apparently edited them and checked 'Post Without Disclosing Your Name?". Nothing wrong with doing that, but John may not have even noticed, since he would have no reason to re-read them.

When I first read those posts, like you I thought it might be a gaffe, but then I checked my e-mail for notification of Und B's posts, (which I was automatically subscribed to since I had already commented), which showed the posts were originally made disclosed.

Good to hear, that explains it.

C, as A explained above, the since undisclosed poster originally posted disclosed. That's why I referred to him by name.

I can see why that's confusing. Thanks for calling attention to it so we can clear it up.

I just was looking over the firmware versions used for this test. Is there any reason your using year old firmware for the Avigilon camera and new firmware for all the other cameras?

Not sure what happened in the text up there, but the camera is current. I'll fix that typo.

Thank you

Is there a new version of this test coming. If I need to recommend a low light WDR outdoor fixed camera, would the results hold good?

Gautham, we do WDR tests with most of our ongoing camera tests.

The difference now is that almost every professional camera now has WDR built-in and the variances in performance have gone down.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Axis ~$100 Camera Tested on Jul 17, 2018
Axis has released their lowest cost camera ever, the Companion Eye Mini L, setting their sights on a market dominated by Hikvision and Dahua. Can...
Digital Watchdog Low Cost 4MP Camera Tested on Jul 02, 2018
Based on member 4MP testing requests, we bought and tested Digital Watchdog's low-cost 4MP DWC-MTT4Wi to see how it performs in real world scenes,...
Panoramic Fisheye Camera Shootout - Avigilon, Axis, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Oncam And Vivotek on Jun 27, 2018
IPVM tested Avigilon, Axis, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Oncam And Vivotek 12MP panoramic fisheye cameras head to head, as shown in the test setup...
Mobotix Releases 'Move' Into 21st Century on Jun 20, 2018
For years, Mobotix stood resolutely against, well, every other manufacturer, selling it as a virtue: MOBOTIX equipment is designed with no...
Hikvision 12MP Fisheye Camera Tested (DS-2CD63C2F-IV) on Jun 14, 2018
Hikvision's DS-2CD63C2F-IV is their flagship panoramic camera, with a 12MP imager, 15m integrated IR, smart codec, and more. We tested the 63C2 in...
Introducing Effective PPF (ePPF) - Improving Video Surveillance Designs on Jun 11, 2018
Pixel density (PPF / PPM) is the best metric the industry has to define and project video quality. It allows simple communication of estimated...
Hanwha Low-Cost 4MP Camera Tested (QNV-7010R) on Jun 11, 2018
4MP usage is increasing noticeably, as IPVM 2018 resolution statistics show. And low-cost, fixed focal cameras, are popular for budget...
Hikvision PanoVu 20MP Flexible Camera Tested on Jun 01, 2018
Hikvision has released their first repositionable multi imager cameras with integrated IR included, atypical in competitors. We bought and tested...
Stats: Upgrading Cameras Far More Common Than Replacing Failed Cameras on May 30, 2018
The old saying "If It Ain't Broke, Don't Fix It" does not apply here. New IPVM statistics show that 60% of cameras that are replaced still work but...
Oncam 12MP Fisheye Camera Tested on May 29, 2018
Oncam has made their name since the early 2000s as a fisheye specialist, focusing only on panoramic cameras. To see how this specialist stacks up...

Most Recent Industry Reports

AI Startup Anyvision Raises $28 Million Led By Bosch on Jul 20, 2018
Anyvision is the most ambitious heavy-spending video surveillance startup in many years. And, now, the startup has raised $28 million led by...
Fail: Dahua "Didn't Check The Lux Levels but It Was Dark" on Jul 20, 2018
Dahua UK has been promoting their camera quality on LinkedIn: I, and others, asked what the lux level of the scene was. (background: Lux Rating...
Free 100+ Manufacturer-Customized Camera Calculator Released on Jul 19, 2018
Now, any manufacturer has a customized IPVM Camera Calculator, free. The goal is to make it easier for companies to help their customers better...
Improved Security And Surveillance Bidding - 2018 MasterFormat Divisions Examined) on Jul 19, 2018
Navigating the world of system specifications and bidding work can be complex and confusing, but a standard format exists, and understanding it...
Last Chance - Security Sales Course Summer 2018 on Jul 19, 2018
Today is the last day to register. Based on member's interest, IPVM is offering a security sales course this summer. Register Now - IPVM Security...
Directory of Video Surveillance Startups on Jul 18, 2018
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known entity...
Ladder Lockdown and Ladder Levelizer Tested on Jul 18, 2018
Ladders are a daily necessity for surveillance and security installers, but working on an unstable surface can be extremely dangerous. In addition...
FST Fails on Jul 17, 2018
FST was one of the hottest startups of the decade, selected as the best new product at ISC West 2011 and backed with tens of millions in...
Axis ~$100 Camera Tested on Jul 17, 2018
Axis has released their lowest cost camera ever, the Companion Eye Mini L, setting their sights on a market dominated by Hikvision and Dahua. Can...
Amazon Ring Alarm System Tested on Jul 16, 2018
Amazon Ring is going to hurt traditional dealers, and especially ADT, new IPVM test results of Ring's Alarm system underscore. IPVM found that...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact