WDR Shootout 2013

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on Jan 22, 2013

One of the most important surveillance camera differentiators is Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) performance. Dealing with bright sunlight and shadows is a key problem for most surveillance deployments and, historically, most cameras were poor. Indeed, in our first two WDR test (see our original WDR shootout and sequel Megapixel WDR shootout), major performance variances were clear. 

Now, many manufacturers are rolling out new WDR models, claiming to provide better performance and lower prices. We wanted to determine how significant these improvements were, if at all, so we put the following cameras to a head to head shootout:

  • Arecont AV3116DNv1
  • Avigilon H3 Series
  • Axis Q1604
  • Bosch NBN-932V
  • Panasonic WV-SP509
  • Sony SNC-CH240

This brought back three WDR MP veterans (Axis, Panasonic and Sony) vs three WDR MP new entrants (Arecont, Avigilon and Bosch).

The Test

We focused our tests on three WDR scenes that represent common real-world scenarios.

Interior, aimed through a door on a sunny day:

door wdr
Interior, aimed through a garage door on a sunny day:

garage door scene
Exterior, with the sun lowering in the sky:

outdoor wdr

Inside, we break down the results.

Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox
Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox

Key Findings

The most interesting takeaway is how much the performance gap between best and worst has narrowed. In previous tests, only one or two manufacturers typically stood out as clear winners. However, in this shootout, all new generation cameras performed reasonably well. This is especially noteworthy in the cases of Arecont and Avigilon, whose 3MP WDR models cost significantly less than other major manufacturers, such as Sony, Bosch, and Axis.

The drawback of all these options is that choice in WDR cameras now becomes more complex. With more options available, more testing in place is required to determine whether a specific camera model will work in a given scene, instead of simply selecting from a small group of trusted, high-performance cameras.

NOT All Cameras are Now WDR

While more manufacturers are taking advantage of new sensors to improve WDR, this does not mean that every new camera will suddenly be strong at WDR. All of the cameras in this test use multi-exposure processing, a 'true' WDR technique. While we expect many more manufacturers to add such support over the next 18 months, still be careful about WDR claims. For background, see our WDR tutorial.

Scene 1: Interior, Man Door

In our first scene, typical of many scenarios WDR cameras are warranted, we aimed the cameras at and through a typical man door, in this case an emergency exit door in an office building. The width of the field of view at the doorway is approximately 13-14'. As noted in this overview image of the scene, the lux differential peaks at about 40x between the interior wall (~150 lx) and the exterior in strong sunlight (~6 klx). These samples were taken in a South-facing door around noon in order to maximum the effects of the Winter sun.

Scene Overview

In this first shot, the subject is standing in the middle of the doorway, measuring about 300 lx, ~20x difference in illumination. All cameras perform relatively well here, though the Q1604 is noticeably darker on the subject's face than others. In wider fields of view, with lower pixel density, this may become problematic.

Man door, in doorway

With the subject standing to the side of the door, in the darker (~150 lx) area, performance remains generally consistent with the above. The NBN-932V is more washed out than others in this scene, however, with some loss of detail on the subject.

Man door, inside

When the subject moves to the area outside the door, the brightest spot in the scene at around 6,000 lux on target, there are some noticeable performance differences. The subject's face is noticeably less clear in all cameras, with Arecont, Bosch, and Avigilon most affected.

Man door, outside

Scene 2: Interior, Overhead Door

In our second scene, we set the FOV to capture the entirety of a standard overhead door, as well as a few feet next to it, to best simulate the lighting differences users in warehouses and garages may experience, for example. We left the lights off in the warehouse to create the largest light/dark differential possible on a sunny day (~11 klx measured straight up).

Overview

With the subject standing in the center of the overhead door, illumination on target was measured at approximately 90 lx. Arecont and Avigilon perform best in this scene, though all cameras provide usable details, though the SP509 is verging on being too dark.

Overhead door, in door

With the subject located in the dark area next to the door (~60 lx on target), Axis is noticeably brighter than other cameras. Arecont, Avigilon, Bosch, and Sony perform much the same as above. The Panasonic camera, however, no longer produces usable video of the eye chart and loses detail in the subject, though he is still detectable.

Overhead door, next to door

Moving the subject to the outside of the warehouse, all cameras perform fairly well. Arecont displays some hazy artifacting around the subject and letters on the chart, though facial details are still visible.

Overhead door, outside

Scene 3: Outdoors, Sun Behind Subject

In our final WDR scene, we moved the cameras outdoors about an hour before sunset, with the sun very low in the sky, though not in the FOV of any camera. It was clear and sunny on this day (~16 klx measured straight up).

Scene Overview

At this range, the horizontal FOV is ~20', with illumination measured around 5.5 klx on target. Arecont and Avigilon suffer the fewest ill effects from the near-direct sunlight. The subject's face is at least partially obscured on all cameras. Note that we removed Axis from these comparisons because after review, it was not in focus. Users interested in the performance of the Q1604 in these scenes may see our Q1604 Shootout Results for more detail.

Outdoors, in sun

In this scene the subject has moved to the shady area further back in the FOV. At this distance, the HFOV is much wider, about 60'. The subject's face is obscured partly due to the lower light level in the area, though at this distance, PPF is much lower, so naturally fewer details will be visible.

Outside, in shade

Indoor Comparisons

In order to get baseline image quality and bandwidth measurements, we set up the cameras indoors in a conference room with controlled lighting for both "daytime" (all lights on) and "nighttime" shots (lights off). These comparisons may be seen below (click images for larger version).

First, in the well-lit scene, we notice a difference in color saturation between Arecont, Avigilon, and Axis (all relatively true to life) and Bosch, Panasonic, and Sony, which are desaturated to varying levels.

Daytime Indoor Comparison

In this nighttime scene, below 1 lux, with shutters normalized to 1/30s (with the exception of Axis, which cannot be slowed beyond 1/44s with WDR on), Axis and Bosch stand out as providing the most usable image, with Avigilon moderately worse. The Panasonic WV-SP509 still displays some image of the subject, while Arecont and Sony both provide no usable video.

Nighttime Comparison

Note that the AV3116DN features a binning mode, which is not shown in the image, to keep it standardized with other cameras. However, this mode does improve nighttime imaging and will be covered in detail in our upcoming individual test of the AV3116DN.

Testing Details

In order to normalize camera settings as much as possible, we performed the following prior to recording each of our test scenes:

  • First, the camera was reset to factory defaults.
  • WDR was set to ON in all cameras.
  • Shutter speed was normalized to 1/30s, in all cameras but the Axis Q1604. The Q1604 does not allow the shutter to be slowed past 1/44s when WDR (called "Dynamic Capture in configuration) is on.
  • The cameras were set to the same field of view and auto-focused via the camera's web interface where possible, and manually when not supported.

Note that some of these cameras are 4:3 aspect ratio, while others are 16:9. At least one manufacturer raised a question about this, because the 16:9 cameras' FOV may cut out extremes of light or dark which the 4:3 cameras must compensate for. This may be true in some cases, but we do not see it as having a drastic effect on performance, and these cameras must perform accordingly were these real-world installations, therefore we feel that setting the HFoV to the same width is the best method for our testing.

2 reports cite this report:

WDR Camera Shootout 2015 on May 04, 2015
This is the most comprehensive Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) IP camera shootout ever. We tested 10 of the latest generation multiple-exposure true WDR...
Axis Advances Its Best Overall Camera on Jun 17, 2014
While Chinese competitors rush to sell HD cameras at 1/5th to 1/10th the price of Axis, Axis continues to push up market. Axis has announced the...
Comments : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports on WDR

Covert IP Camera Shootout - Axis, Hanwha, Hikvision, March, Vivotek on Mar 20, 2019
Covert cameras were one of the last holdout areas for analog cameras. However, in the past few years, IP / HD covert cameras have become...
Pelco GFC 4K Dome Camera Tested (IMP831-1ERS) on Mar 12, 2019
Pelco has finally released their first 4K IP camera, after years of competitors' releases. Is this move too late? Or is their new GFC Professional...
8MP HD Analog Tested (Dahua / Hikvision) on Jan 30, 2019
HD analog has promised higher resolution for years, but has lagged substantially behind for years. Now, both Dahua and Hikvision have started...
Verkada Cloud VMS/Cameras Tested on Jan 28, 2019
Verkada is arguably the most ambitious video surveillance startup in many years. The company is developing their own cameras, their own VMS, their...
Camera Course Winter 2019 - Last Chance on Jan 24, 2019
This is the last chance to register for the Winter 2019 Camera Course. This is the only independent surveillance camera course, based on in-depth...
Milesight Company Profile on Jan 22, 2019
Milesight Technology, a Chinese company building an International branded business, says they are slowly building their presence through a series...
WDR Tutorial on Jan 11, 2019
Understanding wide dynamic range (WDR) is critical to capturing high quality images in demanding conditions. However, with no real standards, any...
Worst Products Tested In Past Year on Jan 09, 2019
IPVM has done over 100 tests in the past year. But which products performed the worst? Which ones should users be most aware of? In this report,...
8MP / 4K Fixed Lens Camera Shootout - Dahua, Hikvision, TVT, Uniview on Dec 17, 2018
8MP / 4K fixed lens models are now common in lower cost lines, with nearly every Chinese brand and their OEMs now offering multiple options. To...
Ubiquiti $79 Flex IP Camera Tested on Dec 07, 2018
U.S. Manufacturer Ubiquiti has released a 1080p, integrated IR IP camera, selling it directly for $79, making this one of the least expensive IP...

Most Recent Industry Reports

IBM / Genetec Surveillance System Investigated Over Philippines Human Rights Abuses on Mar 22, 2019
A lengthy investigation into an IBM video surveillance project in the Philippines, raising concerns IBM helped local police conduct a bloody...
Eagle Eye Favorability Results 2019 on Mar 21, 2019
Eagle Eye has been the biggest spender in the cloud VMS market including (via their owner) acquiring Brivo for $50 million and CameraManager from...
Large Hospital Security End User Interview on Mar 21, 2019
This large single-state healthcare system consists of many hospitals, and hundreds of health parks, private practices, urgent care facilities, and...
Silicon Valley Cybersecurity Insurance Startup Coalition Profile on Mar 20, 2019
Many industry people believe cybersecurity insurance is not worth it, as the voting and debate in our Cybersecurity Insurance For Security...
Covert IP Camera Shootout - Axis, Hanwha, Hikvision, March, Vivotek on Mar 20, 2019
Covert cameras were one of the last holdout areas for analog cameras. However, in the past few years, IP / HD covert cameras have become...
Top Metrics For Ensuring Integrator Profitability - Statistics on Mar 20, 2019
How do integrators ensure the profitability of their projects? As part of our profitability study, 100+ integrators answered the following...
Avigilon Launches 'Renewed Products Program' on Mar 19, 2019
There are lots of 'pre-owned' cars but pre-owned IP cameras? While such programs are common in other industries, in video surveillance, they are...
Genetec Security Center 5.8 Tested on Mar 19, 2019
Genetec has released Version 5.8. This comes after a wait of more than a year that caused frustrations for many Genetec partners. Our previous...
Retired Mercury President Returns As Open Options President on Mar 18, 2019
Open Options experienced major changes in 2018, including being acquired by ACRE and losing its President and General Manager, John Berman who...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact