WDR Megapixel Camera Shootout

By: Antony Look, Published on Jul 30, 2011

Dealing with direct sunlight is one of video surveillance's toughest problems. Avoiding the sun is frequently impossible. Making things worse, when a scene has direct sunlight creating both dark and bright areas, image quality can suffer dramatically.

In video surveillance, the technical term used to describe a camera's ability to handle these conditions is WDR or Wide Dynamic Range. In this context, range refers to the variations of light levels that a camera can capture and deliver a quality image. The greater the range, the more likely the camera can handle both very bright and dark areas (e.g., sunlight on a person's face, shadow on the car in the corner).

Earlier this year, we did our first WDR shootout with (2) SD and (2) MP cameras. One of the clear, yet surprising, results was that cameras with more pixels (i.e., megapixel) tended to outperform (i.e., capture more image details) than standard resolution cameras, even if the SD cameras were marketed as supporting WDR.

Given those results, in this test, we wanted to learn more about the differences in megapixel camera WDR performance. To do so, we tested 6 Megapixel cameras from Arecont Vision (AV1315), Axis (P1344), Panasonic (WV-SP306 and WV-NP502), Sony (CH140) and Vivotek (IP8151P) to see who was the best and worst at handling WDR scenes.

[UPDATE 2012: We have tested the Axis Q1604 against the best performing WDR cameras in this group.]

We picked 2 common real world scene:

  • Doorway entrance facing outdoors - this is a common pain point for users who cannot properly identify individuals coming inside for hours a day as the sun faces the door
  • Sun setting in the line of sight of an outdoor camera - this is a frequent problem for parking lot and street surveillance. Accidents or thefts occurring during those times of day can be obscured by the sun.

In addition to testing core WDR performances, we did additional testing of 2 advanced features to see what benefits they provide:

  • Face WDR: Panasonic has an optional feature that can detect faces and then adjusts exposure to maximize the image quality of the detected face.
  • Exposure Regions: A number of cameras, including Arecont and Axis, support exposure regions that allow lighting to be optimized for a specific area of the scene (e.g. region specified for where faces normally appear).

Below is a preview of our test results from the doorway showing fairly dramatic differences among the 6 megapixel cameras tested:

Inside the Pro section, we share full results and rankings of each camera's doorway performance.

Below is a preview of our test results from the outdoor setting sun scene showing major performance differences among the 6 megapixel cameras tested:

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Our tests revealed a fairly consistent pattern of performance variations. Based on observable differences in image quality captured, we rank the 6 camera's performance into 4 major categories:

  • Superior: Sony CH140
  • Above Average: Panasonic WV-SP306 and WV-NP502
  • Below Average: Arecont AV1315 and Axis P1344
  • Inferior: Vivotek IP8151P

Below, of course, are the raw video clips and the prepared image comparisons so that you can judge for yourself.

Key Findings and Recommendations

Here are the key findings:

  • WDR performance was generally better in cameras specifically marketing or stating WDR enhancements/capabilities - namely Panasonic WV-SP306, Panasonic WV-NP502, and Sony CH140. The exception was the Vivotek IP8151P
  • Cameras demonstrating good/strong WDR performance (indoor hallway), tended to handle harsh direct sunlight conditions effectively as well
  • Direct harsh sunlight does not necessarily produce a lighting differential that is characteristic of a WDR scene, but WDR capabilities appear to improve image results nonetheless
  • The Sony CH140 consistently outperformed the field throughout the WDR tests
  • The Panasonic WV-SP306 and WV-NP502 generally outperformed the field, except the Sony CH140, throughout the WDR tests
  • The Panasonic WV-SP306 performed similarly to its Panasonic counterpart and predecessor the WV-NP502 in the majority of WDR tests. This is despite marketing claims that MegaSuperDynamic (WV-NP502) is more advanced than SuperDynamic (WV-SP306)
  • The Panasonic WV-NP502 exhibited delay 'turning on' WDR when conditions changed suddenly
  • The Panasonic camera's face WDR feature did not demonstrate any practical benefits in our tests.
  • Exposure regions (such as with the Arecont) were generally or overall detrimental to image quality for a majority of the WDR test scenarios

In light of these findings the following is recommended:

  • Consider cameras with proven WDR capabilities for both conventional WDR scenes (e.g. bright doorway or window) and scenes with direct sunlight. Such cameras can significantly improve image quality under these difficult lighting conditions
  • If you are considering a Sony camera for a WDR application, note that WDR is only available in their premium line (V series, i.e., the CH140 but NOT the CH120)
  • If your WDR application undergoes abrupt changes in lighting (e.g. door opening suddenly) consider a Sony WDR over a Panasonic WDR camera. If not subject to sudden changes in lighting, you may wish to consider the Panasonic WV-SP306 at ~$350 less than the Sony CH140 online
  • In general, do not expect or rely on exposure regions to solve issues in WDR type scenes

Download Video Clips

To review the raw video, download the sample clips from each test run:

  • Indoor WDR Hallway (Door Propped) [link no longer available]
  • Indoor WDR Hallway (Door Closed/Open) [link no longer available]
  • Outdoor Direct Sunlight [link no longer available]

Indoor Hallway (Door Propped)

This is a prototypical WDR scenario of a long hallway with a propped open doorway creating an intense backlight relative to a dimly lit hallway. The lux differential peaks to roughly 20x when the subject is positioned very near to the cameras.

Bright (~1500 Lux)

[link no longer available]

There is quite a spectrum of reactions by the various cameras to the intense WDR/backlight in this scene. At one end is the CH140, which renders strong details within the backlit regions. The WV-SP306 and WV-NP502 are able to produce modest level of details within the backlit regions. At the other end of the spectrum is the IP8151, in which the image is nearly completely washed out and is of little utility at this point.

Dark (~150 Lux)

[link no longer available]

At this point in the scene the lighting differential is ~10x, and the two Panasonics and the Sony appear to handle the variation quite effectively. In contrast the rest of the field exhibit some level of over exposure or characteristic white haze effect.

Darker (~75 Lux)

[link no longer available]

Here at a ~20x lighting differential is where differences become much more apparent between cameras. In the 1315DN and IP8151 the subject's face is severely under exposed - almost a complete silhouette. The Panasonics and the CH140 provide a relatively better level of exposure of the subject. Interestingly, the P1344's image of the subject is somewhat over-exposed.

Indoor Hallway (Door Closed/Open)

This scenario is a variation of the same hallway scene, except that the door is now opened and closed. The key differences to note here are that the backlighting is introduced 'suddenly' into the scene when the subject opens the door; and furthermore, as the door closes passively behind the subject the lighting differential decreases rapidly - eventually returning to a non-WDR scene.

Bright (~1100 Lux)

[link no longer available]

As the door is opened the scene experiences an abrupt increase in WDR character. Interestingly the WV-NP502 appears slow to react. This is evidenced by the subject appearing slightly more washed out in this scene versus the previous scene where the door is propped open, and also by the fact that the sign on the door - '5' - is completely obscured.

Dark (~120 Lux)

[link no longer available]

When the subject arrives at this position the backlit region is considerably less than the ~1100 lux at initial opening. The lux differential is therefore only ~5x, and across the board cameras appear to provide better image quality compared to the previous 10x 'dark' scene.

Darker (~25 Lux)

[link no longer available]

At this point the door has completely closed and the scene is no longer one with WDR characteristics. As a result even the 1315DN and IP8151, which were completely under-exposed in the previous 'propped' counterpart scene now provide relatively well exposed images of the subject.

Outdoor Direct Sunlight

In this scene harsh sunlight is directed into the cameras and poses a particularly challenging lighting situation. The first composite is fully zoomed out to demonstrate the overall effect the difficult lighting has on each camera.

Overview Composite

[link no longer available]

The same cameras performing well in the indoor WDR scenes (namely, the WV-SP306, WV-NP502 and CH140) appear to do well in this outdoor scene as well . The converse appears true as well with the P1344, 1315DN and IP8151 showing signs of difficulty with the harsh lighting.

Digitally Zoomed Composite (Wide FoV ~50ft)

[link no longer available]

The P1344 and IP8151 are severely washed out compared to the field. They also have a distinct pinkish tinge or haze blanketing their images. The Panasonics and Sony are relatively better than the rest of the field, but blurriness and lack of sharpness still limit facial details at this wider FoV.

Digitally Zoomed Composite (Narrow FoV ~20ft)

[link no longer available]

At this nearer FoV details begin to emerge from the Panasonics and Sony images. There is little sign of lighting difficulties present in their images as well. The WV-NP502 exhibits particularly good contrast and facial details. In contrast the P1344 and IP8151 continue to provide poor subject facial details and show considerable signs of adverse lighting effects.

Additional WDR Techniques

Face WDR (Panasonic)

Both Panasonics tested support a feature called Face WDR. It requires that an analytic feature called face detection be enabled. After a face is detected within the scene, the camera purports to use WDR enhancements around the face to better resolve facial details.

Below is the WV-SP306 with a Face WDR off/on comparison:

[link no longer available]

Below is the WV-NP502 with a Face WDR off/on comparison:

[link no longer available]

The foregoing comparisons assume that Face WDR was indeed triggered at the point of the 'ON' snapshots. However, as this event is monitored through a separate interface (the camera's web interface), exact confirmation was difficult to ascertain. Based on preliminary testing however, the subject is in a region where the face detection showed a high probability of being triggered. Through these initial tests it was also noticed that face detection/face WDR events did not correspond to any meaningful improvements in facial detail or clarity.

With these reservations in mind, the images depict no clear advantages to using Face WDR in this particular test scenario.

Exposure Region (Arecont)

In this battery of tests, we configure exposure regions on the bright areas of both the indoor hallway scene and the outdoor harsh sunlight scene. The overall effects of this strategy are evaluated via the composite below:

[link no longer available]

Placing an exposure region around the door frame when the door is propped open, decreases overall exposure on the subject when in the bright area. This tends to provide a better overall image of the subject at this point. However, the rest of the scene is essentially 'blacked-out', and the subject is totally undetectable throughout most parts of the hallway interior.

In the next scenario when the door is initially closed, the abrupt opening causes the subject to become under-exposed with the same exposure region in effect. The subject is still considerably under-exposed as he moves inside and to the left. As the subject progresses, and the door shuts behind him, the image obviously improves (not shown) but this is due to an evening out of lighting (loss of WDR character) in the scene and not due to the exposure region.

In the outdoor scenario an exposure region placed near the bright horizon causes the entire picture to darken. As a result, the majority of the scene is heavily under-exposed, significantly obscuring subject and other object details.

Methodology

Here are the six (6) cameras used in the WDR Mega-Shootout:

  • Arecont AV1315DN (online $460) - 1.3MP D/N; 1/2.7" CMOS; MPL4-10; 0.1/0 (Color/BW)
  • Axis P1344 (online $759) - 720p D/N; 1/4" CMOS; F1.2 Computar ; 0.05 Lux (BW)
  • Panasonic WV-SP306 (online $550) - 1.3MP D/N; 1/3" MOS; WV-LZA62/2 lens; 0.3/0.05 lux (Color/BW)
  • Panasonic WV-NP502 (online $950) - 3MP D/N; 1/3" CCD; WV-LZA62/2 lens; 1.0/0.08 lux (Color/BW)
  • Sony CH140 (online $800) - 720p D/N; 1/3" CMOS; F1.2 Fujinon; 0.1 Lux (BW)
  • Vivotek IP8151 (online $754) - 1.3MP; F1.2 Computar; 0.04/0.001 (Color/BW)

All camera lenses were configured at a uniform lens angle (~45 degrees) in order to make fair comparisons. Video was simultaneously recorded and analyzed at their highest VMS supported resolutions. WDR was enabled on all cameras supporting it (WV-SP306, WV-NP502, CH140, P1344). Note the IP8151 markets as a WDR enhanced camera, but apparently does not require it be enabled manually; also the 1315DN is not marketed as having an explicit WDR capability.

Here are the 3 key scenarios:

  • Indoor Hallway (Door Propped)
  • Indoor Hallway (Door Closed/Opened)
  • Outdoor Harsh Direct Sunlight

Each scenario involved two (2) recordings. The first involved basic WDR turned on, while the second involved turning on Face WDR on the Panasonic cameras and an exposure region configured on the AV1315DN.

4 reports cite this report:

Prebid Meetings and Walkthroughs on Mar 06, 2012
Integrators who fail to take prebid meetings and walkthroughs seriously can lose the job or lose their shirt when responding to RFPs. While prebid...
Directory of Camera Shootout Series on Dec 27, 2011
The following directory lists all of our camera shootouts. These shootouts pit 4 - 8 different surveillance cameras in simultaneous tests on real...
Top 12 Reports for 2011 on Dec 25, 2011
Here are our top 12 reports for 2011, starting with the state of the surveillance industry: 2012 Video Surveillance Guide - Key trends reviewed...
Axis Q1604 WDR Camera Reviewed on Sep 18, 2011
In September 2011, Axis announced a new HD camera, the Q1604, optimized for Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) performance. This camera joins the low light...
Comments : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports on WDR

Pelco Sarix Pro3 Camera Tested on Oct 16, 2019
Pelco has released their Sarix Professional Series 3 cameras, claiming "more security detail in challenging scenes with excellent low light and...
Avigilon H5A Analytic Cameras Tested on Oct 07, 2019
Avigilon has released its H5A analytic cameras, claiming to "detect more objects with greater accuracy even in crowded scenes." We tested the...
Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) Guide on Oct 01, 2019
Understanding wide dynamic range (WDR) is critical to capturing high quality images in demanding conditions. However, with no real standards, any...
Vivotek 4K S-Series Camera Tested on Sep 30, 2019
Vivotek's highest-end S-series camera claims "Supreme Night Visibility", "Smart IR II", "Smart Stream II", "WDR Pro for unparalleled visibility in...
Uniview Prime Series 4K Camera Tested on Sep 18, 2019
Is the new Uniview 'Prime' better than the more expensive existing Uniview 'Pro'? In August, IPVM tested Uniview 4K 'Pro' but members advocated...
Panasonic 4K Camera Tested (WV-S2570L) on Sep 13, 2019
Panasonic has released their latest generation 4K dome, the WV-S2570L, claiming "Extreme image quality allows evidence to be captured even under...
WDR Camera Mega Shootout 2019 - Avigilon, Axis, Bosch, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Panasonic, Vivotek on Sep 04, 2019
This is the biggest WDR Shootout ever, with 23 cameras from 8 manufacturers: We included true multi-exposure WDR and non-WDR models, ranging...
Uniview Pro 4K Camera Tested (IPC3238ER3-DVZ) on Aug 29, 2019
In our 8MP / 4K Fixed Lens Camera Shootout, Uniview's low end 8MP was firmly in the middle of the pack. Does their higher end Pro Series 4K camera...
Wyze Image Quality Tested vs Axis, Hikvision And Nest on Aug 27, 2019
With Wyze's new AI feature, it is strong at analytics, but how good is the camera's image quality? Is it just as good as incumbents like Axis,...
Anyvision Facial Recognition Tested on Aug 21, 2019
Anyvision is aiming for $1 billion in revenue by 2022, backed by $74 million in funding. But does their performance live up to the hype they have...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Alarm Veteran "Demands A Criminal Investigation" Of UL on Oct 18, 2019
The Interceptor's Project pressure against UL continues to rise. Following Keith Jentoft's allegation that "UL Has Blood On Their Hands", Jentoft...
Camect "Worlds Smartest Camera Hub" Tested on Oct 18, 2019
Camect is a Silicon Valley startup that claims the "Smartest AI Object Detection On The Market", detecting not only people and vehicles, but...
Hikvision Global News Reports Directory on Oct 17, 2019
Hikvision has received the most global news reporting of any video surveillance company, ever, ranging from the WSJ, the Financial Times, Reuters,...
Camera Calculator V3.1 Release Improves User Experience on Oct 17, 2019
IPVM has released a new version of our Camera Calculator, V3.1, with significant user experience improvements, a new development plan, and an...
Securing Access Control Installations Tutorial on Oct 17, 2019
The physical security of access control components is critical to ensuring that a facility is truly secure. Otherwise, the entire system can be...
Access Control Course Fall 2019 - Last Chance on Oct 17, 2019
Register Now - Fall 2019 Access Control Course. Thursday, October 17th is the last day to register. IPVM offers the most comprehensive access...
US DoD Comments on Huawei, Hikvision, Dahua Cyber Security Concerns on Oct 16, 2019
A senior DoD official said the US is "concerned" with the cybersecurity of Hikvision, Dahua, and Huawei due to "CCP" (China Communist Party)...
Pelco Sarix Pro3 Camera Tested on Oct 16, 2019
Pelco has released their Sarix Professional Series 3 cameras, claiming "more security detail in challenging scenes with excellent low light and...
IPVM Camera Calculator User Manual / Guide on Oct 16, 2019
Learn how to use the IPVM Camera Calculator. The guide below includes instructions, images, gifs, and videos demonstrating and explaining the...
Altronix Claims Tango 'Eliminates Electricians' on Oct 15, 2019
Power supply provider Altronix claims its new Tango power supply 'eliminates the need for an electrician, dedicated conduit and wire runs'. In...