Big City PSIM Claims Reviewed

Author: Carlton Purvis, Published on Nov 21, 2013

The U.S. has one of the highest crime rates in the world. Within the U.S., Baltimore is one of the worst and its need for security and surveillance is particularly acute. IPVM recently participated in a tour of the city's command center during Secured Cities. In this note, we examine the system and some of the more unrealistic claims made.

System Overview

********* ***** *** ****** '*********.' *** ****** ******** *** *******, ** **** ** ** 2006. ** ********** ******* **** ******** *********** ** **************, ********* ********** and ******** ******** ***** ***** ********. 

********* ********* ***** **** ** **** *********:

  • ************ ** *,*** *******
  • ********* *,*** ***** ******** **** ********** ******** ********
  • ********* *** ******* *** ******* ****** (********* *********, ***** *** murders - ****** *** ****** ****)
  • ********* ** ******* ******* ******

*** **** ** *********'* ************ ********* *** **** ** **** feeds, ****** ***** ******* *** ************ ****** ************** ***** * Vidsys ****. **** ********** **** ****** ** *** ****** *** other ******** *** ***** *** ******* ** ***** *** ** eyes ****** ******* *** **************. *** ****** ******* **** ****** ************, and ***** *** * ****** ** **** ** **** ** video. 

***** *** **** *** *** ***** ***********, *** ******* ****** was ***** *** **** ** *** ********** *****, **** *** side ********** * ***** ****** ******* *** * ********** ***** and *** ***** **** *** ******** *** ***** *** ** to ** *********. ** **** **** ** *** ****, ***** were ** ********* (******* ****** ********) *******. ****** **** *** eight *****.

**** ** *** ******** ******** ******* **** ** *** ** ***** ** *** *** ******:

*** *** **** ** *** ****** ** * ****** *** operators *** ***** ** *** ******* ** * ******* ********. The ****** ****** ** * ********** ** ************** ******. *** bottom **** ** * ******* ****** ******. *** ** *** right ****** *** ******** ** * ******* ******** *** ***** accessed **** * *** *******. *** *** **** ** *** screen ** * **** ** ******* *** *********. 

Questionable ******

***** *** * *** ****** **** ** ********* ******** ****** Lieutenant ****** **** ****** *** **** **** ******* **** ********:

Instant ****** ** *******

** * ************ ** ******* ****** *** *** ***** ** the ****, ** **** ***** ******'* ******* ***** ** ****** up ***************, *** ****** *** ****, ************* ***** ***** ****** a ****** *******, *** **** ** **** *** ****** ****** the ****** **** * ******* **** / ****** ********* *** a ****** ** ****. "******* ******" ** ********* **** "****** in *** *******," ********** ** ** ********* ** ********** ** a **** ******** ********.

Capturing ******* ** ****** ***** ********* ** *****

*** ******** ****** ** ***** **** * ******** ******** ** video ** *****. * ****** ** *** ***** *********** **** he **** *** * ****** ****** ** **** ** * camera ********* ** *****. **** ** ****** **** ** ** was * ***** *********** *******, ***** ***** ** ******* ****** **** * ****** *** would ****** **** ****** ** ** ******** ** ******. ** would ** ** ********* ***** **** ** ****** * ****** with * ****** ********* ** *****, ********** *********** ** *********** it ***** **** ** ***** ****** ** **** ***** ** capture * ***** **** ** * ****** ********. 

No **** *** ******

*** ******** **** **** ********* *** ********** *** **** *** police ********.

"** * ******* **** ****** * ******, ** **** ***** up ** **** ** *** **** ***** [**** *** *******]," he ****. **** ****** **** ** ******, *** ****** ** many ******* ******** ***** **** ******** ****** **** *********** ****. Beyond ****, *** ******* *** * ********* **** ********* ****** ** ****** **** ********** ** ********.

Operators *** ********** ******** ****** ** ********The cameras are monitored around the clock. Hood said operators will routinely alert police to crimes before dispatchers even get a 911 call. Hood did not provide any hard numbers on how many times police were dispatched based on something an operator observed, but said it happened "all the time."

** ****** **** ************ ***** ******* ** ******* ****** **** robbery ** *****, *** **** **** ** *** ******, ***** is ** *** ** **** **** ********* *** ******** ** key ** ** * ******* - * **** ** ***********. 

**** *** ****** *** **** ******* ** **** *** ********* do **** **** ***** ** ********* **** * ****** ** carrying * ********* ****** *** *********** ********** ********. ** *** *****, the ******** ******* * *** ****** ************ **** * *** ** parked ****. *** ******** **** *** ****** ** ****** *** man ***** ** ***** * *** ******, **** *** ****** dispatched ** *** ********. ** ******* ***** ** ******** ******* what ***** **** * ********* ****** ***** * ****'* ******. The ******** *********** * **** **** ****** *** ******** **** a *** ** *** ****. 

Caught ** ** *** ****

* ***** **** **** ** **** **** **** *** ***** can ********* *** ****** ** ** *** **** **** **** have ** ********. ****** *** ****** ** ****** *** **********, but ****** ** **** ** *** ** ****** *** ******** bullets ** ****** ** * *******. *** ********* ****** ** "Believe," *** ********* ****** *** **** ** **** ***** ****** with * ***** ** ****. 

No *********** ** ************

*** **** ******* ** *** ************* ** * **** **** it *** ******* ** ***** *** ****** ***** **** ** took ** *** ** **. *** ******* **** ************ **** a ****** ** ******** ********* *** ******** *********** ** **************, Emergency ********** *** ******** ********, *** *** *** ***** ********* systems, *** ********** ******* *********. * **** ******-** ** *** ************ would ** ** *********** ******* ** ************ ************* ******* *** agencies, ***** ******** *** ****** ********** ** ****.

Comments (13)

This is a good article. It shows that there is still a large gap between TV/Filme and the reality of real surveillance systems. Its very hard to get an audience with the implementers on how they went about it. They tend to hide behind the security screen "I cant tell you that otherwise we would be exposing our weaknesses"

Very interesting article. I wonder what the response time is from when a surviellance operator confirms a suspisious suspect to a police response and possible arrest. Also, the section pertaining to a camera capturing a moving bullet at 30FPS had me laughing. The Citiwatch slogan "Beleive" sure is befitting.

The response time is pretty fast. Operators have direct radio contact with police.

People rarely want to admit mistakes in some things like purchasing decision and will try to put on a best face, especially when the public is there in your face judging value.

But overall I don't think it's a bad system. It certainly didn't need the embellishments.

There are only three statistics I care about, and I only see one of them: participation in arrest (which we see), participation in prosecution, and cost per succesful prosecution.

Arrest is nothing without prosecution, or at least an attempt at prosecution. And the NYPD's stop and frisk policies show that you don't need to have a lot of fancy, expensive technology to arrest everyone who looks suspicious or walks funny, just a lot of cops.

How can we evaluate the effectiveness of this system without these statistics?

A comprehensive study of the Baltimore PD was just released last week. At a cost of $285,000, the report discusses certain aspects of CitiWatch. As one of the most violent cities in America, I think one has to ask "What would the city look like without CitiWatch and how can CitiWatch become even more effective?". I participated in this tour and definitely learned a few things to apply in my agency.

Mark, thanks for sharing that. What cost $285,000? The report or the system? If it's the report, that sounds like a lot. If it's the system, that sounds way too low :)

John

The consultant's report cost $285,000. Not sure about the entire CitWatch system.

"In a presentation at Secured Cities the day prior to the tour, he said other agency's cameras could be called up instantaneously, but during the tour, instantaneous often meant within a couple minutes, the time it took the system access the camera with a loading icon / symbol displayed for a period of time. "Instant access" is different than "access in two minutes," especially in an emergency or responding to a live security incident."

I find this problem surprising... we have delivered many interagency projects (e.g. safe city, defense) and we have yet to encounter this kind of issue. Did they provide any explanation on why this delay occured? Maybe there a "human in the loop", e.g. another agency's operator must first manually authorize the transmission of video to Citywatch?

Christian Laforte
CEO, Fortem

This is in the basement of the Baltimore command center:

It's a good question. Carlton and I talked about this before publishing. The cause was not revealed. Carlton can try checking, but Vidsys is long on marketing and short on real explanations.

Thinking about it, there could be plenty of valid reasons to use a man-in-the-loop approach to authorize video transmission from one agency to another. Legal restrictions, minimizing upload bandwidth, preventing unauthorized information leak, etc. My bet would be on security personnel that routinely watch the public, but are afraid of being watched by other departments and being held responsible if something goes wrong. That kind of double-standard is almost the norm, and it's holding back a lot of potential cost savings and improvements in operational efficiency.

We are just finishing one interesting safe-city project that isn't held back by this kind of organizational fear, involving 6 agencies that want to share cameras and analytics. We had to extend a lot of our permission features, e.g. to support complex new rules to automatically grant temporary permissions to some cameras based on opened alarm type, escalation, location, etc. Some agencies have policies that restrict archive vs live feed sharing. Fun stuff.

Yep, I'll see if I can find out.

Baltimore in the past said the operating cost for this system was $1.4 million annually and is now requesting an additional $700,000. The city also increased it maintenance contract to $8.2 million to account for "platform integration and a limited expansion of the system." All this after a review found the system had severe deficiencies.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports

Massive Leak Of Chinese VMS Provider Exposes Xinjiang Surveillance on Feb 20, 2019
A subsidiary of China’s claimed largest VMS provider is tracking the precise location and ethnicity of millions in China’s Xinjiang region,...
Austria’s First GDPR Fine Is For Video Surveillance on Jan 29, 2019
Should EU businesses be concerned if police see a business' surveillance cameras filming public areas? This is what happened with Austria’s first...
Mobile Surveillance Trailers Guide on Jan 17, 2019
Putting cameras in a place for temporary surveillance where power and communications are not readily available can be complicated and expensive....
The False SCMP Story on Hikvision NYC AI on Jan 14, 2019
In the past week, one of Asia's largest publications, the South China Morning Post (SCMP), posted an article about "Chinese [facial recognition]...
Infinova's Xinjiang Business Examined on Dec 07, 2018
As pressure mounts for companies to stop doing business in China’s Xinjiang region amid a severe human rights crisis, IPVM has found Infinova sold...
ADT Wins Fire Death Suit But Faces Appeal on Dec 05, 2018
ADT/Protection 1 has won a wrongful death court case in which it was sued by the estate of a deceased customer. However, the attorney for the...
Evidence of Dahua's Involvement In Xinjiang Surveillance on Nov 28, 2018
IPVM adds new details about Dahua’s activities in Xinjiang, a Chinese region where mass surveillance used to facilitate grave human rights...
Pressure Mounts Against Dahua and Hikvision Xinjiang Business on Nov 19, 2018
Pressure is mounting against Hikvision, Dahua, and other companies operating in Xinjiang as an international outcry brews against the Chinese...
Directory of Access Control and Intrusion Startups on Oct 30, 2018
This directory catalogs access control and intrusion detection startups IPVM has found noteworthy. The directory is provided for your review to...
IACP 2018 Police Show Final Report on Oct 08, 2018
IPVM went to Orlando to cover the 2018 IACP conference, the country's largest police show (about as big as ASIS), examining the 700+...

Most Recent Industry Reports

From The Basement To Buried Behind Chinatown: ISC West Emerging Technology Zone on Feb 22, 2019
What does ISC West think about 'Emerging Technology'? Well, last year, they put those companies in the basement. This year, they moved them up to...
Private School IT Manager Surveillance Interview on Feb 22, 2019
This IT manager describes himself as the "oft-maligned IT person" whose "opinions may not always be appreciated by the integrator crowd." But he is...
Outdoor Camera Mounting Hardware Guide on Feb 21, 2019
Mounting cameras outdoors can be challenging, requiring understanding different types of equipment and methods. In this guide, we teach this...
HID Favorability Results 2019 on Feb 21, 2019
HID favorability results were strong, in the 2019 IPVM integrator study of 200+ integrators, with a net +62% and low negativity as the table below...
First US State, Vermont, Bans Dahua and Hikvision on Feb 21, 2019
The first US state, Vermont, has issued a ban on a number of Chinese and Russian manufacturers including the world's 2 largest video surveillance...
ADI 'SAVE BIG' On FLIR And Hikvision Examined on Feb 20, 2019
One is a major US defense supplier. The other is owned by the Chinese government. But you can "SAVE BIG" on both at ADI. In this note, we...
BluB0x Company Profile on Feb 20, 2019
BluB0x has doubled in revenue every year since its founding in 2013, according to CEO Patrick Barry. We originally reported on them in 2015. At the...
Massive Leak Of Chinese VMS Provider Exposes Xinjiang Surveillance on Feb 20, 2019
A subsidiary of China’s claimed largest VMS provider is tracking the precise location and ethnicity of millions in China’s Xinjiang region,...
Security Installation Tools Guide - 22 Tools Listed on Feb 19, 2019
In this guide, we cover 22 tools that security installers frequently use. This is one part of our upcoming Video Surveillance...
Sales Cuts At Rasilient on Feb 19, 2019
Over the past 2 years, video surveillance storage specialist Rasilient has expanded its workforce significantly, aiming to build its own branded...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact