Thermal vs Day/Night Shootout

By: Ethan Ace, Published on Nov 27, 2012

What should you do for dark outdoor scenes? Thermal cameras are getting a lot less expensive. Conventional cameras are getting better in low light. We decided to test these two categories - thermal and day/night - head to head to better understand what's better to use.

The Test

We tested in a large outdoor level field, overviewed below:

test site

Three cameras were used:

  • A DRS WatchMaster IP Elite, 320x240 imager, with a 40-degree field of view. Other cameras were matched to this field of view.
  • Axis Q1602 with Computar F1.0 lens.
  • Bosch NBN-932V with Fujinon F1.2 lens.

The DRS was selected because it is the least expensive thermal IP camera on the market while the Axis and Bosch were chosen do to their strong performances in previous low light shootouts (see the Q1602 test and the MP low light shootout).

The following scenarios were tested:

  • Daytime, between ~4500-5000 lx (a partly cloudy day).
  • ~0.1 lux with both visible cameras defaulted, 1/30s shutter speed, day/night set to auto.
  • ~0.1 lux with the Q1602 set to 1/30s shutter speed, in black and white.
  • ~0.1 lux with the Q1602 set to 1/2s shutter speed, in color.
  • All tests were performed at ranges between 150-550', the specified limit of human detection range of the DRS camera.

With this approach, we could determine not only what was 'best' in low light but what tradeoffs existed during the rest of the day.

  • In night testing, the least expensive thermal was still significantly better at detecting subjects than the leading SD camera when using the 'standard' 1/30s shutter.
  • However, using a 1/2s slow shutter for the SD, the two cameras essentially tied, which was surprising given how extremely dark our night test conditions were. Tradeoffs still exist when using slow shutter and our examined at the conclusion of the report.
  • While the 1080p HD camera was significantly better in the day than both thermal and SD, in the night test, at 1/30s shutter, no detection was possible even at the closest test point.

Conclusion: For long range, very dark conditions, a top low light SD D/N camera may be viable but only if used in slow shutter mode, recognizing the limitations of slow shutter. However, since a thermal camera only captures 'blobs' anyway, the comparable loss of a D/N with slow shutter is minimal.

Future Test: In December, we will do a shootout using add on IR illuminators to compare performance.

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Daytime

In the daytime, not surprisingly, even at 150', both SD and HD delivered significantly more details:

daytime 150'

Thermal's relative performance improves at 300' as the color images get less detailed:

daytime 300'

Increasing the distance to 450',

daytime 450'

Finally, at 550', while the subject is hard to see with both the thermal and the SD, the 1080p camera shows the subject fairly clearly - a certain advantage for HD.

daytime 550'

Low Light with 1/30s Shutter

After the sun went down, we tested the cameras using the same default settings: 1/30s shutter speed, with automatic switch to monochrome mode. This scene is approximately ~0.1 lux.

In all of these scenes, the 1080p camera did not deliver usable image even though the one used (Bosch) was the best performing 1080p low light camera we have tested so far.

At 150', the thermal camera shows the subject brightly and clear while the SD struggles to make out an outline.

low light 1/30s

At 300' the pattern continues:

night 1/30s 300'

At 450', it gets harder to make out the subject on thermal but still fairly obvious. By comparison, with the SD, it's nearly impossible.

night 1/30s 450'

Finally here's 550' with the trend continued:

night 1/30s 550'

Low Light with Color Mode

We also tried it with color mode on for the SD and black hot for thermal but results were roughly the same.

Here's a sample at 150':

night 1/30s 150'

And at 450':

night 1/30s color 450'

 

Slow Shutter in Monochrome

Finally, we tried using a slow shutter to see the tradeoffs. Interestingly, a 1/2s slow shutter on the Axis Q1602 hardly delivered any improvements over a 1/30s shutter.

Here's at 150':

night slow shutter mono 150'

And at 300'

night slow shutter mono 300'

Slow Shutter in Color

Though slow shutter in monochrome mode provided little improvement, forcing the camera into color mode with a 1/2s exposure greatly brightened the scene, almost to where it felt like we were looking at a daytime image. However, our subject became extremely blurry when in motion, making our subject indistinguishable, even at close range. The improvement in brightness and this ghosting can be seen in this image:

Ghosting in Axis 1/2s exposure

For strict detection, however, this setting does much to bring the Q1602 on par with the DRS thermal. Objects are much easier to distinguish, as they're now shown as colors against the neutral background, instead of simply greyscale. This is evident at all ranges:

First At 150':

night slow shutter color 150'

Then at 300'

night slow shutter color 300'

Now at 450'

night slow shutter color 450'

Finally at 550'

night slow shutter color 550'

At 1/2s shutter, the image delivered of a standing (or slow moving person) is essentially a tie. However, clear tradeoffs / risks exist with putting an SD camera at such a slow shutter:

  • Analytics will suffer numerous problems, likely forcing one to only manually / visually verify.
  • Faster moving objects will likely appear as a blur. On the plus side, it should be easy to visually verify something is moving but it will be hard to see what it is.

Video Clips to Review

Watch the clips for yourself:

1 report cite this report:

Sony 35mm Super Low Light Camera Tested on Oct 31, 2016
Sony is making a big push for their SNCVB770 camera, touting its low light capabilities that they claim can deliver true color in pitch black...
Comments : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

Hikvision ColorVu Camera Tested on Jun 24, 2019
Hikvision says their new ColorVu line captures "vivid chromatic images in darkness", with unconventional white light illuminations whereas most...
Repositionable Multi-Imager Camera Shootout - Avigilon, Axis, Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Panasonic, Vivotek on Jun 19, 2019
Repositionable multi-imager cameras are one of the fastest growing segments in video surveillance, with a slew of new offerings being recently...
False Verkada 'Unrivaled' Low Light Performance Claim Removed on Jun 12, 2019
Verkada falsely claimed that it delivered 'UNRIVALED LOW LIGHT PERFORMANCE' until IPVM questioned. In fact, Verkada's low light performance is...
Camera Course Summer 2019 - Register Now on Jun 12, 2019
Register for the Summer 2019 Camera Course.  This is the only independent surveillance camera course, based on in-depth product and technology...
Avigilon 32MP and 12MP H4 Multisensor Cameras Tested on Jun 11, 2019
Avigilon has released their H4 Multi-Sensor line of cameras claiming "broad scene coverage and high image detail" We bought and tested the...
Vivotek 20MP Multi-Imager Tested on May 30, 2019
Vivotek has released their latest repositionable multi-imager camera, the MA9321-EHTV, a 20 MP model claiming "Supreme Night Visibility", "Optimal...
Panasonic 32MP Multi Imager Camera Tested (WV-X8570N) on May 16, 2019
Panasonic has released their first multi imager models including the 32MP (4x4K) WV-X8570N, claiming "Extreme image quality for evidence capturing...
Mining Company Security Manager Interview on May 10, 2019
First Quantum Minerals Limited (FQML) is a global enterprise with offices on 4 continents and operations in 7 countries with exploratory operations...
11 Facial Recognition Providers Review (Secutech) on May 09, 2019
Adding to our 19 Facial Recognition Providers Profiled report from ISC West, IPVM focused on facial recognition technology for our Day 2 coverage...
Hikvision DeepinView Camera Analytics Tested on May 08, 2019
Hikvision is expanding its 'deep learning' offerings with a new camera series called 'DeepinView' claiming false alarm reduction and improved...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Security Dealer 'Social Media Contractor' Program on Jun 25, 2019
A $20,000 video surveillance system can be yours for free if you are willing to post on social media about the security dealer. Good deal, bad...
Axis Live Privacy Shield Analytics Tested on Jun 25, 2019
Privacy is becoming a bigger factor in video surveillance, driven both by increased public awareness and by GDPR. Now, Axis has released Live...
Directory of 55 Video Surveillance Startups on Jun 25, 2019
This directory provides a list of video surveillance startups to help you see and research what companies are new or not yet broadly known. 2019...
Hikvision Colorvu Camera Tested on Jun 24, 2019
Hikvision says their new ColorVu line captures "vivid chromatic images in darkness", with unconventional white light illuminations whereas most...
China Subway Facial Recognition System Examined on Jun 24, 2019
A China city of 6+ million people has installed facial recognition-enabled gates in subways, allowing commuters to enter stations by simply showing...
HID Mobile Tested on Jun 21, 2019
HID Global is one of the largest access brands, but their mobile access has had challenges. Indeed, the company has already restructured their...
Genetec Beats Milestone For IHS #1 on Jun 21, 2019
For years, Milestone has touted that they are the #1 VMS. Now, Genetec has beaten them in IHS rankings. But what is this? Even other manufacturers...
Risk of Amazon Alexa Guard: No Battery Or Cell Backup on Jun 20, 2019
Amazon positions its Alexa Guard Service as a "smart home security system" and says it can help you "keep your home safe". However, the...
Exacq Remote Cloud Access Tested on Jun 20, 2019
Remote cloud access has been missing from most VMSes (including Exacq and Milestone). Now, Exacq, after releasing Cloud Drive Storage earlier in...
Briefcam Buys Frost Award* on Jun 20, 2019
Frost 'awards' are well-known and widely disrespected. Now Briefcam is touting their win. The way it has worked for many years is that Frost...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact