Testing IP Thermal Camera (Axis Q1910)

By: Benros Emata, Published on Jun 01, 2010

In the last 6 months, interest in IP based thermal cameras have increased with Axis, FLIR and Pelco announcing relatively low cost product offerings. 

In this test report, we investigate how well the Axis Q1910 thermal camera works in the field, integrating it with Exacq's VMS and with Agent Vi's video analytics. We also contrast the performance of the thermal to Axis's Q1755 HD camera to better understand tradeoffs.

We explore the following questions:

  • What is the setup/configuration required to use the camera?
  • How far can the camera see?
  • What is the maximum FoV width to detect humans?
  • How does the camera's performance compare to a megapixel camera?
  • What palette or color profiles should be used to optimize viewing?
  • How does the camera impact the use of video analytics?
  • What limitations should be factored in for using the camera?

Below is a 1 minute preview of the premium report inside:

From our test, we found the following key points that can impact selection on thermal cameras and the Axis Q1910.

  • Setup: No special setup or configuration required. From a software and integration perspective, the camera works like any other Axis camera.
  • Palettes: The default palette is white hot but we found black hot to be the best option for a live monitor detecting subjects in the video.
  • Details of Subjects: Fine details of subjects were essentially impossible to detect unless a person was extremely close to the camera. The camera allows you to detect the presence of a subject but little more.
  • Night-time performance: Not surprisingly, at .3 lux when the Axis Q1755's image was dark, the Q1910 could easily show the outline of a person in the FoV.
  • Visibility: We were able to view subjects up to 500 feet away from the camera (approximately 150 foot wide FoV). At that distance, subjects are fairly tiny and can strain the eyes to track (especially if the subject is moving slowly).
  • Temperature impact: When the outdoor temperature is similar to human body temperature, visibility of humans can suffer significantly. We note this in the video analytics screencast where we used the camera during a summer day.
  • Light Resistance: Changes in lighting (like headlights from cars or glare of the sun) were not picked up by the thermal camera at all. We found this to be useful in reducing false alerts for video analytics.
  • Moving Foilage: Swaying leaves/trees that had a background of grass had minimal impact on the thermal camera (that is, it was hardly visible because of the same temperature). However, swaying leaves/trees that had a background of concrete/pavement were highly visible and can trigger significant false alerts (just like a color camera).

Product Overview

We tested the Axis Q1910 thermal camera in outdoor environments during daytime and lowlight conditions.  The following key specifications that were verified during our test should be noted:

  • The camera supports a maximum resolution of 160 x 120
  • The camera supports MJPEG and H.264 CODECs.
  • The camera supports ONVIF.
  • The camera supports Axis Camera Application Platform.
  • The camera supports PoE.
  • The camera supports a maximum frame rate of 8.33 fps. Note: According to Axis, US export regulations restricts general distribution of thermal cameras over this frame rate. Axis reports that it can provide higher frame rates for projects where the end customer and final destination are known plus appropriate paperwork is submitted.

Pricing

The Q1910 (indoor) has an MSRP of $2995 USD.  The Q1910-E (outdoor model) has an MSRP of $3495 USD. On-line pricing is moderately lower and can be referenced at Google products.

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Physical Overview & Web Interface

The following screencast covers the physical form factor and web interface of the Axis Q1910.

Key points include:

  • Similar in form factor to the Axis Q1755
  • Q1910 has a fixed 13mm lens
  • Image sensor has a resolution of 160x128
  • In the web interface, image can be scaled up to 720x576
  • Web interface has a palette option that changes the thermal color scheme on the camera image

Thermal Palette Comparison

In the following screencast, we discuss and preview the variety of palette options the Q1910 interface provides.  This test was conducted during nighttime at 0.3 lux, in an outdoor environment. We compared each thermal color scheme to see what would most compliment an operator's view in detecting a human.

Day Versus Night Color vs Thermal Operation

In this screencast, we contrast the performance of the Q1910 thermal camera with the Axis Q1755 day/night camera in daytime and nighttime scenarios.  The objective is to find the tradeoffs and options for each use within the given scenario.

Key points include:

  • During the day, the subject's heat profile was similar to vegetation in the environment, which reduced the impact of the thermal but did not affect the color camera
  • In daytime, the color camera had an advantage to make out details than the thermal camera
  • At night (0.3 lux), the thermal camera had an advantage to human identification than the color camera
  • Although thermal camera could detect human activity, details could not be determined from image

Maximum Distance Test

We tested how the resolution of the Q1910, combined with the thermal performance, impacted the ability to detect humans at different distances.  We conducted this test at night with a light level of 0.3 lux, in an outdoor environment.  We had our subject in camera view stop at pre-defined points every 100 ft, up to 500 ft.

Key points include:

  • At 200 ft, 63.8 ft wide field of view, subject's head started to blend with background (body temperature was similar in color to background environment temperature)
  • At 400 ft, 128.6 ft wide field of view, subject not as bright, getting difficult to detect
  • At 500 ft, 161.3 ft wide field of view, subject was small and with colors blending with background, made it a challenge to detect
  • Using the Black-hot palette displayed contrast better than the default White-hot

Video Quality Samples

You may download sample video clips (90 MB) from the Q1910 thermal camera that we have been referencing throughout this report.

Using With Analytics

In this screencast, we examine the performance of the Q1910 thermal camera's use with video analytics.

Key points include:

  • For night performance, thermal camera does a better job at seeing a subject than a color camera under natural light
  • For analytics, thermal cameras require less pixels per foot, with the additional potential benefit of better nighttime performance
  • Drastic changes in light and shadows often create issues with analytics
  • Thermal camera image does not change under direct, shining light, nor with moving shadows
  • Different temperatures between a tree in foreground and parking lot in background increases the tree's visibility which may cause false positive results in analytics
  • Depending on the environmental conditions, human subject may have similar body temperature to ground, causing possible missed analytic detection

3 reports cite this report:

New Surveillance Products Spring 2011 Final on Apr 06, 2011
In this report, we provide a single source listing new video surveillance...
New Products Reviewed Fall 2010 on Oct 12, 2010
In this report, we aggregate all our new products reviews for Fall 2010...
Examining Axis New Thermal Camera Offering (Q1921/-E) on Oct 04, 2010
Axis announced the release of the Q1921/-E thermal cameras (where -E is the...
Comments : Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

FLIR A Series Temperature Screening Cameras Tested on Jun 04, 2020
FLIR is one of the biggest names in thermal and one of the most conservative....
FLIR Screen-EST Screening Software Tested on Jun 30, 2020
In our FLIR A Series Test, the cameras' biggest drawback was their lack of...
Directory of 199 "Fever" Camera Suppliers on Aug 04, 2020
This directory provides a list of "Fever" scanning thermal camera providers...
Dotty "Hot Or Not" Elevated Body Temperature App Tested on Jun 01, 2020
What if you could take an existing phone or tablet and transform it into...
USA ICI Elevated Skin Temperature Detectors Examined on Apr 06, 2020
Infrared Cameras, Inc. (ICI) is aiming to help slow the spread of COVID-19...
Hanwha Wisenet X Plus PTRZ Tested on Feb 14, 2020
Hanwha has released their PTRZ camera, the Wisenet X Plus XNV-6081Z, claiming...
Video Surveillance Cameras 101 on Feb 25, 2020
Cameras come in many shapes, sizes and specifications. This 101 examines the...
ZKTeco Body Temperature and Mask Detection Reader Tested on May 26, 2020
While dedicated fever cameras emerged first, now tablet/kiosk fever detectors...
Euklis Presents AI Analytics on May 05, 2020
Euklis presented its AI facial recognition, LPR, and object recognition...
Kogniz Health Thermal Screening System on May 15, 2020
Kogniz, a Silicon Valley AI surveillance company is claiming to offer...
Seek Scan Thermal Temperature Screening System Tested on May 28, 2020
Now that IPVM has tested Dahua, Hikvision, and Sunell, we are returning to...
New Axis M30 Cameras Tested on Mar 26, 2020
Axis has released a new generation of, for them, relatively low cost M30...
Trueface Presents AI Face Recognition, Mask and Temperature Detection on Jun 10, 2020
Trueface presented its AI facial recognition, mask and temperature detection...
Injes Tiny Temperature Terminal Tested on Jul 17, 2020
While temperature terminals have trended bigger, the Injes DFace801 is...
FLIR Presents Dual Spectrum High Security Focused PTZ on May 01, 2020
FLIR presented its Elara DX-Series bispectral, visible and thermal, PTZ...

Recent Reports

Google Invests in ADT, ADT Stock Soars on Aug 03, 2020
Google has announced a $450 million investment in the Florida-based security...
US Startup Fever Inspect Examined on Aug 03, 2020
Undoubtedly late to fever cameras, this US company, Fever Inspect, led by a...
Motorola Solutions Acquires Pelco on Aug 03, 2020
Motorola Solutions has acquired Pelco, pledging to bring blue back and make...
False: Verkada: "If You Want To Remote View Your Cameras You Need To Punch Holes In Your Firewall" on Jul 31, 2020
Verkada falsely declared to “3,000+ customers”, “300 school districts”, and...
US GSA Explains NDAA 889 Part B Blacklisting on Jul 31, 2020
With the 'Blacklist Clause' going into effect August 13 that bans the US...
Access Control Online Show July 2020 - On-Demand Recording of 45+ Manufacturers Presentations on Jul 30, 2020
The show featured 48 Access Control presentations, all now recorded and...
Face Detection Shootout - Dahua, Hanwha, Hikvision, Uniview, Vivotek on Jul 30, 2020
Face detection analytics are available from a number of manufactures...
Sunell is The First China Manufacturer to Market NDAA Compliance on Jul 30, 2020
Most China manufacturers are going to be impacted by the NDAA 'Blacklist...
Ink Labs Relabels China YCX Fever Camera And Steals Dahua's Marketing on Jul 30, 2020
A US company marketed a 'thermal temperature scanner' as its own, selling...
Genetec and Dahua-Backed Intelbras Split Examined on Jul 29, 2020
China is the cause of the breakup between Canada's and Brazil's largest video...
This YouTuber is Now Selling ThermoHealth Temperature Screening on Jul 29, 2020
An enterprising 20-year old is mass marketing medical devices on Facebook and...
Hikvision Returns To Growth Driven By Overseas Fever Cameras on Jul 29, 2020
While Hikvision's revenue fell in Q1 2020, it rebounded in Q2 attributed to...
Brazil's Biggest Domestic Surveillance Company Intelbras Profile on Jul 29, 2020
While Intelbras is not widely known outside of Latin America, Intelbras is a...
The Kiosk Market Pivots To Temperature Screening (Interviewed) on Jul 28, 2020
Video surveillance is not the only market that has pivoted to medical device...
Integrator Acquisitions 'A Good Market' During COVID-19, Says Greybeards on Jul 28, 2020
Industry broker Ron Davis of the "Greybeards" says that the integrator and...