The Most Dangerous (and Easiest) Way To Export Surveillance Video

By: Brian Karas, Published on Mar 11, 2016

Rogue cellphones.  

Most DVRs/NVRs and VMSes have options to limit video export to external devices, but none of them can fix the analog hole.

Circumventing Security via Cellphone

Facilities may implement security policies for user logins that prevent exporting or sharing of video, but that does not stop an operator from making a video with their cellphone.

Video of high-profile people can net a security guard a payment that could be more than a year's salary, as in the Ray Rice video. 

The Jay Z elevator video is rumored to have gone for $250,000.

  

Other times the video might be exported just for fun:

It can be difficult to track down the source of cell-phone video leaks, making it tempting for employees to export video this way. The leaker of the Jay-Z video was found out and fired, but the leak behind the Ray Rice video was never identified.

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

Another example: The Ft Lauderdale shooting video has been released, via a cellphone recording, again from TMZ:

Easier than Clumsy Systems

Sometimes cellphone recording and sharing of clips is to make up for clumsy or inefficient export functions.  If you are trying to send a short clip to someone in a hurry, this method can be much faster than going through the process of selecting video for export, letting the export process complete, converting video to non-proprietary format and then emailing the clip.

For short videos, where the story is more important than the details in the video, screen recording via camera is effective. Videos of the brawl captured by the FLIR/Costco DIY system fit this example. 

Often Used By Police

Police often complain about difficulties with exporting video.  If video stored on citizen NVRs/DVRs cannot be intuitively exported in a simple format police officers have had to resort to using cellphones or body cams to record directly from monitors.  This method reduces the quality of the video from the native format, but may be the only practical option in those cases.

No Cell Phone Policies

Privacy-conscious organizations have implemented "no cell phone" policies for operators that routinely work with video surveillance systems. Many video monitoring central stations prohibit operators from having cell phones in their possession while on shift.

With cameras built into phones, tablets and laptops it can be very hard to completely close off the analog loophole and prevent employees from recording on-screen video.

1 report cite this report:

Exporting Video Surveillance Tutorial on Oct 05, 2017
Exporting video surveillance is important when incidents or crimes occur. However, there are multiple ways to export video which have their pros...

Comments (12)

Only IPVM PRO Members may comment. Login or Join.

...but none of them can fix the analog hole.

Couple, three far out 'fixes' for the analog hole.

LCD refresh

You know how sometimes when you make a video of a PC it comes out really bad; dim and with rolling lines thru it? Usually this is a function of the display technology used + PC's refresh rate + the cameras shutter speed.

If you look at the individual frames, you would see many blank screen or partially blank screen frames. The brighter the screen of the PC, the faster the shutter of the cell phone, and the greater the chance of catching the PC during a blanking interval.

And unlike CRT's or even plasmas, LCD screens have little persistence in the luminance of their pixels. They switch on and off quickly and with little effect due to hysteresis. They also have a far wider range of refresh rates available, from 30hz to 240hz. I wonder if a rate could be found that would substantially degrade the picture?

Macrovision ripoff

You may have tried to copy a blockbuster VHS tape and been disappointed with the result. That is likely due to Macrovision protection, a scheme by which the auto gain of the recorder is fooled by a extremely quick and false signal that causes the recorder to constantly adjust the gain, leading to a crappy recording.

Likewise, perhaps a subliminal signal, to quick to be perceived by our eyes, could be introduced that would cause the cellphone camera to adjust by lowering the gain and degrading the video.

Key Lemon

Taking a different approach, there is a face recognition/authentication single sign-on program called Key Lemon, which can automatically lock the session if it no longer detects your face directly in front of the screen. It also records people who try to enter your session. Although, I'm sure someone could stay in front of the screen and record at the same time, I wonder if it could be modified to lock a session if it sees a cell phone in the frame.

I'm sure even that could be beat, but remember the people who take these videos have not figured out how to beat these systems ahead of time, it's not like they are expecting J-Z to walk into an elevator and beat someone up on camera. So just a decent deterrent that makes it harder than just point and shoot may be all you need to make someone think twice.

"It also records people who try to enter your session."

More generally, add a camera on the operators / control room. They may not like that but it would help in checking who filmed the video with their phones.

Exactly, second issue though is having people with access to this who are not trustworthy, if you have dodgy staff then you should be paying for the mistake of not having the right people. (my view on the companies that have these dodgy security guards recording the footage on cellphones)

How much do you have to pay a guard a year so that $250,000 in a day won't tempt him?

I don't consider there to be a correlation between ethics and pay level

Though they say "Every man has his price"...

It's true that cell phones are a problem and the cell videos of celebrities in jail and such are a liability. Look at the award against Marriott for the peep hole video.

Many VMS platforms log who reviews video and for what cameras, but once the genie is out of the bottle it's hard to get back in. Who can you trust and do you use two person authentication to review video?

It won't be the desk clerk paying 22 million in damages.

I have had customers give keys to the building to one employee and alarm codes to another. Two man rule.

Same concept the military uses in silo's. It doesn't make it impossible but it does reduce the odds.

High security places don't allow phones with cameras so for a long time Blackberry made a smart phone with no camera for government workers.

Just having fun here, but most crap DVRs are recording in a lower resolution than the monitor being viewed from yet an iPhone camera resolution is greater so there would actually be more pixels being used to record a video taken directly from a computer monitor attached to a crap DVR (with an iPhone).

This is kind of like the scanners being sold today, what is the point when you can take a picture with your iPhone at 12MP and hit send.

Technology is fun.

TMZ / cell phone strikes again: FT Lauderdale airport shooting footage recorded by cell phone, feared sold to TMZ.

Another vulnerability to be aware of is a MITM attack on the HDMI output of a VMS client that is undergoing the security reviews. I would think that one would even be able to capture 4K with this method with the right gear. I also have seen posts of encrypted HDCP streams failing on such attacks when the intent is to protect the stream. Security is from end to end and not point to point.

I would ensure strict guidelines and processes are set for those who leak video. Make the operators sign a non-disclosure agreement that if they end up leaking the video they could face with serious legal action. Enforce the same. 

I usually put a small microdome camera in the Operator Room recording whenever there is someone in the room. This is to let the operators know that they are being watched. If someone does pull out a cell phone to record video - it will be captured.

Setup an Audit Log to capture all actions performed by an operator. Usually they would playback a video at a later date then record it. (not during the actual incident). 

Ensure exported video is watermarked & digitally signed - both on storage & export ensuring a chain of trust. 

Unfortunately whatever you do may still be a step short for someone who has intent. One can only hope that they have covered all bases. 

 

Related Reports on Police

Hikvision Global News Reports Directory on Dec 02, 2019
Hikvision has received the most global news reporting of any video surveillance company, ever, ranging from the WSJ, the Financial Times, Reuters,...
China Uyghur Analytic Projects Require Intel And NVIDIA, Intel Condemns, NVIDIA Silent on Dec 02, 2019
At least 8 PRC China police projects require NVIDIA and Intel chips to power their Uyghur-detecting analytics, according to procurement documents...
China Government Spreads Uyghur Analytics Across China on Nov 25, 2019
IPVM has found 12 recent government projects across China (PRC) that require Uyghur analytics and a general government guideline requiring such...
Dahua Co-Founder Says Human Rights Sanctions Shows Strong Dahua Technology on Oct 29, 2019
Despite Dahua doing nearly a billion dollars of projects in Xinjiang, including building and operating police stations, Dahua not only denies 'any...
Covert Elevator Face Recognition on Oct 24, 2019
Covert elevator facial recognition has the potential to solve the cost and complexity of elevator surveillance while engendering immense privacy...
Critiquing Carnegie's AI Surveillance Paper on Sep 25, 2019
The Carnegie Endowment has issued an ambitious paper on the Global Expansion of AI Surveillance. While its aim is applaudable, the paper has...
UK Facewatch GDPR Compliance Questioned on Aug 27, 2019
Even as the GDPR strictly regulates biometrics, a UK company called Facewatch is selling anti-shoplifter facial recognition systems to hundreds of...
Suprema Biometric Mass Leak Examined on Aug 19, 2019
While Suprema is rarely discussed even within the physical security market, the South Korean biometrics manufacturer made global news this past...
Biometrics Usage Statistics 2019 on Aug 13, 2019
Biometrics are commonly used in phones, but how frequently are they used for access? 150+ integrators told us how often they use biometrics,...
Embattled $400 Million China Funded Philippines Surveillance System Proceeds on Jun 13, 2019
An embattled 12,000 camera surveillance system project that will cost ~$400 million will proceed. The project contract was awarded, had its...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Disruptor Wyze Releases Undisruptive Smartlock on Dec 06, 2019
While Wyze has disrupted the consumer IP camera market with ~$20 cameras, its entrance into smart locks is entirely undisruptive. We have...
Bosch Budget 3000i Cameras Tested on Dec 05, 2019
Bosch has long had a hole in its lineup for, as it describes, "competitively-priced cameras". Now, Bosch has released its 3000i series cameras...
Anixter Resisting Takeover From Competitor on Dec 05, 2019
Mega distributor Anixter is going to be acquired but by whom? Initially, Anixter planned to go private, being bought by a private equity firm....
Security Sales Course 2020 - Last Chance Save $50 on Dec 05, 2019
This sales course is customized for the current needs and challenges specific to professionals selling video surveillance and access control...
Ireland National Children's Hospital Chooses Hikvision End-to-End With Facial Recognition on Dec 05, 2019
The world's most expensive hospital project ever, the New Children's Hospital in Ireland, has chosen an all-Hikvision surveillance system including...
AVTech ~$70 IP Cameras Tested Vs Dahua and Hikvision on Dec 04, 2019
Taiwanese manufacturer Avtech is taking direct aim at low cost leaders Dahua and Hikvision with ~$70 starlight and white light illuminator...
Ultinous European Analytics Startup Company Profile on Dec 04, 2019
European analytics-startup Ultinous pitches customers to "Have your own video analysis service!" We spoke to Ultinous to better understand their...
Access Startup Multi-Mount Aims To Streamline Reader Installs on Dec 03, 2019
Startup Multi-Mount claims it makes installing access readers 'Fast', 'Secure,' and fit 'any size frame.' The company states its bracket 'fits most...
Resideo CEO To Step Down on Dec 03, 2019
Resideo's CEO, Mike Nefkins, is stepping down, just 18 months after being brought in to lead the now plagued spin-out. Inside this note, we...
Arcules CEO Retracts False GDPR Claim + Dahua and Milestone Claims Examined on Dec 03, 2019
Arcules CEO has retracted a false claim about his organization being a "fully compliant GDPR company" after IPVM reporting (Arcules CEO Threatens...