Testing Panoramic Cameras Outdoors

Author: Ethan Ace, Published on May 12, 2013

Outdoors, PTZs tend to be a favorite for covering large open areas but they only see whatever they are currently pointed at. Panoramics are an emerging alternative but how well do they perform and what type of video quality do they deliver?

Following our groundbreaking panoramic camera shootout, we took a group of panoramic cameras to a moderately busy intersection scene to test their performance viewing pedestrians and vehicle traffic at various distances, shown in this overhead view:

The cameras were mounted on our portable tripod, about 13' off the ground:

Delivering panoramic overviews like so:

We then dewarped each of the panoramics and created 8 image comparison - at 8', 25', 50' and 100' from the camera during both day and night.

********, **** **** ** ** * ******** *** ******** ***** open ***** *** **** **** *** ******** **** *** ********* pointed **. ********** *** ** ******** *********** *** *** **** do **** ******* *** **** **** ** ***** ******* ** they *******?

********* ***************** ********* ****** ********, ** **** * ***** ** ********* ******* ** * moderately **** ************ ***** ** **** ***** *********** ******* *********** and ******* ******* ** ******* *********, ***** ** **** ******** view:

*** ******* **** ******* ** *** ******** ******, ***** **' off *** ******:

********** ********* ********* **** **:

** **** ******** **** ** *** ********** *** ******* * image ********** - ** *', **', **' *** ***' **** the ****** ****** **** *** *** *****.

[***************]

Key ********

**** *** *** *** ******** **** *** ****:

  • **** ** * **** *** ******* *****, *********** ** * human ******* ** ******** **** ** **** ***** *****, *.*., a ****** ******* ** ***** *** ******. ** ** ***** in *** ****** ********, ********* ******* **** *-** **** ******* little ** *** *** ** ************ *******.
  • **** ** *** ******** ***** ********, **** * *** **** past *** *******, ******* ****** **** *** ********. *******, ****, *****, and ***** ** ******** ** ****** ********.
  • *********** ****** ****** ** *****. *** **** ***** ******** *** human ******* ****** ** ****** *********, *** ******** **** ******* frames *** ******* ******* ****** ******. ********* ******* ****** ****, but *** ***** ******* ***** *** ** * *** *****. Finally, *** ******* ******* ******** *** ********* *****, *** ***** and ***** ***** ******** **** *** ******* ********* ** **** and ******** ********* ** *********.
  • ** *****, *********** **** ** ***** ********* ** *********, *** to ***** *** ****** ******. ********* ** * ******* ** medium ** **** ****** (**'+) **** ******* *********. ******* *********** becomes **** ********* ** ******, *** **** ******** ** **********, noise, *** *** ******. **** *** ***** **** *** ******** to ********* ** **** *****, *** ***** *** *********** ********** to *********.

****** *** ***** **** *******, ** ******* *** **** *** for ********* ******* ******** ** *********** ********* ****. ***** *** find **** ********* ** *********** **** ***** *******, ** ******* an ******** ** ********** ** *** *****, *** ******* *** ability ** ****** ******** ** ******** ** **** **** ********** the *****. ** ** *** ********* ***** ********* ******* ** any ***** ** ************** ** * ***********, ***** **** ******* make *** ***** ** **** *** ******.

Daytime ***********

** ***** ** **** **** ******* ****** ** *************, ** had *** ******* **** **** ************* ***' ** **** *** crosswalk ******, ***** *' **** *** *******. ******** **** **** overview *****, ** *** *********** *** *********** ** ***** *** brightness ***** *** ***** *******. **** ** **** *** ** accounted *** ** ********* ***** ******* ****, *** *** **** left ** ********* *** *** *****.

*** ***** ******* ********** ** *** **** ** *** **** each ****** ****. ** *** *** *** ***** **** ** the ******* ** *** *****, ***** ********* ***** **** ***. Vivotek **** *** **** **, *** **** *** *** *** user *** ** *** ****** ** *** **. **** *** have ** ****** ** ***** *******, ** ********** ******* *** further *** **** ******* *** **** ** *** *****, ******* in *** ******** ** *** **** *****. *******, *********** *** much ****** *** ******* ******* *** ******* ******** ** *** camera. *** ******* ** ** ******* ** ****, ** **** image ** ****** ** *** ** ** ********, *** *** image **** *** ****** ******** *** *******, ******* ** *** other *** ******, ******* *** ******* ***** ******* ** *** same ****** *** *******.

** ***', *** ******* ** *******, ******* *** **** ** fine *******. ***** ***** *** (** ****) **** ***** ** all **** *** ** **** ***.

****** ** ***** **', ** *** ********* ****** ******** *** street, ******** **** ****** ** ********* ** **** *******, ****** not ****. ** **** *****, ** *** **** **** *********** in *********, **** *** ******* ********* ***** ** *** **** M3007, *** ************* ************* ** *** ***** *******. **** ***** be ** ***** ** ****** ** ***** ****** ** * subject.

** **', ** *** ***** ** **** *** ****** ********. At **** ***** *** ******* *** ** ************ ** **'* known, *** ********* ***** ** **** ** ******** **** **** resolution. *** ******* ***** ******* ***** ***** *** **** ****** than ******.

*******, ** *', *** ******* ** ************, **** ******* *** hair *******. * **** ** ****** ******* ** *** *****, as ****.

**** *** ***** ** ******** ****** ******* *** ************ **** not ********* ** *********, *** **** ** *** ******* ******** range (~**'), ******* ****** **** *** ***********:

**** **** ***** ******* ** ****** *** **********. ***** *********** **** ***** ****, ** ****. **** **** **** *** ***** *** **-***** ******** ** the ******, ** *** **** *** *** ** *******. *** FE8172V ******** ********* *** ********* ********, *******, ** ***** *** view *** ***** ***** ***** **** ******* ****** ********.

Nighttime ***********

*********** ** *** **** **** ** ***** ******. *** ******** in **** ***** ****** ******* ************* *-** ***, ********* ** how ***** *** ****** *** ** ****** *** ******* ******, and *********** *** ******* ** **********. *** ******* ********* ******** enough ******* ** ******* **********, ****** ******* ** ****** *** human ******* ** ******** **** ********* ** ******. *** **** M3007 ******** *** ******** ***** **** *** ****** ***** *** least *****. *** ********* **-***** ******* ********** *** ********** ****, but *** ******* *** ******* ** *** *******, **** *** subject ********* ** ****** ** *****. *******, ****** *** ******* is *** **** **** ***/***** ****** ** **** ****, *** it ******** ****** ******, ** ******* ********** *** ********** ******, and *** *********** ***** ******** ** *** ***** ***.

** ***', *** ******* ** ****** **********, ** ****:

** **', *** ******* ** *********** ** *** *****, ****** without *** ******. ** ******* ********* ** **** ** *** other *** *******, ** ** ***** ****** ***/** *****:

** **', ******** *** ** ** ***** ********* ********** ***** the *****, *** ** ** ****** **********.

*******, ** ***** *****, ******** ******* **** ** *********, *** some ****** ****** ** *********.

*** ***** ***** **** "*****" ** "****" *** ********* ** determine *** ** ***** **** ********** *** **********, ****** ***** a **** *****. **** *** ***** **** *********** ********** ** determine, ** ****, *** ** *****, *****, ** ****** ****.

**** ***** ***** ***** ******* ** *** ********* ******* *****. Users *** ************ * **-****** ***** ****.

Test *******

** ****** ***** ******* **** *** ********* ********:

  • **** *****-** -- *** ******, ******* ** ******* **** ****, ******** ** camera
  • ********* **-*****: *.*** ******, ******* ** *.*** **** ****, ******** ** ******
  • ******* *******: *** ******, ******** ****** ****

*** ******** **** **** *********, ****** ******* *****, ***** *** standardized ** */***. ********** **** ** *** ******'* ******* ******** frame **** *** **********.

Comments (15)

Good test Ethan. Interesting seeing all the results of the big three we're seeing.

Nthan...great work! However assuming that the images were time synchronized, why are the images from the Vivotek camera always lagging behind the others?

Hi Michael, the cameras were synced to the same time server, and they're double checked before each test. There may be very slight float in the time (less than a second), but they generally show the same time. I suspect the lag we see is due to encoding latency, more than anything, as I can see it even in live video.

Ethan,

As I expected...I knew you would have them time synch'd! My comment was specifically directed to the encoding latency issue...and wondered why it's so noticeable w/ Vivotek and apparently nonexistent in the other 2?

Hey Michael, the Vivotek actually showed the least lag (all the way on the right in the embedded clips above), followed by Panasonic about a half a second (or less) behind it, then Axis about 1.5 seconds back.

I suspect it may have to do with how many streams the M3007 sends out, as we've noticed other issues because of this, too. I've already asked Axis for comment, and will circle back with whatever they tell us.

Ethan...yes, it was Axis...I was goijg from memory as I had closed the window long before I added the comment. It will be interesting to see what their response is...and it it's related to the number of streams, I wonder if shutting some of the added streams off would improve the performance?

Hello Ethan,

did u done any test on arecont vision 360/180 deg camera in indoor & outdoor application>

We have done a test of the 20MP 180 degree model.

We plan to test the upcoming 12MP 360 head to head against these models above.

Do you plan to test the 180 panoramics, such as those from scallop imaging? Would be interesting to see how they compared to 360 fisheye cameras, particularly with their ultra low light unit for night time.

Ben, we will do one general comparison between 180s and 360s to show fundamental tradeoffs but we are not going to 'shoot' them out head to head as it would not be apples to apples (dramatically different field of views).

As for Scallop Imaging, the issue we have is the max 1fps frame rate for full resolution. Regardless of its low light capability, at 1fps, that's a huge limitation. Our understanding is a new generation will come out (sometime) that will improve this and when that happens, we definitely test Scallop.

I would like to see how Immervision does in this comapriason. Are you planning to run include Immervision any time soon?

Jim, we included Immervision 1.3MP in the overall panoramic shootout, so you can see that comparison. Immervision image quality was in the middle of the pack there. As such, we would expect the same here.

More importantly, soon Immervision has their 5MP lens coming out and the first 3rd party minidome embedding their lenses. We plan to test both and would assume better performance from those new ones vs the old lens they have had out for years.

Right. I read that post with great interest some time ago. Awsome job by the way... I was also at the ISC when you did the live comparison. What i meant was that i wanted to see in in the 'street corner' version of the shootout. Should have explained myself better.

Also, that 5 mp Immervision lens was to have shipped under the Fuji name this month. I wanted a couple for a job I'm doing now, but they are not yet selling them. You are correct about the form factor issue. So i am sticking an Axis camera in a cylindrical light fixture (see below) that matches with other fixtures in the space. But after your shoot out, i am having second thoughts and thinking more about Arecont.

I am very interested in your test of the Brickcom camera (which imbeds the 5mp lens in a dome camera). I like the form factor and the fact that i don't have to worry about the VMS support issue; but i know nothing about the company. Tell me more....

Jim, thanks for the feedback and the diagram. Nice approach.

It's too bad that the 5MP lens keeps getting delayed. It's been going on for a very long time.

As for Bricksom, they are a Taiwanese manufacturer who first entered the surveillance market a few years ago. They are a subsidiary of Gemtek, a wireless broadband networking provider. Brickcom has a fairly standard line of surveillance cameras, with their key differentiator, not surprisingly being for wireless / cellular integrated options.

Immervision says they are going to embed their M mount lenses into many other minidomes over the next year so you can pick from Brickcom or later on, see who else Immervision adds.

Very interesting testing, thank you. I have implemented modeling panoramic cameras in VideoCAD8 and compared results of modeling with these tests.

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports on Panoramic

Camera Application Selection Guide 2017 on Aug 23, 2017
Entrances, hallways, rooms and parking lots are perhaps the 4 most common areas where surveillance is deployed. But what is the best type of camera...
IP Camera Specification / RFP Guide 2017 on Aug 14, 2017
RFPs are hard. Do them 'right' and it takes a lot of knowledge and time. Do them 'wrong' and you can be (a) unwittingly locked into a specific...
PTZ Usage Declines 2017 - Statistics on Jul 03, 2017
PTZ usage is declining, now at ~6% of all cameras integrator use, down from ~10% of cameras used in 2014, according to new IPVM...
Panoramic: Fisheye vs Multi-Imager Usage on Jun 09, 2017
Panoramic cameras are a growing trend within video surveillance. The two main options are fisheye cameras using a single imager with an ultra-wide...
48MP 180 Camera (Digital Watchdog) Test on May 10, 2017
Camera resolution continues to advance, with Digital Watchdog offering the MegaPIX PANO 48MP 180° camera, the highest resolution mainstream camera...
Hanwha 9MP Fisheye Camera Tested (PNF-9010R) on May 09, 2017
12MP sensor fisheye panoramic cameras are becoming increasingly common. We have tested Hikvision's DS-2CD63C2F as well as Panasonic's SFV481 4K...
Panoramic Camera Usage Rising 2017 on May 08, 2017
Panoramic camera usage (including fisheye and multi-imagers) continue to rise rapidly. However, the race to the bottom is hindering even stronger...
Vivotek 3MP 180 Wall Mount Camera Tested on Feb 28, 2017
Purpose-built wall mount panoramics have become an attractive niche to cover entranceways. In 2013, we bought and tested Vivotek's 1MP...
Axis 15MP Multi-Imager Tested (Q3708-PVE) on Feb 07, 2017
Axis continues to expand in the multi imager market, adding to a segment started with the 33MP Q3709. We bought the Q3708-PVE and tested it...
Lux Rating / Minimum Illumination Guide 2017 on Dec 23, 2016
Lux ratings are one of the poorest specifications to use in selecting cameras. Now, with the rise of integrated IR, they are increasingly...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Cisco Falling - Favorite Network Switches 2017 on Oct 20, 2017
1 major manufacturer fell and 1 outsider manufacturer gained as integrator favorites for network switches from more than 140 votes / explanations...
Uniview Recorder Backdoor Examined on Oct 20, 2017
A Chinese research group has identified a vulnerability in Uniview recorders that allows backdoor access in a method similar to the Dahua...
Hikvision Access Control Tested on Oct 19, 2017
Hikvision aggressive pricing and marketing combined with generally reliable hardware and free software has made them a major player in video...
Verkada, Silicon Valley VSaaS Startup, Targets Enterprise on Oct 19, 2017
Verkada says they are building an enterprise-class VSaaS offering, calling it "The new platform for video security". This is a departure from the...
Exacq Unbreaks Avigilon Integration on Oct 18, 2017
For nearly 4 years, Exacq had broken and effectively blocked use with Avigilon cameras, as IPVM reported in January 2014. Now, Exacq has...
Search More Important Than Live Monitoring - Statistics on Oct 18, 2017
Search is overall more important than live monitoring to integrators, according to new IPVM statistics.  The key themes found in integrator...
Axis 'Sold Out' P3707-PVE Multi-Imager Tested on Oct 18, 2017
Axis faced significant product shortages over the summer. Perhaps the most notorious and significantly sold out model was the Axis P3707-PE 8MP...
Dahua Removes Auto Rebooting on Oct 17, 2017
For years, Dahua has automatically programmed its IP cameras to reboot weekly, a highly atypical and questionable practice. Following IPVM...
Deep Learning Tutorial For Video Surveillance on Oct 17, 2017
Deep learning is a growing buzzword within physical security and video surveillance. But what is 'deep learning'? In this tutorial, we explain...
Multipoint Lock Access Control Tutorial on Oct 17, 2017
Doors are notoriously weak at stopping entry, and money can be misspent on wrong locks that leave doors quite vulnerable. While closed and locked...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact