Testing Avigilon Integrated IRBy: Ethan Ace, Published on Jul 15, 2013
Integrated IR is a big trend in IP cameras. After years of major manufacturers criticizing IR illumination inside their cameras, pretty much all IP camera manufacturers offer integrated IR options.
Avigilon's integrated IR cameras claim to now only eliminate IR washout/bloom, but to extend coverage range far farther than any of their competitors. Specifically, Avigilon offers a 9 - 22mm lens option that is rated for 60 meter. Here is an overview of how those claims match up:
Because of this, we were interested to know how well the Avigilon IR bullets truly performed. So we bought 2 of their 2MP IR bullets, the 'short' focal length and the 'long' 9-22m one, and put them to the test.
Inside, we break down performance in image quality comparisons and video screencasts.
Here are our key findings from this test:
- Infrared illumination reached specified distances (30 or 60m, depending on lens type), rare among integrated IR cameras, as most overspecify.
- However, IR power is greatly weakened at maximum range, making image quality suitable for detection only, a drastic reduction from daytime image quality.
- Illumination was even across the field of view at multiple FOVs, with no visible blooming or hot spots, common when using many integrated IR cameras.
- Adaptive IR was most effective outdoors, very responsive with moving objects in the scene.
- Indoor effects of adaptive IR were lessened, due to the smaller area and reduced IR power.
- Full light performance similar to other Avigilon cameras and competitive models.
- In very low light (<1 lux) bandwidth decreases substantially with IR on, ~50% outdoors, and ~80% indoors.
MSRP pricing on the HD bullet series starts at $795 USD for the 1.0 MP 3-9mm model (The 9-22mm lens option is $40 more). Based on dealer discounts, we estimate street pricing to be in the mid-$600s for the 1.0 MP 3-9mm model.
This pricing is less expensive than many major brand IR cameras, such as Axis, Arecont, and Sony, though on par with Vivotek, and pricier than comparable from ACTi and Dahua:
- Avigilon 1MP HD Bullet: ~$650 USD estimated street price
- ACTi E45: ~$450 USD online
- Arecont AV1125IRv1: ~$750 online. No adaptive IR. Resolutions up to 5MP available.
- Axis P3364-LVE: ~$1,000 online. 1MP only, no higher resolutions available.
- Dahua HFW3101C [link no longer available]: $337 online [link no longer available], 1-3MP models available
- Sony SNC-CH160/CH180: ~$860/$1,200 online. 1080p versions, the SNC-CH260/CH280 are also available.
- Vivotek IP8352: $621 online
For night time / low light monitoring, the Avigilon IR bullets are worth considering as they cover a long range and eliminate the blooming / overexposure common in integrated IR cameras. The main constraint is recognizing that the coverage area still falls significantly compared to day time performance.
In an upcoming test, we will match up Avigilon IR bullets with Axis Lightfinder and Bosch Starlight models to see how they compare in low light.
In this screencast, we review the physical features of the HD bullet camera. Of note:
- Cast aluminum housing, articulated at multiple points to adjust for proper mounting angle.
- Bottom mounted Ethernet port for easier installation and maintenance, not found on most competitive models.
- Newer design IR LEDs larger and more powerful than smaller LEDs found on many cameras.
This video reviews the web interface and configuration of the HD bullet camera. The bulk of the web interface is identical to other current generation Avigilon cameras, with the addition of settings controlling the camera's adaptive IR.
Adaptive IR Performance
Avigilon's adaptive IR claims two benefits:
- The illumination angle is changed as the camera's field of view is adjusted, better matching to the scene. This occurs via multiple sets of IR LEDs with differing illumination patterns, which are switched on and off as the camera zooms.
- IR power is reduced based on the scene. This may be due to either reflectance in background objects or moving subjects.
We found that adaptive IR resulted in even illumination across the scene at multiple zoom ranges, without substantial hotspots or blooming common in other IR cameras where the illuminator does not match the FOV. Additionally, the IR power adjustment worked well in response to moving objects in the scene in our outdoor tests, adjusting power quickly. This is shown in the following screencast:
In our indoor test scene the effects of adaptive IR on our subject were very limited. With the subject directly in front of the camera, at about 6', there is minimal difference in images with adaptive IR on and off, seen in this example below.
IR Range Performance
We found Avigilon's actual IR range to be closer to the specified range (30m/60m in 3-9mm/9-22mm models, respectively) than many other cameras/illuminators we've tested. However, at max ranges IR power is weak, essentially suitable for detection only despite relatively high pixel density. We review this in the following screencast:
These images compare each camera's widest and narrowest FOV in both sunny daytime scenes and low light scenes with IR on, to show this drop in image quality.
First, using the 3-9mm model, with the subject at 30m (maximum IR range), the camera is barely able to detect our subject in low light at 3mm. At 9mm, he is easily detectable, but with no details:
This images compares the 9-22mm model's widest and narrowest FOVs. At 9mm, our subject is detectable at night, with very little detail, making even classification as human or animal difficult. At 22mm, details are improved, with the top line of the chart minimally readable in low light:
We tested the HD bullet's license plate capture performance by setting it to its narrowest field of view, 11°, about 30m from our test car. With the car moving at approximately 30mph, the license plate was easily readable (ELJ-55**, last two characters masked). Significant motion blur and artifacting made identifying the make and model difficult.
However, despite these issues, the license plate was clear, seen in this image.
Note that this test was run using default shutter settings (1/30s). Motion blur may be less of an issue using faster shutter speeds, but we have not tested capture performance using anything other than defaults. Users may download a clip of this scene (~13.9 MB).
Full Light Performance
In full light, the Avigilon bullet is comparable to the non-IR Avigilon H3 series camera, with slightly less saturation. The H3 and Bosch NBN-932V, another current generation 1080p camera, are shown here for comparison.
Performance in Avigilon Control Center
As we demonstrated in our test of Avigilon's image adjustment features, Avigilon Control Center may provide modest improvements to low light performance. Due to these adjustments, at maximum IR range (60m), detection performance is improved, as can be seen in the comparison below. However, enhancement is modest, with no additional identifying details available.
This daytime image shows both cameras at their widest field of view, 3mm and 9mm, respectively, with the subject located 30m from the camera (click image for larger version):
This image shows each at their most telephoto, 9mm and 22mm, with the subject 60m from the camera:
The HD bullet's IR illumination significantly reduced bandwidth both indoors and outdoors. In the following comparisons, note that Avigilon uses VBR encoding with a cap with a maximum value of 12 Mb/s.
Outdoors, below 1 lux, we measured the following averages:
- Avigilon HD bullet, 1080p: ~5.5 Mb/s
- Avigilon H3 series, 1080p: ~11.5 Mb/s
- Bosch NBN-932V: ~9.5 Mb/s
This equates to an approximately 40-50% reduction in bandwidth.
Indoors, again under 1 lux, bandwidth reduction was greater, due to the more reflective area. Bandwidth dropped by as much as 80% with IR on:
- Avigilon HD bullet, 1080p: ~2.5 Mb/s
- Avigilon H3 series, 1080p: ~11.5 Mb/s
- Bosch NBN-932V: ~9 Mb/s
Finally, we measured bandwidth in our indoor scene in full light to provide a baseline of bandwidth. In this case, bandwidth is near equal to the Avigilon H3 box camera, though higher than Bosch:
- Avigilon HD bullet, 1080p: ~3.7 Mb/s
- Avigilon H3 series, 1080p: ~3.5 Mb/s
- Bosch NBN-932V: ~1.1 Mb/s