First GDPR Facial Recognition Fine For Sweden School

By Charles Rollet, Published Aug 22, 2019, 08:57am EDT

A school in Sweden has been fined $20,000 for using facial recognition to keep attendance in what is Sweden's first GDPR fine. Notably, the fine is also the EU's first GDPR fine for facial recognition, adding some clarity to use of the technology in the GDPR era.

IPVM Image

In this post, we examine the fine and its impact, including:

  • First Sweden GDPR fine ever
  • First GPDR facial recognition
  • What happened at the school
  • How the school justified it
  • The role of a data protection impact assessment
  • How the fine was calculated
  • Warning for further use
  • GDPR compliance for facial recognition
  • Negative market impact of such precedent
  • UPDATE: school will appeal

IPVM Image

First ****** **** **** ****

**** ** *** ***** GDPR **** ** ****** ever, ** ****** ** the****** *******:

IPVM Image

First **** ****** *********** **** ****

********* ** ** **** review ** **** *****, including ******* *** *************** *********** *******, **** ** *** first **** * **** fine *** **** ****** for ****** ***********.

What ********

IPVM Image

*********** * ************** ** ********** **** ********** ********* ('Datainspektionen'), ** ******** ** Anderstorp’s ***** ********* ****** in*********å *************** ***** ********** ******** via ****** *********** *** a * **** ***** period ** ****. **** was **** ****** ** a ************ ****** ***** at *** ******** ** a *********; ***** **** no ******* ***** *** camera's ***** ** **** software *** ****.

********* ** *** ********, the ****** ****** *** system *** ** **** time ******** ********, ***** takes ** **** **,*** working ***** *** ****:

** ******** ********** ********* to *** **** ******, a *********** *** ***** 10 ******* *** ****** and ** ***** **** recognition ********** *** ********** control ** *****, ********* to *** ****** *****, save **,*** ***** * year ** *** ******* school.

** ** *** **** how ******** **** **, though *** ****** ******* said ****** ********** *** each ****** ********, *******, whether ** **** ** minutes *** ***** ****** is *******.

Legal ***** *** **********: *******

*** *******' **** ***** for ********** *** *******, as *** ******** ******** had ****** ******* *****. The ****'******** ***** ********** ********** ****** for * *** **********, including "******** *******" **** data ********.

GDPR ******** ** ******* *** *****

******'* *** ***** ******* major **** **********. *******, it ********** **** *** Article * ******* ************* was *** *****, ***** there ** ** ******* balance ** ***** ******* the ****** *** *** students, **** ******* ***** not **"****** *****":

** *******, ** ** clear **** *** ******* is ** * ********* position ** *** ****** in ***** ** ******, funding, *********, *** **** future **** ** ***** opportunities.

Other **** *********: ****************

*** ****'******** ******* **** ******** **** collection ** "********, ******** and ******* ** **** is *********" *** *** purpose ** **********. *******, the *** ****** ***** facial *********** ******* ****** in * "********** ********" ** *** school *** "**************** ** relation ** *** *******" of *** **********, ******:

********** ****** *** ** done ** ***** **** that *** ******* ******* violation *** ********.

No **** ********** ****** **********

*** ***** **** ********* was **** *** **** school, ***** ** ******* out * **** **********, did *** ******* * Data ********** ****** ********** as ********** ******** ** the****'* ******* **.

***** *** ******** **** any ********** "***** *** technologies" **** ******** "********** on * ***** ***** of ******* ********** ** data" [*.*. **********]. ***** must ******* ******** ************ of ********* "***** ** the ****** *** ********" and * "********* *** proportionality" **********.

***********, *******'* ******* ********** **** *********** "******* the *********** *********" ***** to ********** ** *** DPIA ********* ** "***** result ** * **** risk" ******* ********** ********.

*** **** ****** *** not ******* * **** nor ******* **** ******'* DPA, ********* ******** ** and **.

How *** **** *** **********

*** ******* *** ********** the ************* "***********" *********** that "*** ********* *** ******** sensitive ******** **** ********** children *** ***** * ********** ******** in ******** ** *** high ******." ************, ********* Articles * *** * was ********** "**** *******" than ***** **** ********.********** ******* ******** **** only ** ******** **** involved *** *** **** period *** ******* (* weeks).

****, * **** ** 200,000 ******* *****, ** slightly **** **** $**,***, was **********. *** **** school ***** *** ****** the ****.

******* *** ******* ***

***********, *** ****** ******** says **** **** ** continue ** *** **, prompting *** ******* **** Protection ********* ** ******* a *******:

*** **** ****** ***** of *********å ************ *** stated **** **** ****** to ******** *** **** recognition *** ********' ******** control. ***** ********** **** similarly ******* *** ********** of **** ********** **********. Due ** *** **** of ****** ********** ** In ********** **** *** planned **********, * ******* is *** *****

UPDATE */*/**: ****** *********

*** **** *** ******** by *** ****** ** September *,********* ** ** *******************, * ******* ***** for ***** ***** ********, which ******** *** ******:

*** ******** *********å'* ******** to ******. ** **** be ** *********** ** deepen *** ******* *** Data ************'* ******** *** conclusions. ** ******** ******** and ******* ** *** members' ******* *** ****** development ** * ******* age, **** ***** *********, Director ** *** ********** of ************ ** ***.

**** **** ***** **** appeal *** ****** **** it ** *******.

******** ****** ******

******* *** *** ** the ******* ****** ******* for ****** *********** ****** the *****. **** ****** could **** * ******** effect ** ***** ******* that *** ** *********** using ****** *********** *** increases *** ********** *** risks ** ******* ****** to **** ****** *********** to *******.

**** ***********

**** *********** *******:

  • ** ****** *********** ****** on *******, ** **** be "********" *** "****** given" ** ********** ** the ****. ** ***** is * ***** ********** in *** ******* ** power ******* *** ********** and *** **** *******, Data ********** *********** *** not ******** ** *****.
  • ***** *** **** ********* for *** *** ** facial *********** ***** ***** result "** * **** risk ** *** ****** and ******** ** ******* persons". ***** **** ******'* DPA *** ********* **** filming ******** *** ********** constitutes **** * ****, this ***** *** *** can ** ***** ****** reached.
  • ***** ** ****** *********** must ******** ******* **'* proportionate - *** *******, is ***** * ****** way ** ** **** without **** ** ********* technology?
  • ****** *********** **** ***** are ****** ** ** higher **** ***** ****, with *** ******* *** explicitly ****** **** ** fines ******* * (*.*. biometrics) ***** **** *******.

Comments (22)

**** * ******* ****** providing **** ******* ** this ******:

** ****** * ********** upper ********* ******. ************ those **** ** ******* have ********* **** **** attendance. ****** *** ********* between **-** ***** ** age *** * *** less ********* ******** ** students ******** **** *********** and **********/******* *********** ***************. What * ** ****** to *** ** **** attendance ****** ***** ********** be * *********. ********** is **** ********* ** a ******** (********** ** federal ***** ** *** US) ***** ********* ** approx. *** ******* * month. ****’* *** ********** checks *** *********.

******* ***** *** *** class – ** * here? ***/*** ******* ***** say. “***, *** ****** now.” *** **** * doesn’t **** **. ******** that ***** *** **-** students ** * ***** - ** ******* ***** quite **********.

Agree: 2
Disagree
Informative: 6
Unhelpful
Funny

*** ******* ***** ******* interviewing *** ** ******* of *** ******, *** ********:

*** **** ******'* ** strategist ***** ******** ** surprised *** *** **** expecting ****** ******* ** was * ***** ******* project.

- * ** *** understand ***** ********** *****, moreover ** *** **** out ** ** ******** were **, *** ****** did *** ****** *** approval, ******** ***** ********.

*** ************ *** *** yet ******* ******* ** will ****** ******* *** authority's ********.

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny

*** ** ** ******** were **, *** ****** did *** ****** *** approval, ******** ***** ********.

*'* ** ******... ******* ********** ** ******** * pretty ****** ***** *** appeal ***...

*** **** ************'* ******** of '********** ** ******* of *****' ** ******** undermined ** *** ***** from **. ******** *****.

#***********

Agree: 2
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

*** ****** *** *** submit *** ********

****, ** *** ****** did *** ****** *** approval, **** *** **** make ** ***** ***** GDPR? ******* ******* ** required *** ********* ********** unless ***** ** ****** interest, ***** **** *** apply ****. ***/**, *******?

Agree: 1
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

* **** ***** ** saying **** *** * students *** *** *** 'opt **' **** *** used ** *** *****....

* ***'* **** **** that *****, *** *'* like ** **** *** explanation *** *** *** 7 **** ********, *** if ** *** **** this ** ** *** case * ***** ** has ****** ******* *** appealing *** *********.

Agree: 1
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny

* ***** **** *** pursued ********* ******* ***** ignored *** *****-******** *** guidelines ********* **** ** has ** **** **** before ******** *** *** technology - ***** ** didn't **.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

**** ************ ******** *******

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny: 2

* ***** **** **** means ** **** ** out ** ** ******** signed ******* *****, **** the **** ****** ***, i.e. ***** * **** not ******** ********** ** all. ** ***** *** IT *******'* ******** ***** is: '***, ** *** students *** *** ** this, *** **** ***, but ** ***** *** sanctioned'.

*******, **** ******* **** students ***** *** *** no **** ****** ***** the ****. *** **** issue *********** ** *** data ********** ********* ** the ***** ********* ******* students *** *** ****** ("** ** ***** **** the ******* ** ** a ********* ******** [** the ******]"), ******* ******* cannot ** "****** *****." There ** ******* ** the **** ******** **** factor **** ******* **** data ******** ****** ** opt ***. ******* ******:

** ***** ** ****** that ******* ** ****** given, ******* ****** *** provide * ***** ***** ground *** *** ********** of ******** **** ** a ******** **** ***** there ** * ***** imbalance ******* *** **** subject *** *** **********, in ********** ***** *** controller ** * ****** authority

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny

***** * **** *** facially ********** ** ***

**, *** **** **** work ************? ** *** camera *** ** ** such * *** **** the ******** *** ***** out *** ********** ***** the **** **** *** facial *********** ****** ** covering?

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

***** * **** *** opted *** **** *** being ******** ********** ** the ***** **** **** did *** ******* *******/********* that ******* *** ******** to ***** **** *** record ***** **********, ** was **** **** *** other ** ****, *** the ******* *** ******:

*** *********** **** *** been ********** *********** **** ** *** form ** ****** ****** as **** ** ***** and **** *****.

** ***** * **** never ******** ***** **** to ** **** ** the ******. *** ****** was *** * **** controller ** ***** ********** information. **** **** **** not * ***** ** the ****.

*******, ***'** ******* **** if ***** * **** were ************ ***** ****** by * ************ ******, even ** **** ****'* provide ***** **** ********** and **** **** *** being *******, **'* ***** considered ********** ********** **** requires ***** *******, ** we *** **** ****** ** ************ *** *********** ***** states **** **** ******* need ******* **** ******** being ******, *** **** the ****:

*** *** ***** ****'* unclear **** *** ******* DPA's ****** ** ******* there *** * ************ camera ** *** ********* recording *** *** ********, or ** ******-******* **** system **** ********** **** student ************ (*** ******* via * ****** *********** terminal):

** ** *** ** access *******-**** ******, ***** would ** ** **** issue **** ***** * students *** *** *** consent, ** **** ***** easily ***** ***** ****** altogether. *******, ** ***** was * ************ ****** filming *** ***** *********, for ** ** ** fully **** *********, ** would **** ** ***** filming *** ***-********** ******** - ****** ** ******** them **** *** ******'* FoV ** ***** **** kind ** ******* ******.

*'** ******** ** **** the ******* *** ****** what **** ** ****** was ** *** *** will ****** **** ******* upon ********.

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny

"** ***** ** ****** that ******* ** ****** given, ******* ****** *** provide * ***** ***** ground *** *** ********** of ******** **** ** a ******** **** ***** there ** * ***** imbalance ******* *** **** subject *** *** **********, in ********** ***** *** controller ** * ****** authority"

"*** **** ***** *********** by *** **** ********** authority ** *** ***** imbalance ******* ******** *** the ******"

*** *** *** *********** agencies ********* ****** *** EU **** ******* *** facial *********** ***** ***************** * ***** ********* of ***** ** ********?

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 3
Unhelpful
Funny

**** ** * **** question *** *** *** correct **** ***** ** always * **** ********* of ***** ******* ** individual *** * ****** force. *******, ** *********** are **** ***** ** this, ***** ** *** they ***** ***** *** the "*******" ************* **** the ****'******** *- ******* **** *** the "*********** ****** ********" justification, ***** ** ****** separate *** *****:

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

*** **** **** *** cover *** *** ** personal **** *** *** enforcement ********. ***** ** a ******** ***** ********** that ****** **** ****** the *** *********** *********.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

***'** ******* ******, ***** about ** ******* *********** #1. ****** *** ****'******** *('******** *****') ********** ******** law ***********:

****** *********** ************* ******* ******* ********** of ******** **** **** facial ***********, ******* ** is *********

***** ** ******* **** where ******** *********, ******* to *********** ********** *** the ****** *** ******** of *** **** *******

*** ********** **** **** meet *** ** *** three ********* **********:

****** ***, ** **** for ** ****** ** obtain ******* *** ****** recognition.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

** * ***...

*** ********** *** ** used ** *** ***********, but *** ****** ****.

**** ****** ****.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

***** ** ***** * need ** ** ***** about ******* (******** *****) and ************* **** *** law ***********, **** **** sure **** ****** ******. Transparency **** * **** way ** ******* **** of ***** ******. ** someone *** *** ******** this ********** (**) *** over ** ***** (********* in ******** ** ****), we ******* ***** ******* long ***.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

**** **** ** ** are ********* ** ** that ********** *** ****** its ********** ** *** GDPR **** *** ********** Consumer ******* *** ** the ***** ** *** FCC’s *********** ** *** Neutrality **** *** ********* of *** **** **** Internet *****. *’* *** saying ****** ** ***** laws *** *** ‘** all’ ‘*** ***’ ******** toward ******** *** ****** privacy **********, *** ** least **** *** ** and ********** ********** ***** was ** ***** *** both *** ****** **** faith ******* ****** ********** address *** ****** ******* protection.


**** ** ********** ** more ******* ****** ********* Net ********** *** *** current ***’* ******* ** acknowledge, *** ***** *******, the ******’* ****** ********* Internet ******. *** ******* FCC, ***** *** ************ of **** ***, ****** Verizon ******, *** ******* developed * ******* **** of ******* ** ****** the **************, ******* *********, redlining, ********, **********, **** prioritization (“************** *** *** purposes ** ****** *****, not *** ****** ****** or *** *********** ********”), and **** ****-****** — “the ******** ** ********* certain ***** ** ******* from ******** ******* * data *** (***** ***** an ********* ******* *** ISP *** *** ********)” to ******** *** **** Open ******** ***** ***** the ****** *** ************ Tom *******.

Agree: 1
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny

***** ** ** **** Face *** ** ****** among ********** ** *** fact **** *** ********* signal, ****** *** ****, is ****** ** ******* 24/7. ** **** ** would ** ********** ** it ****'*.

** *** *** ****** about **** *******? *** iris *** ******, **** protection ***** *****. *** isn't * **** ******* taken *** ********' **********? License? ******** ** ************ all *** ****? **** is *** ***** ** penalties *** *** ************ data ** ******** ** safeguard?

Agree: 2
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

****, ** *** **** place */* *** ********* of *** ********** ***** identified *** ***. **** most ***** ********** ***** is ******* * ***** interaction. **** ***** ** another *** ***** ** could ** **** */* user ******* ** *** taking *****. **** ** why ****** *** ************ about *** ****** ** surveillance *******. *** **** issues ***** ** *** use ** ******** ****, including **********, ** ** just *** **** **** the ** *** **** can **** ********* *********** realities. ** **** **** opt-in ***** **** ****** as ****'* * **** in *** ******* **** assessment.

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

*** ********* ** **** sure *** ****** **** in*****

Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny
Agree
Disagree
Informative
Unhelpful
Funny

******: ** *'** **** added ** *** ****, the **** *** **** appealed ** *** ****** on ********* *,********* ** ** *******************, * ******* ***** for ***** ***** ********, which ****:

*** ******** *********å'* ******** to ******. ** **** be ** *********** ** deepen *** ******* *** Data ************'* ******** *** conclusions. ** ******** ******** and ******* ** *** members' ******* *** ****** development ** * ******* age, ********* *********,******** ** *** ********** of ************ ** ***.

**** **** ***** **** and ****** **** ** is *******.

Agree
Disagree
Informative: 1
Unhelpful
Funny
Read this IPVM report for free.

This article is part of IPVM's 7,011 reports, 932 tests and is only available to members. To get a one-time preview of our work, enter your work email to access the full article.

Already a member? Login here | Join now
Loading Related Reports