Security Consultant Conflict of Interest

Author: John Honovich, Published on Mar 08, 2011

While security consultants should be totally committed to the needs of their customers, many fear that manufacturers have undue influence on consultant specifications. In this report, we examine those concerns and highlight a case where Axis recently paid for an extravagant Caribbean Cruise to 'educate' security consultants.

Role of Security Consultants

Medium to large projects in the physical security industry are often designed by security consultants, Architects or Engineers. Security managers depend on consultants to help find and plan the best solution.

Consultants are extremely powerful. Their decisions routinely impact hundreds of millions in security spending each year. The designs they select, the specifications they include and often the products they require all shape which manufacturers win and lose.

Manufacturer Motivation

Given the powerful role consultants have, manufacturers are hugely motivated to influence them. Almost all large manufacturers have sales teams dedicated to 'educating' and 'helping' consultants. The amount of help ranges from the benign (specs, webinars and whitepapers) to the dangerous (vacations, sporting events, even occasionally outright kickbacks).

Concerns About Consultants

In our experience, security consultants are generally not well respected. Being a consultant demands greater expertise and stronger independence than most other roles. The inability of many consultants to live up to these higher standards is the likely cause of this disrespect.

Below are a few recent comments about security consultants that are representative of the frustration we hear:

  • Their knowledge: "Most I have worked with have very limited experience with security and are interested in finding someone who knows what they are doing that can assist them."
  • Working with them: "The best way to influence what ends up on the spec seem to be to offer to do the design work for them, spend money on them, or a combination of both."
  • "I assume all A&E's and sadly, even security consultants, are morons until they prove otherwise. I can count on one hand the people whose knowledge I respect."

The most consistent theme we hear is how little most security consultants know about the systems they specify - especially technologies like IP video surveillance. Manufacturers work hard to fill / exploit this knowledge gap.

Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox
Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox

Manufacturer Events

For decades, across technology sectors, manufacturers have run events to 'help' and 'educate' consultants. Often, these are as simple as 'lunch n learns' where the manufacturer pays for sandwiches and delivers a short presentation. Sometimes, the events are expanded into a full day workshop or series of sessions.

The pinnacle of these events is the multi-day off-site gathering where manufacturer can mix business and pleasure. While manufacturers generally pay all (or almost all) expenses, the cost is certainly worth the influence gained. Being able to become friends not only with the consultants but with their wives over the course of multiple days is a powerful sales advantage.

Axis A&E Summit Examined

Like many manufacturers, Axis holds periodic events to educate security consultants. The recent Axis 2011 A&E Event, including a 3 day Caribbean Cruise and excursions to multiple Bahama Islands, is particularly extravagant.

Here is an overview / breakdown of business and free time for the conference:

  • 3 and 1/2 days total
  • morning training / education sessions (13 hours total)
  • Afternoon: free time - cocktails, dinner, land excursions to Bahamas, etc.

Axis covered the following costs:

  • 1 night at luxurious first class resort
  • 3 days and nights on Caribbean Cruise Ship
  • Meals and cocktails (including 4 dinners)
  • Land Excursions to islands in the Bahamas
  • Includes Guest accomodations, Axis hosted meals, receptions and pre-planned excursions

Airfare was not included. We estimate Axis paid approximately $1,500 per consultant for the accomodations, meals, drinks and excursions (including costs for consultant and guest).

The event drew a sizable crowd as shown in their Event group photo.

We shared our concerns with Axis and asked them for feedback and input on the event. Here is their response:

"Multi-day events are more effective because attendees have the time to ask detailed questions, provide feedback and network with other experts and partners in the field. For Axis, we received valuable feedback that will go directly to the R&D teams. For the consultants, they received approximately 5 hours of sessions each day, with time slotted for ASIS course credits, feedback sessions, and partner technology showcases from 13 other companies. Also, each evening, specific networking receptions were scheduled so that attendees had opportunities to meet and have deeper discussions with fellow industry experts, Axis partners, and management.

The main reason we chose the cruise was because Royal Caribbean has an extensive IP camera installation on board this ship and it provided the perfect venue to show a real-world scenario, which was used throughout different sessions. While Royal Caribbean is an Axis end-user, not all cameras on board were from Axis – so it gave an example of the openness that can be achieved with network video."

Ethical Concerns of the IAPSC

We asked a leading Security Consultant organization, the IAPSC, for input on these practices. The IAPSC provides guidelines on consultant practices and allows some expenses to be paid by manufacturers during education events. We asked them for clarification on what expenses and how far manufacturers can go:

"The IAPSC's guidelines for independence allow for manufacturers to pay for simple items, such as lunch, during the course of education events. However, our guidelines do not allow for manufacturers to pay for extended trips, vacations, expenses for guests, etc. Such activities would be reviewed as potential ethical violations."

- Norman Bates, President of the IAPSC

The Conflict

Users trust security consultants to deliver the best solution for the user's needs. A clear expectation exists that the consultant's interests are aligned with user's interests.

A conflict of interest arises when:

  • Contrary interests provide gifts or compensation to the consultant
  • The consultant develops personal relationships or friendships with the members of the contrary interest

Both of these conflicts are clearly happening in the Caribbean Cruise. Regardless of what education occurs, the event is intimately bundled with activities that raise conflicts.

Everyone Loses ... But Big Manufacturers

When the ante to 'educate' consultants is raised to giving away vacations, the only organizations that can pay hundreds of thousands to do this is very large manufacturers. The outcome is simple and obvious: the 'education' of consultants is biased to the interests and abilities of these companies. Small manufacturers, integrators and other industry members will struggle to get their voice heard as consultants minds and bellies are filled by the biggest manufacturer's largess.

What Do You Think?

1 report cite this report:

Top 12 Reports for 2011 on Dec 25, 2011
Here are our top 12 reports for 2011, starting with the state of the surveillance industry:2012 Video Surveillance Guide - Key trends reviewed and...

Related Reports on Criticism

Axis Secretly Paid Anixter Sales People To Push Axis NVRs on Sep 26, 2016
Internal Axis communication shows how Axis paid Anixter and Tri-Ed sales people with secret bonuses to push Axis NVRs. In this report, we examine...
US Embassy Requires Hikvision Cameras on Aug 29, 2016
The US Embassy in Kabul Afghanistan has required only Hikvision cameras in a new US federal government bid. However: Hikvision was founded...
Dahua Distributor Angered "Always Give Good News About Hikvision" on Aug 11, 2016
A Dahua distributor is angry that "IPVM always give good news about HIKvision while destroys Dahua." I can understand the frustration, not of...
Dahua Fakes Being American on Aug 10, 2016
Robbed from the Hikvision playbook, now Dahua takes it turn. Dahua, China's second largest manufacturer, is ramping up its...
Avigilon "Probably Going To Zero Within The Next Two Years" Charges Analyst on May 18, 2016
The analyst who blasted Avigilon 2 weeks ago as being a Cash Strapped, Commodity Company is not backing down one bit. Indeed, the original target...
Hikvision Rejects Responsibility for Hacked Hikvision Cameras on May 10, 2016
After a massive number of Hikvision cameras were hacked, Hikvision has added new, and questionable legal language, declaring that Hikvision will...
ADT's Terrible "Business Video Special" on May 06, 2016
ADT is special. Pricing for HD video has gone down sharply, but not for ADT whose "less than $2 a day offer" is quite...
Drako Launches Fake Charity Sales Promotion on Mar 31, 2016
There is nothing quite like a really rich guy using charity to sell surveillance systems. The children may be the future, but for Eagle Eye...
Hikvision (Stops) Lying About Ezviz Security on Mar 18, 2016
Hikvision promoted the security of their directly sold Ezviz consumer line to Americans in a March 9, 2016 release. False It featured this false...
ADI More Bad Advice: Network Switches on Mar 04, 2016
Run with scissors?  Play in traffic?  Trust ADI for networking advice? The last we checked with ADI, they were promoting bogus numbers from a...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Arecont To Release Industries' Best H.265 Support on Sep 30, 2016
Go big, or go home. That seems to be Arecont's philosophy for H.265, they say they are working on the "best" H.265 implementation in the...
Wall Street Journal Runs Report on Dahua Hack on Sep 30, 2016
The Wall Street Journal is bringing attention to the massive Dahua attack we reported on Tuesday. In an Thursday article entitled, "Hackers Infect...
Dahua USA CEO Tim Wang, Where Is Your Integrity? on Sep 29, 2016
Dahua USA CEO Tim Wang and Dahua Director of Marketing Tim Shen shared their IPVM passwords extensively, resulting in Dahua USA CEO's account...
Allegion NDE Wireless Lock Examined on Sep 29, 2016
While wireless locks are one of the hottest areas of access control, two of its biggest challenges are high cost and limited integration with...
The 'Last Chance to Save' On Hikvision Is Here on Sep 29, 2016
It is over. After at least 8 across the board price cuts in the past 10 months, including an unprecedented back to back 20% off, Hikvision has...
Camera Calculator Class and IPVM Member Orientation October 2016 on Sep 28, 2016
Members, learn how to better design video surveillance systems and get the most out of your IPVM memberships with 2 upcoming live classes. Both...
Axis 4MP Camera Tested (M3046-V) on Sep 28, 2016
Axis has brought 4MP to its camera line in the new M3046-V, the highest resolution model in their revamped M30 series. We bought and tested this...
Hiring Spree At Aimetis 6 Months After Being Acquired on Sep 28, 2016
Aimetis was acquired in April 2016, and is now expanding almost all of their departments, hiring employees from Axis and other industry...
Hikvision Chairman Tours With Chinese Government Boss on Sep 28, 2016
Two China Communist senior officials toured Europe this summer, one was Hikvision's Chairman and the other was his boss, SASAC Director. In this...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact