SD Analog is Finally Dead

By: John Honovich, Published on Oct 19, 2015

Good news.

For years, industry people have hoped for the demise of NTSC and PAL analog cameras. Now that day has come and, after years of steady declines, the end has come suddenly.

IP Failed

But the killer is a surprise.

Though IP has been dominant for years in the high end of the market (larger projects and richer countries), IP has never been able to eliminate analog usage for small projects and less wealthy countries. IP's cost premium and additional complexity continued to hinder its expansion in those areas.

Cause of Death

Analog was killed by... analog. 

In less than 3 years, HD Analog (like HD-CVI, HD-TVI and AHD) has gone from nothing to killing SD analog (i.e., NTSC / PAL and even 960H).

In 2015, SD analog sales will fall more than 50% compared to 2014, a massive drop. And SD's decline has accelerated throughout 2015, as HD analog offerings have ramped up and more suppliers switch away from SD / 960H to HD analog.

Why It Died Now

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

HD analog offers MP at roughly the same price point and with the same cabling as SD analog. Just like MP was the 'killer app' that drove the high end to IP, MP was the driver for moving the lower end of the market from SD analog to HD analog.

IPVM Tests of HD Analog include:

2015 was simply the year that HD analog went mainstream, and in doing so, it knocked out SD analog.

SD Analog's Future

Just like some CCTV VHS machines are still recording in 2015, despite being killed a decade ago, some SD analog will continue for years to come, though only in 'maintenance mode'.

At the low end, where individual kits are bought, we see SD analog quickly becoming extinct.

However, at the mid to high end, where systems are maintained and gradually expanding for a decade or more, some SD analog cameras will continue to be sold, simply to replace broken SD cameras or add small numbers on to SD analog systems that are not ready for complete replacement.

As HD analog matures, we see even SD analog systems adding them even before migrating to HD recording. Increasingly, HD analog cameras are including the option of dual HD and SD analog outputs which would help facilitate this migration (i.e., buy an HD analog camera now to replace a failed SD one, record it SD in the short term and when ready to upgrade to HD recording, 'flip' the camera to the HD output).

IP vs HD Analog

With the death of SD analog (finally), now sets up a new rivalry - IP vs HD analog.

As our HD Analog Usage and Rejection Statistics show, HD analog is taking share both from SD analog and IP. However, since HD analog has started from the bottom of the market, it has had far more of an impact on SD analog.

The bigger question becomes, how competitive can HD analog become against IP?

As our HD Analog vs IP Guide 2015 shows, today, though HD analog wins (big) on price and simplicity, it loses on many other elements - max resolution, advanced capabilities, breadth of vendor support, VMS integration, brand recognition, etc. which makes it unattractive to most on the mid to high end. However, it is quite possible, though not guaranteed, that HD analog closes the gap on most of these in the next few years.

Given the potential / need for HD analog improvements, we believe it is hard to predict the actual outcome. On the other hand, those who simply dismiss HD analog because it is analog, and that analog is dead, are imprudent.

Vote

6 reports cite this report:

Video Surveillance History on May 06, 2020
The video surveillance market has changed significantly since 2000, going...
Surveillance Cameras 2017 Overview on Jan 02, 2017
This report concisely explains the developments and most common options for...
Top 5 Video Surveillance Product Advances Going Into 2016 on Dec 31, 2015
Here are the 5 product areas that have had the most meaningful product...
Security Cameras 2016 Review on Dec 23, 2015
In 10 minutes, this note explains the current state of security /...
2016 Security Manufacturer Outlook Revealed on Dec 21, 2015
Last year, manufacturers nailed the biggest issue of 2015, as we revealed in...
Canon Declares Itself Largest Surveillance System Company In the World on Oct 21, 2015
With both Axis and Milestone firmly entrenched as Canon subsidiaries, Canon...

Comments (42)

Only IPVM Members may comment. Login or Join.

And Todd Rockoff stands vindicated, although not exactly how he thought he would be.

Non-IP HD is a reality, just not the HD-SDI (aka HDcctv 1.0) he pushed for years.

Though not that far from where he began either. Sure, he went Digital instead of Analogue, but that's all he had to work with. Maybe if instead of launching LinkedIn flame wars he might have discovered The Real Inventor Of HD-CVI And HD-TVI.

But 95% of his arguments for SDI apply equally to CVI.

"But 95% of his arguments for SDI apply equally to CVI."

Except for the one about cost. We used to have arguments about this in the 2010 - 2011 era, where our position was that the price of SDI / HDcctv was simply too high. It took the HD analog providers in the past 2 years to offer the rock bottom prices that Rockoff had hoped for.

But Analog still wins in low light all day!!!!! Sure, the image quality looks like an Atari game but its still better than any IP camera out there, take that and pair it with a tube monitor and you got yourself a mean surveillance system............... Totally kidding.

Sean, that's funny because it was a common complaint even up to a few years (recall the Axis SD Q1602, e.g.). I am sure there are still some people who stick to that. However, it's amazing how much sensors have improved that the top non-thermal, non-IR cameras are now 1080p (including from companies like Dahua and Hikvision - see: Hikvision Darkfighter Camera Tested and Dahua Starlight 1/2" Camera Tested).

As 'hackability' becomes more and more of a concern a return to a true closed circuit of devices with only one or two networkable points that need securing will be become prevelent. Also as the developing world scrambles to 'monitor' itself in higher resolution price will be king.

David, interesting point! If cybersecurity continues to rise as a concern for video surveillance systems, HD analog cameras (even using baluns and category cable) could become a useful technique to reduce exposure.

...return to a true closed circuit of devices with only one or two networkable points that need securing will be become prevelent.

Disagree. The "true" closed circuit of yesteryear had 0 networkable points, not 1 or 2.

More importantly, although networks with less devices are nominally more secure, the weakest point is, and will remain the DVR/NVR, as it cannot totally isolated from the outside world in the way that cameras can be.

"The "true" closed circuit of yesteryear had 0 networkable points, not 1 or 2."

What year was that? 1999? :) It's been a long time since CCTV had 0 networkable ports?

That said, I agree the DVR / NVR does remain a risk, certainly if its 16 'secure' HD analog cameras to a single Hikvision recorder....

It's been a long time since CCTV had 0 networkable ports...

Agreed. That is why a 'return to a true closed circuit' is implausible.

If this were true we'd still see parallel ports on printers, instead of Ethernet/wifi as the default connection method.

The security industry at-large still hasn't learned IT security, but that will change. At a minimum hooking up IP cameras to a PoE NVR device (Razberri, et al) effectively eliminates your attack point to a single platform, just like an HD analog NVR.

Still waiting for HD analog/TVI/CVI encoders so we can start using this for enterprise deployments.

Hikvision has an 8 channel and a 16 channel TVI encoder coming out. It's not on their website but I saw it in their fall 2015 catalog.

Ari, thanks for sharing. Hikvision has mentioned they are coming but no firm NA release date.

From the catalog, here is the excerpt of the two upcoming TVI encoders:

Also, Testing Dahua HDCVI Encoder With VMSes

Hikvision USA will have stock before the end of November.

(Disclosure: Hik Employee)

For me, new installs are all about IP. Even if its a budget install. Upgrades of existing systems it's all about TVI. I cant see installing TVI as a new system.

Our technicians who used to be against installing IP, no prefer it and can install it faster. It's worth spending a few dollars more for IP. No need for an external power supply on small projects or messy cable in someones office.

John, thanks, how does the pricing compare for you on TVI vs IP (say with Hikvision)? Is it really just a few dollars total price difference?

If we're installing 720P cameras theres only a $40 price difference per camera, but than you have to consider the cost of a good quality power supply, so it about evens out. Most of the low end TVI cameras aren’t built as well either, so thats a concern for me. I am in the North East, I need to be sure the cameras we install can holdup to the storms. When you add in the additional time of installing the power supply and cleaning up all the cable. It’s almost the same cost.

As someone that spent many years working on analog mobile, wireless and body worn products, I saw a large customer demand for those items but only very limited interest from vendors on them. I'm curious to see what will happen to those areas if analog truly 'dies'.

Mobile IP cameras have been attempted but not very well adopted (for various reasons) but I wonder if any vendors will expend energy on an HD analog mobile dvr. That would solve the major issues with mobile IP, namely how to get 48v POE from a 12v source, and how to harden a mobile NVR with enough processing power for IP cameras in a vehicular environment.... and not break the bank.

"I wonder if any vendors will expend energy on an HD analog mobile dvr."

Scott, give how well HD analog is selling, and the value of using analog in mobile / bus applications, I would expect to see that in the next year or two.

That's a good example of a main limitation of HD analog right now, as it does not yet have more niche form factors / options.

Hikvision is coming out with them. I just ordered some units to start an internal test.

(Disclosure: Hik Employee)

There are many advantages to the "new" HD over Coax that are significant enough to overcome the issues with version 1.0. One single separator other than price is the distances. Parking structures are a prime example where they need better images and that extra 700' or so makes a world of difference. Version 1.0 didn't help with this.

Some of the cameras HAVE some pretty advanced imagers as shown in IPVM tests. It's not all "the lowest cost" when you buy a HD Coax camera with true WDR and Remote Zoom/AutoFocus capabilities.

I see this technology as another tool in the belt to be used when needed, and there is a need. As small businesses have to deal with PCI compliance there will be value in not stringing network access points around the building. There are many in this group that make efforts to prevent issues but this is a limited subset of what is out there.

When encoders are common place it will increase adoption IMHO.

the problem with analog HD is that each manufacturer has its own format.

When using IP, you have ONVIF as an alternative to integrating multiple manufacturer's cameras.

There is no such standard for analog HD.

Jaime,

The 3 way fight (CVI, TVI, AHD) is a drawback, especially for those with larger systems that need to ensure expansion and replacement devices are available for years to come.

We are starting to see some recorders support both TVI and AHD but Dahua (CVI) seems determined to go it alone. There are some cameras out there that claim to work with all 3 but they can have image quality problems and are unauthoried by any of the 3 providers (see: HD Analog Four Way Cameras Tested).

We are starting to see some recorders support both TVI and AHD...

Authorized recorders that support both AHD and TVI?

Thats huge! Are they OEM or real HIK/SAM product?

Digital Watchdog, for example, mentioned this to us. We have heard other people in that space talk about it as well, so I am pretty sure this is going to be more prevalent in 2016.

Yes, it is a problem that there are so many HD Coax formats. Just like it was a problem with so many PTZ control formats and UTP formats like PELCO C and its competitors. Fortunately on the IP side ONVIF came in and made everything IP work perfectly together just like plain old NTSC and PAL (which has also plagued the industry). Three or four formats aren't going to slow the flow as much as a 300' distance limit and expensive cameras did to version 1.0 SDI.

Interesting solution, notably for low latency systems. Are PCI/PCI-Express capture boards planned or available for these HD analogs "standards" ?

Sylvain, we have not seen any, so some might exist, but it appears to be uncommon right now.

Related, there remains limited support on the DVR side. We expect this to change though, given that many manufacturers tend to be conservative, waiting for verifiable market shifts before adding in support for new protocols/ standards/ transmission types. That said, 2015 HD analog results will show quite conclusively that this is a big market.

Sylvain and John, Exar (fomerly Stretch) is now sampling HDCVI PCI-Express capture and compression cards.

Colin, do you expect those cards to be sold individually or only embedded into DVRs?

Yes, our SD and 960H cards go individually through VARs and Systems Integrators as well as OEMs building DVRs or hybrids. We expect the same for HDCVI.

Something interesting about this is the adoption rate. When did CVI / TVI / HD Analog hit the market- 2014? 2013? While it is not exactly dominating the industry it has made a bigger splash in a shorter time than IP did.

Austin, yes, good point. None of the variants really started becoming available until 2014, which underscores how well it has done this quickly.

In terms of its short term splash, HD analog has shot up very quickly. However, if you put it into the context of 'non IP HD', it has taken a long time. The first non IP HD effort was launched in 2009 and it went nowhere for years. And then in 2014, as they switched from non IP digital to non IP anlog, it exploded.

Gonna miss this analog form factor...

Not for long.

You can get those in TVI actually.

Does someone know if there are AHD pinhole cameras?

Carlos, Alibaba shows some AHD pinhole cameras. The problem with AHD, in general, is that there are very few major manufacturers with significant product / form factors available right now.

With over 200 votes, IP won the poll with 61% choosing IP will be more widely used than HD analog in 2020.

However, HD analog did fairly well, given how new it is, with 25% saying HD analog and IP would essentially be tied and 14% saying that HD analog would beat IP.

Here is snapshot of the poll results:

Manufacturers and integrator voting were virtually identically split

Question: If there is existing coax cable infrastructure, would you upgrade to HD with IP or HD coax technology?

Related Reports

Infinova, March Networks and Swann H1 2020 Financials Examined on Sep 02, 2020
While Dahua and Hikvision, helped by fever camera sales, are recovering from...
Pivot3 Mass Layoffs on Mar 27, 2020
Pivot3 has conducted mass layoffs, the culmination of grand hopes, a quarter...
Fever Camera Sales From Integrators Surveyed on Jun 01, 2020
Fever cameras are the hottest trend in video surveillance currently but how...
Bottom: Integrators Start To Stand Vs Coronavirus on Apr 20, 2020
Good news - IPVM integrator statistics show that while coronavirus has hit...
ADI Sales Down 21% in April on May 14, 2020
ADI sales were down 21% in April, the company disclosed, as the pandemic hits...
Uniview H1 2020 Financials Examined on Sep 08, 2020
While Dahua and Hikvision, helped by fever camera sales, are recovering from...
IPVM's 12th Anniversary - Thank You! on Apr 07, 2020
IPVM is proud to celebrate it's 12 anniversary expanding our commitment to...
2020 Mid Year Video Surveillance Industry Guide on Jul 27, 2020
The first half of 2020 has been shocking, for the world generally, and for...
Huawei HiSilicon Shortage Impacts Surveillance Manufacturers on Aug 14, 2020
Huawei acknowledged problems and challenges for its HiSilicon chip business,...
Dahua, Hikvision, ZKTeco Face Mask Detection Shootout on Jun 19, 2020
Temperature tablets with face mask detection are one of the hottest trends in...
Facial Recognition: Weak Sales, Anti Regulation, No Favorite, Says Security Integrators on Jul 07, 2020
While facial recognition has gained greater prominence, a new IPVM study of...
Axis Compares Fever Camera Sellers to 9/11 on Sep 18, 2020
Axis Communications, the West's largest surveillance camera manufacturer, has...
Coronavirus Hits Manufacturers, Standing Now, Worse To Come on Apr 06, 2020
Coronavirus is hitting security manufacturers, though overall modestly for...
Indian Government Restricts PRC Manufacturers From Public Projects on Aug 04, 2020
In a move that mirrors the U.S. government’s ban on Dahua and Hikvision...
Costar Technologies / Arecont H1 2020 Financials Examined on Sep 16, 2020
Costar's financial results have been hit by the coronavirus with the company...

Recent Reports

Temperature Tablet Shootout - Dahua, Hikvision, ZKTeco, TVT + 5 More on Sep 30, 2020
Temperature tablets, aka terminal or stations, have emerged as a 'low-cost...
New Products Show Fall 2020 Tomorrow Bosch, FLIR, Hanwha, Tyco, Avigilon More! on Sep 30, 2020
IPVM's sixth online show concludes tomorrow with our special temperature...
ButterflyMX Raises $35 Million on Sep 30, 2020
Startup ButterflyMX has raised $35 million for its smartphone based intercom...
Worst Access Control Manufacturers 2020 on Sep 30, 2020
200+ Integrators told IPVM "In the past year, what access control...
Access Control Levels and Schedules Tutorial on Sep 29, 2020
Configuring access levels and setting up schedules is central to maintaining...
Avigilon / Motorola VS Virtual ISC West on Sep 29, 2020
ISC West has historically been so dominant that no player would think of...
Dartmouth College Deploys K3 Temperature Screening on Sep 29, 2020
While Dartmouth College has a $6+ billion endowment, the College has bought...
Hanwha AI Object Detection Tested on Sep 28, 2020
Hanwha has added detection and classification of people, cars, clothing...
Favorite Access Control Manufacturers 2020 on Sep 28, 2020
200+ Integrators told IPVM "What is your favorite access control management...
OnTech Smart Services Partners With Google and Amazon To Compete With Integrators on Sep 25, 2020
A pain point for many homeowners to use consumer security and surveillance is...
The Future of Metalens For Video Surveillance Cameras - MIT / UMass / Immervision on Sep 25, 2020
Panoramic cameras using 'fisheye' lens have become commonplace in video...
Hikvision Sues Over Brazilian Airport Loss on Sep 24, 2020
Hikvision was excluded from a Brazilian airport project because it is owned...
China General Chamber of Commerce Calls Out US Politics on Sep 24, 2020
While US-China relations are at an all-time low, optimism about relations...
Verkada Disruptive Embedded Live Help on Sep 24, 2020
Call up your integrator? Have someone come by the next day? Verkada is...
IP Networking Course Fall 2020 - Last Chance - Register Now on Sep 23, 2020
Today is the last chance to register for the only IP networking course...