Samsung Brags: Our Cameras Are Fragile!Author: John Honovich, Published on Nov 08, 2013
Samsung wants you to know that their plastic domes are fragile. We are here to help.
In a recent promotion, Samsung shared tests to "verify to customers that our internal domes with plastic housings could continue to operate effectively even when attacked."
What type of attacks can Samsung withstand? An angry man with a sledgehammer?
Samsung tells us that their tests "produced some surprising results" and that is was "good news."
The news was that Samsung plastic domes garnered IK ratings of 6 to 8. Now what does that mean?
Understanding the IK Scale
Vandal resistance is measured on the IK scale and consists of dropping a weight on the object being tested. (See IEC / EN 62262).
The big issue is that it is a scale and the rating / levels vary dramatically. Here's the official scale with Samsung's positioning marked up:
Samsung plastic domes range from 75% to 95% less vandal resistant than full IK10 rating.
Here's what an IK10 test looks like:
IK10 is pretty solid, though some would argue that a single blow at that speed / weight is not enough. Indeed, some camera manufacturers test to IK10++ which delivers 2.5x the force of IK10 (50 instead of 20 joules).
The worst part is Samsung cameras that are 'vandal resistant' to IK6 (i.e., max of ~1 pound weight from ~8 inches away). Not only is that 95% less than IK10, it is a trivial amount of force. Indeed, a camera that is IK6 implies that it failed the meager IK7 test, which is ~1 pound from ~16 inches away.
Unless you only need to stop a baby from slapping a camera and breaking it, Samsung's plastic dome vandal ratings are worse than worthless.
1 report cite this report:
Related Reports on Criticism
Most Recent Industry Reports
The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.