Samsung Wisenet Lite Cameras Tested
Far lower-cost MP cameras are a major trend now.
So far, the 'Chinese' have been leading the way here.
Samsung's Wisenet III series hit the market offering performance similar to more expensive high-end models at much lower prices. Now, Samsung is aiming at the low end with their Wisenet Lite series, priced competitively with Hikvision and Dahua.
We bought two of these 1080p cameras, the Samsung SND-L6083R varifocal dome and SNO-L6013R fixed focal bullet to see how they compare to low-cost competitors and Samsung's own Wisenet III line, including:
We tested the cameras in interior full light:
Low light:
And WDR scenes:
Here are our key findings:
- Full light image quality similar to competitive models, with slightly more even exposure than other low-cost models.
- Low light image quality superior to other low-cost IR models due to more even IR illumination, with better details of subject and chart.
- Both dome and bullet cameras had IR reflectance issues, from the inside of the dome and the bullet camera's sunshield, though image quality impact was slight.
- Better performance than other low-end models in WDR scenes, with subject details much more visible, though not as good as true WDR SNB-6004.
- CODEC settings allow no control of compression, with default H.264 profile capped at 4 Mb/s with a GOV length of 5, with no way to change these settings.
- Both camera housings are plastic only, with the bullet rated IK08 and dome IK10, compared to most low-cost competitive bullet and dome cameras aluminum/IK10.
Price
Pricing on the Wisenet Lite cameras tested is as follows:
- SNO-L6013R ~$150 USD online
- SND-L6083R ~$250 online
This is competitive compared to models from Hikvision, whose 1080p bullet models typically sell for ~$150-160 online. It is moderately higher than Dahua, whose HFW1200S 1080p bullet can be found for as little as $90-100 online. However, Samsung product is readily available through distribution in North America, whereas non-OEM Dahua models are not.
Recommendations / Market Impact
The Wisenet Lite series is competitive in price with low-cost leaders Dahua and Hikvision, while providing moderately better image quality and IR illumination. These factors, combined with Samsung's strong brand, make it a strong competitor in the low end of the market.
Physical Overview / Plastic
The most notable difference physically with the 'Lite' cameras is that they are both constructed of plastic throughout, instead of the cast or machined aluminum typically used, especially in bullet models. Though both are IK8 rated, some integrators may prefer the metal housings of competitors.
Web Interface
The web interface of the Lite series is essentially the same as the Wisenet III line, with most options similar and in the same location.
However, users may not control image quality/compression as they can in that line, and the camera's default H.264 profile is limited to a max VBR cap of 4 Mb/s and an I-frame interval of 5, with no way to increase these settings. Users may create a new profile which allows access to these settings, but VMSes may see this stream as a substream instead of the main stream, even when marked in the camera as default.
IR Illumination
Though IR illumination was overall even, with no hotspots, both the dome and bullet cameras had reflectance issues which had slight negative impact on image quality.
In the bullet camera, illumination reflected off of the camera's sunshield, seen in the image below. This reflection was visible no matter how far back or forward the sunshield was moved.
In the dome camera, IR can be seen reflected by the inside of the dome, seen in the image below.
Image Quality
First we tested image quality against competitive models indoors, in the approximate field of view seen below. Note that slight differences in FOV were present due to differences in fixed lens models' angle of view.
Full Light
In full light, ~160 lux, the WiseNet Lite cameras performed similarly to other 1080p models, slightly more evenly exposed than models such as the Axis M3006 and Hikvision 2032.
Dark
With lights off, ~0.01 lux, the Samsung cameras are more evenly exposed than the Dahua and Hikvision models, with better details of the subject's face and test chart. Both provide better video than the non-IR SNB-6004, which shows only 2-3 legible lines of the test chart, and the Axis M3005, which is simply black at this light level.
Wide Dynamic Range
We tested the cameras in a WDR scene, with our subject entering a door with strong sunlight outdoors, seen here:
The Wisenet Lite cameras were better in this scene than all cameras tested except the SNB-6004, the only true WDR camera in this test. Details of the subject are clearly visible as he enters, while the sunlight causes severe shadowing in the Axis, Dahua, and Hikvision cameras.
Bandwidth/Compression
The Wisenet Lite models' bitrates were typically 40-50% of the maximum bit rate set in their encoder profile settings. Even in low motion scenes, bitrates did not dip below these levels.
Since the Samsung Lite cameras offered no way to explicitly set compression, we found that adjusting the VBR cap up or down allowed us to set the camera to the desired average Q level. In our scenes, a 5 Mb/s cap resulted in 27-28Q, similar to competitors when standardized.
Competitive Comparison
The Wisenet Lite cameras defaulted to an average compression of about 32-33 on the quantization scale, with no way of adjusting it. Using these settings, bitrates were similar to other cameras in full light, and lower in the dark with IR on.
Adjusting the VBR cap upwards reduced average quantization to ~28. Using these settings, bitrates increase moderately, above other models (aside from the Dahua HFW1200S) in daytime, though still lower than all but the Hikvision 2032 at night.
Teardown
We tore down both cameras to see what chips were in use on these low cost models.
On the SNO-L6013R, the imager is visible after unsnapping four tabs and removing three screws. No markings are visible, however:
Tearing the SND-L6083 down, we can the camera's SoC (system on chip), a HiSilicon Hi3516. Also visible are a Samsung DRAM chip and a chip manufactured by Spansion which is illegible due to text printed over top of the chip markings.
Methodology
Firmware versions used for testing:
- Axis M3005-V: 5.50.5.2
- Dahua HFW1200S: 2.420.0001.0.R, build: 2014-10-13
- Hikvision DS-2CD2032-I: V5.2.0 Build 140721
- Samsung SNB-6004: 3.01_140804
- Samsung SND-L6083R: 1.00_150403
- Samsung SNO-L6013R: 1.00_150403