Recorders Integrating with Other Recorders

By: John Honovich, Published on Aug 23, 2012

Try having one manufacturer's VMS integrate another manufacturer's VMS, DVR or NVR. The results are likely to be disappointing. While integrating different manufacturer's cameras to a VMS is increasingly simple, integrating different recorders into a single interface can be impossible or extremely expensive, requiring a costly new software platforms (like PSIM) and still not work. In this note, we examine:

  • The benefits of integrating recorders with other recorders
  • The technical challenges in implementing this integration
  • The competitive barriers that hold this back
  • The potential for standards to change the market

The Value Proposition

Most users strongly prefer watching video from all cameras on a single user interface. Having to switch back between Vendor A's application and Vendor B's application to see different cameras is typically disliked as it forces operators to remember which camera is one which application. This can cause delays responding to threats and, more generally, confusion and inefficiency for ongoing monitoring.

This drive is so strong it is a major force for end users to standardize on recording platforms. While some larger end users might have a few recorders due to acquiring new companies or from legacy platforms from years ago, overwhelmingly end users will avoid mixing and matching various manufacturer's recorders (as they often do for cameras).

Technical Challenges

Integrating recorded video is hard - much harder than integrating live video feeds from streaming cameras. Doing so requires implementing numerous additional features beyond simply requesting the video feed:

  • Dealing with how video is stored on the external system (which can vary greatly)
  • Making sure you can smoothly fast forward, rewind, go frame by frame, go 2x, 4x speed, etc.
  • Getting any motion flag / marker / indicators
  • Searching for alerts, motion detection in a region, etc.
  • Dealing with variations in how quickly different recorders can retrieve / respond to requests (remembering that the user expects the client side to perform optimally regardless of what recorder the camera is coming from)

Getting the full range of recording functionalities working well can require a lot of work and can hit issues that are potentially insurmountable without changes from the recorder being integrated.

Competitive Barriers

Making it worse, political or competitive issues can be even bigger problems than technical ones. Recorder vendors have long recognized that the lack of recorder integration is a key barrier to keep rivals out of existing accounts. This works both ways. If the incumbent recorder in an account allows recorder B to integrate in recorder B's client, recorder B has a much better chance of breaking into the account. However, even if the incumbent recorder integrates B in the incumbent's client, this too would make it easier for B to break in. Indeed, even if an integration exists, a recorder company will often charge expensive license fees for integrating other recorders to dissuade customers to buying anything but their own.

Standards Developing?

Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox
Get Video Surveillance News In Your Inbox

'Standards' are developing but they are still early and have fairly negligible adoption. Both PSIA, through their RACM spec, and ONVIF 2.0 provides defined interoperability methods for accessing recorded video. However, PSIA have advocated theirs since 2009 with nothing much to show. ONVIF 2.0 is much newer and may have more impact but we do not see any indicators yet that recorder manufacturers will use this to open up their platforms to rivals. Even if they implemented 2.0's recording interfaces, how well it would is still a big question given the complexity and performance sensitivity of retrieving recorded video.

What's Available Today

Very few recorder to recorder integrations exist today. Most VMSes, DVRs, NVRs, etc. support no third party recorders (even bigger providers like Exacq and OnSSI). Genetec and Milestone both support some with Genetec likely having more. However, even these companies only support a minor subset of recorders on the market (and, of course, not each other). Moreover, often a camera license is required for each channel of each recorder integrated within the VMS, in addition to the original cost of the recorder being integrated, essentially resulting in 'double' payments.

Because of all of those issues, most users have no integration of multiple recorders. The rest either integrate through an access control system that can support multiple lines or a PSIM.

Poor Man's Integration

A common hack to integrate recorders that have no direct integration is to display the web client of one recorder inside the thick client of another recorder. This requires a recorder's thick client to support embedding a web client inside a live view pane (or tile).

Below is a conceptual image showing Exacq's web client embedded inside of Milestone's thick client:

poor man's recorder integration

However, this type of integration has important limitations:

  • Awkward Usability: The standard controls for selecting cameras or layouts on the main VMS client will not work with the embedded VMS client. Moreover, embedding the web client into a smaller pane can make it cumbersome to control cameras, move around the web client's workspace and even more difficult with accessing recorded video.
  • ActiveX Control Issues: Often, for security reasons, VMS clients display ActiveX controls from running in embedded web browsers. This can break the web client of many embedded VMS web clients who typically depend on such controls.

This might be a step up from simply switching to a different entire application but often not be much.

Future Developments

We are not optimistic about this improving. The best shot at this problem being overcome is ONVIF 2.0 and that is still a long shot.

2 reports cite this report:

Top 5 Video Surveillance Product Advances Going Into 2016 on Dec 31, 2015
Here are the 5 product areas that have had the most meaningful product advanced in 2015, that you should be looking at incorporating in...
Milestone Launches Disruptive ONVIF Bridge 'Out' on Dec 15, 2015
This is good news for the industry, for those wanting simpler integration and for the much battered PSIM market. As part of Milestone's XProtect...
Comments : PRO Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

Axis ~$150 Outdoor Camera Tested on May 21, 2019
Axis has released the latest in their Companion camera line, the outdoor Companion Dome Mini LE, a 1080p integrated IR model aiming to compete with...
Panasonic 32MP Multi Imager Camera Tested (WV-X8570N) on May 16, 2019
Panasonic has released their first multi imager models including the 32MP (4x4K) WV-X8570N, claiming "Extreme image quality for evidence capturing...
Bank Security Manager Interview on May 15, 2019
Bank security contends with many significant threats - from fraudsters to robbers and more. In this interview, IPVM spoke with bank security...
Milestone XProtect 2019 R1 Tested on May 15, 2019
For the past few years, Milestone has released quarterly software updates XProtect VMS platform. What is new and how much impact do the updates...
China PRC Government New National Video Surveillance Standards on May 14, 2019
The People's Republic of China (PRC) government has released a new set of overarching standards for authorities to follow when they install video...
Access Control Request to Exit (RTE) Tutorial on May 13, 2019
For access controlled doors, especially those with maglocks, 'Request to Exit', or 'RTE' devices are required to override electrified locks to...
Bluecherry Open Sources Entire VMS on May 13, 2019
Bluecherry announced they have "released the entire Bluecherry software application open source with a GPL license". We spoke to Bluecherry's...
Mining Company Security Manager Interview on May 10, 2019
First Quantum Minerals Limited (FQML) is a global enterprise with offices on 4 continents and operations in 7 countries with exploratory operations...
ADT's Top Dealer "The Defenders" Sued 20+ Times on May 07, 2019
ADT's largest authorized dealer, The Defenders, has been sued more than 20 times since 2012, IPVM has verified through analyzing legal...
Aegis AI Gun Detection Video Analytics Startup on May 07, 2019
Gun detection analytic startups are increasing as the promise of AI and the threats of active shooters grow.  One company, Aegis AI, is being led...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Kidnapping Victim Rescued With Video From Ring Doorbell Camera on May 24, 2019
A kidnapping victim was rescued within 24 hours, with the police crediting video from a Ring Doorbell camera as key to solving the case. A girl was...
NJ Law Requires Apprenticeship For Public Works Integrators on May 24, 2019
Few integrators do a formal apprenticeship program. However, now a NJ law is requiring any integrator on public works projects (such as state...
Security / Privacy Journalist Sam Pfeifle Interview on May 24, 2019
Sam Pfeifle is best known as the outspoken former Editor of Security Systems News. After that, he was publications director at the International...
Verkada Video Quality Problems Tested on May 23, 2019
Verkada suffers from numerous video quality problems, not found in commercial IP cameras, new IPVM testing of Verkada vs Axis and Hikvision...
Average Frame Rate Video Surveillance 2019 on May 23, 2019
What is the average frame rated used in video surveillance systems? In IPVM's 2011 statistics, the average was 6-8fps increasing to ~10fps in...
Dahua USA Celebrates 5 Years of Errors on May 22, 2019
Dahua USA is, in their own words, 'celebrating' 5 years in North America or as trade magazine SSN declared: Dahua Technology finds success in...
Access Control Job Walk Guide on May 22, 2019
Significant money can be saved and problems avoided with an access control job walk if you know what to look for and what to ask. By inviting...
ASCMA / Monitronics Declares Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Plan on May 22, 2019
Monitronics is entering into Chapter 11 bankruptcy. The company, also called Ascent Capital Group Inc., aka ASCMA, aka Brinks Home Security,...
US Considers Sanctions Against Hikvision and Dahua on May 22, 2019
The US government is considering blacklisting "up to 5" PRC surveillance firms, including Hikvision and Dahua, Bloomberg reported, with human...
Axis ~$150 Outdoor Camera Tested on May 21, 2019
Axis has released the latest in their Companion camera line, the outdoor Companion Dome Mini LE, a 1080p integrated IR model aiming to compete with...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact