Parking Garage Shootout

Author: Benros Emata, Published on May 14, 2011

Parking garages are a key area for using surveillance cameras. Thefts, assaults, vandalism and accidents are among the many incidents that cameras can help solve.

Monitoring parking garages effectively is more challenging than it first appears. On the plus side, garages are generally enclosed and laid out in long lanes conducive to surveillance camears. However, most parking garages have openings on the side that expose the garages to sunlight. Also, garages depend on artificial lighting that can create great variation of lighting across the scene.

Below is an image from our testing scene showing the presence of outdoor opening and artificial lighting. The cameras were mounted at ceiling level aimed directly down the middle of the driving lane to capture people and cars moving through the garage:

In the test, we used a kit of 7 different cameras (including SD, 720p, 2MP, 3MP and 5MP from Arecont Vision, Axis, Bosch, IQinVision and Sony) to better understand the tradeoffs for ourselves.

The overhead image and map below demonstrates the coverage, distances and pixels per foot at different positions:

Then we analyzed a series of scenes to see how performance varied across the cameras. We digitally zoomed each camera to the same level to see the differences. See an example scene comparison from our parking lot test.

We conducted our analysis across 16 scenes. They are:

  • Midday Back Lighting (Far Vehicle)
  • Midday Back Lighting (Near Vehicle)
  • Midday Even Lighting (Far Human)
  • Midday Even Lighting (Near Human)
  • Twilight Back Lighting (Far Vehicle)
  • Twilight Back Lighting (Near Vehicle)
  • Twilight Back Lighting (Far Human)
  • Twilight Back Lighting (Near Human)
  • Nighttime Color (Far Vehicle)
  • Nighttime Color (Near Vehicle)
  • Nighttime Color (Far Human)
  • Nighttime Color (Near Human)
  • Nighttime BW (Far Vehicle)
  • Nighttime BW (Near Vehicle)
  • Nighttime BW (Far Human)
  • Nighttime BW (Near Human)

Inside the Pro section, we analyze and show the differences captured in each scenario. We focus on the significant practical problems that significant lighting variations may cause.

******* ******* *** * *** **** *** ***** ************ *******. Thefts, ********, ********* *** ********* *** ***** *** **** ********* that ******* *** **** *****.

********** ******* ******* *********** ** **** *********** **** ** ***** appears. ** *** **** ****, ******* *** ********* ******** *** laid *** ** **** ***** ********* ** ************ *******. *******, most ******* ******* **** ******** ** *** **** **** ****** the ******* ** ********. ****, ******* ****** ** ********** ******** that *** ****** ***** ********* ** ******** ****** *** *****.

***** ** ** ***** **** *** ******* ***** ******* *** presence ** ******* ******* *** ********** ********. *** ******* **** mounted ** ******* ***** ***** ******** **** *** ****** ** the ******* **** ** ******* ****** *** **** ****** ******* the ******:

** *** ****, ** **** * *** ** * ********* cameras (********* **, ****, ***, *** *** *** **** ******* Vision, ****, *****, ********** *** ****) ** ****** ********** *** tradeoffs *** *********.

*** ******** ***** *** *** ***** ************ *** ********, ********* and ****** *** **** ** ********* *********:

**** ** ******** * ****** ** ****** ** *** *** performance ****** ****** *** *******. ** ********* ****** **** ****** to *** **** ***** ** *** *** ***********. *** ********* ***** ********** **** *** ******* *** ****.

** ********* *** ******** ****** ** ******. **** ***:

  • ****** **** ******** (*** *******)
  • ****** **** ******** (**** *******)
  • ****** **** ******** (*** *****)
  • ****** **** ******** (**** *****)
  • ******** **** ******** (*** *******)
  • ******** **** ******** (**** *******)
  • ******** **** ******** (*** *****)
  • ******** **** ******** (**** *****)
  • ********* ***** (*** *******)
  • ********* ***** (**** *******)
  • ********* ***** (*** *****)
  • ********* ***** (**** *****)
  • ********* ** (*** *******)
  • ********* ** (**** *******)
  • ********* ** (*** *****)
  • ********* ** (**** *****)

****** *** *** *******, ** ******* *** **** *** *********** captured ** **** ********. ** ***** ** *** *********** ********* problems **** *********** ******** ********** *** *****.

[***************]

Key ******** *** ***************

** **** ****** ****** *** ******* ****** ********* ********* ******* advantages ******** ** ******** ********** *******. ** **** ******, **** relatively **** ********, ********* ********* ****** **********.

**************, *** *** ********* *** *** **** ********* ** ******** in *** *****. *** ********, ****** *** ***, *** ********* in ******** ******* *** ****** *** ******* ***** ****** **** common ** *** *****. **** ********* *** **** ******* **** the *********** ******** ***** **** ** ****** ********(***** *** * *** ********* ******* **** *** ***** *****). At *****, *** ********** ******* *** *** ********** ** ********** lighting ******* ********** ** ****. ******** ********** *** ******, *** lux ***** **** ** ************* ** *** *** ** ******* lights, *** *** ***** ******* ** *** ** * *** - * *********** ******, **** ** *** ** *********** ** the *** ****.

*** ********** ************ ** *** ******* ***** ** ********* ***** certain **********:

  • ****** / ******** **** ***** ****** ******** ********* *** ********** by **** ** ****
  • ******* ****** **** **** *** *** ** ******** ** ***** or ***** ************ ***** **** ************* **** **********
  • ********** ******** **** **** **** ***** ****** ***** ******* ***** time ***********
**** *****, ** ********* *** *********:
  • ********* ******** *** ****** ** *** ******** ********** ** ******* lots. **** *** ****** ** ************ ** ******** **** ******* *** **** ******. ******** *** ******** *********** ** ********* unlikely *** ******* *** *********** ************ *** ********** *** ** quite ********.
  • ** *** ********* ********* ** * ****** ********* ******** ** the ****** *** ******** **********. **** **** *** **** *** will ****** *********** ************** *** *** ********.
  • ******** ***** ***** **** *&* **** ** *****. ***** *** artificial ********, *** ***** ****** *** *** ********* ***********. **** importantly, **** ******'* *&* **** **** ** ******** ***** **** artificial ***** ******* (**** ** *** ********** *** ******** ********).

Midday **** ******** (*** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. ***** is ~**,*** *** ** **** ******** *** ~*** *** ** illumination ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** ******** conditions *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

**** ** *** ******* ******* ********** ******* *** ***** *******. However, *** ****** ** (*** *** ***) *** **** ******* reveal ****** ***** ******** ****** *** ***** ******* *** ****** effects. ** **** ************** ** ****, ***** *** ***** *** considerably ******. ***** *** ** *****, *** ** ******* ******* at ***** **** '****' ** ** *** ****, ***** *** color. **** **** *** *** *****-**** ** ***** ******-***, *** still ******* ** ******* **** *** ******* (***** ******* *** ground *******).

Midday **** ******** (**** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. ***** is ~**,*** *** ** **** ******** *** ~*** *** ** illumination ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** ******** conditions *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

*** ****** ** *** **** ******* ******* *** ******** ***** capture, ****** *** *** *** (******) ***** ** *** *****-*******. Of *** ** ******* *** **** (**** *****) ******** ******** probability ** * ********** ***** ******* - **** **** ******** certainty. *** ** **** ** ******* *** ** ******* ******* no ********** ****** ** ***** ******* *** ***** *********** ***** of *****-******** ***** *********** **** *** ***** **** ****** ** well.

Midday **** ******** (*** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~***** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. There ** ~**,*** *** ** ****-***** *** ~*** *** ** illumination ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** ******** conditions *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

***** ******** ***** * ******* ** *** ****** ** (***, 3MP, *** ***) ***** *** ***** ******* ** **** ******-***, obscuring ****** *******. *******, * **** ***** ** *** *******'* build, ****** *** **** *****/***** *** ** ********. *** **** cameras ******* *** **** ***** ** *****, ****** *** **** color/style, *** **** * **** ** ** ********** ** ****. Note **** *** ***, ***, *** **** **** ******* ** indication ** * **** ** *** ***** **** ******* ** the *******'* *****.

Midday **** ******** (**** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. There ** ~**,*** *** ** ****-***** *** ~*** *** ** illumination ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** ******** conditions *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

******* ************ ** ******* *** ******* ** ** ********* *****-******* here ** *** ****** **********. ******** ** ************ *** ** the ******* *** ******* *** *********** ******* ** ***** **** contours. ***** ***** ********** **** ** *** ******* (** ** SD) *** ******* **************. ******** **********, ******** ** *** '***' scenario, ******* ****** ***** ** ********** - *.*., ** ******* to ****** *** ********** *** **** ***** ** ****. **** even ******* **** ** *** ******** ** * ***** **** is **** ** ****.

Twilight **** ******** (*** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. ***** is ~*,*** *** ** **** ******** *** ~** *** ** illumination ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** ******** conditions *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

**** *** *** ******** * ****** ***** **** ****** *** a ********** ****** ** ***** *******. *** **** (**** *****) provides *** **** **** ****** *** ***** *******. *** ***** pattern ** ****** ***** ** ***** *** ******* ** ****, improving *** **** ** ****/***** **************. **** **** *** ***'* especially ******-*** ***** ******** ******* ** ******* *****, ***** *******, and ******* ********** ** *****.

Twilight **** ******** (**** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. ***** is ~*,*** *** ** **** ******** *** ~** *** ** illumination ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** ******** conditions *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

******* ** *** '****** **** ******** (**** *******)' *********, *** MP (********* *** *** ******) *** **** ******* ******* * good ***** ** ****** *** ****** ****** **** ** * successful ***** *******. ************, *** ** ******* *** *** ********* sufficient ******* *** * ****** ** ******** ****** ** ***** capture. ******* *** **** (**** *****) ******** *** ******* ***** of ******* *** ********** **** ** ***** ******* ***** *** composite.

Twilight **** ******** (*** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~***** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. There ** ~*,*** *** ** **** ******** *** ~** *** of ************ ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** lighting ********** *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

**** ** *** ******* ******* ****** ******* *** *********** *** human *******. *******, **** ******* ******* ******** ** ****** *********** of ******, *****, ********, **** *****/*****, *** ******* **********. *** one ********* ** *** *** (******), ***** ** ************ ******-*** and ********* ******* ** *** *******'* ****** *******.

Twilight **** ******** (**** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. There ** ~*,*** *** ** **** ******** *** ~** *** of ************ ** *** ****** ********** ****. ** * ****** lighting ********** *** * ************ *********.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

**** ** *** ******* ******* ****** ****** ******* *** **** certainty **************. ******, *** ****** ******** ****** ***** ****** ** 'smeared' *** ** *** ******** ** *** *******. *******, ** contrast ** *** '******' *********** ***** ** ** ******* ****** improvement ** ***** ******* *** ****** *****. *** *******, * better ***** ** *** *******'* **********, ******** *** **** *****/***** is ***** - ****** '****** **** ********' ***** **** ***** outlines ** *** ******* **** ********.

Nighttime ***** (*** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. **** that ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* ****** is ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** ** artificial ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* ******* have **** '******' ** ***** ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

******* ** *** '******** **** ******** (*** *******)' ********, **** the *** ******** ****** ******* *** * ********** ****** ** plate *******. **** **** ******* *** *** **** **** ** they ******* * ******* ** ********** ***** *** ******* ***** characters. *******, *** *********** ** * ********** ***** ******* **** the **** ******* ** ***** ********** ** **** ********** ********. Note *** *** ** ********* *********** ***** **** ****-******, ********* in ** ***** ** ****** ******* ************* ******* - *.*. highly ******* **** ******** *** ***** *******.

Nighttime ***** (**** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. **** that ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* ****** is ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** ** artificial ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* ******* have **** '******' ** ***** ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

*** ******* (**** ** *** **) ******* * ******** ** high ***** ** ******* ***** ******. ** ****, * ******** to **** ******** ********* ** ***** ******* ** ********. *** 720p (**** *****) ******* ******** *** **** ****** ***** ** the ******* *****. *************, *** ** ******* ******* ******** ****** clarity *** ***** ******* **** *** *** *** *** *******, which *** ******** ****** *** ***** **** ********.

Nighttime ***** (*** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~***** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. Note **** ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* garage ** ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** by ********** ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* cameras **** **** '******' ** ***** ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

****** *** *********, **** ****** ****** ** *** ***** ******* is ***** *********. ** * ******, ******* ** ************** * likely *******. **** ***** * ***** ** **********, ******** *** clarity ** ** **** **** ***** ******** *********** **** ** gender, *****, **** *****/***** ***. *** *** ******* ***********. **** that ** *** *** *** *** ** *** **** (***** NBN-921), ** ** ***** ********* ** **** ****** ** ****** human ******* ** *** *****.

Nighttime ***** (**** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. Note **** ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* garage ** ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** by ********** ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* cameras **** **** '******' ** ***** ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

** ***** ******** *** '***' ***********, **** ********* ******* ****** detail ****** ** *** ***** ******* ****** *** *******, ****** identification ****** ******. ***** ******* ** *********** ****** ** *** 5MP, ***** *** **** ** *** *******'* ***** ** ***** crisp.

Nighttime ** (*** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. **** that ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* ****** is ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** ** artificial ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* ******* have **** '******' ** */* ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

**** ** *** ******* ******* ********** ******* *** * **** certainty ***** *******. *** **** (***-***) ** ******** *** **** in *** *********, *** ******** **** * ******* ** ******* plate ******* *** * ************ ***** ****** ** ***** *******. The ***** **** ****-****** ** ***** ****** ** *** *** and ***, ********* ** * **** ** ****** ******* **** could *********** **** ** ****, *****, *** ***** ***********.

Nighttime ** (**** *******)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * vehicle ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. **** that ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* ****** is ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** ** artificial ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* ******* have **** '******' ** */* ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

*** ******** ** ******* ******* ********** ******* *** ******** ***** capture. *** ******* ** ********* ***** **** **** ******** (*** and **** **** *****), ******** (**** ***** ***-*** *** ** Axis *****) ** ****** (***, ***, *** ** ***** ***-***). While *** *** *** *** ******* ****** *********** ****** ** bloom **** ****-****** **** *** *** **** ** ******* **** key ******* ** *** ***** *******, ****** *******, *** ******* body ********.

Nighttime ** (*** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~***** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. Note **** ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* garage ** ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** by ********** ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* cameras **** **** '******' ** */* ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

**** ** *** ******* ******* ****** ****** *** **************. ********* two ********** ** ******* ******* ****** **** **** *********. *** in ***** ** **** *** ******** ** * ***** ** detectable ****** *** ***** (*.*., *** *** **** ****), *** another ** ***** * ***** ******* ** *** ****** ** be ******** ** *** (***, ***, ** ***-***). **** ** which * ***** ** ********** ****** **** **** * **** of ******** *** ******* **** ** ***** ****** *********** (*.*. complexion, ******, ******** ***.) ** ****** ** ** ********.

Nighttime ** (**** *****)

** **** ********, ******* *** ********* ****** **** ** * human ******* ~**** ***, ************* ** * **** ** ~****. Note **** ************ ** *** ********* ******* ** *** ******* garage ** ~* ***, *** **** ******** ******** *** *********** by ********** ****** (~** ** ~** ***). **** **** */* cameras **** **** '******' ** */* ****.

***** ** *** ********* ******** (******** **** ***** ****):

*********** ****** ******** *** ******** ** *** ******* ****** *** composite.

***********

*** ********* *** *** ***** (*) ******* **** ** *** 'Parking ****** ********':

  • ******* ******(****** $***) - ***/*.*** */*; */*" ****; ****** **.*; *.* Lux (**)
  • **** *****(****** $***) - **** *****-****; */*" ****; ********** **.*; *.* Lux (*****)
  • **** *****(****** $****) - *** */*; */*.*" ****; **.* ****;*.** *** (BW)
  • ***** ***-***(****** $***) - **** */*; */*" ***; **.* *****; *.* Lux (**)
  • ***** ***-***(****** $***) - ** */*; */*" ***; **.* *****; *.** Lux (**)
  • ********** *******(****** $***) - *** *****-****; */*" ****; **.* **********; *.* Lux
  • **** *****(****** $***) - **** */*; */*" ****; **.* *******; *.* Lux (**)

**** ** *** ***** ******* **** ************** ******** ** ** Exacqvision *** ****** **** (*) *** *********. *** ******* *** set ** ***** ******** ****** *******, ****** ****** *** ********* tests. ****** ********* ***** */* ******* **** ****** '******' **** B/W ** ***** **** ** ****** *********** ** **********. *** camera ****** **** ******** ** * ******* **** ***** (~** degrees) *** ********/******** ** ***** ******* ***********.

**** *** *** *** ******* ******** *** **** ******:

  • ******* ****** - ********* ********
  • **** ***** - ******** ***** '**'; ******** ******* '*********'
  • **** ***** - ******** ***** '**'; ******** ******* '*********'
  • ***** ***-*** - */*** *******; ****** **; *** ** '**'
  • ***** ***-*** - */*** *******; ****** **; *** ** '**'
  • ********** ******* -*/** *******; *****-****
  • **** ***** - */*** *******; ****-**/** **; *** '******'

**** *** *** **** (*) *** ********* ** ********:

  • ****** **** ******** - ~**,*** *** (********* ****); ~*** *** (covered ****)
  • ******** **** ******** - ~*,*** *** (********* ****); ~** *** (covered ****)
  • ********* */* **** - ~* *** (********* ****); ~** ** 50 *** (******* ****)
  • ********* ***** **** - ~* *** (********* ****); ~ ** to ** *** (******* ****)

**** ** *** **** (*) *** ********* ******* *** **** choreographed ********. *** ******** ******** * ***** ******* ******* ******* the ****** *** **** * '***' ******** (~*****) ** * 'near' ******** (~****). ****, * ******* ******* ****** ******* ** towards *** ****** *** **** * '***' ******** (~*****) ** a '****' ********' (~****).

Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Most Recent Industry Reports

Reseting IP Cameras - 30 Manufacturer Directory on Sep 22, 2017
Every camera has a reset button (well, almost) but it is not always clear what these buttons do, how long they need to be held, what settings they...
Genetec Launches Cloud Access Control (Synergis SaaS) on Sep 21, 2017
Genetec's cloud everything expansion continues, with their announcement of Synergis SaaS edition, joining their cloud video offering Stratocast,...
Genetec CEO Warns Against Insider Threats on Sep 21, 2017
With Dahua and Hikvision cybersecurity issues becoming indisputable, a new counter has emerged. Just put them behind a firewall, buy cheap...
New IPVM Calculator V3 Released on Sep 20, 2017
The New IPVM Calculator V3 is released. An entirely new architecture delivers the following benefits: Turbo The calculator is now ~50% faster in...
Automatic Door Operators For Access Tutorial on Sep 20, 2017
Opening and closing doors might sound simple, but it takes a high-tech piece of door hardware to pull it off. Integrating automatic door operators...
'Clowns' Allege Ubiquiti 'Completely Fraudulent' on Sep 20, 2017
A short seller has alleged Ubiquiti is 'completely fraudulent'. Ubiquiti's CEO has responded calling them 'clowns'. Here is the short...
Avigilon 'Blue' Cloud Entry Examined on Sep 19, 2017
Avigilon is moving to the cloud. The company announced their Avigilon Blue platform, designed to be a web-managed surveillance system, utilizing...
HID Buys Mercury Security on Sep 19, 2017
One of the biggest access control deals in years. Mercury Security, the most widely used access hardware OEM, and partner to 20+ manufacturers,...
Hikvision Backdoor Exploit on Sep 18, 2017
Full disclosure to the Hikvision backdoor has been released, allowing easy exploit of vulnerable Hikvision IP cameras. As the researcher, Monte...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact