Motion Detection Performance Tested

Author: Benros Emata, Published on Sep 05, 2011

Motion detection is an important element of many, if not, most surveillance systems. It plays a central role in both storage search time reduction. Storage is routinely reduced by 30% - 80% by using motion based rather than continuous recording. Likewise, an investigator can often much faster find a relevant event by simply scanning through areas of motion rather than watching through all video.

At the same time there are a number of challenges associated with using motion detection:

  • Scene Conditions: The accuracy of motion detection and the amount of times motion is detected can vary depending on what's in the scene - people, cars, trees, leaves, etc. - and the time of day - night time with lots of noise, sunrise and sunset with direct sunlight into a camera, etc.
  • Performance of Detector: Motion detetion is built into many surveillance products - from DVRs to VMS systems and now IP cameras. As such, how well each one works can vary significantly.

Our Test

In this report, we share our results from a series of tests we performed to better understand motion detection performance.

We did a series of tests in different locations:

  • Indoor well light scene to simulate the simplest scene possible
  • Indoor dark scene (<1 lux) to examine what problems low light caused
  • Outdoor parking lot to see how a complex scene with trees, cars and people would perform
  • Roadway to see how a moderately complex scene with periodic cars would perform

Three IP cameras were used with their motion detection enabled to see differences in performance:

With these tests, we answered the following questions:

  • How can one estimate motion percentage accurately?
  • Does motion estimation vary significantly by scene?
  • How accurate was motion detection in each scene?
  • Did certain cameras exhibit greater false motion detection than others? What scenes or conditions drove those problems?

****** ********* ** ** ********* ******* ** ****, ** ***, most ************ *******. ** ***** * ******* **** ** **** storage ****** **** *********. ******* ** ********* ******* ** **% - **% ** ***** ****** ***** ****** **** ********** *********. Likewise, ** ************ *** ***** **** ****** **** * ******** event ** ****** ******** ******* ***** ** ****** ****** **** watching ******* *** *****.

** *** **** **** ***** *** * ****** ** ********** associated **** ***** ****** *********:

  • ***** **********: *** ******** ** ****** ********* *** *** ****** ** times ****** ** ******** *** **** ********* ** ****'* ** the ***** - ******, ****, *****, ******, ***. - *** the **** ** *** - ***** **** **** **** ** noise, ******* *** ****** **** ****** ******** **** * ******, etc.
  • *********** ** ********: ****** ******** ** ***** **** **** ************ ******** - from **** ** *** ******* *** *** ** *******. ** such, *** **** **** *** ***** *** **** *************.

Our ****

** **** ******, ** ***** *** ******* **** * ****** of ***** ** ********* ** ****** ********** ****** ********* ***********.

** *** * ****** ** ***** ** ********* *********:

  • ****** **** ***** ***** ** ******** *** ******** ***** ********
  • ****** **** ***** (light ******
  • ******* ******* *** ** *** *** * ******* ***** **** trees, **** *** ****** ***** *******
  • ******* ** *** *** * ********** ******* ***** **** ******** cars ***** *******

***** ** ******* **** **** **** ***** ****** ********* ******* to *** *********** ** ***********:

**** ***** *****, ** ******** *** ********* *********:

  • *** *** *** ******** ****** ********** **********?
  • **** ****** ********** **** ************* ** *****?
  • *** ******** *** ****** ********* ** **** *****?
  • *** ******* ******* ******* ******* ***** ****** ********* **** ******? What ****** ** ********** ***** ***** ********?

[***************]

Key ******** *** ***************

**** *** *** *** ********:

  • ** ****** ****** (*.*. **** ******** *** ****** ***), ********** percentage ** ****** ** ********** *************** *** *** * *** margin *** *****.
  • ** ******* ****** (*.*. *******, **** ***, ********* ********, *** vegetation) ********** ********* ** ****** ** ********* *** *** **** greatly.
  • ******** ** *********** ****** ******* ********* ************* ** *** ********** of *** ***** *********.
  • *** ***** ******* ********* ******* (** ***** *********/*********) ** *** very ****** ******* ****** ****
  • ** *** ******* *** **** *** ***** ******* ****** ** record ** ****** ** **** ********* *******, *** ** ********** and ******** *******
  • *** ******* ****** ****** *** *********** ***** ********* ** ***-*****/********* scenes ****** *** ** *****/**** ** **** ** **** *** is ******* **** *** ******'* ***. **** ******** ** **** continuous *********.

** ***** ** ***** ******** *** ********* ** ***********:

  • ****** *** ***** ** **** ******, ****** ********* ******** (*.*. masking, ***********, *** ****** ****) **** ****** **** ** ** optimized ** ***** ** ******* ********** ********
  • *** ***-***** ******, ******** ******** ******* ****. ****, ********** **** different ****** *****/****** ** *********** *** **** ************ ** ***-*****/********* scenarios
  • ** ******* ***** ********** ****** ** ******* ****** ** ***'* estimates *** ** *** ***

Daytime ****** (********** ******)

** **** ********, ****** ********* ** ********** *** *** *** interface ** *** *******. *** ******* *** **** ** ****** record *** * ****** ** *** *******. * ******* ****** the ***** ** ********* ****** ** ***** ****** ****** ********* during *** *** ****** ****. * ******** **** *** ****** recorded ***** *** ******** ******** ** ******** *****. **** **** on *** ******** '****' ********** ****** ******** ***** *** '****' indicates ** ***** *********.

********* *** ******** ******* **** *** ******* ******** ******** ****** during **** ** *** ***** ******* ******* **** *** *****. Also, **** ** ***********, ** ***** ********* **** ********* ****** times **** *** ******* *** *** ** *** *****. *** findings *** *** ********** ***** *** ********** ** *** *********** (narrow ***, ****** *** ********** ********, ** **********, *** ***** subject/object).

Nighttime ****** (********** ******)

** **** ********, ****** ********* ** ********** *** *** *** interface ** *** *******. *** ******* *** **** ** ****** record *** * ****** ** *** *******. * ******* ****** the ***** ** ********* ****** ** ***** ****** ****** ********* during *** *** ****** ****. * ******** **** *** ****** recorded ***** *** ******** ******** ** ******** *****. **** **** on *** ******** '****' ********** ****** ******** ***** *** '****' indicates ** ***** *********.

** **** ***-***** ***********, ****** *********/****** ******** *** ****** ********** across *** ***** *******. *** ******* *** ** ***** *** lighting ******* *********** '********' ****** ** ******** *** ** **** effectively ******* ** ********** ******* (**** ***** ******** ****). ** direct ******** *** ********* ***** '********' ***** ** ****** ******* throughout *** *** ****** ******** *** ** * ****** *** produced ** ********* ** *** (**** ***** ******** ****). *** Axis ******** *** **** ** ** *** ** *** ******* indoor *********, ******* ******/***-****** *************.

Daytime ******* (******* ******)

** **** ********, ****** ********* ** ********** *** *** *** interface ** *** *******. *** ******* *** **** ** ****** record *** * ****** ** ** *******. *** ****** ** organic *** ************** ** * **** ***** ************ ********. * snapshot **** *** ****** ******** ***** *** ******** ******** ** featured *****. **** **** ** *** ******** '****' ********** ****** recorded ***** *** '****' ********* ** ***** *********.

*** ********* ** ****** *********/********* ** **** ** *** ******** is ************ **** *** *** ***** ******* (~** - **% motion). *** **** ******* *********** (*.*., *****, ******* *** ***** lighting *******) ****** ***** * ****** ** ***** ********* ****** the *****. **** **** *** ********* ****** *********** ******** ********** the ** ****** ****, *** **** *** **** *** **** slightly **** ***** *********. *** ******* *** *** ***** ********* among *** ***** *** ***** ************ **** ********* **** *********** just ************** ******** ** ********* ****** (*.*. ***** *** ******* subjects).

24 **** ******* (******* ******)

*** ********* ** * ******** ** **** ******** ********* ** two ******* (******** *** *****) ********** ** ****** ****** ********** a ** **** ******. *** ******* **** *** **** ******* scene **** *** **** ***/**** *****. ***** ********** ******** **** insights **** *********** ** ****** *********/********* ************* ****** ********* ****** makes/models. **** **** *** *** ** **** ** ********** *** motion ********* ******** **** *** ****** *** *** **** ** the *** ********** ********.

**** ********* (*:**** - *:****)

****** *** ~* ***** ** ******** ******** ** *** ******** the ******* ****** ******** ************ ******* *********** **** *** **** camera ******* **** ********* **** *** ******* (*** **********) ****** settings. ** * ******, *** ******* ******** ************ ***** *********, whereas *** **** ** ************* ** ***** * ****** ** false *********.

******* (*:**** - *:****)

*** ******** ** ****** ** ** ** **** ***** ********, as ********* ** *** ******** ** * ******* ******** *** FoV ******** ** *** ****** ********* ******* ******. **** **** how *** ******* ****** ** ****** ************ ****** ***** ****** around *:**** (*** *****), ***** *** **** ***** ** ******** the **** ********* ** ****** *********/*********.

*** **** ***** ******** **** (**** ********** ******) ********* ** the ******* ***** ****** ** ******** *********** ***** **** *** Arecont ******** ******* ******* ** *** ********* ****** ****.

********* (*:**** - **:****)

**** ** *** *** ***** ** *** *******'* ***** *********** and **** ********** ********* ******** ****** *** *********/***-***** *****. *** playback ** ****** ** ** ** ******** ***** **** *** Arecont *** **** ******** ******.

***** ******* (*:**** - *:****)

** **** ******** ********, *** ******* ****** ** ****** **** to * **** ********* ********* ******** ** ******* (*** ****). However, ** ** ***** ******* **** ********* *** ***** ******** considerable ***** ********* *** * ****** ***** **** ***** ** recording ** ***-********* (~*:* ** **%). ** ******** *** **** continues ** ****** ****** ** ******* *** **** ********* ** in ******** **** *******.

Other ******* ****** *********

*** ********* ******** ******** ******* *** ****** *********/********* ******** ** two ******: (*) ***** ******* ***, *** (*) ****** ******. Motion *** *******/******* ** *** * ***** ** *** ******** recording *********** ** **** ******* ************ ******.

***** ******* *** & ****** ****** ****/****** ***** (*:**** - 5:30pm)

*** ******* *** ****** *********/********* ********* ** ******** ** *** timeline *** ********* ******** *** ********* ** ********. **** ********* were ** ********** ***** *** ******* *******. **** **** *** FoV ** ** **** ******** ***** *** ** **** *********** to *** ******* **** ** ********.

** *** ****** ****** *****, *** ******** ** *** ********* were *** ** ********** ***** ********/******.

***********

**** *** *** ***** (*) ******* **** ** *** '****** Based *********' *****:

  • ******* ********(****** $***) - *.*** */*; */*.*" ****; ****-**; *.*/* (*****/**)
  • **** *****(****** $***) - **** */*; */*" ****; **.* ******** ; 0.05 *** (**)
  • ********* **-*****(****** $***) - *.*** */*; */*" ***; **-*****/* ****; *.*/*.** lux (*****/**)

**** *** *** ******** ******** *** **** ** *** *******:

  • ******* ******** - ** *****
  • **** ***** - ** *.**.*
  • ********* **-***** - ** *.**
Login to read this IPVM report.
Why do I need to log in?
IPVM conducts unique testing and research funded by member's payments enabling us to offer the most independent, accurate and in-depth information.

Related Reports on VMS

Avigilon 'Blue' Cloud Entry Examined on Sep 19, 2017
Avigilon is moving to the cloud. The company announced their Avigilon Blue platform, designed to be a web-managed surveillance system, utilizing...
Genetec Launches Community Connect Examined on Sep 14, 2017
Genetec has done best in large-scale, enterprise systems and relatively worse in smaller systems such as SMB. Now, Genetec is launching...
Geovision Doorstation Tested (CS1320) on Sep 12, 2017
Geovision has released the GV-CS1320 door station, priced at a fraction of others, with additional bells and whistles like a built in card reader,...
Axis vs Sony Super Size Shootout (Q1659 vs SNC-VB770) on Sep 11, 2017
Super low light, super sized sensor cameras are a growing trend. In the past year, 2 of the most notable entrants for these IP cameras have been...
DoorBird D101 Tested Vs Ring and Axis on Sep 01, 2017
Video doorbells are a big growth market, with Ring, in particular gaining a lot of attention on the consumer side and Axis making a push on the...
Favorite SMB Recorder Manufacturers 2017 on Aug 28, 2017
Low cost cameras have been a major force in the small to medium business (SMB) market (as our 2015 SMB favorites and 2017 SMB camera favorites)...
Hikvision VMS Password Recovery Vulnerability on Aug 28, 2017
Hikvision iVMS-4200 suffers from a vulnerability that allows anyone local, without authentication, to generate a code that Hikvision will respond...
FLIR Restructures Security Division on Aug 22, 2017
FLIR's goal was once to have a single end-to-end security solution. However, FLIR's Security business unit has been struggling, with several areas...
Dahua 4K IR PTZ Tested on Aug 21, 2017
4K has made its way to IR PTZs. In this report, we examine the Dahua 6AE830VNI, a 4K PTZ with 30x optical zoom, 200m (~650') integrated IR, and...
Stolen Video NVR / DVR Statistics on Aug 15, 2017
"But what happens if someone steals my recorder?" Anyone who has done more than a handful of jobs has probably heard this question several times....

Most Recent Industry Reports

Genetec Launches Cloud Access Control (Synergis SaaS) on Sep 21, 2017
Genetec's cloud everything expansion continues, with their announcement of Synergis SaaS edition, joining their cloud video offering Stratocast,...
Genetec CEO Warns Against Insider Threats on Sep 21, 2017
With Dahua and Hikvision cybersecurity issues becoming indisputable, a new counter has emerged. Just put them behind a firewall, buy cheap...
Automatic Door Operators For Access Tutorial on Sep 20, 2017
Opening and closing doors might sound simple, but it takes a high-tech piece of door hardware to pull it off. Integrating automatic door operators...
'Clowns' Allege Ubiquiti 'Completely Fraudulent' on Sep 20, 2017
A short seller has alleged Ubiquiti is 'completely fraudulent'. Ubiquiti's CEO has responded calling them 'clowns'. Here is the short...
Avigilon 'Blue' Cloud Entry Examined on Sep 19, 2017
Avigilon is moving to the cloud. The company announced their Avigilon Blue platform, designed to be a web-managed surveillance system, utilizing...
HID Buys Mercury Security on Sep 19, 2017
One of the biggest access control deals in years. Mercury Security, the most widely used access hardware OEM, and partner to 20+ manufacturers,...
Hikvision Backdoor Exploit on Sep 18, 2017
Full disclosure to the Hikvision backdoor has been released, allowing easy exploit of vulnerable Hikvision IP cameras. As the researcher, Monte...
Avigilon Touting 'Made In America' on Sep 18, 2017
Canadian manufacturer Avigilon, who completed a US manufacturing facility in 2015, is now running a marketing campaign touting 'Made In America',...
Cloud Guy Prints Book, Misses Irony on Sep 15, 2017
On-premise security systems are dead. But $75 print books are alive and well. Such are the lessons from Brivo's CEO new book "The Five...

The world's leading video surveillance information source, IPVM provides the best reporting, testing and training for 10,000+ members globally. Dedicated to independent and objective information, we uniquely refuse any and all advertisements, sponsorship and consulting from manufacturers.

About | FAQ | Contact