News on the Milestone VMS Patent Lawsuit

By: Carlton Purvis, Published on Dec 19, 2013

Last year, a lawsuit shocked the surveillance industry.

The most well known brand in VMS software, Milestone Systems, was sued by a small, but early, VMS company, JDS Digital Security Systems. The contested element is a basic component of many (or most VMSes), specifically, connecting IP cameras to software, displaying them and identifying them by MAC addresses.

Now more than a year later, we look at the progress of the case.

The case over the two patents is making its way through the U.S. legal system at a snail's pace. It was originally filed in May 2012 when JDS sued for patent infringement and is not any closer to being resolved. In 2012 we reported on two patents (1 and 2) for digital video systems using networks cameras. A key element in this case is proving prior art -- a company must prove no prior art existed for more than a year before filing their patent. Both companies were early developers of video management systems.

Where the Case Stands Now

June 2013: A motion filed by Milestone to dismiss the case over a technicality was dismissed. Milestone argued that the original complaints were not clear who was bringing the suit. Milestone argues that "it was impossible to determine whether Joseph Robert Marchese (the president of JDS) or JDS Digital Security Systems LLC was the Plaintiff." That motion was denied.

August 2013: Later Milestone argued with how JDS claims were constructed. A Special Master was called on to make recommendations on claim construction.

November/December 2013: By December, claim construction issues were resolved. But Milestone then asked to bifurcate the case.

"Defendants assert that: (1) this is an extraordinarily complex patent case and bifurcating on issues of liability and damages will make it less complex for the jury; (2) discovery disputes about damages can be avoided if discovery is bifurcated on the issues of liability and damages; and (3) there is little overlap of evidence on liability and damages and thus judicial economy will be promoted and there will be no prejudice to either party if discovery and the trial are bifurcated on the issues of liability and damages."

JDS opposed this saying that it has already provided all it can in discovery and that it would be unfair to have to fight the case to determine liability then fight it again to determine damages. The motion for bifurcation was denied on December 3rd.

Discovery is still ongoing and more than a year later, there have been no decisions or guidance made by the court in regard to the conclusion of Discovery and the start of pre-trial and trial hearings, according to court records and confirmed by Milestone. Calls to JDS were not returned.

Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News
Get Notified of Video Surveillance Breaking News

At this pace, it could take years to reach a decision, though as the OV lawsuits showed, sometimes quick settlements can be reached after lengthy litigation.

No Reexamination Requested

Often, in patent disputes, a re-examination of the patent will be requested in an attempt to invalidate key claims. We could not find any records of such requests being filed.

Legal Siege

Milestone has the resources to carry a case like this out for a long period of time. JDS may not. So, the longer Milestone can drag this case out, the stronger their position may be.

 

Comments (3) : Members only. Login. or Join.

Related Reports

Getting Started With Your IPVM Membership on Dec 02, 2019
Here's how to get started and get the most out of your IPVM membership. Books for Members All members can download the 3 member-only books below...
ADT And 'The Defenders' Silent About Massive Complaints on Feb 14, 2019
ADT's largest dealer, "The Defenders" has been the subject of a massive number of complaints over many years and many forums, most recently a CBS...
ADT's Top Dealer "The Defenders" Sued 20+ Times on May 07, 2019
ADT's largest authorized dealer, The Defenders, has been sued more than 20 times since 2012, IPVM has verified through analyzing legal...
Nortek and SDS Fight Over Failed Settlement on Jun 05, 2019
Distributor SDS said they reached a deal with Nortek but Nortek says no settlement was reached and the suit is still on. In this post, based on...
Briefcam Buys Frost Award* on Jun 20, 2019
Frost 'awards' are well-known and widely disrespected. Now Briefcam is touting their win. The way it has worked for many years is that Frost...
Security Dealer 'Social Media Contractor' Program on Jun 25, 2019
A $20,000 video surveillance system can be yours for free if you are willing to post on social media about the security dealer. Good deal, bad...
Cisco Settles False Claims Act Suit For Video Surveillance Vulnerabilities on Aug 01, 2019
Cisco entered the video surveillance market in 2007 and suffered for many years through a variety of its own errors and arrogance. The conclusion...
"UL Has Blood On Their Hands" Alleges The Interceptor / Keith Jentoft on Oct 14, 2019
"UL has blood on their hands" alleges Keith Jentoft of "The Interceptor Project". We examined The Interceptor in-depth last year, see: The...
Alarm Veteran "Demands A Criminal Investigation" Of UL on Oct 18, 2019
The Interceptor's Project pressure against UL continues to rise. Following Keith Jentoft's allegation that "UL Has Blood On Their Hands", Jentoft...
ADT Acquires Much Maligned "Defenders" on Jan 07, 2020
"The Defenders" has the dubious distinction of being ADT's largest partner and a long history of customer and employee complaints and...

Most Recent Industry Reports

Hanwha Wisenet X Plus PTRZ Tested on Feb 14, 2020
Hanwha has released their PTRZ camera, the Wisenet X Plus XNV-6081Z, claiming the "modular design allows for easy installation". We bought and...
PRC Warns Against China Video Surveillance Hacks, Hikvision Targeted on Feb 14, 2020
Hackers are targeting China video surveillance manufacturers and systems, according to the PRC's main cyber threat monitoring body. The hackers...
IPVM Conference 2020 on Feb 13, 2020
IPVM is excited to announce our 2020 conference. This is the first and only industry event that will be 100% sponsor-free. Like IPVM online, the...
Bosch Dropping Dahua on Feb 13, 2020
Bosch has confirmed to IPVM that it is in the process of dropping Dahua, over the next year, as both IP camera contract manufacturer and recorder...
BluB0X Alleges Lenel, S2, Software House Are Dinosaurs on Feb 13, 2020
BluB0X is running an ad campaign labeling Lenel, S2, Software House, Honeywell, AMAG and more as dinosaurs: In a follow-up email to IPVM,...
London Live Police Face Recognition Visited on Feb 13, 2020
London police have officially begun using live facial recognition in select areas of the UK capital, sparking significant controversy. IPVM...
Converged vs Dedicated Networks For Surveillance Tutorial on Feb 12, 2020
Use the existing network or deploy a new one? This is a critical choice in designing video surveillance systems. Though 'convergence' was a big...
Monitoreal "Completely Autonomous" Home AI Tested on Feb 12, 2020
Monitoreal claims to allow users to "see the things you want (people, vehicles, animals) and ignore the things you don’t”, using AI to distinguish...
Cisco Video Surveillance Is Dead, Long Live Cisco Meraki Video Surveillance on Feb 11, 2020
A dozen years ago much of the industry thought that Cisco was destined to dominate video surveillance. They stumbled repeatedly, failing. Now it is...
BICSI For IP Video Surveillance Guide on Feb 11, 2020
Spend enough time around networks and eventually someone will mention BICSI, the oft-referenced but only vaguely known standards body prevalent in...